GTA V: 10 Ways It Failed To Improve On GTA IV
Grand Theft Auto V is genuinely an exceptional experience, and it deserves most of the hyperbole that it is attracting, but is it really a huge step forward from GTA IV, which was ritually ripped to shreds by fans who expected the world, got a near five star game and were unduly disappointed? The answer is no. Both GTA V and GTA IV are excellent games, despite the venomous bile that the latter inspires from certain quarters: both are monumental achievements, and while GTA V is the superior of the two as a complete package, there are components that simply have not been improved from GTA IV. Perhaps it was unreasonable to expect a dramatic uplift in quality between IV and V, since the games both have to comply with the technological constraints of current gen consoles (which is why graphics get a free pass here) but the issues outlined below are areas that could very reasonably have been fixed or improved upon. And though they might be sorted out by patches, or the PC and next gen releases, it is not unreasonable as a fan to wish they had been improved upon ahead of release. At the end of the day, even with the Game Of The Year award probably under its belt by the time the new generation of games lands in the coming months, will GTA V be considered as genre-defining as GTA IV? Who knows, but with the following issues to consider and in light of how GTA IV was criticised for some of the very same problems, it's certainly an intriguing question. Honourable Mention
No Day One PC Availability
Perhaps a triviality to console gamers, but Rockstar's decision to delay the PC release (and occasionally flirt outrageously with the idea of not releasing on PC at all) is a major point of criticism for fans who prefer their game engine to have a little more PC-powered oomph behind it. Naturally, the reasoning is sound - console gamers are the key market for games like GTA, and releasing to what amounts to a superior platform (in terms of the tech, and the way players can explore the guts of the game - and usually change them) would be effectively like showing console gamers the limits of their technology. But then, the game WILL come to PC eventually, and it was never particularly likely for Rockstar to roll the game out on PC as well at launch. It's far smarter on their part to launch after the next gen launches.
10. The Sidekicks
Roman Bellic gets a lot of undue criticism, but the annoying, portly cousin of Niko gets under the player's skin for good reason. He is one of the best written characters in the GTA series, achieving exactly what the developers targeted, in that he inspires a mixture of frustration and affection (which is wholly visible in the criticism that he attracts) and he is utterly memorable. The ultimate narrative trick that you have to choose between Roman and Kate McCreary is a particularly smart one, and the fact that it is a difficult choice, despite Roman's annoyances, is testament to the enduring, but perhaps perverse, appeal of the character (and probably also the fact that GTA doesn't exactly encourage you to like female characters.) Roman is also head and shoulders above every supporting character in GTA V - none of the central characters who are close to Roman's importance in GTA IV are even remotely as interesting or as smartly conceived. There are some good gimmicks, such as Wade's childish mind, but none feel particularly rounded, or even particularly memorable, other than as narrative devices. As much as he might be hated, there's no denying that there are no supporting characters in GTA V who have the same sort of impact or relevance as Roman Bellic did.
9. The Setting
Though the open world universe of GTA V is a stunning achievement, with a plethora of activities to draw the attention, and a massive number of side missions and intrigue points dotted liberally around the map (including a huge number of Easter Eggs and in-jokes) there's something not quite right with the Californian setting. The sun-drenched Californian community is a great setting on its own - the pools and swanky backyards of the affluent neighbourhoods lend themselves to some entertaining time-wasting (like pool jumping) and the rolling hills and countryside offer scale that hasn't been possible to date. But it's hard to resist the feeling that the neighbourhoods might have been better if you could enter every building, since the move away from a New York City style skyline drags the scale of the game down to street level, and the mountains and hilly areas needed more to do. It simply isn't as appealing as Liberty City, whose vast scale and New York reference points had more of an identity, and felt more appropriate for the content of the game. And it isn't merely the general feel of the setting - the game is so big, and the constraints of console technology so limiting that the environments feel a lot deader than they should, especially on completion of the story mode, which papers over the issues a little.
