Fallout 76: 10 Reasons It Failed

Under the microscope with Bethesda's most controversial game.

Fallout 76 Screenshot
Bethesda

Despite all of the hate it's been getting since, well, its reveal, Fallout 76 isn't completely without merit.

The idea of having a game like Fallout that focuses on post-apocalyptic characters being playable with a few friends is certainly an entertaining one, and with the mild success of The Elder Scrolls Online, there was no reason to expect Fallout 76 to do this badly.

To be honest, there are quite a few good ideas. The world and monsters are interesting, and more unique than what we've seen in the series before, plus things like a photo mode are great implementations.

It has potential.

The thing is about potential is that it actually has to be used properly. Just having potential isn't enough to make a game good, and that's a lesson that Fallout 76 clearly missed.

Wherever you looked following 76's announcement, bad news seemed to follow. As more and more gameplay features were revealed, things started to look worse and worse. Now we're here, and Fallout 76 is the most confusing game of 2018.

The sad truth of the whole situation is that Fallout 76 failed, and it will be incredibly hard to pull things back.

10. It Doesn't Feel Like A Full Release

Fallout 76 Promo Image
Bethesda

This is a triple-A release? It really doesn't feel like it.

For the type of game that Fallout 76 is trying to be, it would certainly be much more suited to a free-to-play format.

Although that might introduce microtransactions into the game, it might actually be a much fairer trade-off than paying $60 for something that feels like an add-on to Fallout 4.

That's one of the key problems with Fallout 76: It doesn't feel like a full game. That's not because 76 is a spin-off either, it just feels like Bethesda hasn't put enough in to justify the price tag.

Fallout: New Vegas added so much to the Fallout formula, and is actually considered as being one of the best and biggest games in the series. That was a spin-off and felt so much more substantial, so there's no excuse for Fallout 76 being as half-baked as it is.

Fallout 76 needs to add more content, or go free-to-play, it's as simple as that.


9. Microtransactions Are Laughable

Fallout 76 Players
Bethesda

As is the case with pretty much every big budget game that features multiplayer, Fallout 76 features a ton of microtransactions in the form of a secondary currency.

This secondary currency can be used to purchase cosmetic items for you and your C.A.M.P, as well as different emotes and icons. It's all cosmetic, but the fact that they've been shoved into yet another game this year is ridiculous.

Although Atoms can be earned through completing challenges in the game, the rate at which you'll be earning them slows down considerably after the first few hours, and it really starts to feel like drawing blood from a stone.

Barely any of the unlockables are worth neither the effort or the money, so it doesn't really make sense to gate them off. All of it adds up to Fallout 76 just feeling like a cash grab made to use the Fallout fanbase.

Clearly publishers have learned nothing from the Battlefront II debacle.


8. Player Vs. Player Is Handled Poorly

Fallout 76 Squad
Bethesda Softworks

Why even include player vs player if it's going to be handled this badly?

If you have a game with multiplayer, chances are those players are going to want to murder one another at some point. That is even more true true of something like Fallout 76, where the only real challenge in the game would be fighting other players.

To prevent griefing, Bethesda decided that players would take half damage from other players that have shot at them, until they decide to shoot back.

This is the perfect example of an idea that's much better on paper than in execution.

Even with a half damage nerf, if another player is significantly more levelled than you, they can still easily take you out with some persistence.

To put it simply, as it is right now, player vs player in Fallout: 76 has no balance and no viable rules.

Why didn't Bethesda just use different servers for player vs player and regular exploration?


7. It's Too Easy

Fallout Game
Bethesda

Fallout games have never been known for their difficulty, but Fallout 76 is laughably easy.

No matter what level you are, you're not going to have a hard time fighting any enemies. Despite the fact that they can be much higher levels than you, they never really pose any kind of threat. The only thing that can get you in Fallout 76 are other players.

The only thing stopping you from going up against these enemies is the fact that you can't use the loot they drop if you aren't the same level as them.

The problem with this is the fact that Fallout 76 never really increases in challenge as the game goes on. The only thing that poses any kind of challenge or interest is getting nuclear codes, and even then that's only because of how many steps it takes.

If the missions are boring and the enemies are easy, all you're really left with is exploration, and that can't carry the whole game.


6. Restrictive Player Count

Fallout 76 15 Wanderers
Bethesda

It's pretty simple: If more players were on a map in Fallout 76, it wouldn't feel like such an empty experience.

Now, no one was expecting 100 players or anything like that, but if you're going to make multiplayer and interacting with players the focus of your game, you really need to step up above 32.

This is a particularly big issue considering how big the world is. It would have been bad enough if it was Fallout 4's map, but Fallout 76 is the biggest world in the series.

