FIFA 14: 10 Players Who Were Criminally Underrated

Daniel Sturridge Fifa 14 For a gamer, this last fortnight has been one of the most exciting of the calendar year. First, on September 17, Grand Theft Auto V was released to universal acclaim and, one week later, EA rolled out the latest iteration in their juggernaut FIFA series, 14. The popular football simulation title has already ousted GTA from the top of the UK sales charts and, perhaps even more importantly, has outsold rivals Pro Evolution Soccer. With the game being out for four days now, fans have been able to delve into 14 and scrutinise its features, from its new gameplay mechanics through to those all-important player ratings. Player ratings are usually a divisive subject and a tetchy one among football fanatics and, as with every passing iteration in the series, there are a few ratings that caught our eye for all the wrong reasons. Players so underrated, it's actually verging on criminality. Rankings so wide of the mark, you can't help but wonder if EA have ever even watched a game of football in the last 12 months. And, with that in mind, here, we bring to you 10 Players Who Were Criminally Underrated In FIFA 14. Click "Next" to get started.

10. Rafael (77)

The Manchester United defender enjoyed a much-improved season last term and has come on leaps and bounds over the past 12 months. Where once he was petulant and immature, and at times a liability due to his hot-headed temperament, the Brazilian is now a more composed, mature player who became an integral member of United's title-winning starting XI in 2012/13. The 23-year-old has made the right-back slot his own at Old Trafford and not since Gary Neville retired have United had quality in that department. Unfortunately, Rafael's progression at United has not been reflected in FIFA 14's rankings, with the fullback remaining on 77, his rating from last year.

9. Romelu Lukaku (77)

Romelu Lukaku Romelu Lukaku has been farmed out on loan twice now in his short career, with the Chelsea striker spending stints at West Brom and, more recently, Everton, his current temporary club. But the 20-year-old has impressed wherever he has played, scoring 16 league goals in 37 appearances for Anderlecht as an 18-year-old back in 2010-11, and a further 17 in 35 topflight outings for West Brom last season. Lukaku is currently at Everton, scoring twice in last night's win over Newcastle to take his overall tally to three goals in as many appearances this season. So EA's decision to award him a rating of 77 really is mind-boggling. Lukaku has been performing consistently for two seasons now, and deserves to be in at least the low eighties.

8. Ander Herrera (79)

Ander Herrera is just one of several horribly-underrated Athletic Bilbao players in this year's iteration of FIFA. The 24-year-old is considered one of European football's most exciting young prospects and is destined for the senior Spanish side in years to come. In March of last year, Herrera dazzled in a bright and attractive Bilbao starting XI that knocked Manchester United out of the Europa League en route to reaching the final of the competition. But a lot of the members of that side, such as Markel Susaeta and Iker Muniain (both 78), seem to have been handed the short end of the stick by EA this year despite being technically-gifted players. Herrera's talents in recent seasons attracted interest from United in the summer transfer window and he is widely tipped to join them in January, perhaps then he will get a higher rating.

7. Michu (79)

Michu2 Michu has been banging goals in for fun since 2012, scoring 15 La Liga goals during his one season with Spanish side Rayo Vallecano before becoming the "basement buy of the season" in 2012-13 when he joined Swansea. The 27-year-old set the Premier League alight during his debut campaign, netting 18 Premier League goals and bagging 22 in a further 43 overall appearances. He helped fire the Swans to glory in the League Cup and up to 9th in the table last season, and if anyone thought he was a flash in the pan (which EA clearly do judging by their valuation of the attacker), Michu has already scored five times in 11 overall appearances this season. It's difficult to comprehend quite how EA arrived at the rating of 79 when evaluating Michu's talents, and this is yet another ranking they misjudged.

