How To Save A Dying Video Game Franchise

How to bring a flatlining series back from the dead.

Crash bandicoot
Activision

Making a single great game is one thing, but spinning a hit title into an enduring franchise which continues to surprise and impress gamers for years or even decades? That's no easy feat.

Practically every long-running video game series sooner or later hits creative stagnation, often resulting in them outright floundering critically or commercially - if not both.

For many franchises, this will force them into a sabbatical of-sorts while their publisher tries to figure out what to do with them. The next step is absolutely crucial in determining the future of the IP.

Some publishers will simply decide to cynically cash-in on current gaming trends whether it suits the game or not, while others will spring for wacky, desperate new peripherals - let us never, ever forget Tony Hawk: Ride's plastic skateboard controller.

But there are smart ways for publishers to rejuvenate their ailing franchises, typically through a combination of sticking to what made people love it in the first place, and acknowledging how their respective genres have moved on in the years since they began to fail.

These steps aren't ever a guarantee for success, of course - or that the sales will match the reviews - but are certainly the smart ways to go about shocking a video game series back to life...

10. Remember, Nostalgia Always Wins

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1 + 2
Activision

If the last few years of video games and Hollywood have taught us anything, it's that people are extreme suckers for nostalgia, for having something altogether familiar re-sold to them in a shiny new package.

At its most base level, the easiest thing a publisher can do to resurrect a dying franchise is simply remind fans of how great it used to be, by re-releasing its most beloved games as part of a remake or remaster collection.

This worked extremely well with Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy and also Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1 + 2, both of which are largely credited with resurrecting their respective franchises.

Then there are games like Call of Duty: Modern Warfare, which didn't strictly remake the original 2007 game, but instead hearkened back to the stripped-down spirit of its predecessor, ditching the increasingly silly sci-fi nonsense for something a bit more down-to-Earth.

As much as we all might agree that nostalgia is one of the most powerful creative tools there is, deciding on the right way to exploit that nostalgia isn't always easy...


9. Make Your Choice: Sequel, Reboot, Or Remake?

Doom 2016
Bethesda

When attempting to dig deep into players' fond memories of the past, there are a number of ways to go, and developers need to think wisely about which path to take.

Those who feel that the established continuity hasn't been tarnished beyond redemption can always just stick to the existing number convention and make another straight sequel - take Devil May Cry 5 following up the well-received but commercially mediocre DmC reboot with a direct follow-up to Devil May Cry 4.

Then there's the reboot approach, such as with 2011's table-clearing Mortal Kombat, or even a soft-reboot as with 2016's Doom re-tooling, which effectively restarted the series but without ditching the existing lore.

And finally there's the remake, of simply doing what the aforementioned Crash Bandicoot and Tony Hawk franchises did by diving back into the most revered back catalogue titles to rejuvenate interest in possible new entries.

Whether sequel, reboot, or remake, however, there's one thing all these types of follow-ups need to do...


8. Act Like The Bad Games Never Happened

Crash Bandicoot 4
Activision

Far more so than film fans, gamers will accept a new game which throws out the existing continuity or ignores a dud sequel entirely.

In part, this is because most video games aren't quite up to the narrative level of a great movie or TV show, with far more of the appeal rooted in the gameplay.

And so, game franchises generally find it easier to course-correct by simply jettisoning failed prior games from the series' continuity, either by actively re-writing history or flat-out ignoring them and pretending they never existed.

The timey-wimey shenanigans of Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time hilariously allowed the game to make a passing reference to the many bungled sequels following 1998's Crash 3: Warped, effectively chucking them out of the timeline as they did so.

Though flat-out reboots and card-carrying soft-reboots are far more common than straight sequels which re-jig the continuity such as Crash 4, the key goal is diminishing the offending game's mindshare in the fanbase and giving them as little reason to think about it as humanly possible.

But it's also important not to rely too heavily on what came before...


