FIFA 14 vs PES 2014: 7 Key Aspects Reviewed And Compared

14 For the last few years, EA's behemoth sports franchise FIFA has dominated the football gaming world. In fact, such was the divide in most gamer's eyes that Konami's Pro Evolution Soccer wasn't even seen as genuine competition. But now, with the release of PES 2014 and FIFA 14, things are about to change. The playing field has been evened and for the first time in years, FIFA is no longer the automatic choice for the majority of football fans. With FIFA 14 jumping to next gen as well as staying on current platforms, many have asked if they have left themselves short in terms of actual development time. I mean, why bother watching a DVD if a Blu-ray can be enjoyed instead? Konami have a brand new engine built from the ground up, while EA's juggernaut looks to have been refined to the point of perfection. But which one is best? After spending time with both games, I can safely say that football fans are spoilt for choice this year, with both games offering more than enough to warrant a purchase. But in a year that sees the launch of expensive next gen consoles as well a stunning line-up of games, which football title is worth not only your hard earned money, but also your valuable gaming time? Here we break down each game into 7 key areas, with one crowned king while the other is relegated for another year.

7. Licences

Fifa 14 Let's kick things off with the elephant in the room. Chances are, if you are reading this, you already understand that Konami still don't have many of the biggest teams in the world officially licensed, but it's not for lack of trying. It's argued that EA have spent more on advertising and on tying up exclusive deals with Premier League teams than they have on all of their other franchises combined. That might seem crazy, but the fact remains that Konami simply cannot afford to compete with EA on that level. It's been a thorn in the side of PES since the series' inception, with the more causal football fan automatically drawn to the more appealing, fully featured FIFA, especially when comparing huge teams like Manchester City, who are named in PES as Man Blue. But for all EA's dominance in that specific area, they are missing out on arguably the biggest and best competition in world football. Konami hold exclusive rights to the UEFA Champions League and use the license superbly. While FIFA have the Barclays Premier League and Bundesliga, Konami offer a different taste with the Europa League and Copa Libertidores. That's even before mentioning edit mode, where licenses become a non issue. Option file-makers create every league they can think of with meticulous detail. Side by side, a fully edited PES 2014 stands toe to toe with FIFA, especially on PC. Some argue it looks better. Ultimately though, FIFA wins on sheer depth alone, even if PES certainly offers an equally exciting package in terms of licenses. The question is, do you prefer the Premier League or Champions League? Winner: FIFA 2014

6. Graphics

Untitled 11 They say a picture tells a thousand words, so I'll let the comparison screenshot above speak for itself. Konami have made graphical leaps and bounds with PES 2014 and it blows FIFA away at every turn. Aided by the new FOX Engine - next to be seen in the stunning looking MGS:V - PES 2014 looks incredible. From the players on the pitch to the cutscenes and replays, it's the one area where PES really does comprehensively outshine FIFA. FIFA is beginning to look stale and bland with shiny, clay-like players often hilariously sticking out in the heat of battle. Some of the world's biggest players such as Drogba and Aguero look atrocious. Even superstar Cristiano Ronaldo looks pretty poor, which is disappointing to say the least. Even though PES 2014 is on current consoles, you could be fooled to think it's not. It makes for an interesting head to head next year between EA's Ignite and Konami's Fox engines. Winner: PES 2014

5. Modes

48 I've already mentioned the unrivalled depth of FIFA 14 in terms of licenses, and the same can be applied for game modes. This is one huge game and literally offers something for everyone. Be it Head to Head, Seasons or the excellent online modes (which I'll get to in a minute) PES 2014 simply can't compete with the sheer volume of modes crammed into this year's offering from EA. Taking away the Champions League, FIFA 14 offers a better Be a Pro mode, better training/skill games and better Pro Clubs. That's without mentioning the series biggest mode - Ultimate Team. Master League is still as addictive as ever and MLO is potentially the best mode of the two games, but for sheer bang for your buck, you can't go wrong with FIFA. Whether you enjoy the base gameplay or not, however, that's up to you, which brings me to the next point... Winner: FIFA 14

4. Gameplay

82 It's a pity that gamers don't rank this as their biggest factor when deciding which game to buy each year, as in my opinion, it's the most defining aspect of each title. For all of FIFA 14's incredible depth, it still can't match the simple elegance of PES 2014. The pace and overall feel of PES this year is amazing. It truly is a near perfect replication of the feel of a real football match. While FIFA 14 has improved considerably, even from the previous iteration, it still feels more restrictive than PES 2014. Even with all the new animations and controlled pace and new fancy dribbling, it doesn't feel like real football. Midfield battles are huge in PES 2014, whereas in FIFA, they are non existent. Defending problems aside, PES controls beautifully, especially after the day one patch. FIFA looks and plays beautifully at times, but issues such as overpowered wing play and spammy crosses can sometimes ruin it. The same can be said about the passing, which is still miles behind its rival. PES captures the beautiful game, well, beautifully. Pirlo plays like Pirlo. Ronaldo destroys teams with sheer class, while Neymar has more tricks up his sleeve than Dynamo. Even better, all this happens in an organic, ever-changing way depending on what is happening on the pitch. PES has finally embraced simulation, and while it is still not perfect, it's a massive step up. With the risk of being overly harsh, FIFA is still arcade-like, with its near-automatic shooting and superhuman goalkeepers. Winner: PES 2014

