GTA VI: 10 Things It Must Learn From Sleeping Dogs

Inspiration can come from the unlikeliest of places.

No doubt right now Rockstar are hard at work on whatever their followup to GTA V is going to be; whether that's a huge wait until the next direct instalment, a Bully/Red Dead sequel - or something totally out of left field like another Table Tennis game. For now though let's focus on GTA, and also a genre that although it was positively booming with copycat titles across the late 00's, has died down considerably in the last few years. The whole 'open-world crime game' template is always one that when given the appropriate care, can be spectacular - and although United Front Games' Sleeping Dogs was always a little rough around the edges back in 2012, with Sony discounting the Definitive Edition on the PS Store, it's prompting plenty fans to give it a whirl, coming away pleasantly surprised on the other end. If you're unfamiliar with the game or the studio, think of the True Crime titles that released in 2003 and 2005 respectively. Although they were certainly far more arcady affairs gameplay-wise than the GTA series, developers Luxoflux threw in a bevy of gameplay styles ranging from high-speed chases to slow-motion Max Payne-style specials, a proper brawling melee system with environmental physics and even a slew of finishing moves. It was all topped off by some great characters and an accurately-modelled L.A. to burn around in (repeated with New York in the sequel), although following that the devs ran into financial trouble, eventually giving up another TC sequel to United Front who turned it into the fantastic Sleeping Dogs, retaining the addictive cocktail of gameplay styles that made the others so enjoyable. So, with GTA VI a ways off and Sleeping Dogs' popularity cemented as a brilliantly fun alternative to its big-budget brethren, let's look at the most essential things Rockstar can take forward into their respective world-conquering franchise.


10. Character Progression & Unlockable Moves

Somewhere along the way GTA opted into this strange idea of being unrealistic enough to have characters get embroiled in situations that would otherwise kill mortal men - but not to much that the gameplay ever changes from hour zero to hour 100 and beyond. Quite the opposite, story-wise Sleeping Dogs has main-man Wei Shen as an undercover cop, playing both sides off against each other whilst forever really wondering which horse he should back in the long run. As he was also a martial arts expert, it opened up three pathways to unlock moves across the course of the game; learning things like leg-breaks and ground-punches at the dojo, weapon disarms or access to additional firearms on the cop path - and brutal sprint attacks or elbow strikes if you favoured the criminal underground. Of course you could eventually get all of them, alongside a 'Face' stat that basically amounted to reputation - holding back certain clothing items and additional functions (like calling for a private car) until you were respected enough. Naturally the flow of SD is different to GTA in terms of where your character is starting out, but considering Rockstar didn't do anything with things like Michael's standing in the world versus that of the more streetwise Trevor or Franklin - as well as the fact they all play exactly the same - it's a huge missed opportunity that Sleeping Dogs more than steps up to.

9. Varied Missions Comprised Of Multiple Genres

Speaking of playing things the same way, there's a particular mission that comes an hour or so into Sleeping Dogs where everything feels like it clicks into place. In the space of only a few minutes you'll bust into a warehouse full of gang members, have a brilliantly brutal melee fight comprised of spinning kicks and environmental interaction, nab a gun for some cover-based shooting - and then hop on the back of a motorcycle and chase down one last fleeing member for the big finish. It's this mix of styles that seamlessly flow into each other that gives SD the edge in pure gameplay. Most of the time in GTA V's missions you're either driving to a place far away for the sake of hearing some dialogue exchange, shooting through a compound, stealthing somewhere or trying to ram someone off the road - although neither of these are all that memorable when the part where you're most engaged only lasts for a few seconds. A lot of GTA's missions feel more like comedic 'bits' - like catching Jimmy as he falls off Michael's boat, being forced to tow trucks as Franklin or doing yoga etc. - whereas everything in Sleeping Dogs focusses on one of the three skills that makes up a trifecta of immediately engaging, memorable and above-all fun gameplay.

