Dungeons And Dragons: How To Create The Perfect One Shot
Condensing a full adventure into a single night is no picnic. Follow these tips & save the day!
Dungeons and Dragons can often be an intimidating game to crack into. The three base books alone offer nearly 1,000 pages of information to sift through in order to fully understand the base mechanics without digging into any of the tactics and improvisation needed to play the game in real-time.
That being said, it's the most popular tabletop RPG in the world for a reason. A streamlined character creation suite and action economy have removed much of the stigma from the game for players. Once someone's settled in, the game fits like a glove.
But what do you do if complacency sits in? If a Dungeon Master just wants a break from the world they've established and have been running for months? Or perhaps a player wants to experiment with becoming a DM for the first time and is feeling some trepidation about making the leap? Then a one-shot is just what everyone needs.
One-shots are just that: an adventure that's contained within a single evening's session, ideally. These games can offer up the chance for new versatility, themes, or campaigns to be explored without being committed to the ideas.
That being said, it doesn't hurt to have a plan before delving into a fast-paced adventure. Here are 7 tips to help get the most out of a One-Shot.
7. Working On The Railroad
One of the first pieces of advice pretty much any Dungeon Master will receive is to avoid what's called railroading. This is the process of forcing your players into a narrow story, limiting their options to tell the story you want to tell. But there's a slight secret to D&D: a little bit of railroading never hurt anyone. A totally open sandbox can work sometimes, but players often thrive when the narrative has a clear-cut goal the players can approach.
When it comes to a 1-shot, you've got a single night to pull off a beginning, middle, and end to the story. Having the players reject the call to action in favor of other activities may work in an open-ended campaign where entire sessions can be devoted to shopping, but that's not what's happening here.
Don't be afraid to give players a nudge in the right direction to get the game underway. It might feel a bit more restrictive than your traditional style, but with a single night to complete a narrative, dungeon masters need to be mindful of the time allotted. And frankly, anyone who is given a one-shot that's presented a clear path on which way to go and soundly refuse to do so aren't creating a good narrative contract with their dungeon master. If players expect you to build a game, it's reasonable for the DM to expect players to play it.
6. Cutting Room Floor
One of the most precarious situations a dungeon master can place themselves in is becoming too attached to singular ideas within a narrative. Recognizing what works and what doesn't in your story is one thing, but recognizing what is essential is quite another.
DMs can be endless fonts of ideas and concepts, which normally can fuel a good D&D game for months on end. In the context of a one-shot, however, that very trait can come back to bite them. It's often said that the one thing a dungeon master cannot prepare for is their characters. That's going to be especially true in a one-shot, when players are using all-new characters, who may have thought processes or idiosyncrasies the DM had no way to prepare for.
Being a good dungeon master means coming to the table prepared for an adventure. But being a great dungeon master is being able to look at the clock, determining if everything you've planned will fit within the time constraints, and making on-the-fly decisions to cut nonessential content.
If done well, players will never know that they're missing out on anything and enjoy a seamless adventure from start-to-finish.
5. Puzzling Matters
Dungeons and Dragons is a game that, at its best, is the sum of its parts. Certainly there are parties of murderhobos that just want to ruin everyone's day with a well placed axe to the face. Similarly there are amateur thespians who relish deep role play and intrigue who don't wish to sully themselves with combat.
For the most part, however, players and DMs alike will get the most out of a well-balanced game. One that includes role play sufficient to understand the motivations of the characters, combat that raises the stakes, and traps and puzzles that can pose obstacles that can't just be solved through traditional means.
As nice as all of those things are, puzzles oftentimes can be the bane of a one-shot. A complex brainteaser that puts the group in mortal peril, or a devious riddle that puts a halt to forward progress can grind the game down to a halt. Remember, players aren't emblematic of their characters; the Wizard might have a 22 intelligence, but Jeff is sitting there rocking an 11.
Puzzles, riddles, and their ilk certainly have a place in the game, but be extremely cautious about whether or not their use will interrupt the flow of the game more than it challenges the party. Failing to do so may result in a game that is ultimately left incomplete, and a table of unsatisfied adventurers.
