Fallout 4 Vs The Witcher 3: Which Is The Best RPG Of 2015?

The biggest battle of the current generation - only one can emerge victorious...

WhatCulture On the face of things, Fallout 4 and The Witcher 3 couldn't be any more different. Guns and super mutants vs swords, sorcery and griffins, towns patched together from corrugated metal vs medieval villages, abandoned vaults vs dungeons - and yet any gamer will passionately tell you that this is the most important video game showdown of 2015. That's because beneath the contrasting facades, both games sit pretty at the peak of the RPG genre. Neither does anything particularly unconventional, instead both of them offer beautiful, believable open worlds that players can get lost in for months. Mechanically, RPGs have certain defining traits such as intricate character-levelling, dialogue choices, and a degree of freedom in how the player can approach quests and objectives. But the most important thing is that its constituent parts fuse together to form an experience that the player wants to get immersed in. Fallout 4 and The Witcher 3 both meet the criteria for RPG greatness with flying colours, but only one can be crowned king in this comparison. Read on to find out which of these two is the best RPG of this generation so far. Note: There are no spoilers in this article.

9. Story

It seems ironic that in this pair of world-class RPGs, the main questlines just don't feel that significant, and aren't in themselves huge selling points for their respective games. RPGs are as guilty as any genre of tending towards cliches and tropes, but The Witcher 3 does its very best to steer clear of them. Rather than starting off as a typical world-saving story, it's essentially about Geralt's search for his surrogate daughter, Ciri, who is being hunted by a group of warriors known as 'The Wild Hunt'. Try though it might, the story does eventually funnel into the usual 'save the world' type fare. On the bright side, there are 40 different permutations to the ending, which help your choices throughout feel weighty and significant. There is also plenty of romance, intrigue and formidable characters along the way, making the main quest an enjoyable ride that's easy to get invested in. Fallout 4 follows the classic series formula of spewing the player from a vault and out into the irradiated world. This time, your motivator is finding your missing child and avenging your murdered wife, which is, erm, original... The main questline is undermined somewhat by the mundanity of the game's protagonist and largely forgettable characters, but at least it's supplemented by the parallel story of siding with one of several factions vying for control of the wasteland, and shaping the political future of the Commonwealth. While neither story is incredibly original, The Witcher 3 ultimately tells its one better. It feels deep and involving, and you care about the characters involved. Its vast number of end-states also nods towards that all-important RPG notion that every decision counts - not just towards which end cutscene you get, but also towards the fates of the characters you meet along the way.

8. Graphics

I'm not part of the seemingly global opprobrium against Fallout 4's graphics. The more saturated colours and vibrancy of the game world make the Boston wasteland a much more appealing place to wander around in than its predecessors, and it's pushed the 50s-retro visual style further than ever to great effect. But on a technical level, Fallout 4 suffers from many of the problems running through other Bethesda RPGs. Character animations are about as fluid as a ballet-dancing Sentry Bot, and while faces no longer look like anthropomorphic potatoes, the lack of variety in expressions and dodgy lip-syncing make most of characters aloof and un-relatable. With all that said, the wasteland can be a genuinely beautiful place, and the graphics don't detract from the joy of exploring it all.
For some reason, The Witcher 3 caught a lot less flak for its graphical shortcomings than Fallout 4, despite having its fair share of them. The game looks vastly inferior to the gameplay trailer that was released in 2013, and many compromises were made to the PC version so it could run smoothly on consoles (thanks for that, console gamers). The Witcher 2, on the other hand, was originally developed for the PC, and therefore had outstanding graphics from the off that still look incredible today. That's not to say The Witcher 3 isn't one of the most beautiful games around. Trees sway sadly in the wind, sunsets look absolutely incredible and environments look moody and stunning. Crucially, facial animations are very well done, with wrinkles in all the right places and nice animated eyebrows bringing characters to life. The Witcher 3 is a looker, and a technical achievement despite not quite living up to the expectations set by its own developer.

