How Live Service Video Games Are Poisoning The Industry
Not every game has to have a 10-year plan.
If there's one prevalent, unanswerable philosophical question in the video game world, it's: "How long should should a game actually be?" By their very nature and depending on the genre, a title can be anywhere from a couple hours long to a couple hundred, and debates have raged over how much of a time return you should be guaranteed for a full-priced purchase.
Unlike other mainstream art forms, gaming is expensive, and for $60 a pop, customers expect to come away satisfied that they've gotten the most out of their money, which more often than not is measured in time spent in a game, rather than actual enjoyment of the package. Obviously, a game's failure or success is more complex than that, but the perception that a short game is worse because it provides less content, has hurt many major games over the past few decades.
In response, publishers and developers - at least in the mainstream, AAA space - have all but eradicated the once-standard 8-10 hour (or less) video game, in favour of expansive live-service releases that are designed to provided content, well, forever. Or at least until the inevitable sequel comes around to replace it.
But, as the saying goes, bigger isn't always better, and we might have dug ourselves into a hole where, as critics and fans, we've put far too much emphasis on how many hours a video game holds, over the quality of those hours, which has had a negative effect on the industry at large.
7. Every Game Wants To Be A Sandbox
Part of the reason that games have gotten longer, especially across the latest console generation, is that the in-vogue sub-genre has moved from being first-person shooters to open world sandboxes. In the heyday of the Xbox 360 era, it didn't matter if the latest FPS only had a five-hour campaign, as long as it had a killer multiplayer suite that could sustain countless matches and rematches, it could become a phenomenon.
Thanks to Ubisoft and Rockstar, though, big franchises were then expected to be these huge, freeform experiences, with a sandbox filled with main missions, side quests and random activities that demanded the player's attention. Consequently, the average length of a game jumped from 10 hours, to 20, to 40 and higher - and sometimes that was just the main story, not counting everything else required to get 100% completion.
While on the surface that was great, as players were getting way more for their money than they were used to, every major franchise adopting a sandbox structure ultimately led to uninspired, homogenised game design that can, if not done right, actively damage the enjoyment of certain titles.
There is a reason why the industry embraced longer sandbox games, however, and that's because they were seen as a great way to stop players buying a title, completing the main story in a handful of hours and immediately trading it in. If it included 10s of hours of busywork - just compelling enough to not become mundane - then players would be less incentivised to move onto the next game immediately.
Of course, developers soon realised that players not trading in their titles meant they could also continue to pay money for a game they already owned.
6. Why Every Game Has To Have Live-Service Elements
The dawn of the PS4 and Xbox One era not only saw the popularity of FPS games start to wane and open-world titles become more dominant, but also introduced a tighter synergy between multiplayer and single-player modes. Previously, the two styles of play were kept separate (which meant predominantly single-player games were mandated to have a tacked-on multiplayer component that nobody actually played), but with online services becoming more prevalent, titles like Destiny attempted to blend the two styles into one coherent package.
Thus, the live-service sub-genre was born, which enabled an element of online integration through the promise of post-launch updates that would constantly transform the world and give players an endless stream of content to sink their teeth into (and pay for), in a package they could either play with others or alone.
In theory, this is amazing, and could have made games better than ever. Having titles that are essentially living entities that never end, packed with the content that already comes as standard but which evolve beyond that with new updates and DLC, seemed like a win-win for players and developers.
Sadly, that's not how it panned out...
5. Games Are Bigger, But Not Better
Despite promising endless hours of engaging, varied gameplay to enjoy, that's not exactly what players got. Instead, the first batch of live-service games like The Division and Destiny were indeed packed with content, but the issue was that they lacked focus, and most of those hours were made up of repeated missions.
In both games, the longevity of the experience came from the grind, expecting players to constantly interact with the same quests and gameplay loops without much in the way of authored, directed content or story to dig into. There was a lot of it, for sure, but it meant the experiences all became one big blur, without any real high or low points. It's all just solid, capital-C content that you plow through without having to really think too much about it. You can play it forever, but nothing really changes after the first 10 hours or so.
Even worse, is that these games are all built on the promise of the roadmap, something which extends the overall length even further. Of course, these post-launch promises from developers and publishers have become as trustworthy as a Peter Molyneaux interview, as they rarely ever pan out as planned.
Recent games like Anthem have seen their roadmap plans delayed or outright cancelled, and what players are left with is a huge game that they're encouraged to keep playing because the actually good content is on the way. Building a long game takes time and effort, but live services have allowed devs to release products that are unfinished for full price, with the expectation that they can be filled in later - which leads to lower quality all around.
4. Live Services Eat Each Other
While these issues so far could seemingly be solved if publishers stopped exploiting the leeway the genre gives them, the bigger problem is that, quite simply, nobody has time to play all of these live-service games. They're designed to encourage you to log into them regularly, perhaps even daily, so you don't fall behind and are ready for the next major expansion. That would be doable if there was only a handful of them, and they were the only games you played, but these days every major release is adopting live-service elements to some extent.
Consequently, unless you dedicate your entire life to playing games, it's going to be virtually impossible to get the most out of these experiences. If you fall behind, or pick up another game, it's difficult to return, because they're designed to be experiences you can't necessarily "complete". The idea, essentially, is that if they consume your life, then they'll consume your wallet as well.
It's not only a problem for players, but for devs as well, whose hard work probably won't be seen or appreciated by a huge chunk of the audience. The days of seeing everything a game has to offer have long since passed, as they're too sprawling and demand all of your time.
The demand for games to be bigger, to adopt live-service elements and be all-consuming on the surface does give players way more bang for their buck, but by focusing so deeply on quantity over quality, it's resulting in the big titles all blending into one homogenous mess of familiar, bloated content that punishes you for not constantly engaging with it.
3. Open-World Mechanics Are Getting Stale

