Gears Of War: Every Game Ranked From Worst To Best

Chainsaws, sad songs and a BUNCH of chest-high walls.

Gears of War ranked
Microsoft

For almost 13 years now, Gears of War has been one of the powerhouses franchises in video games. This series didn’t just fundamentally change the course of the third person action genre, with legions of clones pumped out in its wake, but the trajectory of the Xbox 360 itself.

Gears of War has also been a step in the right direction when it comes to storytelling and character design, as this series has kind of grown up with a generation of players.

What was a series full of musclebound space marine archetypes, slowly morphed into characters that had personality, and many of us truly cared about who lived or died. Who would’ve thought there would ever be any tear-jerking moments when Gears first hit our shelves back in 2006?

It isn’t often that a franchise like this becomes a trendsetter and manages to not only stay relevant, but also still be good so many years later.

You just have to look at the state of Halo and Mass Effect to see how quickly things can fall off a cliff, so with all that mind, how does the whole series rank, and which is the best of the bunch?

8. Gears POP!

gears pop
Microsoft

Back in E3 2018 we had three new Gears games announced: Gears 5, Gears Tactics (which we've seen precious little of), and Gears POP. The latter has taken Gears, fused it with Funko POPs and forced it all into a Clash of Clans style phone game.

Admittedly this is one of the better free to play games released on the mobile in 2019, but that is all it really is. Send waves of troops, Locust or COG to fight another player and destroy their base.

Wait for a cooldown meter to dictate who's freed up and when, then once you’ve done that, just rinse and repeat until you're bored.

Hey, at least you can chainsaw the loser's head off afterwards and there's achievement support.


7. Gears Of War: Judgment

gears of war judgment
Epic Games

The first three Gears of War games come together to make a near-perfect trilogy. It is so damn rare that video game stories have a satisfying ending, so after 3 tied everything up, the only place to go was into the past.

Epic was signed to a four-game deal, so it was inevitable that we were going to be graced with something after Gear of War 3, but Judgment failed to set the world on fire.

As a prequel to the beloved trilogy, it served almost no purpose in the grand scheme of things. It isn’t like players were clamouring to find out the backstory on Baird or Cole, and most of the new cast were totally forgettable.

All of them including Garron Paduk, who then shows up in Gears 5, even though by the end it was neat to have him back and remind everyone that Judgment happened.

What Epic should’ve done with the fourth game is go even further back to the events of the Pendulum Wars to shed a little more light on the history of the COG. At least that wouldn’t have felt so safe or like glorified DLC.


6. Gears Of War

Gears of War
Epic Games

When it comes to most influential games this side of the Millennium, there aren’t many that can stand toe to toe with the original Gears of War.

For a hot minute, everything coming out that wasn’t a first-person shooter seemed the be jumping on the cover-based shooter bandwagon that Gear of War popularised.

And not only that, but this game might be one of the most important to the Xbox 360's lifecycle overall.

Gears cost Microsoft an insane 10 million dollars to develop, and another billion on top of that to double the amount of RAM in each console. Did Gears of War and Epic unintentionally solidify the 360’s dominance for most of the generation? Absolutely.

But putting all of the technical details aside, it is the lore, the world and characters that drew players in. That and the fact these hulking specimens were rocking chainsaws on the end of their guns. It seems so simple, but for the time this was really out there.

Marcus, Dom, Cole and Baird came together to form the Delta squad, with players everywhere growing to know and love them.


5. Gears Of War 4

gears of war 4
Microsoft

Many have started to ask the question, should Gears of War come back after 3, or should we have left that original trilogy alone and treasure it for years to come? Well, that didn’t happen.

We got 4, which is seen as the "Force Awakens" of the series, because from top to bottom, this game is very safe.

Thankfully some new weapons like the Enforcer served to mix up multiplayer enough - finally countering hardcore Gnasher users and bringing the Gears multiplayer to the current generation of consoles.

The new cast of characters are just fine, and for most of this fourth entry, they remain that way as they along with old man Marcus discovered that the Locust threat has returned in the form of the Swarm. Which is something that is totally underplayed and should be way more of a dramatic moment in Gears of War 4.

Unfortunately, this wasn’t the best start for Kait, JD and Del. Gears 4 was the best playing Gears game at the time, but robotic DeeBee’s weren't that satisfying to shoot, the story felt flat for the most part, and even the horde mode felt forced in. Everyone loves a bit of horde, but not three separate times in a campaign.