4. Don't Sweat The Backstory
If a D&D campaign is The Lord of the Rings Extended Cut Trilogy, a series of sprawling epics told carefully down to the last minute detail, then a one-shot is John Wick: taut, purposeful, and nary a wasted movement. Chances are, you enjoy both movies for different reasons. The same can be said here.
One of the most satisfying parts of Dungeons and Dragons is taking the time to really dig into a character, discover their pathos, learn who they are, what makes them tick, and seeing them grow and develop as they go about their life of heroism.
Characters in a one-shot do not have such a luxury. Players oftentimes come up with a "build" rather than a character. They're looking to experiment with new class combinations or abilities they've not used before and may, at best, have a brief story of who they are, perhaps a quirk or two that can be introduced in-game.
The fact of the matter is that time is against everyone at the table. Do not feel obligated to really dig into character pathos that are only meant to last a single night. If the players find a particular affinity to the character, they may bring them back around for more adventures. But for a one-shot, the story is the party is king.
3. Take Of The Kid's Gloves
Similar to X-COM 2, Dungeons and Dragons delves into the world of permadeath. Depending on the levels and capabilities of characters, when someone dies, they may not have a way to come back. There is a very narrow ledge to walk for all parties involved. The dungeon master's responsibility is to make challenging, but achievable encounters for the players to overcome without feeling like they were handed victory on a silver platter.
Not so in a one-shot! Provided that the narrative calls for it, the Dungeon Master now has the opportunity to really test not just the characters, but the players themselves. If these characters are only designed to last a night, why not put them in some truly horrific situations?
Think of a one-shot as a safe space where everyone is allowed to cut loose in new and interesting ways. Don't forget this mentality can go both ways: players, knowing their characters won't be used again, are going to have every intention of expending every possible resource in their arsenal to accomplish the task at hand.
Players and DMs alike may find a particular exhiliration in knowing that the threat of failure is very real in the game. If there was ever a time to see how a group reacted to a TPK, within reason mind you, don't be a jerk to players just for the sake of it, then this is the opportune time.
2. Clear A Path
A reliance on combat in D&D can only get a player so far. The rest of the time, victory will be granted by two things: a judicious use of spells, if the party has them, or skill checks. These checks are tied to the attributes of players and determine how good they are at certain physical or mental attributes. A powerful barbarian with a +7 to Athletics is suited for breaking open the door to a sealed library while the +9 Investigation Wizard can subsequently discover ancient tomes.
While all of this is happening, the Bard is lying to the librarian about the noise and succeeding with a +13 modifier of course, because Bards laugh in the face of your skillchecks.
However, skill checks in a one-shot can be a double-edged sword. Specifically if they're tied to storyline progression. If the Dungeon Master is counting on that Wizard to roll a high Arcana to decipher the forbidden tome's texts and accidentally summon the endgame boss, what happens if they roll a Natural 1?
Dungeon Masters must be extremely cognizant not to make it impossible to advance in the game due to a single bad dice roll. There are plenty of other times when players can conduct skill checks that might result in trouble, decreased rewards, or angering NPCs, but a single roll should not automatically mean game over.
1. Shock The System
One-Shots are a unique beast. They go against the very nature of Dungeons and Dragons, which is designed to be a long-form narrative collaborative play. While that may be the case, that doesn't necessarily mean it's a bad thing.
The first thing a Dungeon Master and their players should ask is why they are choosing to deviate from the original play style they've established. One-shots, as previously stated, are a chance to have fun, be fearless, take chances.
If your traditional game is full of political intrigue, make the one-shot about bumbling orcs. If it's a lighthearted romp, go for a gothic setting with horror undertones. Similarly, players who are used to memorizing dozens of spell mechanics may enjoy the chance to turn their brains off and become barbarians. A player who exists in a support role may be forced to step up as the face of the party.
This gives everyone at the table a chance to enjoy some new tactics, new combinations, and new settings. At worst, it may reinforce the things everyone already enjoys. On the flip side, it may result in some surprising discoveries at for your group not just about the characters, but the players themselves.