FIFA 17: 15 Most Criminally Underrated Players

Imagine a world where Riyad Mahrez can't even get a 90.

Fifa 17 Mahrez
EA Sports

EA's gargantuan FIFA franchise is often accused of overrating certain players, an accusation thrown around year after year. Quick, attacking footballers are often given a stat boost over their more solid, less-flashy counterparts, despite proving to be more consistent or valuable to their teams in real life.

Sometimes, however, a player will enjoy a spectacular season, only to be rewarded with a lowly rating once the latest instalment of the game is released - and this year is no exception. Fans will always believe their favourite teams and players to have been sold short, but their gripes may have a more legitimate edge this time around.

It is, of course, an incredibly tricky task to replicate the ability of a real sportsman in video game form - accounting for pace, power, versatility and consistency - but this year has seen a number of particularly baffling oversights. The life of a FIFA developer, eh?

From those who bossed the Premier League last year to emerging forces from across the globe, we've listed the 15 most criminally underrated players in FIFA 17. There are even a couple of those new legend cards in there...

15. Raheem Sterling - Manchester City

Raheem Sterling
PETER POWELL/epa/Corbis

Rating: 82

I can understand why EA decided to rate Raheem Sterling a fairly lowly 82, given the torrid time he had last season. However, the former Liverpool man has made an explosive start to the season, and seems to have a new sense of purpose under Pep Guardiola.

After his 2015/16 campaign, it was a little too easy to forget that Sterling is one of the brightest young prospects in English football, and that players of the highest pedigree can disappear for a season or more (just look at Eden Hazard and Yaya Toure). He certainly looks to be back on track now.


14. Kingsley Coman - Bayern Munich (On Loan From Juventus)

kingsley Roman bayern munich
© Andreas Gebert/dpa/Corbis

Rating: 81

EA are usually eager - perhaps too eager - to slap high ratings on the wonderkids of world football, eager to be ahead of the curve in predicting a new superstar. In the case of Kingsley Coman, however, I think FIFA 17 has it wrong in the opposite sense.

Coman's rating of 81 is very surprising. Yes, he may lack experience in terms of longevity, but he's already plied his trade at some of the biggest club teams on Earth: PSG, Juventus, and his current temporary home at Bayern Munich. Expect a breakout season for the young Frenchman.


13. Marcus Rashford - Manchester United

Jose Mourinho
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Rating: 76

Like Coman, Rashford runs the risk of being overhyped. He's not made too many appearances for Man United, but his effectiveness so far can't be denied - and even earned him a late call-up to England's Euro 2016 squad.

Rashford is only rated 76 on this year's game, a stock which will surely rise by a good few notches should he continue to perform as well as he has done so far. It'll be interesting to see whether he can break into a first team also featuring Ibrahimovic, Martial and Lingard.


12. Moussa Dembele - Celtic

Celtic v Rangers - Ladbrokes Scottish Premiership
2016 Getty Images

Rating: 71

Of all the players on this list, the least-known is probably Moussa Dembele (the Frenchman, as opposed to his Belgian namesake) - at least until his explosive performance in the recent Old Firm derby, in which he dismantled Rangers with a brilliant hat-trick.

Having spent the previous three years at Fulham, many wondered how well Dembele would transition to the SPL - a place where many careers are developed well, but many are also reduced in stature. It looks as though this particular striker will have no such worries, and should quickly improve upon his lowly 71 rating.


11. Adam Lallana - Liverpool

Adam Lallana
Peter Byrne/PA Wire

Rating: 82

Adam Lallana, like Raheem Sterling, didn't enjoy the best of seasons last time around - but has really hit the ground running in the first few fixtures of the year. He's been a key cog in a vital Liverpool line-up, and hasn't at all been outshone by the likes of Philippe Coutinho and Roberto Firmino.

Time will tell whether the England international will return to his Southampton best, or dip once more as the season drags on - but all the signs so far look as though he's ready to thrive under Jurgen Klopp.


10. Kelechi Iheanacho - Manchester City

Manchester City v AFC Bournemouth - Premier League
2016 Getty Images

Rating: 74

For all the plaudits Marcus Rashford receives, those in the blue half of Manchester will make twice as much noise about Kelechi Iheanacho - and with good reason. The Nigerian international may not have much experience, but he's already proving himself a bit of a super sub.

It's easy to see why Iheanacho is so highly regarded; he has a natural eye for goal and always seems to end up in the right place to tap home a rebound. For some reason, EA have deemed it appropriate to slap him with a 74 rating - but surely a higher number would have been more accurate.


9. Heung-min Son - Tottenham Hotspur

Middlesbrough v Tottenham Hotspur - Premier League
2016 Getty Images

Rating: 78

Son arrived at Spurs with an impressive pedigree. Despite being only 24, the South Korean international has a proven record in the Bundesliga, as well as notching 16 goals for his country.

The forward saw limited action last season, but has enjoyed a great start this year. He's bagged braces against both Stoke and Middlesbrough, and is showing little signs of slowing down. He has a decent FIFA 17 rating of 78, but deserves to be well into the 80s in my opinion.


8. Shinji Kagawa - Borussia Dortmund

Dortmund's Shinji Kagawa
Martin Meissner/AP

Rating: 83

Shinji Kagawa's FIFA rating is probably still tainted by his ill-fated time in Manchester, which isn't entirely fair. Sure, the Japanese international had an underwhelming time at Old Trafford, but has rediscovered his form since returning the Borussia Dortmund.

