FIFA 19 Beta Review: 8 Hands-On Impressions You Need To Know

Is this the year EA right their wrongs?

FIFA 19
EA

FIFA 19 is a little under a month from its release, and while the latest instalment in EA's long-running football series looks to be offering improvements aplenty, finding consensus amongst the sport-sim's fans has proven difficult.

This has proven especially true in the wake of FIFA 19's closed beta, which ended August 20. Issues regarding the game's upcoming Career Mode were documented across various channels, and though the final instalment in The Journey has gotten plenty excited too, there is a danger that this latest FIFA debuts with a whimper, and not a bang.

With the demo set to release to the public in just a few weeks' time, and with minimal changes expected between now and then, time is running short for EA to properly address community concerns ahead of its release September 28.

Regardless of that however, it’s still clear that FIFA 19 is still FIFA - it still plays, looks and feels much like you’d expect a FIFA game to play. There are some tweaks to gameplay worth noting though, and with 19 arguably presenting a greater step-up between entries than its predecessor, it makes sense to detail all that works (and what doesn’t).


8. Passing Feels Great Again

FIFA 19 Finesse Shot
EA

Though the system certainly takes some getting used to, FIFA 19's changes to gameplay are both noticeable and innovative. Nowhere is this more prevalent than in the game's passing, with driven and lobbed passes, through-balls and crosses all feeling that little bit more genuine.

Players should take extra care and attention to hone their skills this time around, but once they've acclimatised to EA's changes, they'll never look back - especially if they're fond of possession-based, tiki-taka football.

While this isn't to say that FIFA 19's new formula is spot-on in every way (wingers struggling to beat their man was an all too common occurrence), the emphasis on rewarding playmakers for a perfectly timed lobbed pass makes for a refreshing twist.


7. The Addition Of The UEFA License Helps Immersion

FIFA 19 Champions League
EA Sports

Prior to FIFA 19, players busy immersing themselves in Career Mode had to make due with two substitute European tournaments. Instead of the Europa League, managers had the Euro League. The Champions League too was completely absent, with the 'Champions Cup' appearing in its place.

It's understandable, then, as to why EA have made such a big deal of attaining the UEFA license. The Champions League is here, complete with its iconic theme, symbol and ball - and to complete the makeover EA have even introduced a new selection of commentators. Before Martin Tyler and Alan Smith would commentate on every match, but now the likes of Derek Rae and Lee Dixon offer a narration of their own.

This greater focus on the license has already proven to be a hit with players, but smaller additions shouldn't go unnoticed either. The English League Cup now has its full Carabao license - Gerry & The Pacemakers' version of 'You'll Never Walk Alone' plays during every Anfield match day - and the acquisitions of the Chinese Super League and Serie A licenses are expected to follow.

Sure, these small aesthetic changes don't change too much, but it'd be disingenuous to say they aren't welcome additions to FIFA.


6. The Step-Up IS Noticeable

FIFA 19 Champions League
EA

Although you'd have a hard time conveying the difference between FIFA 16 and 17, or perhaps even 17 and 18, the step-up between 18 and this year's instalment is noticeable.

FIFA 19 looks, plays and feels different to its predecessor, and while that isn't to say that it makes enough changes (certainly not, at the time of writing), the system on the whole does feel a lot different to FIFA 18. The change in passing has already been noted, but together, it's actually the smaller changes that have combined to impart a fresher feeling on FIFA 19 - irrespective of whether or not it's enough to justify the yearly reinvestment.

So yes, there are noticeable changes. It may be a case of quantity over quality, but at least there's a discernible difference between this year's entry and the last's.


5. But Career Mode Hasn't Changed Enough

FIFA 19 Manager
EA Sports

By far the most frustrating thing about FIFA 19, however, are the lack of changes to Career Mode. Yes, players will be able to get into European competition and customise their manager with a variety of different outfits, but the mode is still a ways away from realising its full potential.

Worse still, it actually feels as though a lot of these upgrades could've probably been added to FIFA 18 in gradual updates to the game. That isn't the case though, and those looking to invest heavily in Career Mode are likely to feel shortchanged just a few months after FIFA 19 releases, as EA once again focus their efforts on the perennial cash cow that is FIFA Ultimate Team.

It's just disappointing, and though these changes are welcome, it's still a case of too little, too late.


