Half-Life: Every Game Ranked Worst To Best

Is Half-Life: Alyx the best of them all?

Half life
Valve

Since its debut in 1998, the Half-Life franchise has remained one of the most critically acclaimed in all of gaming. With Half Life: Alyx providing a massive leap for virtual reality tech in 2020, it's got people talking about the series again.

Which title in the franchise is the most seminal? What did they do for the gaming industry at the time? Which ones - if any - have aged, and what sits at the top of the pile?

For this list, we're looking at ALL official releases - spin-off or otherwise - that have populated the franchise's two decade-long history. That crosses off the likes of the unofficial Hunt Down The Freeman and Project Borealis, fan projects that don't pertain to the official line-up. We'd keep our eyes open a future article exploring these third-party efforts.

While a small handful of developers have worked on Half-Life through the years, not a single one of the twelve games is objectively bad. But some have done more to push the industry forward than others.

From tech demos to multiplayer modes, all the way through to mainline entries, let's rank the entire Half-Life series.

10. Half-Life: Decay

half life decay
Valve

First up at number is Half-Life: Decay, the only title in the series to feature any sort of cooperative multiplayer. As the last of the Half-Life expansion packs developed by Gearbox Software, Decay arrived belatedly in 2001 as part of the PlayStation 2 port of the original game.

Ideally, it aimed to take advantage of split-screen multiplayer on a console, but ended up falling short. You play as the lesser known scientists Colette Green and Gina Cross as they carve their own path through the Black Mesa research facility, having some minor influence on Gordon Freeman's escapades.

Half-Life: Decay isn't all that memorable and certainly pales in comparison to both the 1998 classic and other expansions. The first person action isn't nearly as engaging and the weak story is further diluted with two players messing around in the levels. It's one saving grace is the cooperative play, something that lends the game its own unique moments, even if it doesn't fit the franchise as a whole.

One thing Decay can be credited for however, is providing a base concept for future efforts. Valve would return to cooperative modes with a more puzzle focused formula ten years later with Portal 2


9. Half-Life: Blue Shift

Half Life Blue Shift
Valve

Kicking off the list is Half-Life: Blue Shift. Following up on Opposing Force, the final flourish of the original Half-Life on the PC was once again developed by Gearbox Software.

Before they went on to butcher the likes of Duke Nukem Forever and Aliens: Colonial Marines, Gearbox had a great talent for expanding on original material. However, Blue Shift mostly missed the mark, making for a rather tepid send-off for the original game.

In Blue Shift, you play Barney Calhoun, the Black Mesa security officer who will eventually team up with Gordon Freeman in Half-Life 2.

The focus in the expansion is on escaping as the protaganist mostly keeps his head down with the battle raging above. Eventually it comes down to working with scientists to teleport surviving scientists out of the facility.

When compared to the standout original title and its predecessor Opposing Force, Blue Shift is fairly unremarkable, not adding or enhancing any major gameplay facets. Playing as Barney with his limited selection of tools is novel, but as a whole package, the second Half-Life expansion doesn't offer nearly as much.

The fact that it's a much shorter title didn't bode well with critics and fans, either.


8. Half-Life: Source

Half Life
Valve

Getting stuck into developing Half-Life 2 in the early 2000s, Valve saw fit to convert their original classic to their newly made Source engine in June 2004.

Taking advantage of vertex and pixel shaders to add extra detail alongside additional physics, Half-Life: Source seemed like a good idea at first. The final result was less than impressive, even if the game's core remained intact.

It also trimmed many features enjoyed by the community including mod support, while also making use of the same textures that went into the original release. It was also disappointing that none of the expansion packs were included in the package, leaving them out to dry as the sequel neared completion.

Half-Life: Source could be enjoyed by a section of the fanbase with a sense of humour. But despite claiming to offer the same ground-breaking experience as the original title, it's definitely the weakest version of the bunch. It's very lacking in polish and riddled with bugs from glitchy item placement and janky sound effects.