4. Gears Of War: Ultimate Edition

Gears Of War Delta Squad
Microsoft

Now you might ask, why isn’t the Ultimate Edition and OG version rolled into the same entry on this list?

Well, there is more than enough here to justify the first outing by The Coalition as something more than a remaster, and a game that can stand on its own. Going forward, this should be the only way players experience the first Gears of War.

The biggest changes were that combat feels a lot more fluid, and not as stagnant as the 2006 version now tends to feel. Mainly, although we never realised it at the time, now you can fight more than four enemies at once. The missing chapters that were at one time only available on the PC are now here too.

Of course in this added hour Delta team have to split up, but there is also a decent boss fight against a Brumak and this also explains why Marcus and Dom have to jump on a moving train.

The superb graphical upgrade can go unmentioned, sure back in its day Gears of War was the benchmark in graphical power, but it has aged quite a bit since the heyday. But Ultimate Edition could actually be mistaken for a current title and frankly, this was a promising first effort from the Coalition.

Now all we need is the same treatment for 2 and 3.


3. Gears Of War 2

Gears Of War 2 Marcus
Epic

Coming only 2 years after the original Gears of War, which would be unheard of now and even quite impressive for the time, the second instalment hit with much critical acclaim and was well worth it. This game was longer, the scale ramped up to an insane degree, and it really defined each character going forward.

New characters such as Dizzy really helped to paint a picture of a bigger world for players - this former big rig driver was a conscript for the COG, and wasn’t really there by choice. Tai - who seemed like a great warrior - quickly offs himself after being rescued, which later sets up what might be the fate of Dom’s wife.

The Locust don’t just capture you, they break you.

Sure, the dark heavily atmospheric nature of the first Gears was perfect for the time, but Cliff Bleszinski, Rod Fergusson and the rest of Epic understood that this game had to step it up a gear.

No longer was the combat limited to just four enemies like the first, the variety of beast and weapons served to shake firefights up, and all in all, this game was a set-piece showcase.

Also, who can forget that chainsaw duelling made its way into the series here?

Talk about things we didn't know we wanted until we saw them.


2. Gears 5

Gears 5
Microsoft

Gears 4 was "just another Gears of War game", and not long after launch it seemed as if nobody cared anymore, but with Gears 5, they are onto a winner.

As stated in our review, this game takes the right sort of chances, the open-world works for the most part, and when traditional Gears levels roll out, boy do things kick-off. The Skiff is a joy to ride and has finally broken the tradition of bad vehicle sequences in Gears games.

Scenes and set pieces have so much weight to them now, the cast old and new are the best Gears has ever had, and you’ll find yourself rooting for them all.

There are callbacks to almost every game (even Judgment), which helps tie that whole story in so well. The shooting is also unmatched, there is now an incredible arsenal - so everyone can have a gun to suit their play style.

Where Kait, Marcus and the other will go from here, I don’t know, but the future looks bright for Gears 6.


1. Gears Of War 3

Gears Of War 3 Anya
Microsoft

It was extremely close for this, but Gears of War 3 took the day as the very best a Gears game has to offer.

Not only is it the culmination of the past two games before it, but Gears of War 3 was a moment in time for the gaming industry. The series that had kicked off the 360 was coming to an end, and it certainly left its mark.

The big tough guys from the past two games were now at the end of it all, scrounging for anything they could get, resorting to weapons from the Pendulum Wars and even growing their own food supply to stay alive.

The Lambent posed a real threat for both the COG and the Locust, and mixed up gameplay more than enough in the campaign. Anya also got to join the fight because this really was the last stand. Emergent holes were a thing of the past, now the Lambent ruled the depths of Sera, they would fire out the ground from anywhere, whenever they wanted.

The campaign truly doesn’t let up, and is the best-paced of all the games. Defending Anvil Gate is a standout scene, which comes not much before the best moment in the series.

If you were going to pick one Gears game to hold up as why the series matters so much, it's Gears of War 3.


Contributor
Contributor

Resident Evil Aficionado. Video Games & Fried Chicken are my passions. Occasionally some Wrestling. I used to work in Film & TV, but now I Write, Edit & Present for this website and its Youtube Channels.