Halo 4 - Inside the Gaming Studio: Lead Writer Chris Schlerf Talks Master Chief

interviewed one man who was responsible for giving a breath of fresh air to the story of Master Chief last week in the shape of Armando Troisi, and this week I had the chance to talk to the other responsible party. Chris Schlerf is the Lead Writer in charge of the Reclaimer Trilogy. Writers in video games can get a lot of unfair flack for shoddy writing that can often be attributed to a development team that aren't interested in implementing the story elements properly. However, this clearly isn't the case over in Seattle with 343 industries. Troisi last week talked about how important that all departments grow together, and this week Schlerf has gone into quite some detail about the process and theory behind writing for a AAA franchise. Welcome back to Inside the Gaming Studios. Where it Begins...

It starts with complete immersion in the storyworld of the property. And that goes for whether it€™s something pre-existing or a new IP, where you may just be talking about a loose collection of themes or ideas that are floating around. I try to absorb everything that€™s already available before letting any concrete seeds of where a story could go to take root. In the case of Halo, where there is a breadth and depth of canon that rivals almost anything else out there, you€™ve got this enormous responsibility to understand the fine detail of what has come before. Regardless of whether or not you plan to build off of that foundation or to move in a new direction, your creative decisions are going to live side-by-side in that same sandbox (pardon the pun). I was fortunate in that I was already a big Halo fan coming in, so the learning curve here wasn€™t as steep and I was able to hit the ground running.
Story in games is Developmental
A game€™s story will naturally run the risk of falling apart if it€™s not an equal partner with the other disciplines (design, art, audio€) , and I believe that€™s a fairly frequent occurrence throughout the industry. Also, and this is entirely our fault as writers, many game stories don€™t account for the actual play experience; on paper they may read great, but it€™s important that we remember that we€™re creating a blueprint which will eventually have to be constructed by the player. And so, the €˜writing€™ doesn€™t end when we finish the script (or at least, it shouldn€™t). Because of how iterative game development is, you don€™t have the luxury of just connecting all the dots one time and walking away. We have to be developers as much as writers, which is part of why you€™re increasingly seeing the concept of €˜narrative designers€™ being welcomed into the process. Admittedly, many writers (I€™d argue most) don€™t have the luxury of being continuously involved in the game€™s production, which to me is a fundamental problem. Unless you have someone full-time on your team who is an expert at story creation, it will be next to impossible to maintain the quality of a narrative consistently from moment to moment. This is why you see such loose structure between set pieces; a lot of folks see only those big moments as being the €˜story€™. They become just additional modular elements which gameplay is molded around, and that often contributes to the sense that they aren€™t holistic parts of a single whole. What was interesting with Halo 4 is that, in many ways, the start point for our narrative was predetermined before 343i even existed as a studio; Bungie had already posed a question with the Halo 3€™s Legendary Ending which we knew we€™d need to answer.
Click "Next" to read on...


