Bloodborne: 10 Fan Demands It Must Meet

Dark Souls was great; let's make Bloodborne better.

From Software's Souls IP is a true unicorn of gaming. From the cult-classic beginnings of Demon's Souls on PlayStation 3, the series has ridden its unforgiving philosophy to popularity and beyond with Dark Souls and Dark Souls 2, the latter of which is still seeing DLC installments. As a result, there's a very particular air to the Souls scene, a unique mix of enthusiasm and cultural saturation that every game should strive for. There's no ambiguity among Souls fans; they know why they keep coming back to the games, and they know precisely what they want out of them. Many players very correctly (and humorously) compare their avidity€”the thrill of being stomped into the pavement by a new boss, of having no idea how you can get past that horde of enemies, and so on€”to masochism. This is where Bloodborne comes in, From Software's E3-revealed, PS4-exclusive Souls installment. Though it lacks the titular suffix, Bloodborne has Souls in its veins and has long since been deemed the spiritual successor to Demon's Souls. It marks the new-gen debut of the beloved series, and the biggest opportunity for change it has ever had€”a potent chance to both refine and innovate. Here are 10 of the biggest check boxes on that list of refinements and innovations.

10. Weird Magic That Works

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tPD0dOF0Tg Dark Souls 2 added yet another branch€”Hexes€”to the series' already diverse magic system. On top of Miracles (divine spells), Pyromancies (fire spells), and Sorceries (pretty much just blue lasers), there's certainly no shortage of spells to sling. What's more, the games are known for their collection of unorthodox magic; Chameleon, for example, camouflages your character as a piece of the environment. From repairing gear to detonating corpses to concealing your weapon, there's a magical answer to nearly every what-if situation. The only problem here is the lack of those what-ifs. We've got a raft of answers but no questions. If high fantasy games have taught us anything, it's that a good wizard knows how to do more than just throw around mana of varying potency. Action-RPGs such as Bloodborne should get creative with their magic, but not aimlessly so. Especially so for Souls games, most non-combative spells just gather dust in player inventories, repeatedly outshone by a blunter answer to the problem. It's a small gripe, to be sure, but Bloodborne could make a big improvement by justifying all those wacky spells. Invent situations that can't be solved by introducing enemy faces to fireballs, or actually make hiding in the environment useful (for more than just trolling other players in multiplayer)€”hell, work summoning an orb of light into puzzling somehow. Anything Soul Geyser can't answer is sure to add some flare to the game.

9. Up The Visuals

Largely thanks to its mod-happy community, the PC version of Dark Souls 2 has put a pleasing coat of paint over the game's dated visuals. On the whole, though, graphics haven't changed much since the 2011 release of Dark Souls, and the series is beginning to stand out in the wrong way for it. Thankfully, Bloodborne will be running on the significantly updated PlayStation 4€”updated from PlayStation 3, anyway€”meaning a fresh shipment of eye candy is all but inevitable. However, there's more to the production value of Souls games than pixel count and frame rate. Unlike the distinctly Gothic styling of the original, Dark Souls 2 leaned heavily on Victorian architecture and put a new face to its environments with grand arches, intricate columns, lofty enclosures and the like. This helped the game establish its own identity and to visually separate it from its predecessor, and Bloodborne needs to do the same€”though it is, of course, free to form its own style. That's tradition, after all.

8. Don't Get Lost

In stark opposition to the prevailing method of video game storytelling€”forcefeeding the player cutscenes and scripted events so heavy-handedly that you'd think gamers would die if they so much as thought of driving the plot themselves€”both Demon's Souls and Dark Souls tell their story through a carefully laid trail of bread crumbs, fragments through which the player is able to glean the underlying lore of the Undead's tale. It's a laissez-faire approach that worked wonders for the atmosphere and intrigue of Boletaria and Lordran (the settings of Demon's and Dark Souls, respectively), and would do the same for Bloodborne. All it has to do is properly distinguish between "let players learn the story" and "forget the players, the story doesn't need them." As you may have guessed, the latter approach is what brought the plot of Dark Souls 2 to a grinding halt on many occasion. There is such thing as too vague, and Dark Souls 2 gives all the direction and certainty of a house of mirrors. Even the most integral of characters fall by the wayside€”the most offending of which is the Emerald Herald herself, who isn't so much a character as she is a stand-in writer's convenience€”and the ending has been received by most as abrupt and baseless. Dark Souls 2 is by no means a bad game because of its schizophrenic story, but it's certainly a prime example of what Bloodborne shouldn't be.

7. Memorable NPCs

Of the millions who encountered them, not a single player has forgotten Knight Solaire's quest for his own sun or the underhanded tactics of Patches the Hyena. Similarly, Lordran's onion-headed Knights of Catarina along with Boletaria's Royal Knights€”otherwise known as the sissy brigade, led by Captain Incompetent himself, Ostrava€”remain icons of their respective realms. This is to say nothing of the stylized baddies and bosses which act as intimidating reminders of the challenges of their home areas. The bleak landscapes of the Souls series are populated by merchants, witches, fallen heroes, bosses and fellow Undead adventurers with personalities and appearances so quirky and zealous that you can't help but love them, if only for the contrast they provide. Dark Souls 2 continued this trend with gruff swordsmen, terse merchants and still more devious bandits. Bloodborne has no excuse not to deliver a colorful supporting cast. Besides, if an inexplicably literate pair of crows can get players laughing (and scratching their heads), who knows what eccentrics its horrific cities are home to? Get creative, From Software! You've done it before.

