EA Sports UFC 2: 10 Essential Fixes That Must Be Made

From creating female fighters to refining the controls, EA's got a lot of work to do.

It must be tricky to recreate the complex brutality of mixed martial arts in game form; boxing is difficult enough as it is, but throw in the wildly diverse disciplines that make up your average bout of MMA and things get really complicated really quickly. Brazilian Jiujitsu, Taekwando, Judo, these sports bring so many different moves and styles into the cage that programming it all into one seamless fighting game must be like trying to reconstruct the Eiffel Tower out of sausages. In the dark. THQ and developer Yuke's came damn close with the UFC Undisputed franchise - they surprised us all with the first one, and got progressively better until the third iteration in 2012. And then THQ imploded in a cloud of financial ruin and unpaid bills. Fight fans got quite excited (and a little skeptical) when EA picked up the suddenly-homeless UFC license, and all were thrilled and amazed throughout the development process as EA Canada teased us with the awesomeness that was in production. After all, EA Sports MMA, their first attempt at the genre, was an impressive debut - and fans expected good things. When EA Sports UFC finally showed up on store shelves in June this year it came charging out of its corner looking bloody fantastic. Muscles rippling and flexing under the skin, flesh compounding under the pressure of countless powerful blows, the blood and agony spattered across fighters' faces - hell yes, this is what next generation gaming was meant to be like. But after the beauty pageant was over, things turned out to be less spectacular than first impressions had led us to believe. It wasn't bad, not like Fighter Within bad - in fact there is a lot to love about it - but EA Canada had promised so much and let fans down in a number of ways. Critical ratings reflected our disappointment, and it wasn't long before sales figures began to stall. Make no mistake, EA still pulled in the cash with EA Sports UFC, but you can't help but feel that EA Canada could have done better. Instead of just spitting out negative sentiment though, lets take a look at where they went wrong and what they can do to turn things around for a potential sequel. Oh, and this is EA Sports - you can be sure there'll be a sequel.

10. Fine-Tune The Stand-Up Game

Let's start off with a tricky one. The stand-up aspect of EA Sports UFC is something of a paradox - it's somehow both too fast and frustratingly sluggish at the same time. A lot of real MMA fights decay into an all-out brawl, a blur of reckless bar-fight swings, but in EA Sports UFC when things go thermonuclear in the octagon, something about it just feels a little... odd. It's hard to pinpoint exactly what the problem is, though; perhaps it's the dynamic skeletal animation system not working exactly as it should; could be the unnaturally similar trajectory of spammed strikes; either way, when you see two fighters firing off sets of ten consecutive left hooks without a pause, you're quickly reminded that this is a video game, not an actual fight. Watching these men trading blows in the middle of the octagon with the crowd cheering and the lights flashing, it's easy to overlook the inaccuracies of the animation system and strike mechanic. But that's because you're so busy wrestling with the controls that your brain has begun to melt. It's when you take your tattooed bruiser off to the gym to go through the stand-up training drills that you first notice the crippling lag that handicaps the striking. The issue carries through to the fights themselves, once you're aware of it - there's a discernible disconnect between button inputs and actual strikes. If EA Canada hopes to turn EA Sports UFC into a long term contender for the fight crown, they're going to have to rework that for the sequel.

9. Career Mode Diversity

Often a developer will try to disguise weak or shallow gameplay by hiding it under a thick blanket of unnecessary features and career-path sidetracks that no one cares about. Essentially bloatware - mini-games, superficial extraneous game elements and pointless sideshow activities that add nothing of substance to the game and serve only to distract you into thinking you're dealing with a weighty career mode. Nobody wants that. But EA Canada possibly took things a little far in the opposite direction with EA Sports UFC, giving us a somewhat anemic career campaign to slog through. There needs to be a balance between clutter and tedium. A competitor in the UFC, like any major sport promotion, has more to his or career than simply fighting and training. The addition of a selection of behind-the-scenes, out-of-ring features, random scripted events and management-related decisions to be made which can alter a career, that sort of thing can make a longform single-player element all the more immersive without swamping us with trivial nonsense. Also, within the career, if there could be some level of control over training - making it entirely optional, for starters - that would be great, thanks.

