E3 2018: 6 Ups & 6 Downs From EA's Conference
Anthem still fails to convince.
Start your engines, folks. E3 is well and truly underway with the EA Play conference kicking things off on Saturday evening, and it's fair to say that the show was, well, a bit of a mixed bag.
EA's E3 conferences have been almost universally mediocre over the years so that's not terribly surprising, though considering the long-awaited titles they had the opportunity to show off, it's pretty shocking how counter-intuitive the show's structure and delivery often seemed.
There were at least some neat reveals and even an intriguing nod to what the future of the gaming industry may hold, though huge chunks of the show were basically skippable and didn't offer up too much of interest for the majority of people watching.
It's not a sterling start to E3, but a number of compelling low-key announcements nevertheless ensured it was far from a disaster. It won't be ranking highly among conferences this year - at least surely not? - but it wasn't a total waste of time either...
Downs...
6. Star Wars: Jedi Fallen Order Gets Clumsily Announced...For Holiday 2019
It's been known for quite some time that Titanfall developers Respawn Entertainment are working on a Star Wars game, and during EA's show studio head Vince Zampella gave a rather off-the-cuff confirmation that the game would be called Jedi: Fallen Order and is aiming for a holiday 2019 release.
Zampella further added that the game would revolve around the Jedi "during the dark times", as they're being hunted down in-between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope.
Considering how buzzed-about this project has been, it's a bit naff to not even have Zampella come on stage and introduce the game with a cinematic teaser trailer or even just a logo. He stays sat in his seat and just casually reels the information off like it's nothing.
Plus, considering the game's not due out for around 18 months, they probably could've waited a little while longer before announcing it, no?
5. Command & Conquer Is Back...As A Mobile Game
Good news, Command and Conquer fans... sort of. The much-loved classic RTS franchise is getting its first instalment since 2012's free-to-play browser game Command & Conquer: Tiberium Alliances...but it's back in the form of a free-to-play, competitive mobile RTS.
A painfully overlong live play session showed off the game - complete with agonising shoutcast commentary - and didn't inspire much hope it'll do anything different with the well-worn mobile game formula.
It remains to be seen how the game's inevitable monetisation system is implemented, but regardless, it's depressing to see a brand franchise reduced to this. More to the point, the E3 stage is just the wrong place to reveal a mobile game, especially as it followed a lengthy sports segment.
4. Not Enough Battlefield V
Considering that it's basically an E3 tradition for the next Battlefield game to take up a substantial portion of EA's show, it was pretty shocking that Battlefield V only showed up for a few scarce minutes.
Granted, EA did confirm that the game will also be featured during Microsoft's show. Even so, beyond showing off a few snippets of gameplay and confirming the introduction of a much-requested new mode (but more on that later) as well as the absence of loot-box nonsense, it was a pretty flat showing for such a mainstay EA franchise.
3. Anthem Still Looks Stunningly Boring
EA capped off their show with a "deep dive" 20-minute segment devoted to next year's much-anticipated new IP Anthem, which was first introduced at last year's E3.
Sadly, this presentation's unwieldy combination of cinematic trailer, panel discussion, concept art slideshow and a gameplay footage reveal still didn't convince that Anthem's going to be anything more than another generic open-world multiplayer shooter.
From the hilariously cliched trailer dialogue ("There's a storm coming"), to the distinct Destiny clone vibe, excess of concept art on display and lack of much new compelling gameplay, this just wasn't the fully-fledged coming-out party the game needed.
It didn't help that the segment was wildly overlong - padded out with Twitter questions and recycled gameplay footage - but at least the devs did confirm that the game won't contain any lootboxes, and it'll release on February 22, 2019 (the same day as Days Gone).
Though EA still has 8 months to get the hype train running full speed, they really should've had more to show than this.
2. Too Many Sports Segments
Without question the most complained-about aspect of EA's show every year is the obscene amount of time they devote to covering sports titles, which sports fans are going to buy every year regardless of them appearing at E3. These segments are typically in order to appease investors, while doing very little for the majority of mainstream gamers.
Though EA were at least smart enough to spread these segments throughout the show rather than fill out a long, boring block with them, sporting games still had an excessive presence in an already middling conference that wasn't all that interesting.
That's without mentioning the expected devotion to eSports, which was about as cringe-worthy as you'd expect (nothing against eSports as an activity, but it's painfully uninteresting during a conference).
1. No Sign Of Skate 4 (Again)
After the Skate 3 servers were switched back on this past week for the first time in many years, speculation ran rampant that EA would be announcing Skate 4 during their show.
Sadly, that didn't happen.
