Halo: Master Chief Collection - 10 Issues 343 STILL Need To Fix

The fight to get this back on track hasn't concluded yet.

Halo multiplayer
Microsoft

Halo: The Master Chief Collection was one of the most ambitious video game projects of all time. The game's developers, 343 Industries, deserve credit for aiming so high, but players quickly realised that the studio had bitten off way more than it could chew.

Upon release, the game was littered with bugs and issues that plagued online multiplayer and even affected single-player runs of the various Halo campaigns, with the MCC swiftly branded a disaster. Effectively, 343 had committed the developing equivalent of sticking themselves in the face with a plasma grenade.

Now, four years later, an absolutely gigantic update has finally been released, packing all sorts of fixes and features into a mammoth 73GB download. What's more, the MCC has been added to the Xbox Game Pass subscription service, breathing new life into a title that had been dying a slow death for the last few years.

The recent announcement of Halo Infinity, combined with this big push to finally make the MCC playable, could help to bring the Halo franchise back into the spotlight. A hardcore following of fans have stuck with the series through thick and thin, but more still needs to be done to help this incredible collection of games live up to its initial promise.

10. Voting & Vetoing Maps

halo 3
Bungie

One of the major changes to the multiplayer side of the game is the removal of the voting system. Now, when players head into matchmaking, they don't even know what gametype they're playing until the round actually starts, and they have no option to vote or veto the map or gametype.

This change was enforced in order to help get players in and out of matches faster than before and offer more variety. With the previous voting system, the same gametypes were being chosen time and time again, so there's definitely a good side to this new system as it allows everyone to play maps and modes they might not have been able to enjoy before.

However, there's also a major downside. Quitting has always been a prominent problem in the MCC and players are now quitting more often than ever before if the system chooses to throw up a map or mode they don't like.

A return to the full voting system might not be the best solution, but the option to veto the game's first choice, like the system used in the original Halo 3, could be a good compromise. This would give players a little bit of control over the gametype they play, while also preserving the variety.


9. Playlist Choices

Halo 4 Multiplayer
Microsoft

343 have tried to be as fair as possible when it comes to the selection of playlists available in matchmaking by using polls and community suggestions to try and make everyone happy. Naturally, it's never going to be possible for them to please everyone, but some of their decisions have baffled the Halo community.

Making the Lone Wolves Free-For-All playlist Halo 3-only and not adding in the ranking system seems like a bizarre move, plus the absence of hugely popular gametypes like Snipers, SWAT, and Infection has also left many Halo fans scratching their heads.

In addition, the inclusion of 14 separate multiplayer playlists in a game with a very small population might not have been the smartest idea, and many players have been complaining of long waiting times to find a game, with a few of the playlists seeming to be almost entirely empty.

The MCC is going to live or die by its multiplayer and the choice of playlists will have a huge influence on that. 343 need to make continuous efforts here, listening to their forum users and fans in order to provide the maps and modes people want the most, even if that means that one or two of the Halo titles (we're looking at you, Halo 4) get a little less exposure.


8. Armour Customisation

HALO 4 CUSTOMISATION
Microsoft

Now, more than ever, customisation is a huge part of the gaming experience. Some games, like Fortnite or Overwatch for example, have built entire in-game economies on the ability to customise one's character with different cosmetic items like outfits and accessories.

The Halo franchise was a bit of a pioneer in this respect, but has since regressed with the MCC. Halo 3 and Halo 4 launched with many different armour types and the ability to customise individual pieces at will to create a Spartan that truly felt unique, but the MCC only allows players to choose from full preset suits of armour, vastly limiting players' potential to get creative.

Ever since the game came out, fans have been begging 343 to implement the classic armour customisation systems seen in Halo's 3 and 4. This won't have any direct effect on gameplay, but players will undoubtedly appreciate the ability to change the look of their Spartan rather than having every match filled with the same old suits.


7. A Progression/Experience System

halo 2
Bungie

Just like avatar customisation, progression systems are a huge part of modern games and, once again, Halo did help to set the standard in this area. Halo 3's second major title update added in an experience-based ranking system for players to track their progress in individual playlists, with subsequent Halo games building on this idea.

Unfortunately, progression hasn't really been a part of the MCC, and this is another issue that fans have been complaining about for several years now.

Having a little symbol next to your name and earning experience points might not have any immediate effect on how the game plays, but it gives people a reason to keep coming back and offers a much-needed sense of satisfaction that many modern gamers crave.

The system introduced in Halo: Reach, which offered credits and points for every activity completed in game, including multiplayer, campaign, firefight, and even forge mode, would be a nice addition to the MCC and is one simple way 343 could encourage new and old players alike to stick with the game for the long-term.


6. Firefight

halo odst
Bungie

Introduced in Halo 3: ODST and maintained in Halo: Reach, Firefight was the Halo series' version of a 'Horde' or 'Survival' game mode, pitting a small group of players against wave after wave of AI enemies.

It was a simple and fun way for Halo players to enjoy a bit of cooperative action with friends or random strangers from around the world, and it was very warmly-received when it first launched, but hasn't made it into the MCC despite ODST's campaign being added back in 2015.

