Call Of Duty: Every Game Ranked From Worst To Best

The battle to end all battles...

Call Of Duty Franchise
Activision

Like FIFA, Madden, Football Manager and WWE 2K games, Call Of Duty has ascended to a kind of brand permanence that means it will sell every year no matter what they do with it. They can move as far away from the original concept of a historical war epic as they like - even jumping to space and cyborg warfare - and fans will still flock. Luckily, they usually know exactly what they're doing.

Their releases, including this year's Infinite Warfare, are finely sculpted things of beauty, and testament to their years honing a product for a very specific fanbase. And they might mix things up, but they know the value of sticking to core spirit.

The franchise is considerably bigger than the "core" games already released, with mobile only games, stripped down console alternatives and handheld releases that tend to get overlooked whenever anyone sees fit to talk about the franchise's best (and worst) moments. But ignoring every release is doing the franchise a disservice, because it's a mega-brand that deserves to be considered for both its merits and its failings.

Now that Infinite Warfare is out, this is the perfect opportunity to look back on the longest-running, mega-selling warfare franchise to work out exactly which titles deserve the biggest bragging rights.

Honourable Mention

Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare Remastered

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare Remastered
Activision

It's brilliant, it looks gorgeous and it has new multiplayer elements, so if this wasn't just a Remaster of one of the best COD games already on the market, it would absolutely be up towards the top of the list.

But we can't just start handing out accolades for remasters unless they're completely transformative.

So what of the rest? Here's every single Call of Duty game ranked from worst to best...

21. Call Of Duty: Black Ops: Declassified

Call Of Duty Black OPs Declassified
Activision

Even the very greatest games have to have a worst entry, and unfortunately Black Ops: Declassified feels a lot like the console it was released on, the PS Vita.

The Vita has never been given the focus it deserves by Sony, so it sits as a sort of remainder to the main event: a hugely impressive handheld that has never had a really great run of games, with some good ideas that have never been allowed to play out.

This Vita exclusive was released the same day Black Ops II came out, as a sort of prologue to the game, expanding on the universe. Unfortunately, the developers seem to have used the handheld platform as an excuse to short-change players, with a campaign that's about an hour long and a story that is numb-headed.

And it's not like the Vita couldn't cope, it's just more like they didn't try to let it.


20. Call Of Duty: Strike Team

Call Of Duty Strike Team
Activision

Call Of Duty: Strike Team sought to bring a whole new experience to COD players, with a top down mode that is well suited to mobile play. It's actually quite ingenious, but it isn't really enough to put the game up there with any of the best COD games.

Strangely, it's the first person shooting element of Strike Team that is its weakest element: if the game were just limited to the top down tactical view, in which you guide your strike team with an overhead drone, it would have been a nice little companion piece. With the first person shooter element, it feels a little like the developers are pushing too much for this to be considered a "real" COD title.

In trying to please too many people, the developers actually distracted from their good idea, and that's a real shame.


19. Call Of Duty: Zombies & Black Ops – Zombies

Call Of Duty Black Ops Zombies
Activision

It wouldn't really be right to distinguish the two mobile games released under the Call Of Duty Zombies - they're basically the same game, taking advantage of the mass appeal of Zombies on the full versions of the game. Developers Ideaworks

Both games are parred down, simply infectious zombie survival shooters, not bothering with complex narrative or controls and relying on an easy enough control system and three difficulty levels. It's nowhere near the immersive experience of the full games, but it's entertaining all the same.

You can also play in co-op, which is a great addition to mobile gaming. It's a little annoying that microtransactions play a part, but that's going to be the future of COD gaming at every level now.


18. Call Of Duty: Black Ops DS

Call Of Duty Black Ops DS
Activision

The full version of Black Ops is great (spoiler alert) and it's almost a shame Activision decided they had to release a companion for the DS, because the developers simply didn't do the full version justice. It very much feels like a hack-job done by someone who didn't really get why the full game works.

The Story Mode is no way near as assured as the excellent, intelligent work of Black Ops, but the levels themselves are reasonably engaging. And there is something to be said about their variation in design and gameplay. They're just not very well bridged.

Graphically, the game is best described as idiosyncratic, but the multiplayer element is a great inclusion, and so too is the Zombies sub-game. It's not quite as polished as the Modern Warfare DS version, but it's still a pleasant enough handheld experience.


