E3 2018: 8 Ups & 5 Downs From Sony's Conference
The Last of Us Part II looks incredible.
The pressure was certainly on Sony after it became increasingly apparent that most of the prior E3 conferences were, honestly, a bit on the soft side (if not flat-out disappointing).
Megaton reveals were in frustratingly short supply from EA, Microsoft, Bethesda, Square Enix and Ubisoft, and with countless expected games pulling no-shows, Sony could've decisively "won" E3 just by dropping even some pretty mediocre teasers for these titles.
As it turned out, Sony's show was also a bit of a mixed bag itself. Though the focus on four main tentpole games made a lot of sense, like last year's show it lacked the oomph of 2015 and 2016, instead settling for being a pretty standard, shock-free E3 presentation.
Granted, it's an awkward time in game development as this generation begins to wind down and both Sony and Microsoft start prepping their next-gen consoles, but jaw-dropping announcements have nevertheless been in short supply across the board at this year's E3. Your move, Nintendo...
Downs
5. The Awful Show Format
In a rather misguided attempt to give E3 viewers and attendees a unique experience this year, they opted to kick the show off in a church-like tent before unveiling the first gameplay footage from The Last of Us Part II.
At the conclusion of this segment, the live attendees were ushered into a more familiar convention hall, grinding the conference to a halt for over 10 minutes as people were shepherded to the next room and livestream viewers were forced to just listen to airless discussions and recaps.
The decision to try something different was a bit of a bust, to be honest, and seemed stilted, awkward and even a little confusing. Sony has proven in the past that they can bring the house down with a more conventional conference - just look at 2015's "Year of Dreams" - so why tinker needlessly with a winning formula?
4. Remedy's New Game Looks Like Quantum Break 2.0
Max Payne and Alan Wake developers Remedy Entertainment finally revealed their much buzzed-about new game, a supernatural shooter called Control.
Though the visuals look undeniably gorgeous, it's hard to ignore the fact that the game seems incredibly similar to their previous effort, Quantum Break, what with its protagonist's environment-manipulating powers and the near-identical aesthetic.
As such, the game seems a little on the lazy side, as though it's been quickly cobbled together with pre-existing assets in order to cut corners financially following Quantum Break's failure to become an A-list smash hit.
Perhaps Control can improve upon their previous game's messiness, but this trailer was ultimately pretty underwhelming given the hype surrounding Remedy's mystery project.
3. All The Missing Games
After a number of the prior E3 conferences failed to deliver the games fans were hoping to see, fingers were firmly crossed that many of these highly-anticipated games would end up showing during Sony's conference.
Sadly, that mostly wasn't the case.
A disappointingly high number of buzzed-about games were completely absent from Sony's show, therefore ensuring they completely sat out E3 this year: Square Enix's Avengers game, Rocksteady's rumoured Superman title, the new Splinter Cell, Mortal Kombat 11, Final Fantasy VII Remake, Shenmue and the MediEvil remake
Perhaps most alarming of all was Media Molecule's Dreams, which was used to create animated continuity segments between game reveals, but didn't actually appear in its own right (beyond a brief demo in the conference's post-show).
Sony made it clear they were focusing on four major games this year, but there was surely room for at least a few of these games to make an appearance, no? Incredibly disappointing.
2. The Overly-Scripted Spider-Man Gameplay Demo
Sony closed their show with new gameplay footage from Insomniac's Spider-Man game, and while the demo certainly conveyed the game's agreeably light tone and impressive visuals, it also furthered concerns that it's going to end up too scripted for its own good.
The sequence shows Spidey arriving at The Raft, the maximum security prison housing the world's most dangerous supervillains, and before long, the baddies start staging a chaotic prison break.
As Spidey desperately battles to keep the likes of Electro, Rhino, Scorpion and Vulture at bay, the set-piece is heavily reliant on simple contextual button prompts, sacrificing player agency for a focus on over-the-top acrobatic manoeuvring.
That's not to say that the game won't be fun, but considering the already significant fan anxiety that it will feature too many QTEs, this flashy gameplay segment was a poor choice. A demo that greater exemplified player freedom would've been far smarter and more interesting.