7. Make It The Same... But Different

Sonic Mania
Sega

As much as people love nostalgia, they also aren't stupid, and publishers would certainly get review-bombed if they promised players a new game only to release a thinly-veiled remake.

The goal, then, should be to deliver an experience which returns to the series roots - while, yes, recapturing that precious nostalgia feeling - but also bringing just enough newness to the table to feel like it's more than a quasi-rehash.

Perhaps no game in recent years has pulled off this delicate balance better than Sonic Mania, a game which in many respects is pretty much just a remix of the earlier, better games in the series, but which tweaks and varies the gameplay just enough to be marketable as an homage-heavy new game.

For publishers who want to re-engage the fanbase but without simply dishing up a straight remake, this is the safest and most risk-averse way to do it.

And ideally, the feedback to this spiritual successor can then be used to make a more direct and original new game afterwards.

Speaking of which - Sonic Mania 2, when?

But this isn't the only way to save a flagging franchise. Bold, ambitious developers can go in basically the entirely opposite direction...


6. OR Have Confidence When Taking Risks

Resident Evil 7
Capcom

Alternatively, developers can decide to get a little more brave and creative, and actually take strides to thoroughly reinvent the series as something very different.

There's perhaps no more impressive example of this in recent years than Resident Evil 7, which both shifted the gameplay style from third-person to first-person, and also switched the tone back from shooter to survival horror. That's without even getting into the inspired addition of VR support.

Elsewhere, Metroid Prime brought the series back from an eight-year hiatus - due to Super Metroid's mediocre sales - and restored the franchise's good name with a slick change-up from 2D side-scroller to 3D FPS.

Then there's Hitman 2016, which reinvented the series with a more sandbox-focused approach and also an acclaimed episodic release model.

These risky moves don't always work, admittedly - as with Driv3r's risible attempt to add on-foot gunplay to the series - but when they do, they can lend a sputtering-out franchise a whole new lease on life.

But in slightly less-drastic terms, developers can instead focus their attention on giving their hero a much-needed facelift...


5. Give The Protagonist An Epic Makeover

God Of War Kratos Atreus
Sony

Character redesigns are extremely risky, given the notorious fickleness of just about every major entertainment fanbase on the planet. But when they work, they really work.

There are two clear winners in recent years, the first being Tomb Raider's Lara Croft.

In 2013's reboot from Crystal Dynamics, the acrobatic adventurer was reinvented as a more believable human being.

Not only were her physical proportions less comically exaggerated, but more of an effort was made to portray her vulnerability and invite the audience to care about her as a character.

2018's God of War reboot-sequel similarly ditched the callous Kratos of yore for a more relatable and empathetic old gunslinger called back to fight once again. For those who were turned off by the sadistic violence of the prior games, the 2018 game took Kratos in a decidedly more human direction.

Again, though, it doesn't always work, as with 2013's Devil May Cry reboot DmC, which while a perfectly fine game in its own right, misguidedly re-imagined Dante as an edgy, "emo" shadow of his former self. Thankfully, Capcom eventually reversed tack, bringing classic Dante back for Devil May Cry 5.

But sometimes a simple character change isn't enough, and a series' waning popularity can benefit enormously from a fresh creative perspective...


4. Bring In A New Development Team

wolfenstein the new order
Bethesda

Sometimes a video game concept has simply run its creative course with the established regime, and what's desperately needed is a hungry new team to come in and offer their own spin on a tired formula.

Again, it's a risky approach given the potential for a new developer to either veer too far away from the original vision and risk alienating fans, or simply fail to capture the subtle gameplay nuances of what came before.

But it has been a successful gamble for numerous franchises - MachineGames has brought the stagnant Wolfenstein franchise roaring back to life despite being a totally new outfit prior to starting work on the hit FPS series.

And don't forget Rockstar Games, who resurrected the Max Payne franchise from the commercial doldrums with the highly successful third game.

Again, this is a challenging approach which poses a high potential for failure if publishers don't take the time to find the right developer for the job, but when it works, it really works. Max Payne 4 when, though?

