Fable 4 Officially Announced: 10 Things To Return The Series To Greatness
The biggest open secret in gaming is officially on its way.
The next game in the beloved but shaky Fable game series has been an open secret for many years, with devs old and new tweeting publicly about its existence at Playground Games. So for many people tuned in to the development of this game, the appearance of the company's name in the short trailer at the end of the Xbox Games Showcase was the telltale sign that we were finally getting the game rather than the very recognisable guild seal imprinted on the sword in the forest.
Fable was famous back in 2004 for over-promising what a highly dynamic RPG could be. But now, after two sequels that largely failed to impress and nothing but white noise in the franchise for ten years, the new game is finally on the horizon... and the possibilities are actually endless.
With RPGs continuing to surprise with the sheer scope of their branching paths, beautiful open world maps and fully customisable characters, a new Fable game could be a thing of beauty. And with this game being in "secret" development for many years now, it's fair to say some sweet time has been sunk into it. There are many ways to make sure this new entry saves the franchise from its ever dimming level of fame and doesn't become simply another disappointing Fable sequel.
10. Bring Back The Heroes
The original Fable (and its re-release as The Lost Chapters) is considered the best game in the series by a country mile, and it’s no doubt down to its engaging premise and setting in the Guild of Heroes. Unfortunately, the enormous time jump between Fable and Fable 2 meant the Guild had been destroyed and heroes were essentially extinct.
But what made Fable such a promising concept was the Guild itself. Being nurtured from childhood by the teachers at the Guild and growing as a warrior; interacting with other heroes from both the past and present; taking quest cards to prove your worth (or prove your villainy if you so wished).
Such a charming idea was what made the game special, and it’s completely missing from later instalments. The guild itself doesn’t have to be brought back exactly as we remember it, but some return to the idea of heroes in training rather than just an underdog who rises as a hero because of “fate” would be a great return to what made the game a classic.
9. Bigger Consequences For Being Evil
At the heart of the Fable system is morality. Do you want to be a patron saint with a literal glowing halo, or do you want to take quests to slaughter entire farms with a task card ominously left for you at your school?
At the end of Fable: The Lost Chapters, you’re given the choice to destroy the possessed mask of Jack of Blades or wear it for yourself, ultimately bringing the villain you just spent countless hours tracking down and killing back to life.
And what are the consequences? Well… it’s the end of the game. You can just free roam wearing the mask and no one says a word. Want to waltz through your childhood town and kick chickens? No problem. Sure, people cower when you walk past because you have evil points. But no one cares that you’re a literal supervillain that slaughtered entire towns, like, two days ago. Fable 2 lets you choose some evil options, but they're far less severe than The Lost Chapter's ending. And by 3, the idea of being evil is completely gone bar making dubious governance choices, often for the greater good.
No game in the series ever had real consequences for murdering entire towns on a whim and sprouting horns. You’re just free to go about and keep being the hero the main quest requires you to be. If the idea of a truly dynamic morality system is introduced, it would be great to see some real consequences for your actions.
8. Make Choices Matter
Back when the original Fable was announced, creator Peter Molyneux made all sorts of promises surrounding its dynamic world, morality system and branching paths. His most famous anecdote was that if your character chose to plant a tree, you would be able to watch it grow in real time.
The game is now infamous for its failure to truly live up to what was promised, probably largely down to the fact that the game is from 2004. And the binary choices in Fable 2 and 3 weren't all too thrilling, either.
But since then choice based games have become the bread and butter for successful RPGs, with the likes of Bioware titles and The Witcher 3 having countless ways for paths to deviate, whether they be big or small changes.
Peter Molyneux's original promises of choice are legendary in how far fetched they were for the time, but the kind of things he talked about back then are possible now. Now we could see a return to what was originally conceived for the series. And if we're exploring the concept of morality at a next-gen level, the good and evil branches could be seriously fun.
7. More Interesting Quests
A standout quest from the Fable series is The Game from Fable 3, in which your hero is shrunk down and turned into the main character in a tabletop Dungeons & Dragons style game narrated by three dim-witted ‘magi’. It’s witty, charming, self-referential and unlike any other quest in the series.
The Fable series suffers from having few truly engaging quests with interesting outcomes and possibilities. Its morality system is traditionally based around “this is a good quest, go save someone” or “this is a bad quest, go kill someone.” The first game at least gives you opposing quest choices based on your morality, and there are some memorable NPCs involved such as Lady Grey and Whisper, but they're few and far between.
There’s very little in terms of actual engagement with the story or choices made along the way. If this system is revamped and made more interesting à la The Witcher 3, this could be a quick fix.