Insomniac claims these intensely scripted moments will be fairly infrequent, though the footage they're showing off seems to suggest otherwise. Fingers are crossed, but at least we don't have too long to wait to find out, as Spider-Man releases on September 7.
1. The Lack Of Major PSVR Announcements
Though at last year's E3 Sony showed off surprisingly strong support for PSVR, this year things were a little different, and honestly a bit worrying.
Sony announced just five PSVR games during E3, three of them in pre-conference announcements (Tetris Effect, Ghost Giant and the long-awaited Beat Saber), while the show itself only saw reveals for Rick and Morty creator Justin Roiland's new game Trover Saves the Universe and FromSoftware's first VR game, Déraciné.
With Sony recently stating that VR growth was "below expectation", the total lack of significant, AAA VR titles on offer was incredibly disappointing, and perhaps suggests that the platform's going to largely subsist on smaller indie titles and "experiences" for the remainder of its tenure.
What they showed off looked fun, sure, but where's the investment in large-scale, big-budget games from recognisable brands that fans have been expecting?
Though Sony's conference wasn't the greatest, it still offered up its share of great moments. So, here's everything Sony got right...
Ups
8. The Last Of Us Part II Looks Gorgeous, Brutal & Progressive
Sony opened their presser with the first glimpse of actual gameplay from The Last of Us Part II. The sequence begins with a flashback, as Ellie is led onto a dancefloor by her love interest, Dina, and after the pair share a passionate - and beautifully rendered - kiss, the scene shifts to the grim present.
Here, Ellie is making her way through a rainy forest while trying to remain hidden from her armed pursuers. She stabs a man in the throat, and things only get more ultra-violent from there, as she uses both her bow-and-arrow to fell enemies and some intensely brutal melee combat after being discovered.
Unsurprisingly, the game looks like an absolute technical powerhouse that'll push the PS4 to its very limit. The movement mechanics look ultra-slick and fluid, and though some might take umbrage with the game's disturbing approach to blood-letting, Naughty Dog is clearly picking a tone and sticking firmly with it.
It remains to be seen how this seemingly quite scripted moment will play out when the game finally releases, but the AI and stealth systems are certainly looking spectacular as expected.
Plus, a not-remotely-forced gay kiss in a AAA video game? How can you not like that?
7. Call Of Duty: Black Ops III Is A Surprise PS+ Game
During the awkward break as live conference attendees were herded into the main convention hall, we did at least learn that Call of Duty: Black Ops III is being immediately released as a bonus "free" PlayStation Plus game.
In addition, it was confirmed that four fan favourite Black Ops maps - Jungle, Summit, Slums and Firing Range - will be getting shiny remakes in the upcoming Black Ops IIII.
And better still, if you pre-order BO4, you'll be able to play those four aforementioned maps in Black Ops III also. Sure, BO3 is far from the best Call of Duty game, but as a neat little surprise that's part of your PS+ dues, it's pretty cool all the same.
6. Resident Evil 2 Remake Is FINALLY Revealed & It's Coming January 25, 2019
Almost three years after it was first announced, Resident Evil 2 Remake was finally unveiled during Sony's presser, with a reveal trailer that showed off the new character designs for protagonists Leon and Claire, some of the classic RE2 iconography fans know and love, and also the Resident Evil 4-esque over-the-shoulder camera.
Weirdly, Sony dropped a far superior, shorter trailer for the game after the show (below), which placed a greater emphasis on actual gameplay. Though the new Leon and Claire designs are already dividing fans, and some will be disappointed at the lack of fixed camera angles per the original game, the gameplay and graphics sure do look fantastic.
Plus, fans don't have too long to wait, as the game will release on PS4, Xbox One and PC on January 25, 2019. Expect more details to follow in the coming days as Resident Evil 2 Remake will be playable on the E3 show floor. Get hype.
5. Ghost Of Tsushima Is A Beautiful Samurai Game
Sucker Punch's new samurai IP Ghost of Tsushima was revealed at Paris Games Week last November, and we got our first glimpse of actual gameplay during Sony's show.