You're better off sticking with the original game running on the GoldSrce engine, or even better, a modern remake that reached completion this year. We'll get to that further down the list.


7. Half-Life 2: Episode One

Half Life 2 Episode One
Valve

Following Half-Life 2's smashing success and the launch of Steam, Valve started looking into episodic release models.

As a result, they were able to follow up on their magnum opus with a more compact entry one year later. Picking up right where 2 left off, Episode One details the desperate escape from City 17, as the once mighty Combine Fortress starts a countdown towards destruction.

Some set-pieces in the game were high-tier, most notably the introduction of the suicide-charging Zombines and battle through the hospital. Battling with Alyx as a team was certainly the most thrilling part of the experience, as her AI routines were enhanced to fulfil a more combat-centric role.

With all that said, Episode One is still the weaker offering in Half-Life 2's catalogue for a number of reasons, most notably the beginning and end portions. Re-entering the citadel grew tedious at times and the final confrontation with the single Strider was rather anti-climactic, given how players had fought a whole legion of them in the previous game.

As a middle chapter, Episode One doesn't hold up quite as well, but it did pave the way for its far superior successor, which released the following year.


6. Half-Life: Opposing Force

Half Life Opposing Force
Valve

After Half-Life revolutionised the FPS genre in 1998, thoughts began to turn to expansions. Gearbox Software were chosen by Valve to produce them as they focused on future projects.

Aiming to preserve the integrity of Half-Life while providing new experiences, Gearbox rose to the challenge and released Half-Life: Opposing Force in 1999. The game follows US marine Adrian Shepherd, his unit tasked with eliminating and covering all trace of the Black Mesa disaster. He soon finds himself combating a deadly alien race they are very unprepared for.

It's a brilliant expansion, one that both delivers heaps of new content and runs alongside the original game. On top of that, it offers a genuinely different kind of experience; with Shepherd being a fully equipped soldier, Opposing Force goes all out with new weapons, enemies and level designs that always keep players guessing.

Whether it was using a barnacle to grapple up to higher areas or mowing down aliens in a claustrophobic set of tunnels, the game was certainly more action-focused than the original title.

As it counts down towards Black Mesa's inevitable destruction, Opposing Force marks itself as one of the best expansion packs for any video game, despite its dated


5. Half-Life: Alyx

half life alyx
Valve

Bringing back a long dormant franchise after over a decade of silence is no easy task, but Valve were ready to do so in conjunction with their new virtual reality platform, the Index. It took a good portion of the 2010s for the developer to put together and experiment with the new tech, slowly crafting a vision for their first VR title.

They saw this venture as a way to return to the Half-Life series, while also bringing new innovations to the gaming industry the same way they did with Half-Life one and Half-Life 2. It finally arrived in March this year.

As the first killer app for virtual reality headsets, Half-Life Alyx is a masterclass in designing for the advanced peripheral. It offers a wide range of control options to cater to every player, allows for a wide range of interactive elements and most importantly, maintains the high bar set by previous games.

Moreover, Half-Life: Alyx delivers what the fanbase had waited years for; a smart, well-written and revelatory story that accounts for the franchise's long absence and brings Valve roaring back into the single-player market. Where Valve goes with their Index next is anyone's guess, but Half-Life is sure to be


4. Half-Life 2: Episode Two

Half-Life 2 Episode 2 Muscle Car
Valve

Valve's episodic model ran from 2006 to 2007. With Episode One's occassional doses of mediocrity the previous year, all eyes were on The Orange Box for the next major entry.

While it may have been overshadowed in the eventual release, Half-Life 2: Episode 2 is an excellent shooter expansion, finally moving outside of City 17 and broadening its scenarios to great effect. Picking up right where Episode One left off, Gordon and Alyx continue their journey to regroup with the Lamda Resistance at the White Forest base. What follows is a tightly-paced thrill ride with new enemies and rural environments.