The Difference Between Design and Story while Making them Play Nicely

It€™s difficult to define what the ideal world is. I€™m a storyteller first and foremost, so I naturally gravitate towards story-driven games. But at the same time, some of the most compelling games I€™ve played have had no story at all. That said, if you are going to set out to create an experience where narrative is a crucial component, then I believe it€™s important to introduce it into the process early and consistently throughout. Good story design operates very differently than good game design. Even in the most non-linear fiction, there is still typically a sense of progression and causality. Story isn€™t as good at being modular in the same way that game design is €“ at least, not if you want to create a world with dramatic stakes, character development, etc€ many the sorts of things which make the tales we gravitate towards compelling. Getting those two traits in sync €“ the flexibility of game design and the relative rigidity of narrative dependencies €“ takes an awful lot of work and is a constant process. In the real world, the differences between the two disciplines aren€™t always clear or well understood. Coming from a film background, it took me a long time to understand why game production and film production have entirely different philosophies, and the same is true for narrative theory and game theory.
Harmony between Story and Mechanics is a Key to Creation
The process for how any game deals with story is completely unique to that particular project and team. I know people who€™ve worked on projects where story essentially was just the €˜icing€™ used to give context and flavor to the game€™s design, without much in the way of artistic aspirations or concern for the narrative€™s overall cohesion. And that€™s not in any way meant as a criticism; there are fantastic game developers who think that story just gets in the way of their vision, and that€™s perfectly valid from a creative point-of-view. But in working on a game where the fiction is such a fundamental part of its appeal, it would have been incredibly constricting in terms of what types of stories we could tell if the mechanics weren€™t one of the fundamental building blocks we had at our disposal. We€™ve been fortunate at 343 that our Design team is incredibly passionate about story. They€™ve not only been our greatest advocates, but they€™re also one of our most reliable sounding boards. They have provided some of the most in-depth feedback on even the smallest details of Halo lore. It€™s been an very collaborative relationship right from the beginning, and so that has created a lot of opportunities for both the use of existing mechanics to help articulate the story in new ways as well as the creation of new ones when our existing toolbox proved too restrictive . Sometimes, that interplay between story and game mechanics manifested as subtly as the way a player interacted with new characters like the Prometheans. The very nature of the manner in which the Forerunners are used in the sandbox today speaks volumes about who they are. You look at how the Knights are able to phase through the environment or the sorts of tactical maneuvers the Watchers employ, and those gameplay elements can provide players with a far deeper understanding of the artificial, militaristic nature of these antagonists more robustly than we€™d have time to do through just dialog, cinematics, etc. In a more substantial way, wherever it€™s been practical, we€™d work with Design to bend the typical shooter mechanics to allow us a chance to craft story moments where traditionally we might not be able to. We€™ve done a lot of storytelling with the Chief€™s HUD, for instance. In other cases, we€™d try to introduce elements into the environment like Sentinels that, by taking advantage of a player€™s natural desire to shoot at them, would create narrative possibilities in and of themself. And naturally, that collaboration with the designers went both ways as well. Frequently, Design would want to try something interesting in gameplay and ask us if it was something that would work inside the fiction. One factor that allowed us a tighter integration into the gameplay mechanics was that we wound up designing and implementing a lot of supporting content ourselves on the Narrative team. Things like VO placement, the creation of our €˜secondary story elements€™ (such as terminals, etc), various other narrative devices €“ a lot of that was us getting directly into the code, so it gave us a greater latitude for experimentation and fine tuning. Overall, the benefits of marrying story directly into the gameplay cannot be oversold. The traditional techniques (cinematics, mission dialog, et al) will always have their place, but expanding the palette to utilize the gameplay wherever possible takes advantage of the strengths of the form. It€™s the next evolutionary step of that old adage, €œShow, don€™t Tell.€ Suddenly, it becomes, €œPLAY, don€™t tell.€
Click "Next" for more...


How to Control Story Pace in an Interactive Medium

Pacing is one of the most critical components in terms of dramatic development, regardless of the medium. Each individual€™s play style can be widely divergent (as someone who has probably taken, shall we say, longer than necessary to finish certain games, I have a profound appreciate for this fact€). Approaching a game€™s narrative from a structural point of view, it€™s helped me to look at the global pacing first before worrying about the creation or timing of individual moments (where you€™ve got the least control, obviously). How are the major beats spaced out from one to another? Will there be sufficient time/opportunity between them for the story to evolve sufficiently? Are you looking at any dead zones, where nothing is moving forward for too long? From that, you get together with your team, and work towards increasing the granularity until (hopefully) you€™re able to address the individual story events discreetly and weigh their placement against encounters, mechanic introductions, etc. Anyone who works in games will tell you that the story is constantly changing, and that is especially true with regards to pace, all the way up until it€™s going out the door. But if you€™ve spent the time to keep your narrative spacing as tied to your structural foundation as possible, it will help to keep the overall momentum more stable than if you were constantly trying to compensate solely by tweaking the moments themselves.
The Maturity of the Medium
Theater evolved slowly over thousands of years. Literature less so, and film is just a hundred or so years into its development. With video games, we€™re arguably only in our third or fourth real decade. It€™s a bit like giving a teenager the keys to your new Ferrari. We have all this creative horsepower at our disposal, but that doesn€™t necessarily mean we always know how to use it with finesse or skill. But that€™s also how you learn €“ you throw yourself in the deep end and figure it out as you go. So I don€™t think the speed with which the industry is maturing is necessarily detrimental; if anything, it may just make the ride a little bumpier with more scrutiny paid to our successes and failures at a time when we€™re still figuring out who and what we are as storytellers. The greatest achievement an individual game can make at this point is to say they moved the ball down the field a little for the next group of folks. Also, for as quickly as we€™ve grown, you still have to consider who are playing games today and what they€™re playing. The barrier for entry to AAA story-based games is fairly high €“ as much as my mother may be proud of her first born, there€™s just not much chance that I€™m going to walk in on her playing Halo 4 anytime soon. But at the same time, I constantly find her playing casual games. So we certainly have these avenues for storytelling across a variety of player types, platforms, etc., but we€™re really just starting to scratch the surface of how we make game narrative as ubiquitous in peoples€™ lives as with other mediums like film or TV.
Studying Gaming Critically
I€™ve found the best critical approach is to play other games, frequently and deeply. In many ways, we€™re just entering the Golden Age of Gaming; the semantics of the art form are still being generated, release by release. Our Ken Levine€™s(Irrational Games) and Amy Hennig€™s(Naughty Dog) will be the DW Griffith€™s and Fritz Lang€™s for the next generation of innovators. I also feel that we have a responsibility to look outside our own medium for instruction, and outside the typical genres which influence a lot of our creators. What can we learn about single-set presentation from theater? Is there a way to adapt the spontaneity and improvisational feel of some independent films into an interactive medium? Game criticism/analysis is a field that I think is going to just blow up in the coming years. We have a medium where we€™re still in some ways discerning the differences between technique and style, and as we start to analyze not just why some of the things we do are successful but how different approaches can achieve those same results, we€™ll hopefully start to see the same types of academic and critical interest that other art forms enjoy.