3. Online

Fifa 14 Demo The major selling point for FIFA 14 has to be its raft of excellent online modes. From the addictive Ultimate Team to the frantic madness of Pro Clubs, there really is something for every fan looking to enter the online pitch. The new Legends Mode (exclusive to Xbox 360) looks set to be the next big thing for FIFA, so expect EA to really extend that come this time next year. Joining games is easy and fun, and creating lobbies takes seconds. It really is a streamlined experience that EA should be proud of. Ignoring the ridiculous "buy your way to the top" aspect of Ultimate Team, there is still plenty of fun to be had building a squad from packs. A weak point for PES in the last few years, due to technical issues and connectivity problems with lag cheats, Konami has started to address these issues with PES 2014, and the results are a lot better than last year. Konami place a heavy emphasis on regular patches to tweak the gameplay based on feedback, and even though the community is small compared to FIFA's, there is incredible fun to be had in Master League Online, a game mode that could potentially be better than Ultimate Team. All things considered, PES 2014's online features are rather basic compared to FIFA 14's, so it's probably a stretch to expect FIFA fans to be converted this year. Ultimate Team, like Call of Duty's Zombies, is a game seller all by itself. Winner: FIFA 14

2. Presentation

73 It would be easy to cite the glossy new design of career mode and the aforementioned licences as the reasons for FIFA winning this category outright, but menus and fancy Windows 8-like tiles only paint half the picture when comparing two games that will be in your drive for a whole 12 months. There is no doubt that EA has given FIFA 14 a fresh new look, mostly evident in Ultimate Team and at half-time intervals. The menu system is slick and stylish, with very little clutter, and the once painfully slow process of making substitutions and releasing your inner Jose Mourinho via tactics has been given a small increase in speed throughout the game. It's fast and responsive, but still not perfect. PES 2014 is quite a nice overhaul from years gone by, with a new, more personal style overtaking the rather boring menus of PES 2013 and PES 2012. The kits and player models look incredible too, and really benefit from the added graphical boost. On the pitch is where it matters, though, and this is where PES really comes into its own. From the moment the players step onto the pitch, the atmosphere inside the stadium erupts in cheers and jeers of equal measure. The stadiums are amazingly detailed, and the crowds are very impressive throughout each game, changing with each tackle or attempt on goal. It adds an exciting dimension to each game, especially over the course of a Master League. FIFA 14, for all of its polish and attention to detail off the pitch, remains largely the same. The new entrances and match day build up look nice but, again, ultimately falls flat, as real emotion is never really captured. The players and crowd react the same playing an exhibition as they do in a league decider, which certainly detracts from the immersion. Commentary on both gets boring fast, with the same phrases muttered before, during and after each game. It's one area where there is no clear winner, but because on the pitch is where it should matter, PES 2014 just about shades it - Jim Beglin one-liners and all. Winner: PES 2014

1. Lasting Appeal

31 So into extra time we go. With so many games coming out this year, what with Batman, Watch Dogs and all the next gen titles, if you're going to spend £40+ on a game, you will want to get the most out of it. I have already discussed the depth FIFA offers, with its many modes and re-playability, but is it lacking the most important feature? Games are meant to be fun, even when trying to be a simulation. Is FIFA still a frustrating experience after a few weeks/months? Similarly, PES 2014 might also suffer from this over the coming months. Obviously, we can only look at last year's offering to see the pattern. The one thing that might swing it in Pro Evo's favour is its regular tweaking to not just game play, but to the actual aesthetics of the game, also. Konami has promised fans a regular stream of DLC that will include 100's of updated player faces, classic kits and stadiums and even big gameplay additions. FIFA 14 seems to have lot of subtle changes to tide fans over until Christmas, when most people will be taking the plunge and going next gen. Don't get me wrong, FIFA 14 is a great game, it's just too much of the same thing. It's hard to see someone pouring another 200-300 hours into Career Mode or Ultimate Team, unless you skipped its predecessor, in which case the game will be a revolutionary step up from FIFA 12. FIFA 14 still suffers from gameplay imbalance, with finesse shots and over the top through balls already causing major frustration for fans. It's hard to stomach, especially as its better looking brother looms in the distance. Is FIFA 14 competing with itself, then? Definitely not. PES 2014 has given the series new life, and the possibilities for the future are very exciting. The fox engine is stunning, and one could argue it's even capable of competing with EA's next gen Ignite engine. High praise indeed. At the end of the day, it all comes down to personal choice. This year, there is no clear winner. Konami has clawed back a lot of ground, and for the first time in a long time, casuals are taking notice. MLO is a barebones Ultimate Team, Master League is rivaled by Career Mode. Be a pro and Become a Legend. Licences vs. an amazing edit mode. Each game brings its own unique flavour. Issues aside, you can't go wrong with either game this year, but ultimately FIFA 14 feels like a stop gap before EA fully embrace next gen with open arms. The subtle changes make for an all around better experience, but PES 2014 just begs to be explored. Even at 50 hours in, there are still new animations popping up and new tricks to master. For all the depth it lacks in modes and licences, PES 2014 shines on the pitch. A controversial choice no doubt, but one that is not unwarranted. Both games have issues, and is really does come down to which you will play more of - online or offline modes. A late, last minute goal for PES 2014. PES 2014 - 4 FIFA 14 - 3 Winner: PES 2014 Which game do you think is better? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Barry O' Halloran has been a whatculture writer for the last two years and having recently graduated, now plans on writing about games & movies until his hands fall off. Follow him on twitter!