It seems like an especially cruel move to turn the servers back on so close to E3, as this ignited significant and very understandable hope that the long-awaited sequel might finally be on the way.
Considering how the skating game genre is pretty much a festering wasteland in the wake of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5's failure, this game is agonisingly overdue. Next year, maybe?
As irksome as these elements of the show all were, though, EA's conference wasn't without its easy positives. Here's what worked...
Ups...
6. Battle Royale Is Coming To Battlefield V
Battlefield V may have had a surprisingly scant presence at the show, but at least we got formal confirmation of the least surprising news in the world: Battlefield V is getting a Battle Royale mode, which will be revealed later in the year.
Though we're probably going to hear at least a dozen or two BR modes announced for new games throughout E3, the large-scale chaos of Battlefield lends itself especially well to the ultra-popular game type.
If they don't end up calling it Battlefield Royale, well, they've really missed a trick.
5. Unravel Two Exists & It's Out NOW
Unravel is one of 2016's best games that nobody played, but apparently it sold well enough regardless to warrant the surprise reveal of a sequel, Unravel Two.
Looking every bit as adorable as its predecessor, the sequel has an added wrinkle: co-op play (though sadly only locally). Though players can play the entire game solo, co-op will allow another player to play a blue variant of Yarny and team up to tackle puzzles.
As great as all this was, the clincher is that the game was made available immediately for PS4, Xbox One and PC, making it the first official shadow-drop of this year's E3. Considering how last year's E3 had little in the way of insta-releases, it's hugely encouraging to see EA dropping a megaton like this.
Plus, costing just £15.99 on PSN and £17.99 on EA Origin, it's a total bargain. Shame about the lack of a Switch version, though.
4. Star Wars: Battlefront 2 Is Getting Clone Wars DLC
To their (very minor) credit, EA didn't just brush the Star Wars Battlefront II controversy under the rug while shilling new DLC for the game, and held their hands up regarding its botched launch.
In addition to announcing the introduction of squads and several new gameplay modes, it was confirmed that the Clone Wars, a much-loved aspect of Star Wars lore that hasn't yet been explored in Battlefront II, will be arriving by way of some DLC later this year.
Characters such as General Grievous, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Count Dooku and Anakin Skywalker will be included, alongside the planet Geonosis featured in Attack of the Clones.
Though many clearly fled the game after its appalling launch, news like this just might be intriguing enough to lure some of the sceptics back.
3. Origin Access Premier Is A New PC Subscription Service
It's looking increasingly like Netflix-style subscription services are going to become the next big boom in gaming media consumption, as evidenced by EA confirming Origin Access Premier.
OAP (heh) is a Game Pass-like model for PC, which will allow subscribers to play EA's big new AAA games, such as Madden 19, Battlefield V, FIFA 19 and Anthem. What's more, they'll be able to start playing these games roughly a week before they release conventionally.
Though the service certainly won't be for everyone - the lack of Xbox support is disappointing though understandable, and there's no guaranteeing EA will put enough games on it to demonstrate high value - it's definitely nice to have more options. It'll cost $99.99 a year or $14.99 a month, though international pricing options haven't yet been revealed.
The way things are going, don't be surprised if most of your gaming spending goes into maintaining half-a-dozen subscription services a few years from now.
2. Sea Of Solitude Is An Intriguing EA Original
Once again proving their steadfast commitment to their EA Originals label, EA revealed their latest new indie title, Sea of Solitude. Developed by German studio Jo-Mei, the third-person adventure game apparently revolves around the theme of loneliness, causing a young woman named Kay to become a monster. The game's goal, it seems, is once again revealing her inner humanity.
The game's clearly steeped in allegory, and its writer-director Cornelia Geppert noted that Sea of Solitude is based on some of her own personal experiences.
Though it's easy to get exhausted by the sheer glut of "artful indies" that seem to release every month, this certainly looks like a cut above the average, and considering the typically high standard of the EA Originals that get revealed at E3, it's easy to be confident about this one.
1. Andrea Rene's Fresh Hosting Job
It's a common complaint about EA's shows that they're presented in a dry, stodgy format not by gamers or "real people", but businessmen in fancy suits instead (looking at you, EA CEO Andrew Wilson, who ironically didn't wear a suit this year).
EA smartly made the choice to appoint a somewhat hipper, more down-to-Earth host this year in the form of What's Good Games' Andrea Rene. Though Wilson did pop by occasionally to talk shop and Rene was sadly absent from most of the show's middle, it was still refreshing to have a younger, more appealing presence presenting the show, especially as her passion for games is well documented.
It's a shame the show itself wasn't more convincing, but hey, she did a good job with what she had.
What did you think of EA's E3 conference this year? Shout it out in the comments!