6. Make NPCs Matter
Fun fact: In Fable 2 and 3, you can open up a menu that shows you your relationship with any ambient NPC in the game and change their name. Literally call them whatever you want. That’s how little NPCs matter in these games.
While you can romance and marry any of these stock NPCs, there’s little-to-no engagement with them whatsoever. Only Fable 3 gives you a romance you actually care about in your childhood sweetheart that you can choose to marry later in the game, but after their key side quest even they become an empty shell of a character that you could randomly choose to shoot in the head if you wanted to.
Even NPCs involved in the main questline are reduced to: your dog, your tutorial character that speaks to you in annoying voiceover, a villain, and pretty basic "companions". No side quest NPCs are important or memorable, and your main questline companions get very little development or time dedicated to them.
The NPCs that give you quests are all essentially stock characters. There’s no emotional investment in any of them as people. Even the more interesting characters, like Maze or Walter, appear intermittently and with short, scripted interactions only. Changes to the choice system could easily make them more engaging.
5. A Good Villain (Please.)
The original Fable had a fantastic villain in Jack of Blades. Creepy, murderous, masked and bloodied. He’s truly terrifying. He murders your entire family in front of your eyes and his final form is a literal dragon. That’s cool.
Fable 2? A powerful rich man that’s absent for most of the game who dies from a single gunshot wound that you yourself might not even fire. Fable 3? For the first half of the game it’s your arrogant distant brother the King, who is then abandoned in favour of The Crawler, a creepy distant threat that’s essentially the Smoke Monster from LOST.
Fable 2 and 3 lacked urgency in terms of their villains. They were hardly ever on screen, you hardly fought any of them and you certainly weren’t ever scared of them. Jack of Blades is the kind of villain Fable 4 needs.
4. Keep The Dog (And Give It More To Do)
Arguably what saved Fable 2 and 3 from being complete step-downs from the original is the addition of your trusted dog companion.
The dog is ever by your side, fighting and finding treasure for you. He even makes a heroic sacrifice for you in Fable 2 in a heart-wrenching scene, and the choice at the end of Fable 2 to either bring back your beloved dog or bring back literal thousands of people murdered by the villain is often an easy one in favour of the former.
Keeping the dog is a must, but it would be great if it had a larger involvement in stories and quests rather than just steering you five minutes off track to dig up 500 gold. The dog didn't have much involvement in the actual storyline, just a way of getting you extra loot. It's such a cute, personable addition to the games, but so much more could be done with it.
3. Dialogue Choices
This isn't totally necessary for an RPG to be successful, but for a series so rooted in choice and extreme morality differences, the fully voiced companion introduced in Fable 3 and presumably returning could really do with some dialogue options to hone in on the idea of choice.
In the first few games, the only choices that could be considered dialogue choices are when making an action-based choice in a quest that dictates how it ends (such as farting in someone's face to show what you thought of them... yes really), and in Fable 3 the morality dialogue choices are simply deciding what to do with Albion once you sit on the throne.
Different tone and outcome choices in conversations and plotlines would go a long way in establishing the franchise as what it was initially promised to be: shaped by your decisions.
2. More Customisation Options
Anyone who’s played this series knows how dire the customisation situation was in every single instalment. Ugly hairstyles, facial hair, tattoos and clothes dominated each game.
None of the casual clothes are nice bar the original outfit your character is given (which you will probably end up wearing for the entire game). None of the armour sets are interesting. The hairstyles are all blocky and horrible (yes, they’re old-ish games, but they were still horrible). The dye system barely worked and there just weren’t enough options to make your character feel like yours. There was also micro-transaction drama back in the 2010 days of Fable 3 where you had to buy the dye pack with black in. None of your clothes - or your hair for that matter - could be black unless you forked out cash for dye DLC. It was bad.
A way to fix this would be to go fully customisable and have a character creator. The hero is yours to shape, so it would make sense to be able to spend hours on a creation screen altering the height of their cheekbones. And this kind of thing is pretty common in RPGs these days.
1. A Combat Overhaul
Combat has never been Fable’s strongest area in terms of
gameplay. The weapons all pretty much do the same thing, magic in Fable 2 is overpowered to the point of breaking the game, and your magic gauntlets in 3 are a serious limitation on your abilities to wield magic in a fun way with pretty boring melee and ranged combat to supplement.
The most important thing needs to be the range of spells available. In the original game, morality points were linked to certain spells; healing was a good spell, while necromancy was an evil spell. Certain spells could only be accessed at top levels by heroes of a certain morality, and as we've discussed; morality needs to have a greater focus in this entry.
Magic is essentially a messy afterthought in the later instalments, and the basic attack/flourish system gets tiring pretty quickly. The series would definitely benefit from a new combat system, perhaps with a more tactical approach, or at the very least a wider variety of movement and attack types.