Half-Life 2: Episode Two, unlike its predecessor, makes many marked improvements on the base game. The writing has more heart, the levels more varied and the set-pieces more spectacular. A reworked helicopter chase and the standout defence of White Forest against a legion of striders are just a couple of the more extravagant moments in the Episode.

Of course it was all capped off by a brutal cliffhanger that left fans in the dark for so long. For a time we all thought it would be the final release and the series would never return. Half Life: Alyx beg to differ...


3. Half-Life

half life
Valve

The original Half-Life, a landmark achievement in gaming history, as well as the conclusion of the classic FPS genre. A seemingly ordinary day at work turns into a nightmare for Gordon and the Black Mesa team as the resonance cascade triggers an massive alien invasion from Xen.

Half-Life's greatest claim to fame was that it allowed to player to experience all of it through Gordon's eyes without any disruption from cut-scenes. It offered an unparalleled immersion that pushed the genre forward, not to mention being a pillar of gaming's advancement into full 3D.

With a campaign oozing with memorable moments, awesome weapons and creepy enemies to challenge the player, Half-Life was an instant classic. Just the way you start in the bowels of the Black Mesa facility and escalate into all-out war on the surface level was incredible to play through.

Valve's debut title remains easily the greatest of any developer starting out, the changes it brought to the genre paving the way for other franchises in the 2000s. It continues to resonate to this day, with its only blemish being some dated visuals and animations.

Luckily, a certain Crowbar Collective was ready to upgrade the title for our number two spot...


2. Black Mesa

Black Mesa
Crowbar Collective

It may not be an official release in the series, but in its final form, Black Mesa is very deserving of its place near the top. It was a fan project years in the making, with Crowbar Collective getting started on it following the mediocre response to Half-Life: Source in 2004.

Feeling that the original classic could be massively upgraded, the small team got to work; creating a modern look for Half-Life while also fixing many issues the older game had. After many iterations and an extended period in early access on Steam, the final release arrived in early 2020.

Whether you've played the original or not, Black Mesa will floor you with how great it looks; every graphical element has been overhauled and certain parts of the levels have been reworked for a more balanced experience.

Much like the elusive Half-Life 2: Episode Three, Black Mesa would be viewed as vapourware for some time as the thirteen-person team worked over many years to make the final product as polished as possible.

Even Xen, Half-Life's final set of levels that received criticism have received an upgrade. Accomplishing a remaster as brilliant as this is an awesome feat, making it the superior version of Half-Life is something else entirely.


1. Half-Life 2

Half Life 2
Valve

But in terms of remaining fully playable . Twenty years after the events at Black Mesa, Gordon Freeman is brought out of stasis and sent to City 17, an urban centre ruled by the totalitarian Combine.

The silent protagonist, with Alyx Vance in tow, goes on to begin a revolution, which takes the player across one of the most tightly focused and memorable campaigns in gaming history.

It's a masterfully produced thrill ride as Gordon escapes the city via the canals, makes his way along the coastline, assaults Nova Prospekt prison and finally returns to the settlement in a desperate confrontation against the alien menace.

Once again, it all goes down without a single interruption, leaving the player firmly immersed. It went much than deeper than that however, with the legendary gravity gun complementing the action exquisitely. Half-Life 2 was and still is a landmark shooter that became the golden standard for FPS pacing and seamless storytelling.

It's also a pioneer in game physics, character facial animation and audio design, representing the second major leap the series made for the industry. Half-Life 2 is Valve at the peak of their development prowess, and more importantly, it's one of the best games ever released.


The IMPOSSIBLE Half-Life Franchise Quiz: How Will You Do?

Half Life Opposing Force
Valve

1. Who Was Gordon Freeman's Military Antagonist In The Half Life Expansion Game, Opposing Force?

In this post: 
Half Life
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A tough but fair writer and critic broadly covering games, movies and just about every type of entertainment media. Spent a good part of the last seven years blogging and more recently, making amateur videos under "The Cainage Critique". You can follow my work on my website https://robc25.wixsite.com/thecainagecritique and my YouTube channel at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCftJ6WcozDaECFfjvORDk3w