4. Timed Finishing Feels Kind Of Pointless

FIFA 19
EA Sports

One of the biggest changes to FIFA 19's gameplay is the addition of 'Timed Finishing'. Billed by EA as a 'risk vs reward' feature designed to add a new dimension to shooting, players will now be given the option to press the shoot button a second time after charging up their initial shot. If the second touch falls inside the green bar, then they'll be rewarded with a more accurate and powerful blast - mistime it, and it's likely that they'll sky it into the stands.

The most perplexing thing about this feature, sadly, is that it's not actually essential. Players can simply choose to ignore it if they so choose, and though that could be taken as a means to ensure FIFA retains its broad appeal, those looking to use the feature are basically adding more challenge to their game than their needed to be in the first place.

Shooting was, for the most part, fine in FIFA 18. Driven shots were slightly broken, yes, but they weren't unfixable. Timed Finishing, on the other hand, feels like a solution to a problem that wasn't there to begin with - and not a particularly good one at that.


3. The Realism Will Impress And Annoy In Equal Measure

FIFA 19

Yet again FIFA is visually stunning; from the sweat glistening on a player's brow to the awe-inspiring sights as your players trot out in one of the games many infamous stadiums, but in terms of realistic gameplay it ranges from pleasantly surprising improvements to controller-breaking frustration.

AI when both attacking and defending is much better, whereas before I'd be yelling at players to provide support or overlapping runs when going forward, as long as you've set the right tactics you'll be far more of an attacking unit with players giving you options to break opponents down. Defensively, they're far more proactive, stick with who they're marking, and are there to cut out misplaced passes far more effectively than in previous versions of the game.

On the downside, how realistic the game is when it comes to first touches and accuracy of passing will be a real source of initial annoyance. In fairness, it's good that FIFA 19 reflects the varying levels of ability but with the introduction of the 'Active Touch System' and the aforementioned passing system, things you took for granted and assumed you already had mastered will take some getting used to.

Speaking of which...


2. You'll Need To Train To Get Used To Some New Features

EA Sports

Even those players who are seasoned FIFA veterans will need to spend some time on the training pitch in order to utilise the new features that have been introduced.

Although 'Timed Finishing' can be simply disregarded, if you can hone your skills with it almost any player can become lethal in front of goal. Similarly, the changes in passing mean that whilst you'll eventually just get used to the new system and it's benefits, spending a short while re-learning the basics will really help in the long run and allow you to vary the way you move the ball across the park.

Finally, the new 'Active Touch System' when mastered can be a complete game-changer and add a completely new dimension to your attack. What with it being a new addition to FIFA there's a step-by-step guide to how and when to utilise this feature so invest some time in the training and you'll be vastly rewarded in the game.


1. Tactics Are Actually Effective

FIFA 19

Despite all the new features, improvements, and addition of the Champions League, the increased effectiveness of tactics may well be the crowning glory of FIFA 19.

Tactics in the new game are far more comprehensive than ever before, an example being the variety of defensive styles. Whereas before the changes felt nominal, now you can select from Balanced, Pressure On Heavy Touch, Press After Possession Loss, Constant Pressure, and Drop Back, all of which come with a visual demonstration and description of what each style does, and genuinely have an effect on your style of play.

Almost every area of tactics can be customised in FIFA 19; from number of players in the box for corners, to how deep you want your team to sit when defending, to the ability to apply custom tactics to the D-Pad rather than pre-set attacking & defending options.

Previous versions of the game allowed you to develop personalised tactics but it always felt as though they had little impact on the game aside from what formation you set out to play. On FIFA 19, your team genuinely gegenpresses your opponent when told to, encourages forward runs from your full-backs when instructed, and can execute an offside trap like never before.

Tactics have been transformed from an afterthought or last resort, to the ultimate tool in personalising and getting the most out of your team. They make you feel like the next Guardiola, Klopp, or Mourinho...if that's your kind of thing.

--

Read Next: PES 2019 Review: 5 Reasons It's Awesome

PES 2019
Konami

We love teamwork! Who doesn't? This article is a collaborative effort between Ewan Paterson and Adam Wilbourn.
In this post: 
FIFA 19
 
Posted On: 
Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.

Contributor
Contributor

Lanky, specky, ginger bloke who loves all things wrestling, football and quiz related. The man who invented the #BloodyGoodQuiz.