7. Side-Quests

And so we arrive at one of the defining features of the RPG genre. For me, a rich sea of side-quests is more important than the main story or graphics. It's in the side-quests that that you really get to shape your character and decide what kind of person they'll be. Do you side with the drug dealer or drug addict? Do you try to extract as much money as possible from a peasant asking you to take out a monsters' nest, or do you do it for free? These kinds of questions crop up all the way throughout Fallout 4 and The Witcher 3, and both games do a great job of executing them. One way in which The Witcher 3 bests Fallout 4's side-quests is in the way it deals with the player's dialogue decisions. Much like in real life, it's not always clear what the right answer is, and sometimes saying what you think will resolve a situation peacefully could lead to bloodshed. This makes each chat a more tense and interesting affair, whereas Fallout 4's new Mass Effect-style system is a bit more black and white. Even if you ask questions to which you may or may not get an answer (the ones highlighted yellow or orange), you have nothing to lose in giving it a shot, and that just feels too simplistic.
Both games have an excellent sense of spontaneity about their side-quests, and are packed with intriguing locations that pull you in and encourage you to investigate them. From my experience, side-quests feel easier to just stumble upon in Fallout 4, and there seem to be more random encounters in the wilderness that act as springboards for further questing. Many of the quests in Witcher 3 originate on notice boards in towns, which just doesn't feel quite as organic as Fallout's system. And, of course, we shouldn't forget settlement-building in Fallout 4, which is not so much a side-quest but an entire game unto itself. It doesn't actually serve a massive mechanical purpose apart from giving you extra places to trade your items and do some crafting, but boy does it make you feel involved in shaping the game world - or rather, 'playing a role' in its future, yeah?

6. The World

If strong side-quests are the bread of RPGs, then a believable, all-immersive world is the butter. We're dealing with two very different beasts in the Fallout 4 and Witcher 3 worlds. While the former feels densely packed with unique locations and dungeons (or the post-apocalyptic equivalent of), The Witcher 3 wins out in terms of sheer vastness and topographical variety. Plenty of gamers seemed unimpressed by the 'slightly bigger than Skyrim' map size of Fallout 4, but pay no heed to those naysayers, because this is one of the most vibrant, jam-packed open worlds around. You can walk to the top of any hill, and looking around you're guaranteed to see several intriguing points of interest that you can walk towards and find adventure. I was also blown away by the contrast between the countryside and urban Boston. While the city of Boston occupies only a small corner of the map, it feels like a true ruined sprawl, brimming with dangers, tall abandoned buildings that you can climb, and treasures to uncover. When you finally get out of the claustrophobic city alive, you just want to take a deep breath of the irradiated countryside air. The Witcher 3's Continent thrives in its natural beauty; snowy mountaintops, wheat fields blowing in the mind, and mysterious islands surrounded by dark, violent seas. It's the greatest fantasy world in video games, and that's saying a lot. Despite being huge, the world also feels intimate, as you're never too far from a place with a story to tell - whether it's a village populated only by children, a tree with rebels hanging from it, or a haunted house. The fact that around half a year on from its release I'm still being surprised by its dark corners and secrets is a testament to its design, and only time will tell whether Fallout 4 can offer the same kind of longevity.

5. Combat

With their focus on building an entire convincing world to explore, RPG developers can be forgiven for having traditionally been found wanting in the combat department. Ever since games have gone 3D, western RPGs have mostly featured real-time combat mechanics, which have often proved tricky to implement, with previous games from both Bethesda and CD Projekt RED demonstrating this point. In Fallout 4 and The Witcher 3, these hurdles have been overcome, with both games making huge advancements on their predecessors. In Fallout 4, combat finally feels fluid, and I didn't feel like I had to essentially pause the game and rely on VATS all the time to get those impactful shots in. Sprinting helps a great deal in getting to cover and making combat feel dynamic, while switching between the new slo-mo VATS and real-time combat feels flowing and seamless. Enemies actually use cover too. The melee combat still feels quite primitive, and the opposition are way too accurate with their grenade throws, but these are minor gripes. The Witcher 3's combat system takes certain cues from Dark Souls, in that it relies heavily on dodges, stamina, and timing. It's a huge jump on The Witcher 2, which often felt messy with its targeting system, though still risks slipping into confusion at times. It's not an easy learning curve (certainly tougher than Fallout), but extremely rewarding once you get the hang of it; cleaving apart a bunch of enemies with your adrenaline maxed out feels not only stylish, but a real achievement. The quick-select radial menu for spell-casting and ranged weapons works brilliantly too, slowing down time to keep the combat flowing and the pressure on while also letting you get your attacks together. Both games' combat systems differ completely from one another, and feel perfectly suited to their respective games. That doesn't mean I couldn't pick a winner if I tried, but both systems are really top-end, and among the best employed in RPGs to date.