6. Let Us Play With Friends

Dark Souls Covenenants Multiplayer is one of the more divisive features of this series. Typically, players either love the added challenge of besting invaders and the option to aid others, or quickly become fed up with randomly being put on the receiving end of a backstab. There's very little middle ground with its reception, but one thing both sides agree on is that playing Souls with friends needs to be, well, doable. As it stands, creative summon sign placement and prayers to the server gods are your only ways of joining a friend's game, which is a coin flip at best. Technological hurdles aside, it isn't a terribly difficult idea. Helping a friend through a difficult portion is perfectly in line with the Souls mentality€”the ethereal connections between worlds€”and would do wonders for the social aspects of the game. Set a would-be Soapstone aside for it (because who knows what will trigger multiplayer this time around), queue up a friends list or simply add in a PSN invite€”whatever the means, Bloodborne could use a party feature.

5. Greater Equipment Variety

As is the case with virtually every competitive gaming scene, Souls PvP is dominated by only a handful of character builds, despite a wealth of options for the actual building. The reason for this is one games like Diablo 3 and The Elder Scrolls: Skyrim are intimately familiar with: demonstrably better gear. This is reflected in single player playthroughs by a single choice of equipment standing out as the only sensible option from a statistical standpoint. The problem here is not that some armor is better than others, or that certain weapons outclass lower-level versions; that's to be expected of RPGs. Things become monotonous, however, when a certain setup becomes the de facto end goal for a character, when one particular equipment arrangement is unassailably better than another. Weapons should be tiered, certainly, but not necessarily so stringently that adopting a different play style can only be done by sacrificing combativeness. The role-playing aspects of the game€”customizing a character to fit your vision of them, not the invisible "you must be at least this buff to ride" sign set outside every boss€”are limited by this as well, as a visually striking armor set may very well be on the low end of gear. Everyone will never be happy with the equipment layout; someone will always want what they call the prettiest setup to be stronger. But beefing up the options and offering more, and equal, choices at a given power level would help to prevent pigeon-holing characters.

4. Bigger And Badder Bosses

There is a clear and definable standard for what constitutes, beyond just a boss fight, a Souls boss fight, one set by the likes of Tower Knight, Gaping Dragon and Manus, Father of the Abyss. It's not simply a matter of how hard they hit or how big their health bar, but a quality stemming from an imposing presence capable of instilling a true sense of disbelief. It's adapting your play style to meet this boss€”to dodge its tail, assail its massive paws, stay wary of its devastating wide-range attack and so on. And quite frankly, the many iterations of "A Dude In Armor" seen in Dark Souls 2 just aren't up to snuff. Bloodborne is built upon a premise of disease and mutation, one which has already borne countless and increasingly hideous abominations. Where in there does your run-of-the-mill swordsman qualify as a proper boss challenge? That's beneath you, Bloodborne; break out the half-spider people, the scaleless dragons and the undead armies. Go bigger, and if at all possible, as eldritch as you can.

3. Let There Be Miyazaki

Director Hidetaka Miyazaki is largely to thank for Demon's Souls and Dark Souls, while two newcomers€”Tomohiro Shibuya and Yui Tanimura, who were hand-picked by Miyazaki€”piloted Dark Souls 2. Meaning no offense to Tanimura or Shibuya, their turn at the reins resulted in an experience, while stellar, somewhat lacking in the atmosphere its predecessors delivered. With Miyazaki returning to the helm for Bloodborne's development, it will be the deciding factor in whether his directorship is the source of that ambiance. Fortunately, Miyazaki has already taken to the PlayStation Blog to explain his intentions with Bloodborne. More aggressive and dynamic combat, a new emphasis on exploration, and an undying sense of new€”he's made some big promises already, and has the résumé to back them up. All From Software needs to do now is let him run his show.

2. It Has To Be Hard

If game reviews were limited to one word, you can bet Souls games would spark arguments of plagiarism. Crushing, brutal, unforgiving, difficult, relentless€”they've been called many things, but at their core, they are hard. Interestingly, merely being hard has gained the series much of its fame. In an age where games so frequently hold their players by the hand, it seems gamers were eager to be thrown to the wolves once more, and From Software delivered. So you can bet that with this and any subsequent Souls installments, players will riot if they don't risk breaking their controller or their thumbs. We're already picking out plexiglas and notably rage-proof cases for our TV; don't waste them.

1. Surprise Us

We're three games deep in this series already; it has firmly established its angle and offer, meaning everything hereon is just pushing the envelope further and further. The last thing From Software needs to do is be predictable, to release what is effectively the same game with a larger number stapled to the end. Players want plenty from Bloodborne; if you haven't noticed, we just covered that. But games are at their best when they do the unexpected, when they turn once tired ideas on their heads or build a new style of their very own. If nothing else, Bloodborne needs to do that, to stand out and hold its own, not lean on the pedigree of its name. Let's not have Souls go the way of Final Fantasy, eh? Do you have high hopes for Bloodborne? Let us know what you want to see in the comments below!

In this post: 
Bloodborne
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A freelance games writer, you say? Typically battling his current RPG addiction and ceaseless perfectionism? A fan of horror but too big a sissy to play for more than a couple of hours? Spends far too much time on JRPGs and gets way too angry with card games? Well that doesn't sound anything like me.