FIFA 14 vs PES 2014: Which Game Really Is Best?

Fifa Pes We've all heard of them, we've all seen them being played but which one, FIFA or PES? That is the question. When you see these two titans of video gaming come head to head on release day, it's hard to pick which one will provide the most sanctification of endless matches, while locked away in bedrooms for weeks and of course, broken controllers. These games allow those to choose their favourite team and players as well as stuffing opponents, friends or if you feeling really cruel, a team that has the lowest rating - come on we've all done it...right? But which of these two can be claimed as the best game? It's one that will cause huge debates among fans from either side of the spectrum, but lets try get some indication of who trumps the football gaming world, first up it's FIFA.

FIFA

Fifalegacy The franchise didn't really get going until 2008 when EA decided to really up the ante and upgrade its match engine, menus and players characteristics. It is truly impressive how much the game has come on over the years with each one somehow beating it's predecessor year-in, year-out. A vast amount of time was spent on adding as much detail to clubs, players and stadia alike, with the end product looking incredible and the full use of the FIFA licence pays in dividends, particular with the big clubs such as Barcelona, Manchester City and the inclusion of New York Red Bulls too. Career mode, Ultimate Team and online modes are all still, if not, more popular and they go from strength to strength, adding a certain addiction to either improve yourself as a player at your club, rummaging through gold packs to find an in-form player or trying to beat your friends via the internet, over and over again. Hours, days, weeks and months are spent on this game and it can never get old, like, ever. Most of that time - from my perspective anyway - is spent on Ultimate Team, buying players and trying to win league upon league whilst not throwing a controller off the wall at the same time. It can be infuriating, but that's what makes it so good, that's what makes it so addictive to play. On the downside, the recent rumblings of constant server crashes, dodgy AI and fluidity of the game has shown a few chinks in FIFA's armour, something that may have put people off in the past. In the long term aspect of the game, the feeling is that EA are running out of ideas and with the launch of the new consoles later this year, their attention may wander to focus on the next generation rather than maintaining the current generation, and you can just sense Electronic Arts may tail off their interest. In fairness though, the game is one of the best played around. It's a popular choice and it does have it moments of brilliance - easily a huge favourite for the best out of FIFA vs PES. But hold your horses, let not rule out PES just yet, the gang at Konami do have a case to retaliate with...

Pro Evolution Soccer

Pro Evo header Pro Evolution Soccer burst on to the scene in 2001 and launched for the Playstation and Playstation 2, taking the world of football-gaming by storm (International Superstar Soccer aside of course). From the off, Konami had unearthed an extremely bright gem within their ranks, providing the kind of game that is simple yet very effective to those who loved the sport as well as a new football game to play. Although it will always face criticism of a lack of licence - the reason why team names, stadiums and players are a wee bit dodgy - PES always made up the negatives with a specific system that was impressive for the level of graphics available to consoles 12-years ago, keeping you hooked for hours. As the years progressed, so to did the game. Match engines greatly improved and the overall experience of playing not only in the famous Master Leagues became more enjoyable but so did the ability to play online, albeit not as well known as it's rival. It started playing to the cover start excellently as well, starting off with the piercing stare of Pierluigi Collina for the third instalment and even adding Lionel Messi between 2009 - 2011, before Cristiano Ronaldo made it his own from 2012. Sadly however, the game did drop off over time and began to lose its footing next to FIFA once it got up and running. Problems with online games, smoothness of games and even questionable player likeness all received a hammering by critics and gamers alike. No matter how hard they tried, even by adding licences to the Champions League, Spanish, Italian and French league to their repertoire, they just could not compete against the powers of EA. But this year however, things are starting to look up. PES 2014 has made up a lot of lost ground, the overall gameplay itself - along with going it going back to basics - has really brought the game closer to the fans. With the constant complaints of glitches and crashes in FIFA, most users are starting to go back, just to enjoy playing a football game again. More teams are available along with almost crystal-clear player likeness with certain clubs and even the commentary has scored some much needed points for Konami, giving them a perfect platform to build on for next year. But what's the verdict then? Find out on the next page

Winner - FIFA

Fifa14wow Only by the skin of its teeth has FIFA won this. If it wasn't for their history of consistent games and Ultimate Team, then PES would have claimed this by a mile. FIFA really have raised the bar over the years, implementing bits and bobs to enhance the experience of playing football with PES left behind, no matter how many new features are added. It will always be the one game that everyone knows, talks about, spends every available hour playing until the sun comes up and thumbs are flattened...or TV screens are ruined. But as I have mentioned, FIFA looks like they have slipped up a little this year, costing them a few fans to return to the good old days like in 2001 onwards. Who knows, next year the roles could be reversed, FIFA could lose ground and a whole new playing field could be put out there. What do you think? Do you agree that FIFA is the winner or has PES always been the top dog of football gaming? Comment below!

Contributor
Contributor

A North East freelance sports journalist who contributes in both written and video formats, with particular interest in athletics and football. I also like to dabble in a spot of gaming as well as film, mainly comic book themed and reading a few too. I am Batman.