How Mass Effect Fixed Video Game Storytelling

I'm Commander Shepard, and this is the future of video game storytelling.

Mass effect 2
Bioware

Mass Effect is far from Bioware's first foray into a cosmic setting, with the superb Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic bringing the developer their first smash hit.

Tackling the Star Wars license in the summer of 2003 before a quick pit stop in Chinese myth, Bioware returned to the sci-fi genre by creating an entirely new IP. Mass Effect's immense attention to detail in its galaxy-wide lore enamoured those who picked up the first entry in the series, and though the storytelling reached a somewhat uninspired conclusion, the journey through the stars was simply unforgettable.

The galactic groundwork of Bioware's crowning space opera brought with it a cast of characters who's unrelenting charm and surprising depth are at the centre of the series' critical success. Erudite Asari, brutish Krogan and mysterious Quarian people litter citadel space, each offering intriguing narratives and curious beginnings, many of which are uncovered throughout Shepard's journey.

The interplanetary races and their relationships with one another provided the backbone for an otherwise formulaic plot to unfold, as the quest to banish a faceless evil was wonderfully decorated by foreign affairs with radically different bunches of compelling races.

Mass Effect 2
Bioware

Mass Effect's emphasis on character development and its conservative approach to choice-based storytelling forged an overarching experience spanning three games (covering Commander Shepard's heroics in bringing down the Reapers) that rivals that of long-standing sci-fi counterparts like Star Wars and Battlestar Galactica, and Bioware's crowning achievement is proof that video games can stand beside such fictional titans.

Cont.


Reinventing the (Dialogue) Wheel

mass effect dialogue
Bioware

Non-linear storytelling is nothing new in the realm of interactive entertainment. The early years of role-playing video games lifted components from tabletop RPG's so the desire for choice-based stories was felt from the get-go, and with AAA developers leaning into such mechanics in recent years it's almost become an expectation. Alternate endings, binary choices and dialogue options tailor the experience to the player, and often heighten the enjoyment to be had knowing that the story unfolding is specific to the player's tendencies.

However, devising and creating an air-tight, engaging and believable story is immensely difficult when the writers have to allow for the player to inject their own spin on the tale. What was once a process of careful storytelling is now a frantic game to plug holes in a story to ensure that the carefully constructed tale doesn't lose all tension when the player decided to pop off to save a cat from a tree. The alternative is to lock the story into an immovable and unchangeable affair, and while there are plenty of exceptional games that succeed by using this strategy, a galaxy-wide RPG series without any player agency seems like a waste of a good opportunity.

Surely a conundrum that Bioware acknowledged, Mass Effect takes the best pieces from each narrative philosophy to create a compelling story that allows players to alter small but significant aspects of the core story. The picture is always the same, but the way it's coloured in will vary from person to person, and though Mass Effect 2's 'suicide mission' can see the untimely demise of any and all crew members, the fundamental structure of Mass Effect 3's quest to save the galaxy will remain.

Such small changes to the core narrative are more often than not provoked by a flick of the dialogue wheel, offering speech selections of how Shepard should best handle a situation. From sassy dismissals to heroic and confident assertions, Shepard's personality and relationships with fellow crewmates are given a layer of uniqueness and complexity with an incredibly simply gameplay mechanic. Never does the dialogue wheel get in the way of the series' many combat encounters, nor does it slow a game's pacing in any way. The emergence of the dialogue wheel is far more exciting than its simplistic mechanics deserve, as the opportunity to converse with any of the series' interesting side characters is a constant highlight.

From seemingly inconsequential dialogue choices filling the paragon or renegade paths to essential decisions of who to save and who to leave behind, the Mass Effect story will always be centred around the fight against the Reapers, but saving the Rachni Queen, sparing Wrex on Virmire, assisting Tali on the Migrant Fleet and romancing Liara (the ONLY right answer) nudge the story in a direction that makes it feel unique to each playthrough.

Mass Effect 3 Dialogue Wheel
BioWare

Cont.


Races & Characters

mass effect tali
Bioware

Though the Mass Effect series spends little time in our native solar system, the smattering of alien races that pepper the series are --for the most part-- immensely relatable and always compelling.

