Dark Souls 2: 10 Improvements That Must Be Made

Dark Souls 2 The announcement of Dark Souls II at the 2012 VGAs was greeted by fans with both great enthusiasm and also, I think it€™s fair to say, a little bit of uncertainty, even worry. Original creator and lead designer Hidetaka Miyazaki was stepping down as director and passing on the reins to Tomohiro Shibuya, who said he wanted to take the series in a more mainstream direction. There€™s no doubt that the original Dark Souls was one of the most intense and (some would say sadistic) gaming experiences of 2011. Brutal and uncompromising it in its bleak environments, obtuse storytelling and challenging boss fights, Dark Souls was clearly not for everyone. Those who persevered would have experienced a richly engrossing game and a deep (though ultimately obscure) story. Dark Souls was hard but fair in its difficulty, rewarding perseverance and careful progression; all in all an experience one was not likely to forget. Yet, no one would argue that it wasn€™t without its problems. Let€™s look, then, at ten improvements that should be made to Dark Souls II that would make it an even more memorable gaming experience.

10. Improved Frame-Rate

The original Dark Souls was capped at 30fps on console, although as anyone who€™s travelled to Blighttown, New Londo Ruins and other busy areas will tell you, that could drop to as low 15fps as the game creaked under the weight of its own slightly outdated engine. Casting certain spells and pyromancies (Fire Whip, for example) also slowed the frame rate down to a crawl, making the game unplayable and spoiling player immersion in the process. It€™s a no-brainer, then, that for Dark Souls II, From Software should look to improve the game€™s frame rate in order to avoid sudden dips and troughs performance wise that take players out of the fantasy.

9. A Less Obscure Story

Dark Souls II This had me thinking for a while, because while I personally liked not being handed every single story beat on a plate, it€™s also true that I found myself shifting through countless YouTube videos just to try and make sense of the lore (I did have a blast doing so though). Scratching the surface of the story meant talking to NPCs (and even some of the bosses), while bits and pieces of the lore of Dark Souls are buried within the brief descriptions that came with all the items, rings and weapons. There is a deep, fascinating story in Dark Souls; it€™s just a pity that most players won€™t even be able to begin deciphering it, or won€™t bother doing so. From Software have already confirmed that the story in Dark Souls II will be made clearer to players, though I for one hope that they do not take away the mystery of it completely. There is a fine line between removing over-complexity and stripping away important elements of lore, and it must be navigated smartly.

8. Better Graphics

Dark Souls A At the risk of sounding shallow, the original Dark Souls impressed more in the art direction department than on a purely technical level. User made PC mods aside; the game just doesn€™t look as pretty on console as some of its contemporaries. Happily, From Software (and consequently Edge, who had the distinction of being treated to a 10 minute demo) has confirmed that Dark Souls II will far excel its predecessor in terms of looks. This is thanks largely to a brand new game engine that Tomohiro Shibuya, Dark Souls II director, has helped build at From Software. What this new game engine will mean in terms of actual gameplay, is still up for speculation, but From Software has already said that in terms of graphics, Dark Souls II€™s visuals will come "tantalisingly close" to being hyper-realistic. Hopefully, that's not just hyperbole to sell advanced copies...

7. Improved Dual Wielding

Dark Souls Dual Wielding As in Demon€™s Souls, dual wielding in Dark Souls was largely unpractical except with a few exceptions, and working out the correct weapon combinations was largely a case of practicing to see what worked and what didn€™t. For example, in theory you could wield a rapier or a spear in your left had in order to jab at an enemy, catching him off guard while you then delivered the killer blow with a heavy weapon in your right hand. However, due to the poor stun to hit ratio on the left hand, enemies were hard to stagger, and attempting to dual wield could backfire on you. For the most part, you were better off using a shield in order to block/parry. For Dark Souls II, From Software should look to implement a proper dual wield system in which a large combination of weapons can be used, and where enemies are easier to stun/stagger. The developer has already hinted that it wants to make subtle changes to the combat system on the whole, though I doubt they€™ll want to stray too far from the tried and tested formula of the original.

6. Joining/Leaving Covenants Should Carry More Weight

Dark Souls Covenenants Covenants was an integral, if slightly hidden, feature in Dark Souls, where people could join different factions by swearing certain oaths to specific NPCs. The result of this was players were rewarded with diverse items and abilities. If you joined the Chaos Servant covenant, for example, you were rewarded with the Great Chaos Fireball pyromany spell. Certain covenants also affected online play and interactions. Once a player became a member of a covenant, he or she could deepen their allegiance to it by offering humanity and/or other items. However, there seemed to be little or no consequence to joining or indeed leaving covenants. I for example was able to simply hop from covenant to covenant while on a playthrough, and was not punished in any obvious, tangible way (or if I was, the game did not make it clear to me). Shibuya himself has already said that he felt covenants were a little bit difficult to fully absorb and experience in the original game, and that he intends to make it more accessible to the player in the sequel. Expect a bit of an overhaul in the covenant system in Dark Souls II, then.