The creative midfielder was a crucial part of last year's side, and made it into the Bundesliga team of the season. His 83 rating isn't bad by any means, but Kagawa has once again become one of the most high-profile attacking midfielders in Europe.


7. Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang - Borussia Dortmund

Pierre Emerick Aubameyang Dortmund
Martin Meissner/AP/Press Association Images

Rating: 86

There are players that seem on the cusp of greatness, often identified as a hot prospect a year or two before exploding in a big way - but sometimes certain players seem to become lethal overnight. Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang is certainly one such player.

Aubameyang has been a fearsome striker for a good few seasons now, but continues to plug away at Dortmund - despite a near-constant cycle of big transfer rumours every summer and winter. His FIFA rating is an impressive 86, but with the rest of Europe's top strikers hovering closer to the 90 mark, the Gabonese international certainly deserves to be up there too.


6. Mauro Icardi - Inter Milan

Inter Milan forward Mauro Icardi, of Argentina, celebrates after scoring during a Serie A soccer match between Inter Milan and Sassuolo, at the San Siro stadium in Milan, Italy, Sunday, Sept.14, 2014. (AP Photo/Luca Bruno)
Luca Bruno/AP

Rating: 82

Inter striker Mauro Icardi has been so firmly in the media spotlight over the past few years, it's easy to forget that he's only 23 years old. The Argentinian forward was embroiled in controversy due to an affair with his former teammate's wife (now his own wife), but such a volatile incident can't overshadow the fact that he's dynamite in front of goal.

The frontman has notched 53 goals in 96 league appearances for the Italian side, and is widely regarded one of the brightest young players in Europe. Despite this, his FIFA 17 rating is inexplicably as low as 82.


5. Rio Ferdinand - Legend

FILE - A Sunday, Sept. 22, 2013 photo from files showing Manchester United's Rio Ferdinand during their English Premier League soccer match against Manchester City at the Etihad Stadium in Manchester, England. Rio Ferdinand says he is leaving Manchest
Clint Hughes/AP

Rating: 88

Rio Ferdinand obviously needs no introduction, and is one of the new legends introduced in FIFA 17 - yet his rating is bafflingly low.

Obviously it's a good rating - Rio finds himself at 88 - but I find that a very low score for a man regarded as one of the best defenders in the history of English football.

Despite that, Rio isn't the most underrated legend in this year's instalment of the game...


4. Paul Scholes - Legend

Manchester United's Paul Scholes celebrates after scoring against Wolverhampton Wanderers during their English Premier League soccer match at Molineux Stadium, Wolverhampton, England, Saturday March 6, 2010. (AP Photo/Jon Super) ** NO INTERNET/MOBILE
Jon Super/AP

Rating: 89

There's a bit of personal bias here, admittedly, because I think Paul Scholes is absurdly good. The Manchester United legend would find his way onto many people's all-time Premier League team, and with good reason.

His 89 rating may not seem too shabby at all, but I believe Scholes should be regarded as a player in the 90s. He enjoyed one of the greatest careers we're ever likely to see from an English midfielder, and was an invaluable part of the most dominant team in Premier League history for almost two decades.


3. N'Golo Kante - Chelsea

Chelsea v Liverpool - Premier League
2016 Getty Images

Rating: 81

Jamie Vardy and Riyad Mahrez scooped the lion's share of praise during Leicester City's incredible league winning season, but a key cog in midfield was the tireless N'Golo Kante. The diminutive Frenchman was incredible at times, breaking up play, moving the ball, and generally running the team from the centre of the park.

His FIFA 17 rating is a bizarrely low 81, which says nothing about his presence and poise throughout 2015/16. Even a move to Chelsea has failed to boost his rating, despite EA often bumping up players on the basis of transfers rather than form - but hopefully he'll go on to prove his quality as the new season progresses.


2. Paulo Dybala - Juventus

Italy Soccer Serie A Dybala
Massimo Pinca/AP

Rating: 85

Paulo Dybala, like Mauro Icardi, is a young Argentinian striker who has been making serious waves in Serie A. The Juventus forward scored 19 goals in 34 league appearances last year, and was instrumental in the Turin side's success. He has yet to score for his country, but only has four caps, and should see plenty of opportunities to build international experience over the course of the season.

The faith Juve have in Dybala was proven when they offered him the number 10 shirt (last worn by the departing Paul Pogba), but the Argentinian preferred to keep his original number. He has a variety of skills up front, from dribbling to hold-up play - and of course a lethal eye for goal - but for one of football's brightest emerging talents, his FIFA rating remains a not overly impressive 85.


1. Riyad Mahrez - Leicester City

Mahrez Leicester City
Adam Davy/EMPICS Sport

Rating: 85

What more is there to say about Riyah Mahrez that wasn't covered last season? The Algerian international was voted player of the season, and without him, it's doubtful the Foxes would have sealed their astonishing Premier League title.

Despite being linked with a big-money move to teams including Barcelona, the creative winger remains a presence at the King Power Stadium for now - but has a FIFA rating as low as 85.

As in the case of Dybala, 85 is certainly nothing to be embarrassed about, but last season's Player of the Year should really have been given a greater boost for this year's instalment of the game.


Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.