17. Call Of Duty 3

Call Of Duty 3
Activision

What a way to endear yourself to your franchise's original fans: Call Of Duty 3 was a controversial game thanks to the decision not to release it on PC (because Treyarch hadn't worked on the platform previously). Add to that the fact that it was in production for just 8 months - and by God does it show - and you've got the recipe for a poor game that was a terrible follow-up to the excellent Call of Duty 2.

With advancements more recently like Black Ops III, Infinite Warfare and Modern Warfare before them, the lack of courage shown in churning out COD 3 is even more stark. Sure the predecessor worked well, so reinvention entirely would have been a gamble, but adding a lick of paint and a poor campaign was not a smart move.

The mission types were unimaginative, the AI was terrible and the glitching was off the chart. That's what you get for not catering to PC gamers.


16. Call Of Duty: World At War – Final Fronts

Call Of Duty World At War Final Fronts
Activision

Final Fronts was a strange release, coming well after most people had moved on from the PS2, and at a time when Modern Warfare had basically reinvented what it meant to be a Call Of Duty game.

This was the PS2 version of World At War, developed by Rebellion rather than just Treyarch trimming the full game and releasing a lie. Unfortunately, though clearly capable of making great PS2 games, Rebellion fudged the landing with Final Fronts, relying too heavily on cliches.

The result is a limited, paint-by-numbers Call Of Duty with some great moments of fun. On their own, they're all well and good, but the direct proximity to Modern Warfare was particularly damning. It just felt like you'd picked up an expansion of an older COD title, with ruinously brain-dead AI and a general lack of the top level of gloss you'd expect.


15. Call Of Duty: Ghosts

1274836

Ghosts should have been great: it debuted on new consoles and had no excuse not to use the new technology to the fullest. Unfortunately, Infinity Ward dropped the ball somewhat, releasing a fairly tired game with a painful lack of innovation in the campaign mode and fatally not taking advantage of the visual advances at all.

This was definitely a low point for campaign longevity of play: it clocked in at an insulting four hours for anyone who would be bothered to play it, recycling ideas and feeling very much like a perfunctory tag-on for the multiplayer, which was admittedly a lot better.

Activision may have an excuse in the fact that they didn't know what the next-gen consoles could do, but Ghosts is probably even more critically disappointing because of what it could have been had the developers really flexed their muscles.


14. Call Of Duty: Finest Hour

Call Of Duty Finest Hours
Activision

Treyarch might not have wanted to acknowledge as much when they made Call Of Duty 3, but COD was originally a PC game, and it was too advanced to be ported over to the PS2 generation without taking a lot away to fit.

Activision decided on a compromise, asking Spark Unlimited to create a spin-off for console players instead, and the result offered a more compact, smaller-scale World War II version of the PC version. It still managed to do justice to the Call Of Duty name too, even if direct comparison didn't serve it too well.

Finest Hour had a strong solo player campaign, but it was the multiplayer that really shone, allowing 32 players to gun it on the XBox version and 16 on PS2. Back in 2003, that might as well have been a thousand players on endless maps of infinite size. Even now, it's an impressive number.


13. Call Of Duty 2: Big Red One

Call Of Duty 2   Big Red One
Activision

Some may sneer at Big Red One as a parred down version of Call Of Duty 2 for the outgoing XBox and PS2 generation, but it's actually a pretty good stand-alone experience. The game focused on a single group of soldiers - the 1st Infantry Division (Big Red One, hence the name), and while it cannot compete directly with its "big brother", it was still a worthy wielder of the Call Of Duty banner.

There was also a great voice cast, including Michael Cidlitz and Rock Gomez - who had played significant roles in HBO's Band Of Brothers - and Mark Hamill as the narrator. This was no second thought.

It's a simpler game, and playing it back now feels like a window into an entirely different time for shooting games, but it was definitely rewarding and it's nice to go back to a time when such care was taken for a dead generation of consoles. It's almost unthinkable that they'd bother now.


12. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

Modern Warfare III
Activision

If Modern Warfare is the most popular of all of the Call Of Duty sub-series, the third entry in the series is definitely the least popular. It actually represented the point the series started to lose fans, as the lack of originality started to be particularly noticeable.

The solo campaign felt most like a secondary thought (aside from an obligatory attempt to out-No Russian No Russian with the terrorist attack sequence), the visuals were showing their age thanks to the end of the last generation of consoles and the multiplayer maps were mostly forgettable.

For a modern COD game to mostly miss on such key features was almost unforgivable, but there are moments that redeem it, certainly and it is perhaps only less fondly remembered because it came after such great ones.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.