If hand-picking some new blood to shepherd a franchise into a new age is as brave as it gets, on the other side of the coin, there are more cynical options...


3. "Borrow" From Whatever's Popular

Shadow Of The Tomb Raider Lara Croft
Square Enix

It's a universal maxim of video games that any massively popular game will get a ton of me-too imitators, many of them cheap knock-offs, but also a number of blatant admirers in the AAA sphere.

There's no example more egregious - or successful, perhaps - than Crystal Dynamics' 2013 Tomb Raider reboot, which so obviously took most of its stylistic and gameplay cues from the Uncharted series.

With a more cinematic approach to action than ever before, the new Tomb Raider was an enthusiastic leap far away from the stiffer, more sober prior games, and ably brought Lara Croft kicking and screaming into a new era.

While nowadays this tends to materialise in far more cynical ways, by including loot box mechanics, micro-transactions, and maybe even a Battle Royale component, games which attempt to capitalise on current trends have a high probability of actually succeeding with the casual market.

But when even this doesn't seem feasible, there is one desperate last resort, which we'll call The Nuclear Option...


2. If All Else Fails, Wait It Out

Streets Of Rage 4
DotEmu

Sometimes it's a simple fact that players are tired of a franchise - of its aesthetic, of its gameplay, of basically everything about it. Maybe the franchise over-saturated itself with an excess of titles, or perhaps it simply failed to move with the times.

There are worse things than for franchises to take an "extended hiatus" and actually sit a generation out, allowing fans to actually miss them and crave their return.

Take Streets of Rage, which went into hibernation in 1994 after the release of the third game, and due to numerous stalled attempts to get a fourth game made, Streets of Rage 4 wasn't finally released until earlier this year - to strong acclaim, even.

Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy and Crash 4 both succeeded on the virtue of fans having long missed the series, no matter its considerable downturn over the years, yet without such a huge gulf of time, these projects could've struggled in the market.

Waiting for a generation (or two) to pass is typically a smart idea, because it affords developers the opportunity to truly wow fans with a shiny new game that takes full advantage of modern platform tech.

But again, it doesn't always work - Guitar Hero Live and Rock Bond 4 both attempted to revitalise the rhythm game in 2015 to little success, despite sitting out around five years a-piece.

And though it's vitally important for publishers to consider all of these pointers before attempting to rejuvenate a dying franchise, there is one more fact to consider - a fact they absolutely won't want to hear...


1. But Remember, Not All Franchises Can Be Saved

Duke Nukem Forever
3D Realms

The simple truth is that not all video game franchises were meant to last forever, and sometimes a series has its time in the sun before it runs out of steam and disappears into the ether.

Some franchises simply don't have the staying power to endure in perpetuity: take Duke Nukem, which attempted to will itself back to life with 2011's long-delayed Duke Nukem Forever, yet was met with critical failure and commercial mediocrity.

Elsewhere the Alone in the Dark series has had more retoolings than most people have had hot dinners, with 2015's Alone in the Dark: Illumination receiving near-universal critical disdain, enough that some reviewers believed it to be the death knell for the survival horror series.

Then there's Medal of Honor, which has similarly made several unremarkable attempts to restore its former FPS glory, yet hasn't felt truly relevant or worthwhile in around 15 years.

Though the upcoming VR game, Medal of Honor: Above and Beyond, looks pretty fun, its niche appeal should prevent it from breathing too much life back into the series.

These three franchises all have one thing in common: they've all failed to reinvent themselves in clever or creative ways as the gaming world has moved around them. And in some cases that isn't worth shedding tears over.

Occasionally, however, there are games fans absolutely want to see resurrected, but legal red tape simply prevents it from ever happening - take TimeSplitters, for example.

Sad as it is when a classic video game IP gets put out to pasture, sometimes it's just the natural course of things. Not every video game franchise actually needs, even deserves to be saved.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.