8. A Likeable, Relatable Hero

Did you like the three guys that fronted GTA V? Like really, "Oh man I LOVE those characters"-type love? Of course not, it was impossible to. Michael was someone always out for himself, Franklin forever unable to stay away from those dragging him down and Trevor; he was purpose-built to be as unbelievably off-putting as possible from day one. There was no one in V that made you happy or glad to embody them; not like Tommy Vercetti or CJ - not even like GTA III's Claude; who as a mute protagonist let you project your own responses and dialogue into the many exchanges he had with the criminal underworld. For Sleeping Dogs Wei is fantastic, not afraid to get stuck in and confront the mob bosses or influential figures that other characters in these games always bow down to. He's not cocksure to a fault, and instead comes across as someone who's well aware of the situation he's put himself in, with even his friends needing to be kept at arm's length - as they might be getting arrested the next second. As someone returning to Hong Kong from overseas Wei has the quintessential "new person in the big city" approach that always sells this genre the best, and considering how whacky GTA V's world of OTT mediation and societal commentary is - they don't do anything to really make you invest in the people tied up in the middle of it.

7. Vicious Melee Combat

GTA's melee combat has never been anything to write home about - in fact chances are the only decent showdown you've ever had with someone was at the close of one of GTA IV's opening missions, where you punch a guy so hard he flies out a window into the harbour. A huge missed opportunity in V was to vary up things like the way the three characters threw their punches - or in particular the counter animation; which is always the same "duck and one-two punch" every time. In future if we're going to see a continuation of this multi-protagonist approach, make each one feel distinguishable outside their voice actor and walking animation. In addition, although the kung fu movie-style brawls in Sleeping Dogs may be a little too much to carry over into VI (unless our hero has hit the gym/dojo before the game), it would be a hugely welcome addition to suddenly have the ability to counter effectively, land solid punches, grapple and throw people etc. - especially when the physics of GTA would allow for some fantastic gameplay when you combine them all together.

6. Tell One Hell Of A Story

What do you remember about GTA V's story? Most people play the series to indulge in the overly anarchic custom set-pieces you can put in motion; from overblown cop chases to launching sports cars in all manner of directions - it's clear that although IV tried to tell a very weighty and consequential tale about 'life in the big city' from a foreign perspective, it didn't sit very well with the series' chaos-loving demographic. V had Trevor bring that back in abundance, but it lost all relatability in the process; we had no heroes to champion, no villains to lament - nothing worth getting invested in to see through to the end. Instead it was a sea of grey with a bunch of random things peppered throughout for the sake of it - even moving containers on a dock for the sake of character interaction. Not the best. Sleeping Dogs instead went for the tried n' true 'undercover cop' approach - something that's bore fruit everywhere from Point Break to The Fast and the Furious; and it worked a treat. You had the perfect mix of higher-up officials knowing what you were up to, whilst the cops and gang members on the street were none the wiser. You met up with some great characters caught up in the whole thing for a variety of reasons, and as you personally tried to balance the morality of being a cop whilst slowly understanding why the criminals did what they did, on-screen Wei was saying exactly what you were thinking. Sure the whole thing 'just another action plot', but occasionally that's exactly what's needed.

5. Celebrity Voiceovers

Remember when GTA had celebrity voices behind their major characters? III featured legendary actors Joe Pantoliano and Michael Madsen, Vice City's Tommy Vercetti was Ray Liotta - and San Andreas had more celebrity appearances than a few seasons of The Daily Show. Then for IV, Rockstar proclaimed that they were doing away with the idea; under the reasoning that people were hearing the actor/personality behind the character, rather than the character themselves. "Fair point", you might think, but that seems to miss the point of casting an actor in the first place - you write the role first and find the best talent to bring it to life, just like in film. Some of the funniest and most memorable performances in past games were from notable names, primarily as a mix of whoever they've been typecast as in the past, or just through delivering a solid performance. For Sleeping Dogs, United Front brought in a bevy of celebrities to back certain characters; Emma Stone is the first girl you meet and introduce to the city, Tom Wilkinson is your main commander - even Lucy Liu turns up across the main campaign as a mainstay for a few key missions. Minus Wilkinson, some of these inclusions felt a bit more like cameos than fully-fledged characters, but it's always fun to have them pop up regardless - especially if like with Pantoliano and Madsen they're highly regarded within the crime genre anyway.