Now imagine trying to find someone in a world that big.

The only saving grace is the fact that you can fast travel to points in the map, but doesn't that defeat the purpose of exploring a bit?

It feels like Fallout 76 really might have achieved some of its ambitious goals if it had increased the player count to a more weighty number. The dream of having players act as NPC's and questgivers can hardly work if you aren't seeing other people.


5. It's Too Boring

Fallout 76
Bethesda

Although Fallout 76 may have a pretty big world, everything inside of it is boring.

This is especially weird when you consider that every Fallout game beforehand was anything but boring. Exploring a post-apocalyptic world and shooting deadly mutants should be great, but it falls completely flat here.

The main problem is the missions. Every single one falls into the typical MMO trapping of either being a fetch quest or going somewhere to kill something. No characters to connect to, no memorable locations and no real advancement of anything.

If Fallout 76 had some sort of plot to work towards then there might be some excitement to be had, but it's completely barebones here. Past games haven't had the most riveting main stories, but that's where side-quests came in, and Fallout 76 does little to distinguish the two.

The only saving grace with Fallout 76 is the fact that you can play it with friends, and even that isn't really done right.


4. Combat Is The Focus

Fallout 76 16 Assaultron
Bethesda

Fallout has never been about combat, but with no story or characters it starts to be the most notable thing about it.

That's not to say that combat is bad in Fallout 76, but it's nothing special. The combination of the poor enemy AI and lack of good-feeling weapons leads to a very unsatisfying combat system that can be easily exploited.

Both melee combat and gun combat are extremely simple, with the only interesting thing being the weapon modification. It can't carry a whole game though.

The biggest problem with this is the fact that V.A.T.S - the system that once made Fallout stand out - has now been reduced to another aiming mechanic. All that happens here is that enemies are highlighted, and you get a % "chance" meter.

Although being an online game makes V.A.T.S hard to implement, there's barely any point of putting it in. All of the problems with combat are another one of the consequences that come from turning Fallout into an online-only game with no NPCs.


3. Connection Problems Are Common

Fallout: 76 Connection
Bethesda

Although a big influx of players is expected to make connection a problem in the first week of release, Fallout 76 has made it a much bigger problem.

Chances are when you get into Fallout 76, you'll be disconnected shortly after. Players have been documenting the connection issues since the game launched and they tend to be numerous.

If that wasn't bad enough on its own, a lot of the connection issues cause glitches as well, such as removing hours of progress or getting rid of loot. It's a whole new level of Bethesda bugs, and something that is hopefully being properly looked into.

Connection problems are another consequence of having an always-online world, which must be especially painful for the people who want to play the game on their own.

A potential fix for this could be to add private servers to the game that allow players to play completely on their own. A basic feature like that should really already be a part of the game, but hopefully Bethesda are going to add it.


2. It Barely Functions

Fallout 76 Glitch
Bethesda

For a triple-A game released in 2018, the state that Fallout 76 is in is completely unacceptable.

Bugs are everywhere in Fallout 76, and are somehow much worse than any other Fallout game. Character models disappearing, enemies respawning in front of players and more have been spotted so far, and that's just the beginning.

Even worse than that is the connection issues, which can also completely wipe any progress made on the game since logging in. This is to be expected of an early release, but the problems are still ongoing right now.

The excuse that this is a Bethesda game is not a valid one, and that should no longer be accepted for any of the titles that they release. Yes, they do make big worlds with plenty in them, but so do companies like Rockstar and their titles are nothing like this.

This would be another benefit of going free-to-play, as it would have at least given Bethesda a little bit of leeway on how the game performs.


1. Lack Of NPCs Makes The World Feel Empty

Fallout 76 Solo
Bethesda

This is the thing that killed Fallout 76 right from the start, and something that is likely to always hold it back.

Easily one of the best parts about all of the Fallout games are the world you explore and the characters you meet. The role playing elements really come to life when it comes to interacting with other characters and deciding how to play, and it's really

To get rid of that entirely is completely baffling, and really shows a lack of understanding of what makes Fallout great.

Without any NPC's in the game, there's barely any sort of basic plot to follow or any objectives to really be interested in, and it makes the world feel empty in the worst possible way. It's somehow more empty with other players than previous solo Fallout games.

If you had pitched a Fallout game with multiplayer in the past, many people would think of a cooperative role playing game of some sort, and that actually sounds like fun- as long as there were actual characters in that world.

The sad truth is that nobody asked for Fallout 76. Not like this.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Fallout 76
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jumping through portals, swinging through cities, destroying beings made of darkness and occasionally shooting a gun or two. I also write about games.