The MCC does feature Halo 4's Firefight-equivalent 'Spartan Ops' mode, so it's a shame to see that classic Firefight hasn't made it into the game just yet. Between all the different campaigns, custom games, and matchmaking playlists, MCC players already have a wealth of options available to them, but there's a big chunk of the community that simply adores Firefight and would really love to see it added in.


5. Custom Game Browser

Halo 3
Bungie

This is one feature that 343 have said they are working on, so Halo fans can expect to see a custom game browser arrive in the MCC at some point in the future, and this could be a huge boost for the game and community overall.

Custom games have always been a major part of the Halo experience, with many of the game's most popular alternative modes like Grifball and Rocket Race actually being invented by the fans. The Halo esports scene, which thrived during the Halo 2 and Halo 3 years in particular, has also always been dependent on the ability to customise settings and maps.

With Forge mode and countless settings to tweak and tune, the options for custom games in Halo are almost limitless, and the inclusion of a custom game browser will finally give every player the opportunity to try out some completely new and original modes and maps with friends and other players. These kinds of browsers have proven successful in many other titles and could add a lot to the MCC.


4. Dealing With Quitters

Halo 2
Bungie

Quitters are a problem in every single multiplayer game out there, and no developer has ever really been able to find a foolproof solution. Halo games, like many other online shooters, have regularly enforced bans and suspensions for people who quit too often and the ability for players to boot other individuals out of a match for unsporting behaviour.

However, it feels like much more could be done in this area. Far too often, players are quitting out of games right at the start just because they don't happen to like the map or mode, and some games are actually starting with uneven teams, putting innocent players at an undeserved disadvantage.

When one player quits, it's logical to say that their teammates don't deserve to be tarred with the same brush and receive the same punishment. Unfortunately, long-time Halo players know only too well that trying to win a 3 vs 4, especially in an objective gametype, is almost impossible. So many players end up losing and getting de-ranked just because of the careless actions of others.

Games like Overwatch have introduced systems to automatically cancel games with early quitters, while also allowing other players to leave without suffering a ranking penalty if someone else quits on their team. These features would be welcomed by the Halo community and make the MCC far less frustrating.


3. Maps

Halo The Master Chief Collection
343 Industries

One of the best things about the MCC is the inclusion of Halo 2: Anniversary, which took a bunch of beloved Halo 2 maps and remade them with beautiful new textures and a HD look. Players love these maps and 343 have proven themselves to be adept at taking classic Halo environments and giving them a fresh lick of paint.

But why stop there? If the developers are serious about making MCC great again, additional content has got to be part of the plan. Halo 4's maps are already attractive enough, but maps like Narrows and Construct from Halo 3 or Prisoner and Hang 'Em High from Combat Evolved could massively benefit from a HD makeover.

If that's too much to ask, the least 343 could do is add in some custom-made maps built by players in the game's Forge mode. There's a lot of creative talent in the Halo community and fans have created some fantastic play-spaces over the years. The MCC already has dozens of maps to choose from, but additional variety and options couldn't hurt, and a whole matchmaking playlist dedicated to the best user creations could prove very popular.


2. Bugs & Region-Lock Issues

Halo flood
Microsoft

This new major update for the MCC has done a lot of good, but 343 has to keep at it. The company's news updates and blog posts have made it clear that they intend to keep on fixing this game in the coming months, and they really need to back up those claims with solid action.

The MCC is currently fully playable and a lot of fun for most people, but like any modern game, it's still got a lot of issues and the studio will need to continue working hard to track bugs and apply fixes as needed to keep players happy.

Currently, one of the biggest issues has come from the decision to effectively region-lock the game, leading to many players outside of the US having a lot of problems finding matches in multiplayer. Players in Australia, for instance, are having enormous wait times and, in many cases, simply can't find matches at all.

The Halo Waypoint forums are littered with users complaining about this particular issue and many more problems are being reported with every passing minute. Since there's so much content in the MCC, it's almost impossible for 343 to fix every single thing, but when large portions of their player-base can't even get into games, they need to act quickly and decisively to solve the problem.


1. Add Halo: Reach

halo reach noble team
Bungie

It's the one major change that could truly give the MCC a whole new lease of life, and it's something fans have been asking for since the title was first announced: Halo: Reach needs to be added into the game as DLC.

343 were clever in naming the game 'The Master Chief Collection', effectively limiting it to the Halo titles that only involved Chief himself. However, they added ODST, which doesn't involve John-117 at all, so there's no reason why Reach shouldn't be allowed in the game.

The developers have recently addressed the popular demand, stating that they're "constantly evaluating" the idea of adding Reach into the game, and that's a pretty good sign, but they already waited four years to fix the game in the first place and can't really afford to waste too much more time at this point.

Upon release, Reach wasn't as warmly-received as past Halo titles but is retrospectively regarded as a fantastic part of the series, even favoured over Halo 4 by much of the community. All of its multiplayer maps and modes, as well as Firefight and a terrific campaign, would add so much to the MCC and make more people start caring about this once dominant franchise all over again.


Contributor

Mike Pedley hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.