8. Flying = Impossible
You might think that GTA V's addition of planes as a drivable vehicle has to be counted as a major plus point over GTA IV (and the many, many modders who made it happen in GTA IV would probably attest to that) but the overall flying physics in the game are a step backwards. In both games it is possible to take control of a helicopter, with the obvious addition of planes in GTA V, but the addition of more realistic air turbulence, and the general impossibility of piloting a flying vehicle in every game ever made make the whole experience more of a chore than it should be. Flight school in particular is flat out boring (and it's not 100% clear that you don't even NEED to complete it to progress, which is remarkably frustrating after two hours, a broken controller and several removed clumps of hair.) Okay, so maybe it is easier than in San Andreas, but the turbulence issue might as well be replaced with a giant random Godzilla reaching into the sky and smashing your puny plane of chopper to pieces on the ground, because that's exactly how random it feels. Then of course there are more specific problems with flying, such as the online racing portion of the game that can lead to beautifully stupid moments like this happening...
7. The Music
The soundtrack in GTA V is just about okay - there are some excellent tracks on there, but it definitely feels like the musical accompaniment to the GTA games has been on a steady decline since the heady days of Vice City. Despite the high-points, it feels a lot like Rockstar haven't invested in music as heavily as fans might demand - which is perhaps why they found themselves facing legal action over the use of two songs by rapper Daz Dillinger (via TMZ.) Surely a cardinal sin for any game's music department is to make it preferable to turn the music off entirely and that's exactly the effect that prolongued exposure for the majority of the radio stations achieves in GTA V. It's unfortunate that Rockstar still haven't rolled out an MP3 player in the game, or at least a customisable radio station - which will no doubt be added for the PC release early on by modders, as it traditionally always is - to allow players to bring their own musical tastes to their gameplay experience. Perhaps it's down to the fact that Vice City's commitment to music was so incredible, but the series has never had anything like that sort of high-point since, and the music in GTA V is often unforgivably boring.
6. No More Fast Food
Making a game harder should never be considered a bad thing: though GTA V has dropped some of the more gritty elements of GTA IV and gone all-out for a higher fun factor, the healing system has been given a more realistic update that makes the game fundamentally harder. That in itself is a good thing - though dropping health for running quickly over long distances is clearly an issue - because it makes the player think more about what they're doing, rather than allowing themselves to be run over, knowing that it might not necessarily be fatal. In GTA V, the health system is mostly more authentic (despite the moments of stupidity when players fall out of the sky, land on their backsides and are miraculously not dead) but the removal of fast food outlets is an annoyance that doesn't need to happened. Clearly some compromises had to be made for console strain, but the fast food outlets in GTA IV were one of its high-points (in terms of fan engagement anyway,) with the functional appeal of being able to boost health compounded by the attention to detail that gave various workers different duties in the restaurants. And then of course there was also the dlightful opportunity to rob a Cluckin' Bell as soon as you'd paid for some tasty, and life-giving chicken. Making health easier to lose is a plus point, but making it harder - and crucially, anti-progressive - to find health boosts is a step backwards.
5. The Comedy Physics
The physics in GTA IV were often hilariously poor, despite Rockstar's commitment to bringing in a new system to make climbing and vaulting smoother. In theory that was a major step forward for the franchise, but the execution was far from smooth, and the result was a main character who was beyond stupid when it came to interacting with environmental changes like tiny ledges, or choosing whether to vault over a small wall or to leap into oncoming traffic in entirely the wrong direction. This was one of the areas fans hoped would get a total revamp to fix the stupid moments, but GTA V is blighted by similar idiotic blips. It might not happen so often, but the controlled character definitely still suffers from a lack of basic intellect, and the punishment for poor physics completely outweighs the actual mistake - such as moments like the video below, where attacks go wrong and a simple misplaced jump into a seemingly harmless monument can result in death... And then of course there are moments like the flying car glitch, or the fact that being run over can either result in you falling over and cursing, or being flung long distances and dying immediately. Or the fact that crashes often elicit comical results (such as a train being able to shrug aside two giant dumper trucks, as above, despite the fact that a single wet leaf can often make the train network in Britain grind to a halt for hours.) Physics and collision detection are better than they have been in the past - particularly in GTA III - but the problems that happened in GTA IV are still present, because the game is still based on the RAGE physics engine (albeit with some positive tweaks.) Perhaps it was unfair to expect a whole new physics engine with the improvements that came in with the implementation of the RAGE system, but there are just too many jaw-droppingly stupid physics fail videos out there to suggest that the problems have been sufficiently dealt with.