Cinematic techniques can be used to create better Gaming Experience

I don't think that there is anything particularly wrong with games being like movies. That might be a bit controversial for some people as I know there€™s a degree of €˜sibling rivalry€™ that goes on out there between the two which I€™ve never quite gotten. To my memory, at least, it€™s not like people were criticizing text-based adventures for being too much like novels€ Historically, every artistic medium has leveraged the ones which came before it. When movies debuted, the same arguments were being had over the degree to which they could or should be emulating the stage experience. These are healthy discussions to have; they lead to innovation and new perspectives that we might not have if the approaches we take weren€™t being challenged. In practice, film and (many but not all) modern 3D games utilize a lot of the same tools and techniques. To not leverage the experience that has gone into creating other works of art seems a little short-sighted. Contrary to the beliefs of a certain segment of gamers, cinematic cameras or a linear, Campbell-esque story aren€™t some heretical bastardization of the gaming medium; we€™ve seen some very, very good titles that have used precisely those techniques. Does that mean it should be the standard by which all games are created? Of course not - that would be idiotic. The glory in making a video game is that there€™s no practical reason we have to be constrained to a single €˜standard€™. Our palette is far broader than in any other creative medium. Why limit ourselves to only being X but not Y? There seems to be a great deal of discussion out there about what games should be as opposed to all the millions of things they can be. But back on topic - if there is any €˜dangerous€™ aspect to specifically opting for a more cinematic presentation in your game, I€™d say it€™s that there€™s a risk of using those techniques as crutches as opposed to making the creative decision to employ them. Which is probably why you see some backlash against cinematics in games; they€™re frequently the easy answer as opposed to the best one.
Gaming could use more Auteurs, But...
Currently, I feel like the auteur-driven game is a bit underrepresented in our industry. Again, when we think of someone as an auteur, we think of them as an innovator. A unique creative voice. An artist who can be easily identified by their work. I€™m not entirely sure why we don€™t have more of those types of developers (which is certainly not to say we don€™t have ANY), but I€™m of the opinion that we€™ll need them and in greater numbers if we want to gain the same respect that other art forms have. That being said, the auteur-driven project is just one small slice of any medium€™s output. Studio movies are predominantly NOT auteur-driven; you€™ve got seasoned directors who do a job but either don€™t have a personal stamp or aren€™t allowed to because they don€™t have the clout. Big-name bands frequently have their albums tweaked, poked, and prodded by their record labels €“ and sometimes outright rejected. How many authors out there aren€™t subject to the whims of their editors/publishers/etc? Auteurs are a crucial aspect of any creative ecosystem, but not typically the most dominant one.
Games as Experiences of Expression
It€™s funny; we were just having the great €˜will there be a Citizen Kane of video games€™ debate in the office just this week. Really, time is the decisive factor here €“ Kane was certainly respected when it came out, but it wasn€™t a financial success, didn€™t win Best Picture at the Oscars, and made Welles a pariah in many ways. Only after years of film criticism did it rise to become the sort of artistic barometer that it is today. Obviously, we already have many great game stories which may stand the test of time. Will there be that one, transcendent game that will be referred to for years to come as that high water mark even by people who never played it? I think so. But we€™re also still stuck in the €˜Roger Ebert€™-era of people asking if video games ARE art, much less what is the pinnacle of that expression. And generally, when we start talking about stories on that level, the ability to capture the human condition tends to be one of the qualitative traits we look for. Will that hold true for games? I don€™t know. Maybe. Maybe not. Personally, I hope so. Aside from simply reveling in the instantaneous visceral feedback many games give us, it€™s just as exciting for me to find new ways to make people think and reflect, as opposed to just reacting and moving on. There are all sorts of discussions out there about player agency, and the silent protagonist vs. the developed character, and to me, these are all just different techniques trying to reach that same end: exposing players to experiences which they wouldn€™t normally be exposed to. The next question creatively we have to answer as a medium, I believe, is - what message are we trying to convey through those experiences? What mirrors do we want to hold up to people?
Indie Games and their 'Totally Crazy' Ideas
The topic of how indie games fit into this picture brings us back to the speed with which we€™ve been maturing, and as the form moves forward, will it be those developers who are more agile and experimental who pull the rest of us along? You€™re talking about smaller teams with greater freedom and less moving parts. In situations like these, the €˜totally crazy€™ idea is less likely to die on the vine when the stakes are lower. From a storytelling point of view, that€™s an incredibly exciting place to be. Thus far, a lot of what I€™ve personally been exposed to coming out of the indie scene has been more mechanics-based, but just as the larger industry as a whole has seen story become more important in its development, there€™s a good chance you€™ll see a similar trajectory with indie devs and that you€™ll see more storytellers rolling up their sleeves and diving in.