8. Gender Equality For Career Mode

If you've seen the stunning (and deadly) "Rowdy" Ronda Rousey in action inside the octagon, you will know that the fairer sex has more than earned a place in the UFC. Rousey and the rest of the hard-as-nails girls who run rampant in the UFC Women's Bantamweight Division have proven that this isn't just a man's sport anymore. With the addition of a Women's Strawweight Division on the way it looks like this isn't just a passing phase - the ladies are here to stay. And rightly so; seeing gender equality in a sport like this shows young girls in the gaming audience that anything is possible. All of this makes it particularly strange that it was decided to turn the EA Sports UFC career into a boys club. Let's be generous and assume that it was purely because there aren't enough women involved in the UFC at the moment to create a fully realized career campaign. But with two full divisions to play with things should look a lot brighter for their inclusion for the EA Sports UFC follow-up. These girls are just as exciting to watch in the octagon, if not more so, and you can be sure that a large portion of the UFC gaming crowd would relish the opportunity to create a female brawler and guide her to championship gold.

7. The Devil Is In The Details

Make no mistake, EA Sports UFC looks incredible. In certain instances still screenshots of the octagonal action can look almost photo-realistic. There is an seam of authenticity which runs throughout the game's aesthetic that should be applauded. But gamers are never entirely satisfied, and so, dear EA Canada, for the follow-up we're going to have to demand that you go to even greater lengths to make things look, feel and sound like the real thing. The character models are already better than almost anything out there, but there is a bit of work to be done on their facial sculpting - their vacant eyes are especially disconcerting close up - and their animation routines could do with some fine tuning. It's not all about the visuals, though, but the small details which add texture and flavor to the action. Things like the post-match celebrations, which currently start to repeat within only a few matches and quickly grow tiresome. What about post-match interviews, or some level of interaction between fighters other than the actual fight; in real UFC matches you will often see them acknowledging one another, or even the victor checking that his opponent is ok after a career-ending knockout or choke. EA Canada needs to work on filling the gameworld with the small things, those background elements which make a game really come alive. Corner-team variety; more organic pre-fight sequences where the fighters stalk back and forth waiting for the bell; improved particle physics for persistent blood on the mat; these are the things which blur the line between game and reality.

6. Custom Full Names For Career Fighters

This might seem like a fickle thing to complain about, but it needs to be addressed all the same. We're now at a level where our gaming hardware is capable of some truly amazing feats - these sleek black boxes have the processing power of a supercomputer from a few years back, and we expect great things from them. So can someone please explain how, in an age when we can land a space probe on a moving comet or print functional bodily organs, we can't figure out a way to program readable custom full names for sports games? You've spent hours crafting a wishful replica of your sexy self to take along the gaming career path, plastered him with dodgy tribal tattoos and sent him out for his UFC debut. Looking good so far. And then, just as you're being sucked into the authentic atmosphere in the octagon, you hear Bruce Buffer on the microphone... "In the red corner, this man is a kickboxer, weighing in at 165 pounds, fighting out of California, USA... Bulldog!!!". And suddenly you're reminded that you're not a professional MMA fighter. You're a chubby kid sitting on your couch with a gamepad vibrating in your hands. And your name is Bulldog. Why? Because no one has come up with a foolproof method of getting the announcers and commentators to include your name in their dialogue. Whether its a clever bit of coding that allows in-game voices to "read" any name fed into the game, or a way to submit your name to be added via DLC, or, at the very least, just a hugely expanded roster of preset names to choose from, this is a problem which plagues all sports games, and it needs to be taken care of.

5. Instant Replays

EA Canada did an incredible job recreating the brawlers who make up the UFC roster. At the time of launch the EA Sports UFC character models were considered among the most stunningly authentic of the current generation, and even to day they stand out for their lifelike skin textures and muscle structure. They're beautiful to look at, so you have to wonder why the developers didn't include a proper instant replay feature so that we can examine these beasts in glorious slow motion. The editable, saveable replay system of the more recent Fight Night releases proved a killer feature, perfect for capturing those nose-cracking, brain-damaging knock outs and deadly combinations, so why not implement the same for EA Sports UFC? The highlight reel that plays at the end of each round, and in its entirety at the end of a fight when it's time for the judges to score the bout, does a good job of replicating the television broadcast feel of the UFC, but it's not enough. The unpredictable nature of MMA means that there will be many random moments throughout a match which you'll want to see again and again, not just the three strikes that a programming algorithm has decided were the key moments of the fight.