5. Greater Environmental Interaction

dark-souls-impressions-600x300 Among the new additions and changes that a brand new game engine should deliver, one of these should surely be improvements to the game environment and a player€™s interaction with the world they€™re immersed in For example, (and destructible pillars in the Smough-Ornstein boss fight aside) Dark Souls featured almost no destructible environments that the player could plough through. Imagine, then, being able to wield something akin to Smough€™s hammer, and to be able to smash up bits of the environment (walls and pillars for etc.) and bring them down on enemies. Or imagine making your way through terrain that shifts and moves, forcing you to be quick on your feet. Exploring the different realms and areas of Lordran was no doubt a fascinating and deeply immersive experience, and From Software managed to create a huge, compelling world for us to lose ourselves in. But as was mentioned before, there was very little interaction with the world itself (aside pulling the occasional lever, opening a door or climbing a ladder). There were also little annoyances like not being able to mount small steps in the environment, forcing you to take the long way around to reach the higher ground. More interactive environments such as Sen€™s Fortress (giant rolling rocks, wall traps, deadly swinging guillotines) or Northern Undead Asylum (were the ground literally crumbles beneath you) would be welcome in the sequel. Hopefully, Dark Souls II€™s new game engine will make this possible.

4. More Varied Boss Battles

Dark Souls Boss Fight Though the actual design of the bosses varied, the fights themselves followed a very similar pattern, which required the player to learn a boss€™s movement and thus learn when to attack and when to run and when to summon players to help you deal with some of the more difficult ones. One of the few exceptions to this was the Bed of Chaos boss fight. Not a direct fight, the Bed of Chaos battle was more about evading its attacks and being wary of your environment as you made your way towards the areas protecting its weak points. It was a welcome change of pace from the hacking and slashing of the other boss fights. Dark Souls II could take this even further by offering up greater variety of boss fights, where not every encounter needs to be decided by brawn alone. Variety is the spice of life after all.

3. Selling Your Gear

Dark Souls Undead Souls are currency with which you buy spells, items, armour and weapons in Dark Souls. However, you couldn€™t actually sell your unwanted items back to vendors or merchants, and the result of which was that players had to either drop these items or consign them to the bottomless box at a bonfire, never to be used again, which seemed a little like a sloppy oversight. You could give items and titanite fragments to Snuggly the Crow at the Northern Undead Asylum or Kingsseeker Frampt in exchange for other items, so why not have vendors who accept your unwanted loot in exchange for souls? Perhaps this is something that Dark Souls II could incorporate into its trading system, and come inline with most other RPGs in the process.

2. A Return To Dedicated Servers

Dark Souls dropped the dedicated servers that its predecessor Demon€™s Souls used in favour of a peer to peer system, which meant that everyone could play with anyone anywhere at any time. This meant that it was very difficult to players to find the same pool of core people to play with over and over; this might have been From Software€™s intention, but it certainly seemed to annoy quite a few players if a scan through the forums is anything to go by. Imagine being able to find friends rather than random players. Imagine being able to put down a soapstone specifically for them and not having to worry about some random stranger accepting the summon sign before your pals can get to it. Some might argue this is counterproductive to the sense of loneliness and isolation From Software wants you to feel while playing the game, but the idea of being able to play online with your friends is certainly an attractive one. And fans who want to see a return to Demon€™s Souls€™ dedicated servers rather than Dark Souls€™ P2P system will be happy to learn that they are making a return in the sequel. Shibuya is quoted as saying €œSetting up a dedicated server lets you retain your data, making it easier to share it with other players. We'd like to evolve the asynchronous message-oriented online support from the previous game; we're imagining a framework where players are able to directly interact with each other€. A return to dedicated servers could mean a more integral online experience were friends will be able to meet up to help vanquish each other€™s foes. It would be also good to see From Software fix some of the glitches with soapstones in the original game, namely soapstones randomly appearing and disappearing, problems with summoning other players and the occasional lag that presents itself when two or more players meet up in game.

1. World Tendency/Morality System

Dark-Souls-2-logo-600x300 A return to dedicated servers could also mean the return of the world tendency system from Demon€™s Souls. This was a kind of morality system where players€™ choices and actions during the course of play had a knock on effect on the world around them. Killing major bosses shifted world tendency towards White, while dying and/or killing either players or NPCs would shift it towards a state of pure Black. This influenced (among other things) the game€™s difficulty, number of souls dropped by enemies and one€™s attack power when in soul form. The idea of having a morality system such as World Tendency may not be unique to Demon€™s Souls (though arguably no one has implemented it in as an idiosyncratic a manner as From Software), but the act of having your actions have real time consequences on the world around you is a fantastic way of adding greater depth and immersion, as well as a tangible sense of having to weight up choices and act on them accordingly. Here€™s hoping, then, that Dark Souls II sees the return of the World Tendency system in some form or another. So there you have it: my top ten changes that I believe would make Dark Souls II a richer and even more memorable experience than its predecessor. A few of these issues are already being worked on by From Software; others they may only have in mind or perhaps not thought about. One thing is for certain though. Dark Souls II will be a gaming experience that fans will not soon forget. This list is by no means exhaustive, of course, and a lot of people out there will no doubt have their own lists of things they feel need bettering or want to change in Dark Souls II. Let us know what they are in the comments below.

Contributor

John Henry is a mild mannered journo by day but an absolute film nut by night. Go on, ask him a film related question...