4. Driving
There are certainly incontrovertible truths when it comes to GTA games - there will be swears, there will be adult content, and driving will suck, despite the fact that it accounts for a massive portion of the gameplay. Over the years Rockstar have spent some time fixing the driving mechanics, so they're a lot smoother and realistic than they used to be, but you can still recapture the feeling of riding on the back of an unguided missile whenever you choose to steal one of the faster cars in the game. No matter what your ability in other driving games, GTA's driving mechanics will not reward you - it's like there's a whole other skill set required to master driving through streets than there is to drive as vast speeds around unforgiving racetracks in all conditions outside of the GTA world, and that shouldn't be the case. You might think you're in control one minute, but you're never too far away from a comical disaster, either because some NPC vehicles take it upon themselves to drive like utter maniacs, or because the axels and steering column of your car will all of a sudden turn to jello at high speed. That's not to say they were any good in GTA IV either, but you would have hoped that Rockstar would have had a team working on the driving physics and car damage parts of the game solely since the release of the last game, since they are so highly in focus.
3. The Hero & The Villain
Like Roman Bellic, there's no beating Niko Bellic in the charisma stakes, even when you come armed with a trio of main characters. Niko and Roman are the defining characters of the entire series, driven by riches and power (especially in Roman's case) but also by a conviction to protect or avenge important people in their lives (as with Niko) and haunted by underlying past issues. Niko is Grand Theft Auto, and it would have taken a monumental effort to eclipse the achievements that went into making him such a memorable character. To their eternal credit, Rockstar made a valiant effort - Michael, Franklin and Trevor are each very good protagonists, though Michael would have worked better as a sole hero, Trevor is a little too pantomimey, and Franklin occasionally wanders into stereotyped territory too often. The mix is good, but because of the split focus, it's hard to imagine anyone saying any of the individual characters are better, or more engaging than Niko. Likewise, the villains in GTA V aren't as memorable as Dimitri Rascalov and even Mikhail Faustin - there is something far more personal about the villains of GTA IV than the more corporately driven antagonists in the follow-up, and getting rid of them is distinctly more pleasurable.
2. The Broken Bits
Along with the driving physics being broken, the other accepted inevitability with every GTA release is that the game will be full of bugs and outright broken in places. This should not be the case, but the sorry fact is that most GTA players will accept that every new release will be blighted with problems at launch, and that it will take several patches and updates for Rockstar to get the game up to the standard that it should have been on release. Like other GTA games - especially GTA IV - GTA V was broken on release, and the GTA Online portion was even more broken when it was released, prompting accusations of undercooked elements, and unforgivable corner cutting based on the knowledge that fans would still buy the game and accept the problems up to the point they are fixed. This is a culture in gaming that should not be accepted, but as long as the monetary returns beat the volume of the online complaints (and money talks loudly) there's no way Rockstar will further push back any GTA release because of bugs, and wide beta testing is not an option considering how the GTA hype machine would value leaks.
1. The Storytelling
In the early days following the release of GTA V, the hyperbole attached to the story-telling element of the game was almost comically overblown, but now that the honeymoon period has somewhat cooled, it is patently obvious that the story, and its delivery in GTA V does not surpass the quality or success of its counterpart in GTA IV. Despite all of the criticisms levelled at GTA IV, the general consensus still states that the game's story-telling is its chief success, and the reason it is rightly considered a genre-defining achievement. It is that success beyond all others that drove the hype that came attached to the announcement of GTA V, and rightly so, it is the element of GTA V that has been criticised the most as a result. Though the individual story elements are great and entertaining, the strands are not interwoven completely successfully, and there is a general lack of deep character development that is part and parcel of sharing focus between three protagonists that didn't happen in GTA IV. The make-up of the inter-weaved story elements was also far from completely successful, as important character events are frequently paused to allow another character to tackle something in their portion of the game, making key elements feel slightly tacked on in a reactionary way to add set-pieces. All-in-all GTA IV's story-telling is far smarter, and more engaging as a whole, even if the mission variation is a problem, and individual missions aren't necessarily as well-conceived or executed as in GTA V. At the end of the day, GTA V will still be crowned Game Of The Year, and probably the biggest selling game of the year by some distance, and neither of those achievements will find any argument here, but every game released has room for improvement, and blindly accepting anything as perfect, despite noticeable shortcomings, or a lack of progression in key areas, as outlined here is entirely reductive. Do you think GTA V should have improved on GTA IV more? Do you believe the game to be perfect? Share your opinions in the comment thread below.