The real issue is, however, that the formula and monetisation of live-service online games have made their way into regular sandbox or story-driven AAA games as well.
Sony's recent major exclusive, Days Gone, was a prime example of a game that didn't need an open world, and how how padding for the sake of length can actively undermine the experience, rather than strengthen it.
The title is good, don't get me wrong (in fact, i enjoyed it way more than most critics), but you can't escape the pervasive feeling that a shorter runtime would have benefitted everything from the gameplay to the story. The latter element would most obviously improve with a shorter length, as the title's core gameplay loop is genuinely amazing. Hunting down zombie nests, taking out human bandits and exploring the open world is great, but it doesn't fundemantally change from hour one to hour forty.
There are few new activities to unlock as the experience goes on, and by the late game you'll find yourself repeating the same patterns only with better skills and bigger weapons. It's fun, but nothing fundamentally changes - you just learn to complete the tasks quicker.
This is maybe expected when it comes to the side content, as not every studio has the manpower of Rockstar to make sure every element in the open world is unique, but if that's the case, what's the point of including them at all? If all they add is length to the game overall, and they're not offering new gameplay opportunities, then why not cut them and stop them from distracting from the stronger missions?
2. Video Game Stories Don't Benefit From Long Runtimes

The open-world structure impacts the story the most, though. While Deacon gets a cohesive arc, in order to justify its length, the game constantly throws in new characters, locations and themes to tackle.
That only results in an unfocused story, though, where the actual main narrative is obfuscated as threads are dropped and picked up hours apart, and villains are introduced and dispatched on the regular. At one point, when the game feels like it's building to a climax, you're thrown another 10 hours of busywork that sucks out any and all momentum from the story. The pacing is terrible, and that stems from the title being so lengthy and padded with side content.
For the most part, in both the story and gameplay, Days Gone feels like it's on the same level for 40 hours. It starts out good, and it ends good, but the padding and lack of peaks and troughs makes for an experience that all blurs into one, with it being difficult to pick a high point out of what becomes a hodge-podge of similar feeling and looking events.
This is just the most recent example, but the same criticisms could be levelled at plenty of other modern open-world games, from Far Cry 5, to Marvel's Spider-Man, to Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain.
1. Shorter Games Are Inherently Punchier

The story and missions of Days Gone, or The Division, or Anthem could have been far more impactful had the devs not been so concerned with creating experiences that never end so you can keep playing and paying.
For instance, compare them to shorter games that are more tightly paced, like The Last of Us, Spec Ops: The Line, or the recent Resident Evil 2 remake. These releases are still "big", but can be finished in 15 hours or less. Just about every element in them benefits from a brisker pace though, which allows the devs to finely tune the highs and lows to deliver memorable, major set-pieces that contrast with quieter, character-driven beats.
Even better, they don't skimp on the gameplay or player freedom, still giving players plenty of options to express themselves out of the linear story. The brevity ensures every hour counts and every beat is purposeful. It's rare that content is only included for the sake of it - to tick something off on the back of the box - and ultimately, that makes the experience that bit more impactful.
Of course, the issue is that, for the most part, once they're done, they're done. Publishers don't have a way to further monetise the experience, and players don't have a reason to not trade them in.
The point isn't that these shorter games are inherently better, but that length shouldn't be the only thing devs (in the AAA space) strive for. The concern shouldn't be packing in as much content as possible out of fear that players will feel like they've 'finished' a game and stop engaging with it. Players reward great games, and devs and publishers don't need to trap them in live services that never end while forcefully sucking their wallets dry.