6. Kevin Strootman (79)

Another midfielder who got something of a raw deal in the player ratings this year is Roma's Kevin Strootman. The 23-year-old is widely accepted as one of the best young midfielders in the game with his physical style of play and tactical awareness earning him comparisons to Manchester United legend Roy Keane. So much so, United were interested in the player up until recently, before Strootman was instead snapped up by Roma for ‚17 million. It's a pity EA don't quite rate Strootman quite so highly. With the Netherlands international adding goals to his game last season, he is looking more and more like the finished article and is certainly one to watch out for in years to come.

5. Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang (80)

Aubameyang The brilliantly-named Gabonese star didn't receive quite as sparkling a rating in FIFA 14. That's despite the fact the 24-year-old has been quite prolific in front of goal recently, scoring 39 overall goals in his final two years with French outfit Saint-‰tienne. Form which attracted the attention of a number of the continent's leading sides, before German giants Borussia Dortmund pounced this summer and snapped him up for an undisclosed fee. There, Aubameyang has wasted no time in impressing, and has hit the ground running at his new club with 5 Bundesliga goals in just six outings. Another consistent performer who has been impressing in European football for over two years, we can't help but feel aggrieved that the striker's rating comes in at just 80.

4. Theo Walcott (81)

Despite enjoying a much-improved season last term, finishing as the Gunner€™s top goalscorer for the season with 21 goals from 43 appearances, along with 14 assists, Theo Walcott has been rated 81. The 24-year-old enjoyed a vastly-improved campaign in 2012-13, and what makes his rating smart all the more is the fact Manchester City€™s David Silva, who was comparatively poor last season, is still considered the 12th best player in the game with a rating of 88. Yet EA have somehow put their heads together and decided Walcott should stay on the rating of 81 he was afforded last season despite having become a more complete player in the 12 months that have followed.

3. Stephan El Shaarawy (81)

Stephan El Shaarawy "The Pharaoh", as he is known to his legions of fans, didn't receive the kingly rating his nickname, and recent performances, warranted in FIFA 14. Stephan El Shaarawy has come into prominence at AC Milan recently, after signing from Genoa in 2011. His eye-catching performances at Milan in his debut season saw him scoop the Serie A Young Footballer of the Year Award in 2012 before bringing goals to his game in the following campaign. In 2012-13, the Italy-born international netted 16 Serie A goals in 37 appearances to fire his side into a third-placed finish in the league. His goal-scoring exploits belie his youth - he is only 20 - and his rating this year should surely be higher taking into account even better times lie ahead for the starlet.

2. Daniel Sturridge (80)

Daniel Sturridge has been a revelation since leaving Chelsea for Liverpool in January this year. At Stamford Bridge, the England international cut a frustrated figure, making just the seven appearances in his final months at the club before completing a switch to Anfield in the winter window. There, however, he has sparked into life, bagging himself 10 goals from 14 appearances before going on to score a further seven in eight overall outings this term, too. With Luis Suarez up until last week suspended, Sturridge has delivered the goals for Liverpool and has stepped up to the plate when he was most needed. It is for this reason why the star deserves a much better rating of 80, considering he looks set to finish this season as one of the top goalscorers in the division.

1. Christian Benteke (79)

By far the most criminal rating in the game however is that afforded to Christian Benteke. We've given this one much deliberation and, having thought about it for quite some time, still cannot quite figure out how EA arrived at the conclusion to rate the Belgian star 79. The Aston Villa striker was the Premier League's fourth-highest goalscorer last season with his 19 league goals putting him just behind the likes of Robin van Persie, Luis Suarez and Gareth Bale. Perhaps EA thought, as they did with Michu, that Benteke was a flash in the pan and would suffer "second season syndrome", but that absolutely has not been the case with either. The 22-year-old has already bagged himself five goals from six overall appearances and, though he has been sidelined with injury recently, is still on course for another successful season. And it's a shame that isn't being reflected by EA and FIFA 14. What do you make of these rankings? Who do you think was criminally underrated in FIFA 14? Let us know in the comment section, below.

In this post: 
FIFA 14
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.