Mass Effect 3's frequent shift to each race's home world offers insight to each people that provides much needed clarity, from the destruction of Palaven in the game's early hours to fighting on the frontline in Asari territory on Thessia. We'd grown to love Liara and empathise with Matriarch Benezia, but understanding the values of the Asari by witnessing it first-hand brought immense depth to an otherwise secretive race of people.

Mass Effect 2's ragtag crew of misfits make every meander around the Normandy an interesting one, as every character has their own woes that often coincide with their race.

Hearing of Tali's separation from the Migrant fleet during her pilgrimage, Miranda's wavering dedication to Cerberus and Garrus' vigilantism on Omega deepens Shepard's --and indeed the players'-- relationship with them, so when you go to war in their company it feels like you're entering battle with friends.

Mass Effect Citadel DLC
Bioware

Loyalty quests strengthen that bond, and while some are better than others, the time you spend earning the respect of Thane, Mordin or Jack make for some of the game's finest moments.

At surface level, Jacob is a somewhat uninteresting soldier in a sea of other Cerberus agents fighting for the survival of humanity, but hearing of his potentially re-emerging father on Aeia, reaching the planet in question and uncovering the truth strengthens the bond between Shepard and himself, making him more than just a nameless Normandy crew member.

In the age of social distancing, conversing with Mass Effect's diverse and compelling cast is sufficient enough social interaction, which is perhaps the highest compliment one can give.

Jacob mass effect 2
Bioware

Cont.


Galactic, Yet Grounded

mass effect 4 krogan
Bioware

There are certainly deeper social commentaries of xenophobia, and a prominent emphasis cultural differences that provide problems and situations that hit close to home (like Cerberus' devotion to human development and the Krogan's distaste for almost every race not from Tuchanka).

Inserting very real human issues that litter headlines in the real world into a universe-spanning story of galactic survival ensures the series and its characters remain interesting to the player.

The sci-fi genre is regularly quick to confuse, and chatter about obscure alien technology so often sends a story spiralling out of control, but the injection of real world talking points while reaching for the stars wonderfully keeps the players' attention throughout. We don't know the inner workings of the Prothean weapon designed to defeat the reapers in Mass Effect 3, and the game doesn't try to explain it to you, which makes room for the far more interesting themes of survival and hope that the series relies on so much.

Mass Effect 2 Arrival
BioWare

Commander Shepard could just as easily be Aquaman and the Normandy could just as easily be a submarine; the sci-fi setting doesn't matter anywhere near as much as the story unfolding, and weaving in and out of countless planets' orbit is a lovely --albeit unimportant-- dressing for an incredible tale to be told.

Though the Normandy zips from cluster to cluster in a flash (well, in the time it takes to load the next screen), Mass Effect's emphasis on very human politics and social issues are at the centre of its success as a story. Resisting the ruthless practices of Cerberus while tensely working alongside them in the second game is made easier by uncovering their obvious xenophobia, and forging a bond with all manner of races highlights the importance of fighting for a common cause, regardless of physical, emotional or social differences.

Cont.


Plotting The Next Relay Jump

Mass Effect
EA

Part of Mass Effect Andromeda's failure was the lack of compelling characters or interesting premise. Deviating from the heroics of Commander Shepard and Co was a risky move, and in the eyes of many the game presented wasn't worthy of the lofty expectations of its title. It's a massive missed opportunity, and continuing down the fork Andromeda created would be an unwise choice unless developer Bioware knocks its sequel out of the park.

Shepard's cryptic conclusion is surely also one avenue that should be left alone, but that's not to say the IP hasn't got potential. Established in the first three entries in the series are a smorgasbord of interesting races, jaw-dropping settings and rich lore that the series could pull inspiration from.

The shooting mechanics refined in Mass Effect 3 work beautifully, the dialogue wheel is a stroke of genius and the writing is always top notch, so re-entering the Mass Effect interpretation of our galaxy to tell a fresh, new story is too good an opportunity to pass up.

Mass Effect is the definitive space opera, in gaming or otherwise, and the agency it gives the player to experience its tale in their own way while stubbornly adhering to linear storytelling beautifully balances the experience so it never loses its charm. It's the culmination of years of development on other franchises for Bioware, and it will perhaps always be the developers' greatest story.


In this post: 
Mass Effect
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Fan of ducks, ice tea and escapism. Spends much of his time persistently saying 'I have so much studying to do' before watching Zoey 101 for the millionth time. Thinks Uncharted 3 is the best one.