FIFA 13 Demo vs PES 13 Demo: Which Demo Was Best?
Before both games release, we look at the mini-battle between the rival demos, to see which was better.

Round One: Gameplay
FIFA 13 In a word, excellent. The new features, brought in with an obvious eye on the game's overall authentic feel, work wonderfully to add that realism as well as making the game feel fun again. Both the defensive AI and attacking AI have been given a revamp after some of the problems of last year, and attacking play in particular feels a lot less one-dimensional than it has at times in the past. Thanks to the increased intelligence of team-mates, there are always a number of options available to the attacking player, and if the player should decide to take it on themself, the change in the dribbling system, and control system mean that trying to take a man on is not the furstrating experience it was in FIFA 12, when the containment system meant evasive one-twos were a lot more successful (though less entertaining). Unfortunately for PES, this is the most real football gaming has ever felt, and that comes without a compromise in the entertainment factor, which has got to be the ideal balance. PES 2013 Though there have been some serious improvements on last year, there is still something not quite right about the fluidity of play and gameplay can feel slightly awkward in comparison with FIFA. That has something to do with the ball, which seems to lack weight, even despite how much more typical its behaviour is, and the movement of the players on the ball, which lacks the grace of FIFA. It is easily the less realistic of the two in terms of gameplay, though it is still entertaining all the same (which was the bias this game was once loved for predominantly), and there has clearly been a lot of work gone into tweaking the engine to make matches play better. Like FIFA, PES has been given a make-over in terms of the control system, which stands out well, and passing between players is accurate and slick, despite the lack of ball weight, but it feels a lot more difficult to score goals, like the bias of the play leads the player to passing around more than looking for a killer touch. That isn't helped by the lack of impact on scoring that should be the reward for hitting the back of the net - there just isn't the ceremony of FIFA unfortunately.
Round Two: Graphics
FIFA 13 A key factor for many who praise FIFA's virtues in the great debate, and something that detractors often point at as an indication that FIFA prefers to just dress up the same game with some nicer looking graphics and slightly better player likenesses, rather than concentrating on the engine of the game. But this year, with the engine under-going some very tangible changes, the aesthetic qualities of the game are free to shine again for what they really are - a secondary, but still very important concern. Players look more like their real life counter-parts much more than they ever have before (though there is still some distance to go until they have that unquantifiable life-likeness to match their likenesses), and animations are slick and nice-looking. The one problem I have is with the lighting contrast, which looks nice on screen, but which is plainly too defined between light and shadow, as it was in EA Sports' Madden 13. It's by no means a fatal fault, but it's annoying having to adjust your eyes to a game like that. PES 2013 Again, the likenesses have enjoyed an increase in quality, and this version of the game is bost themost realistic and best looking of the Pro Evo's released to date, unsurprisingly. The fact that the game doesn't have any visual issues like the lighting issue for FIFA means that Pro Evo closes the gap considerably on the still slicker FIFA, and indeed Konami can have a lot to be proud of this year. The uplift in visual quality isn't quite the same as it was between 2011 and 2012's versions, but that is perhaps down to Konami's obvious decision to go back to fusing simulation and arcade thrills, rather than simply trying to go for FIFA's crown as the best football simulation title on the market. In-play animations and likenesses look good, but in celebration animations, the slickness levels drop quite markedly and players tend to lose their spark of liveliness, which is a shame. But that's what happens when you're faced with an all-powerful opponent, and it's better that Konami ploughed their focus into the on-pitch experience, rather than on making the frilly bits more pretty. For now that shows, but spend enough time in the game and it won't matter as much when you realise how much better the game plays.
Round Three: Presentation
FIFA 13 Typically slick, and the new Match Day set-up looks to add a lot more pomp and circumstance to the match experience, and those presentation choices really add some ceremony to the games, in a move that feels like EA Sports are trying to bring some elements of the Madden experience into their soccer game. The commentary sounds a lot better, though the demo was rather comically out of date, talking about Robin Van Persie's unresolved transfer situation, which of course can't be helped - I can't help but think they had enough time to take that one element out though before the demo hit the download stores, but again, it's hardly a fatal error. As usual the soundtrack choices are excellent, mixing pop and world songs with a tub-thumping overall ethos to gee up the player as they prepare for matches or celebrate between online matches. Unfortunately, like all sports game titles, the menus are still way too complex, and though the demos menu trails ultimately lead to text screens promising exactly what the player can expect from the full version of the game, when it's all their live, it might be a little daunting to begin with to navigate. But then simplicity has never been at the forefront of EA Sports' minds when building their games, and they more than make up for it in slickness. PES 2013 Menus are fine, and the art design away from the pitch is solid and good-looking, but the major issue here for some people will always be the lack of licence - and while that doesn't feel like too much of a problem at this stage with the demo, the promise of a reduced licence will be a deal-breaker for a lot of players. That distracts from what is a solid if slightly unspectacular package, whose limitations are completely forgiven when you consider the changes that have happened on the pitch for this year's Pro Evo. That makes up for the lack of depth in modes, and the uninspiring soundtrack, but once you start lining these elements up against FIFA, Pro Evo begins to show its threads a bit more. The solo and versus modes are all well and good, and the gameplay experience is rewarding enough, but there just isn't the kind of depth that keeps players around for the entire year, and Konami would do well to look at their biggest rival for some tips in that respect, even if they're not so big on "copying" round those parts.
Round Four: Hype
A difficult thing to quantify, but one that matters all the same - this section relates to how well the demos convinced us to go out and buy the full versions of the games on release day, including how they teased new features and extra content. Basically, how good an advert the demo was for selling the game. FIFA 13 The problem of the delayed PS3 release might not have been down to EA Sports, but it left something of a bitter taste to the demo launch, and though the content included was excellent, and the gameplay even more so, there just wasn't enough included in the demo in terms of content compared to Pro Evo's package to really sell the game to anyone looking for more than the in-match experience. Still, the improvements from last year's FIFA 12, which had some serious issues, are huge, and the demo definitely suggested that those PES 2013 A victory for the Pro Evo team here, who actually released a second demo fixing some issues and teasing more content than the original demo previously released - it looked like Konami were listening to fan reactions, as they fixed a couple of bugs with the first version and made more teams available to play to the delight of fans. Had it not been for the unfortunately highly publicised antics of PES Team Leader Jon Murphy, who didn't need to go public with his anger at EA Sports and their perceived dirty tactics, I could have given the pre-release marketing a better score all round, but that coupled with the fact that Konami just don't seem to advertise as much as EA Sports left something of a blemish. I can say however, that the demos released were a great advert for the game, and speaking to a lot of fellow gamers can confirm that for the first time in a long time, for a while it was Pro Evo 13 that I was looking forward to the most of the two games. And the winner is...? FIFA 13
Though the demo was lightweight on actual content and playable teams, the gameplay experience was so entertaining at the same time as feeling realistic that it's impossible not to be bowled over by the game. Yes, some might say it's hard to get excited by the changes made to a game that releases every year, and will sell no matter what happens, but EA Sports seem to have really concentrated on making a slicker and more authentic gameplay experience, which is aided by the uplift in presentation and aesthetics that usually comes with the new year. That isn't to say that Pro Evo 13 is a bad demo - far from it in fact, and this year's battle between the two big guns of football gaming was closer than it has been since Pro Evo briefly reigned supreme. A lot of gaming hours have passed since then, but on the strength of this demo, Konami are definitely heading in the right direction and EA Sports had better be looking over their shoulder even more. So what do you think? Was the FIFA 13 demo better than the Pro Evo 13 one? Which game will you be buying? Share your thoughts below.