Bottom 10 Most Underrated Games of All Time
In a community built on reputations, it's hard for some games to bounce back and earn the fame and fortune they really deserve.
Some games just plain suck. Everybody knows they suck. But others, well others just get a bad reputation. In a community built on reputations, it's hard for those games to bounce back and earn the fame and fortune they really deserve. These are ten of those games... 10. Clyve Barker's Undying (PC)
Brought to us by one of the true masters of modern terror, Clyve Barker's Undying gave the player an great mix of FPS action and suspense from the get go. This classic story of a haunted mansion put the player in the somewhat magical shoes of a psychic detective, with the unique ability to "scrye" past events or phantasmal presences by focusing his energy. Also, despite his job description, he wasn't a new age pansy ass, so he carried a six shooter with him at all times. Like every true horror, the game utilized suspense and disbelief to a great degree. Often, you might find yourself shooting at shadows. Though I played the game years ago, a single moment still stands out to me a clear as day as a representation of the kind of true suspense the game gave players. I was walking down a hallway. At the end of the long hallway I approached a dresser, which caused my "scrying meter" to glow, indicating it had some other worldly connections. I "scryed" at it, causing a ghost to appear in front of me. I shot several shots before realizing it was a mirror, then spun around and shot several more into thin air, as if bullets would hurt a ghost anyway. I was then totally empty on ammunition. The game was chalk full of moments that challenged the gamer's self control and the eventually their coordination, as the game became more focused on the FPS aspect in the second half. Unfortunately, Undying never really took off. Critics gave the game generally favorable reviews, but there simply wasn't enough focus on the shooting for FPS players, and it had too much shooting for people looking for a good survival game. It was truly unfortunate that more people didn't get a chance to live through this terrifying mystery.
9. Descent (PC)
Descent was a game that came inches from totally changing the gaming world. At its heart, Descent was an FPS. But, it was unlike any other FPS of the time, because it wasn't a two axis game. Players piloted a space ship through an asteroid mining station. Because the game took place in space, and therefore had no gravity, the action took place in an environment with no established up or down. It was confusing, disorienting, sometimes annoying or nauseating, and innovative. It gave the gaming community a whole new look on what the FPS was capable of. In a time where games like Duke Nukem 3d and Shadow Man (both good shooters, but nonetheless totally uncreative) dominated the market, Descent offered something totally unlike what had come before. Descent received excellent reviews from pretty much all sources. Critics and gamers praised it for all these reasons and more. However, sales couldn't keep up with more popular (and ultimately more approachable) competing titles. Descent's makers through a few sequels together, but none got the attention that the original received, and the IP eventually faded into memory. It was years before the FPS genre made any real changes to the formula with the introduction of Halo's new approach to shooters. Had Descent's inventive system of play been more popularized, it could have influenced the way FPS games were made for a whole generation of systems.
8. Freedom Fighters (Xbox, PS2, Gamecube, PC)
Few things are as easy to pull off as making a game about the US being invaded by Soviet Russia. Throw together an alternate time line, add some dramatic orchestra music, toss in a few AK-47s and a statue or two of Lenin and BAM, you've got a game. And to that end, Freedom Fighters didn't really do anything all that special. It was, in essence, a videogame version of Red Dawn set in the early 2000's. What Freedom Fighters did do though was make an amazing squad based 3rd person shooter with a solid narrative, believable characters, and a combat system that gave the perfect mix of fun and realism. Yeah, it was actually all of that. What the game didn't include was a decent revenue. Critics almost unanimously rated the title in the 9/10 range, but it never got the sales it deserved. The game did enjoy a moderate amount of sales on PC, but the console versions of the game just couldn't hack it against games like Halo and GTA, which were absolutely dominating the market at the time.
7. Beavis and Butthead (SEGA/SNES)
Just typing the game's name makes me smile in memory. It was easily one of the most challenging and diverse titles available on the Sega Genesis/Megabox. In this pseudo-side scroller players took control of either the fart wielding Beavis or the belching Butthead. You spent the entire time attempting to gather all of the pieces of your shredded GWAR concert tickets by running around town and avoiding random crap being thrown at you by passerby, because apparently people really just hate the shit out of Beavis and Butthead. But the game was deeper than a basic side scroller. There were levels of racing, platformer levels, and heavy combat zones. And, the game required players to do a small amount of point and click style puzzle solving based on collecting objects and interacting with the environment. In essence, it was the only side scroller/ adventure game ever made. Also, GWAR! This game was a landmark in pop culture crossovers. Not that there hadn't been a million videogames made about movies before. But, this was the first time that a game based on some other piece of pop culture was both good AND creative in its own right. With solid voicing, a great soundtrack, a sense of humour honest to the series, and graphics that were actually quite high quality for the time there was nothing bad about this game, other than it was mind numbingly hard. Of course, you know where this is going. Critics hated it, giving it as low as at 5/10 score. The one exception being the level design. To this day, the sewer level of Beavis and Butthead is cited as one of the best examples of level design in the history of gaming. That's the history of all games, ever. As in, it's as good as Mario. The game did see pretty decent initial SNES and Genesis sales based on the popularity of the show, but the sales quickly dropped off as the word got out that it apparently sucked.
6. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem (GameCube)
Seriously, write off every other survival horror game, and just buy this one. There are no others out there that compared with it. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem was everything that a game should be. It had true terror, suspense, the jump out of your chair moments, and it truly rewrote the book on how to dick with the player's mind. Throughout the game, the main character's sanity would fluctuate based on insane things they might encounter (say a half dead, half dessicated zombie crawling on the ceiling). The more crazy shit you saw in the game, the crazier the game would get. By the time you were at full on poop-eating madness, the game's volume would be constantly increasing/decreasing, flies and other bugs might appear to be crawling on the screen, rooms would appear upside down, and a slew of other very creative ways of not only messing with the character, but also the player. Requiem killed it in the reviews. Pretty much every critic that played the game told the world that it was amazing. However, since it was GameCube exclusive, and not very heavily marketed, it saw very little in the way of commercial success. It remains one of the best games of its genre and one of the most shining examples of how console exclusive game development hurts the art.
5. Gangland (PC)
To be fair, Gangland wasn't really all that special. This PC title about controlling a fledgling mafia empire came out in a time when simulators and 4x RTS games were starting to become quite popular. It followed a fairly predictable pattern. Players start small, bullying local shop keepers for money with hired goons. Eventually, players are extorting entire cities, building illegal gambling operations, and going to all out war with other bosses in the area. There was nothing too creative about the idea. However, it was still a ton of fun to play. The game captured the perfect mix of cartoonish violence, economic management, and novelty. Critics didn't really think so, though. Gangland received a couple decent scores from more generous reviewers, but the majority of publications saw it as boring. Additionally, sales lagged well behind competing titles. It was essentially a failure on the part of the developer. None of that changes the fact that it was still an intensely fun game for any gamers looking to live out their dream as a crime lord.
4. Hybrid Heaven (N64)
Though Hybrid Heaven did decently in Japan, it bombed hard in the western world. This JRPG/action title for N64 followed the adventures of some kind of secret agent as he.....um....investigated.....um a secret lab, I think? And, there were bad guys. And, someone was a robot in the end. Or, were they a clone? It's all kind of fuzzy, as Hybrid Heaven's subtitles and extremely convoluted narrative style made the story almost impossible to follow. Despite that, the game was still extremely fun. The basic idea was that you control a very muscular Brock Sampson looking secret agent, who uses a bubble gun(?) or something to shoot out cameras, and then body slams monsters. Yeah, the last part really sold the game. As you ran from room to room in an underground facility, you were constantly under attack by monsters of some kind. But, rather than using a dynamic combat system that would have actually fit with the game's 3rd person roaming style, the developers decided to use a kind of turn based pro wrestling combat system. The idea was that each time an enemy attacked you, you would enter a combat mode. The combat would then consist of the opponents waiting for their energy to charge (which gave attacks more power, and increased defensive ability) then hit a button to begin attack mode. THEN, you would choose a ridiculous wrestling move like power bomb, back suplex, or arm toss from an equally ridiculous list of attacks. THEN, the attack would commence and you would wait as the computer did that math and played the combat animation. God, it was convoluted, but GOD it was funny as hell to play. It was like being the guy in a rubber suit in a Japanese monster movie. Not surprisingly, Hybrid Heaven was not hailed as the next big game by reviewers. In fact, they let everyone know how much it sucked, and by their actions prevented countless youths from just pissing themselves with laughter.