The footage confirmed that at least part of the game will take place during a Mongol invasion, as the protagonist climbs atop his horse and rides through the lush countryside.
Inevitably, of course, a swordfight breaks out against multiple foes, who all meet grisly ends. The most memorable moment, however, is unquestionably a one-on-one swordfight underneath a beautifully rendered, well-weathered tree. Leaves are blowing all over the place, and it's certainly one of the few things we've seen this E3 that could comfortably pass for next-gen.
It remains to be seen whether or not Sucker Punch has learned from Infamous Second Son's problems - fun though it was - but this certainly feels like an encouraging step forward.
4. Kingdom Hearts III Gets A Pirates Of The Caribbean-Themed World
Rather than just recycle that awkwardly-edited Kingdom Hearts III trailer once again, Sony's conference had something a little different to show: confirmation that the game will feature a Pirates of the Caribbean-themed world.
Moreover, Captain Jack Sparrow himself and a number of the franchise's other memorable characters - namely Elizabeth Swann and Will Turner - will appear, rendered in decidedly more lifelike detail than the cartoonish style of the game's other worlds.
The world will allow players to partake in naval combat while piloting the franchise's iconic vessel the Black Pearl, and though the game's framerate still seems disappointingly choppy during intense action sequences, the actual mechanics and homages to beloved properties do seem absolutely on-point.
3. Death Stranding Gameplay Is Eyeball-Melting...And Totally Confusing
Perhaps the most hotly anticipated gameplay reveal from Sony's show was that of Hideo Kojima's Death Stranding. Though the 8-minute sizzle reel indeed showed off the eye-popping beauty of Horizon Zero Dawn's Decima engine, concrete plot and gameplay details were still incredibly thin on the ground.
Most of the gameplay sequences showed Norman Reedus' protagonist Sam walking through a series of beautiful yet desolate locales, with a closing hint that - shocker! - stealth will be a major component of the game. The final moments show Sam using a baby-powered device (!) to detect malevolent supernatural entities in the vicinity, which ultimately capture and overcome him.
Kojima has suggested that death isn't a game over in Death Stranding, though, and the curious lack of emphasis on combat and gunplay is especially interesting.
That's not to forget that the trailer also revealed that Spectre's Lea Seydoux will seemingly play the currently unnamed female lead, and Emmy-winning character actress Lindsay Wagner (The Bionic Woman), who despite being in her late sixties in real life, appears here as a much younger version of herself. Could she be Sam's wife, or even his mother?
In typical Kojima fashion, the trailer raised more questions than it answered, and though some might express frustration with the lack of information about the plot, gameplay mechanics or even a release window, the game's sure shaping up to be another ambitious brain-scrambler from a master of the medium.
2. Nioh 2 Is Coming
One of the more surprising left-field reveals was the announcement that a sequel to last year's cult action PS4 RPG Nioh is in the works. The brief trailer didn't really show off much of significance, but it at least confirmed that Team Ninja is back for the follow-up, so there's every reason to expect another intense, fiendishly challenging experience.
Sony's show may have been lacking many significant megaton surprises, but this was a neat little treat all the same, all the more so considering the general lack of pre-E3 speculation about it.
1. Making Daily Announcements Leading Up To The Show
One of the better and more forward-thinking choices Sony made this year was to make five smaller announcements in the five days leading up to their E3 conference.
This was great for several reasons: for starters, it made the agonising wait for E3 to kick off a little less tough, and it also allowed these games to have their own moment rather than get swallowed up amid the bombast of the more significant gameplay reveals.
What were the announcements, you ask? A PSVR Tetris game, Tetris Effect, is on the way from the Rez Infinite devs; Days Gone releases on the increasingly-crowded date of February 22, 2019; Life is Strange devs Dontnod's new game is a psychological thriller called Twin Mirror; Fe developer Zoink's new VR game is Ghost Giant; and Star Wars-themed rhythm game Beat Saber is confirmed for PSVR.
None of these announcements would've blown the roof off the actual E3 show, and though they could've easily slotted into Sony's ultimately low-key conference, it was probably better for the games themselves to have their own delineated time in the spotlight.
What did you think of Sony's E3 conference? Shout it out in the comments!