4. Deeper Stamina System

The absence of a traditional health bar is one of the game design decisions which shapes the way we play MMA games. The sometimes chaotic, random nature of a UFC fight means that there needs to be room for sudden changes of fight balance, shocking flash knockouts and so on, so the usual health meter just won't suffice. The stamina mechanic which takes its place works well, but needs to be developed and expanded in key areas to bring us closer to the real thing. The most essential tweak needs to be a persistent stamina drain based on specific limbs you're using. This needs to carry through both striking and absorbing strikes, as well as specific pressures applied during ground work and the clinch. They've already added a few good ideas, like how your fighter struggles to defend against head strikes when he's been rocked by a few thunderous body blows, but this needs to be refined. Ideally they need to implement a stamina system which removes the incentive for strike spamming - right now a lot of the stand-up game boils down to a flurry of one-sided head kicks. Limb fatigue (both from giving and taking strikes) should last right through the fight, and possibly even bleed through into your career post-fight if severe enough.

3. Expanded Creation Features

Not everyone enjoys (or even bothers to use) the suite of creation tools which come bundled with WWE titles, but this deeply customizable system opens a whole new world for those who've taken the time to get to grips with it. Professional wrestling is a far more flamboyant form of entertainment than the UFC, so it is probably better suited to over-the-top entrance sequences, custom championships with user-designed belts, outfits and arenas, but EA Canada needs to carry at least a touch of that over to the MMA realm. In EA Sports UFC your creation options are limited to the bare essentials by today's standards. Noone don't expect EA Canada to take it to WWE extremes, but they really could flesh it out a little for the next franchise entry. At least implement a deeper level of facial construction variables - the available selection of preset mugs makes it tricky to build a fighter who doesn't look like a grumpy caveman who's just been told an offensive joke. Add a few stadium entrance options to tweak (and for heaven's sake, give us a few more worthwhile songs to walk out to), perhaps an option to create fight camps, and they'll be on to a good thing. It's all about allowing gamers to create an MMA experience that is uniquely their own.

2. Severe Injuries And Doctor Stoppages

To borrow (and then bend) a quote from Snatch's Turkish, "this isn't a tickling contest, these lads are out to hurt each other". Statham's character was talking about unlicensed boxing, but the same rings true for mixed martial arts. Yes, there are rules in the big leagues of the UFC, but this is a ferociously violent sport - blood is spilled, bones break, people slump lifelessly to the mat. EA Sport UFC brings this brutality to life in vivid streaks of crimson and sweat. But there are aspects of the damage model which should be taken further in the quest for realism. To be fair, the cuts and bruises which form on the fighters during a bout are a massive improvement over what has come before. Only after continued play does it start to become repetitive, slowly revealing that these battle wounds are not being generated as procedurally as first thought. From a gameplay perspective, the biggest omission is that there don't seem to be any broken bones anywhere to be seen, or medical stoppages either. You could spam your opponent with roundhouse head kicks until the blood is pouring from his face like the Niagara Falls, and still no one steps in to check that his brain isn't leaking out of his skull. Doctor stoppages don't happen a lot in reality, but they happen. Similarly, if you saw Uriah Hall's toe bone sticking out in all kinds of bad ways at UFC 175 you would know that proper injuries can change the course of a fight - and a fighters career - and this should be taken into account for EA Canada's next effort.

1. Streamlined Controls

This has to be EA Canada's most difficult issue to address. Why? Because the insanely complicated control system of EA Sports UFC is at once the most glaringly obvious problem, and the one problem which no one seems able to get around. THQ's take on MMA gaming had the same problem; EA Sports MMA made a few minor steps to simplify matters; but EA Sports UFC has to be one of the most vexing, brain aneurysm-inducing controller layouts of all time. You can't be too harsh on the developer though - in reality mixed martial arts is a sport of instinct and adrenalin, but in video game form it becomes a process of complicated, calculated input sequences. Where your average beat-em-up places all its emphasis on perfectly tuned stand-up striking gameplay, an MMA game needs to incorporate striking with fists, elbows, knees and feet, from normal standing position, from the clinch, and on the ground, as well as the intricate inner workings of grappling, wrestling, and more, across a number of fight disciplines. And so what you're left with is a game which uses every button on the latest consoles' fancy new gamepads, with the exception of the "start" and "menu"-type buttons. And not just one button at a time: often its a combination of three inputs at once, just to pull off one unremarkable move. Fans are quick to complain, but what are the other options? Is there any fathomable way to implement submission holds, clinch transitions, ground superiority struggles and the rest without calling the gamepad into action in its entirety? There's no solid solution right now, but if EA Canada can conjure up some way to streamline even just a few of the gameplay elements they could dramatically improve the MMA gaming experience. They built a strong base with EA Sports UFC, so lets hope that they can build on it for the sequel. What else do you want fixing from EA's latest effort? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Game-obsessed since the moment I could twiddle both thumbs independently. Equally enthralled by all the genres of music that your parents warned you about.