3. Star Wars: The Old Republic (PC)
We've all seen the recent news. SWTOR is going free to play. It's the latest in a seemingly endless line of MMOs to just get murdered by WoW. Of course, 900,000 active players isn't at all bad, but in a world where WoW clocks in at 10 million, it's hard to call SWTOR a victory for Bioware. Despite its lacking sales, though, SWTOR is arguably the best MMO ever launched. Compared to its predecessors (at launch) Old Republic offered hundreds of hours of more gameplay, better PvP, a much more interesting leveling experience, immersive stories, unique class stories, amazing cinematics, amazing group quests and dungeons. If this game had come out in the same year that WoW had been launched,it would have devastated Warcraft with extreme prejudice. I've always wanted to say that. Were I 19 years old again, I would gladly be failing out of college right now, because I would be too busy playing SWTOR all day, every day. Sadly, I'm not 19 anymore, and I simply don't have the time to play an MMO. However, if I did, I know which MMO I'd play. Sadly, what killed SWTOR was its own high expectations. Bioware thought they could compete with WoW, and set up their game to serve millions of players. Instead, the game's high cost and large number of servers left each server feeling empty. And, an empty feeling MMO is a dying MMO. And though WoW deserved and received critical acclaim, it's already looking at ways to recoup losses, because so few people are playing it.2. Doom Troopers: Mutant Chronicles (SEGA/SNES)
You may remember the name Mutant Chronicles from the absolutely amazing/terrible action movie of the same name. It was important, because it starred the Highlander. That's really all I remember about it. Doom Troopers is based on the same fictional universe as the aforementioned awesomeness. Doom Troopers was a side scrolling action/shooter that really challenged the norms. At a time where shooters still consisted of actual dots floating across the screen as bullets or plastic guns, Doom Troopers delivered gory, angry, fast paced action. The Sega version was the superior product, so we'll talk on that one. Considering the technology available, Doom Troopers looked freaking amazing. Enemies exploded into fountains of sinew and guts upon being shot, animations were smooth, and each level had a unique look. Players took control of one of two intergallactic badasses (how are neither of those words in spell check?) that kick around on different planets, shooting the ever living crap out of demons. The basic gameplay was similar to any other shooters: run, jump, shoot. Players did some platforming, some gunning, and a lot of ammo collecting. But, three things set Doom Troopers apart. First, DT had realistic bullets. Rather than dots floating out of your guns, when you pulled the trigger, something on the other side of the screen instantly got shredded with lead. This tiny change greatly affected the gameplay by eliminating the wait between cause and effect, and added to the realism (something we'll touch on later). Second, Doom Troopers was straight up bloody. It was unnecessarily bloody. I mean, it was like, "seriously, there's just no call for that" bloody. In the first level alone, players had to build a bridge by shooting enemies in the face and walking on their corpses, and fight enemies that were impaled on giant pikes. Why they chose to impale themselves, I'm not sure, but it made for a gruesome spectacle. Finally, Doom Troopers aimed for an adult audience in a time where games were seen primarily as entertainment for children. Sure, kids played it, but it was clearly a game that was marketed at a more mature audience. As with all the games on this list, Doom Troopers didn't fair very well. It was seen as both run of the mill and simply too difficult. It was pretty damned hard, to be fair. Critics also railed it for not having a lot of replay value, but action games from that era rarely did.
1. Alpha Protocol (XBOX360/PC)
Let me start off by saying, "yes, I know Alpha Protocol had a lot of bugs and lacked the polish of many Triple A RPGs." Let me follow up on that by saying, "bite me." Alpha Protocol got the shit end of the stick in a lot of ways. Immediately upon being released,this modern day spy story/action RPG was hounded by reviewers from multiple reputable sources. Several publications tore it down as being flimsy, weak, poorly designed, or anything else that would just sound like a crappy game. Sure a 6/10 might not be bad for an indie game or the first major title for a new developer, but this was Obsidian's brain child. It was supposed to be a shoe in for 9/10 slots and RPG of the Year awards across the board. So, if it sucked so hard, why is it at the top of the list for being underrated? Well, mystery solved, it actually was an amazing game. Alpha Protocol may have started off a bit rough, but beyond the rough patches was one of the best RPGs made. Players could truly choose how they wanted to progress through the game. Everything from combat style, to morality, to interaction with side characters could be written exactly as you wanted it. I played through the game 5 times, and I still never experienced the same story twice. Why? Because the players actions dictated how the game played out. Since the game's story is based on a spy, players spend a substantial amount of time interacting with different contacts around the world. How you choose to interact with each character affects their opinion of you, and how the level plays out. You can choose to ally, alienate, or kill pretty much anyone you wish, which then affects the story accordingly. And I don't mean the game might then allow you to see a different cinematic at the end. I mean that your conversations may allow you to choose if an NPC becomes a level boss or a future friend. Players also had several styles of play to choose from. Since the game is an action shooter at its heart, you could take the old run and gun approach to levels. Or, if you wanted to be a bit more respectful of the idea of sentient life, you could get through many levels without any combat at all, or at least very little. And the skill system allowed stealthy players to still be combat effective when thing went sideways, with a series of hide and seek based combat abilities such as being able to pop out and instantly fire 4 pre aimed shots, as long as you are using a pistol. Alpha Protocol was exactly the direction RPGs should be moving, but its lack of polish made many shortsighted reviewers dismiss it, and prevented many gamers from getting too deeply involved. In essence,it's the definition of being underrated. It had everything you could want from a game, but it was put in a crappy package that turned people off.