4. The Protagonist

RPGs with protagonists that have been in any way pre-written or prescribed tend to have a tough time making them into interesting characters. It's an awkward compromise between offering the player a degree of freedom in going about their actions, and imbuing the protagonist with convincing motivations and goals in the world. With The Witcher 3, Geralt asserted himself as a bonafide video game icon. Sure, he's been criticised in the past as being a bit of an uber alpha-male, humping women left and right like some kind of horny husky dog, but in The Witcher 3 he tones down on that a bit, and actually has moments of genuine humanity shining through his gruff, cynical facade.
Fallout 4 took something of a BioWare approach with the protagonist, giving him or her his own personality while allowing you to choose their appearance and name. But Bethesda didn't quite get things right on this front, as no matter what actions you carry out throughout the game, the way in which the hero expresses himself always makes him sound like a reasonably nice but dull guy. While Geralt feels like he's specifically been crafted as a morally ambivalent character who can swing either towards good or evil, Fallout 4's hero just feels like a bit of a dullard, and if you choose to play the relentless badass it seems at odds with the slightly Ned Flanders vibe he gives off. I don't feel particularly invested in his personal story, nor compelled to empathise with him. On the other hand, I want nothing more than for Geralt to finally settle down and live out his days in happiness (or at least as close as a sulky witcher can get to happiness).

3. Character Levelling

The hallmark of any RPG is a robust levelling system that lets you mould the character in your image (ok, not in your exact image, but how you like to imagine you'd be in an RPG world). Both games take a different approach towards character-levelling. While Fallout 4 gives you a blank slate, and allows you to really fine-tune your hero to be a certain 'class' entirely of your own making, Geralt pretty much is what he is - a master swordsman with magical abilities. The only thing for you to do is decide which of his preexisting skills he gets better in. CD Projekt REDCD Projekt RED It's a bit of a strange comparison to make because The Witcher just wouldn't be The Witcher without Geralt, and Geralt wouldn't be himself if he was anything other than a Witcher - with all the accompanying abilities. With that said, the Fallout perks system - simplified a bit from previous games - offers exactly the kind of freedom I fantasise about in an RPG. With every playthrough, I can play the game completely differently - I can be a bat-swinging thug with no social skills in one game, a sneaky master sniper who crafts his own guns the next, and a smooth-talking gunslinger after that. This incentivises repeat playthroughs in a big way, certainly more than the focused, Geralt-centric system in The Witcher 3.

2. Crafting

While a great idea in principle, crafting often feels clunky and tedious, and The Witcher 3 demonstrates why. Potions are crafted using mixtures of herbs, but I'll be damned if I'm expected to remember what each plant in the game looks like or what area of the world it grows in.
The game is packed with lore, so why can't you just sit down and read up on certain herbs, or ask local traders where they grow so they're then marked out on your map for future reference, or even give the option to mark them on your map yourself? Weapons and armour are dealt with a bit better, though the interface to do this still feels way more fiddly than it should. While not perfect, Fallout 4's crafting system at least tries to make things simple for you. When you find weapons, you can disassemble them and use their scopes, grips, muzzles and so on for different loadouts, or just turn them into scrap and put them towards your settlement-building resources pile. The interface is easy to navigate, and you often have to make trade-offs between things like weight, damage and fire rate. It's satisfying, robust, and one of the finer examples of an RPG crafting system to date. Go, Bethesda!

1. Conclusion

Both games have been a credit to their genre, and both ought to be played by absolutely everyone looking for escape to a gorgeous RPG reality over the winter. Fallout 4 offers players the greatest post-apocalyptic wasteland in gaming history - a dense bubble of questing, beautiful barren locations, and surprises round every corner. The Witcher 3, meanwhile, is a vast, mysterious continent with a haunting atmosphere and an impressive sense of history - as if you're exploring a world that could've existed in some forgotten medieval age.
With its self-contained world, simpler UIs and new-and-improved shooting mechanics, Fallout 4 is certainly the more accessible of the two games. But as I've been playing (and loving) it, I couldn't help but feel that Bethesda rested on its laurels in some areas, failing to push boundaries in terms of graphics, character interactions and storytelling. It's great that they used fan mods for inspiration in Fallout 4, but it'd have been better if they used a bit more of their own imaginations in the process. The Witcher 3 may not be particularly friendly to newcomers, with a tough combat system and lore that assumes some knowledge of previous games in the series, but its relentless ambition really shines through. It feels massive, majestic and brimming with character, a new watermark for all RPGs to aspire to. There's just no way you can throw any accusations of laziness CD Projekt's way, as the game was evidently made with a huge amount of passion, bolstered by just as much skill. You should definitely, absolutely play both of these incredible games, but it's The Witcher 3 that deserves the accolade for best RPG of 2015, and this console generation so far. Do you agree? Or maybe you think that another RPG altogether beats these two? Let us know what you think in the comments, or better still, write for WhatCulture and let the whole world know what you think!

Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, Researcher of strange things. I'm a writer-editor hybrid whose writings on video games, technology and movies can be found across the internet. I've even ventured into the realm of current affairs on occasion but, unable to face reality, have retreated into expatiating on things on screens instead.