4. Worthwhile Side Missions

Despite their best efforts, the majority of the side missions in GTA V were a bit... weird, to say the least. Most of the things that got offered to your characters made you at home go "F that!" only for them to accept, leading to minutes later attempting to find some soiled celebrity's garments for a couple of elderly collectors, chasing down parts of a crashed probe, or fending off aliens in a weird Saints Row-style acid trip. In Sleeping Dogs you get missions that play into the fact Wei is still a cop underneath everything else, letting you bust some heads with a posse of A.I. officers, as well as in an additional DLC mode there's an Enter the Dragon-tribute where you take part in an island-centric martial arts tournament. Considering Trevor's position as trying to get his self-named Trevor Philips Industries off the ground, there should have been plenty opportunities to get stuck into the practices surrounding that; clearing out factories for potential workforces, or on a much smaller scale just defending your stash against the many enemies he made at random points.

3. Clothing Bonuses/Perks

Although Rockstar would later patch in the option to change things like hats and shades from a pop-up menu, for the most part in GTA V you were forever going to specific shops to outfit your characters in their respectable duds - only to play as someone else and lose your preset every time. Assumedly this was included to show that the characters have a 'life' outside of you controlling them, but to be honest is that really necessary? It essentially does away with the very idea of customising your character in the first place - something that on the flip-side didn't offer anything of any real value anyway. Instead of having clothing options be utterly meaningless either way you look at them, instead do what 'Dogs does and tie both reputation within the world, gang affiliation and other perks like melee damage or slow-motion windows to exactly what you're wearing. San Andreas had this where whatever colours you had on meant different gangs would treat you accordingly, but since then it's essentially been dropped.

2. A More Condensed & Focussed World Size

With GTA V we saw the most detailed and expansive world created so far; every single pixel was laboriously hand-crafted to compliment an unmatched sense of immersion, with a city that positively pulsated with life. However, bigger is not always better, and aside from hailing a cab to get around exploring for the sake of exploring, it was more of a chore realising your checkpoint was a good 5-10 minutes of game-time away. With so many instalments in, the general allure of burning round the city just doesn't hold up - especially when there's always going to be more variety on-foot through weapons, cover points and infiltration possibilities. This isn't to say that the world should be drastically reduced to last-generation proportions - but when you think about it, what benefit is there game-wise to worlds that take considerable amounts of time to traverse? Sleeping Dogs got the balance down-pat; going across the entire map took a good few minutes but your checkpoints were always within pretty close reach of one another, making for an experience where you could get distracted doing side missions or tracking down collectibles, but the main thread was within arm's reach when you were ready.

1. Better Use Of 'Special Abilities'

It's a bit weird when you think back on their inclusion within GTA V, as between Michael's slow-motion toggle, Trevor's Rage Mode and Franklin's enhanced driving; the latter especially felt extremely out of place when suddenly you could control any vehicle like an RC car, dodging and weaving through traffic Burnout-style. Neither of the three characters' powers were necessary, and most people only used Franklin's to make a particularly tight corner or Trevor's to survive falling off a roof - in fact it was pretty easy to forget altogether about Michael's, despite it being the coolest-looking. Sleeping Dogs doesn't bother to explain why Wei can go all super slow-motion either, but United Front did make more of an effort to have it factor into the gameplay. As well as being able to extend the time you can last in this mode through perks and unlocks, it'll always auto-trigger whenever you bound over cover, meaning if there's a particular enemy just out of sight you can close the gap on them instantly, bounding forward and keeping the pace up. Because the whole thing isn't metered it encourages more stylish and enjoyable play all round, and although GTA V definitely has the edge in terms of how the world around you reacts to explosions and gunfire, Dogs knew exactly how to play to its strengths instead. What did you like or dislike about both Sleeping Dogs and GTA V? Would you cross over any elements or leave them as they were? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.