The Sequel Culture

As far as people being weary of sequels, we have a tendency as a culture to go to the well a little too often. Some stories are simply not built to be ongoing; the ones where the characters are a good fit for continuing adventures are less likely to wear people down than a franchise where there€™s no rational reason we€™d continue following the people or events. Plus, it also comes down to quality €“ unless you€™re constantly bringing your A-game, of course there will be diminishing returns. So I don€™t know that people are down on sequels so much as bad, unnecessary sequels.
The Luxury and Problems of a Trilogy
€˜Problem€™ may be the absolute last word I€™d use to describe my feelings about writing for a trilogy. I can barely articulate the sheer joy at being able to work on something of that scope; it€™s fantastically exciting to have the opportunity to tell such a sweeping epic over multiple games. That doesn€™t mean it€™s not a challenge of the most daunting proportions, however. One of the earliest things we talked about with the Reclaimer Trilogy was how self-contained we wanted each individual story to be, and I feel like on the first one, we€™ve found a good balance between resolving the events which the player is concerned with and yet still creating something which operates as the first act of a much larger tale. To accomplish that, naturally you will create elements of your story which you don€™t resolve right away, but I€™m of the opinion that people should be able to appreciate the broad strokes of each story individually regardless of whether they€™ve played the others. Approaching a trilogy as opposed to a single story actually both gives you more and less breathing room at the same time. Obviously, over a longer timeline, you can roll out elements at a very different pace, and explore areas you might not be able to in a more condensed and economical format. But also, the individual stories need to hold their own weight, which means you have the burden of establishing a new setup (even if it€™s a continuation of the previous) each time and ensuring that you€™ve got the requisite beats to draw things to a conclusion of some sort by the end. Trilogies can borrow elements and techniques from serialized storytelling, but at the end of the day, you still have 3 distinct and separate boxes €“ and if you want your overarching story to be effective, that means structuring it in such a way that you are reinforcing what€™s truly important for players to remember from the first part to the last.
Like Troisi would say, Halo 4 isn't a revolution of a working system but instead an evolution, which seems to be a recurring word at 343 industries. They have shown that the Halo franchise has found a very safe home who have a world class approach to their games. This hopefully won't be the last time I get the chance to speak with Armando and Chris, as I would love to talk about specific elements of the story but lets give you guys some time to play through it and the guys a chance to knock it out the park with Halo 5. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Inside the Gaming Studio is a new series of articles from Patrick Dane that tries to explore to talk to some of the most interesting, promising and established game developers. With an ultimate goal to teach and allow games to think more critically about the choices made by developers. Asking questions of 'Why?' and 'How?' as opposed to simply 'What?', the series hopes to create a database of knowledge for reader to learn and understand game design.


Contributor
Contributor

Patrick Dane is someone who spends too much of his time looking at screens. Usually can be seen pretending he works as a film and game blogger, short film director, PA, 1st AD and scriptwriter. Known to frequent London screening rooms, expensive hotels, couches, Costa coffee and his bedroom. If found, could you please return to the internet.