How Rockstar Can AVOID Ruining GTA 6

Do you miss the old design ethos of GTA?

GTA 6
Rockstar

As an iconic and very well known veteran game studio with a very unique past, Rockstar are in a fascinating place.

Their legacy involves arcade one-offs turning into the biggest open-world crime franchise of all time. Of playing the industry's bad boys across the 2000s, funnelling GTA's profits into pet projects like doing a sequel to 1979's The Warriors in game form.

Hell, amongst all this, they released Rockstar's Table Tennis - something that did exactly what it said on the tin, simply because they needed to recoup funds after developing a whole new engine for GTA IV.

Point being, that they've always done things their way. GTA rose to prominence because it injected open-world Nintendo games like Mario 64 or Zelda: Ocarina of Time with entire mission sets, gameplay mechanic toolkits and a huge variety of traversal options.

GTA 3 was an overnight revolution, and as Rockstar would go on to shape the open-world genre, they'd also get so much bigger. In attracting more sizeable - and more casual - audiences than ever, their design ethos started to pivot.

Yes, you can still mess around and go on hour-long police chases where all hell breaks loose, but mission scope would be reigned in considerably.

Cont.


Red Dead Redemption 2 Saint Denis Heist
Rockstar

Play Red Dead Redemption 2 and you'll see this "new mentality" in full force. "Steal X stagecoach and leave it exactly here", "Kill X target with THIS weapon", "Infiltrate X place from THIS entry point".

Any deviation, and it's game over.

The result both here and in GTA 5 is something that feels polished to a mirror sheen, but you're following mission prompts almost the entire time. Gunfights break out exactly where they're supposed to, you drive from A to B and back again, watching a cutscene in between.

In short... it can feel spectacularly boring, especially compared to the wider mission goals and experimentation that used to frontload the older titles.

In GTA 3, Vice City and San Andreas, you were given a target with no clear way to take them out. Maybe a handler produced a pistol, but buying a sniper rifle and eliminating your target from across the map worked just as well.

A character going to make a getaway in a car? Get there ahead of time, plant a bomb and watch them explode instead. Even the various street races you could partake in could be "gamed" by placing vehicles on the track, then gaining the upper hand as the A.I. plowed into them.

Granted, it's entirely possible all these things were happy accidents, as Rockstar were literally sculpting the genre. These outcomes could've come more from the games only registering the death of a targets rather than scanning for specific methods, but point being: It worked.

We all fell in love with this version of GTA, and for me it's what makes the older titles more fun to go back to.

Cont.


Liberate Outposts far cry 3
Ubisoft

Speaking of Rockstar setting the bar though, it's clear Ubisoft have taken what were tenets of GTA and ran with them. Far Cry 3 put clearing outposts at the top of its feature list like the gang hideouts of San Andreas, and even Ghost Recon: Breakpoint gives you an open world with tons of gameplay options that come from the character and environment, rather than scripting.

GTA 5, Red Dead 2 - as Rockstar have gotten bigger and drawn thicker lines in the sand as to how missions should play out, they've lost that playful sense of experimentation and dynamic interaction that made their sandboxes so much fun in the first place.

For GTA 6, we need a return to the "here's a set of mechanics, go have fun" version of GTA we used to know and love.

Give us open-ended mission goals that spark ten ideas at once in the mind of the player. Don't have every shooting segment end with a car chase unless the A.I. randomly decides to do so, and for the love of all that is holy, ditch the scripted "joke missions" like Scouting the Port and the LifeInvader stealth sequence.

Rockstar need to remember what made GTA so stellar, and that was routed in being the most experimental crime sandbox in all of gaming.


Watch Next


The IMPOSSIBLE GTA: Vice City Quiz

Tommy Vercetti, GTA Vice City
Rockstar

1. Who Voiced Tommy Vercetti?

In this post: 
GTA 6
 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.