Kingdom Hearts 3: 10 Reasons It's A Disappointment

It wasn't worth the wait.

Kingdom hearts 3
Square Enix

Kingdom Hearts III has finally been released and out in the wild for a few weeks now, so you've perhaps had time to work your way through Square Enix's long-awaited JRPG, or at least make a decent dent in it.

And though the game received strong reviews for the most part, as a fan, it's hard not to feel short-changed by the end result.

Is Kingdom Hearts III a terrible game? Absolutely not, but does it live up to more than a decade of hype and meet the high standard set by its predecessors? Not nearly.

This is a game as frustrating as it is entertaining, loaded with mind-boggling design and creative decisions which hamper the core experience.

Though Square Enix is to be commended for the title's terrific visuals and grind-free gameplay, getting to the end of the 30-hour adventure is more of an exercise in patience than anyone wants to admit.

Between this and the underwhelming Final Fantasy XV, it really feels like the company needs a major creative overhaul if they're going to maintain their status as a top-tier AAA publisher...


10. The Disney Worlds Are A Mixed Bag

Kingdom Hearts 3 Monstropolis
Square Enix

The game's array of Disney-themed worlds are wildly inconsistent quality and entertainment-wise, with the easy highlights being Toy Box, the Caribbean and San Fransokyo.

On the flip side, Monstropolis was a colossal disappointment, taking the vibrant world of Monsters Inc. and boiling it down into a series of dull, repetitive factory hallways that proves oddly reminiscent of FFXV's infamous, soul-destroying Chapter 13.

Frozen's Arendelle was also a major letdown, consisting of little more than copy-paste tundra environments while the player is simply tasked with running up and down a stretch of mountain.

And the game's trip to 100 Acre Wood is meanwhile shockingly brief, forcing the player to spend most of their time playing soulless, unimaginative mini-games.

Too many of the worlds just lazily retell the story from their respective movies, and the expected intertextuality with Sora's own story isn't really there.

To this end the game too often feels like lazy Disney fan service rather than an inventive collision of two distinct properties.


9. The Pacing Is Terrible

Kingdom Hearts 3 Winnie The Pooh
Square Enix

Though Kingdom Hearts III is to be somewhat commended for the lack of grinding required to make it to the end, it's still an absolute slog of a game for most of its 25-30 hours.

The main problem is the utterly wonky pacing, with the majority of the Disney-themed worlds presenting little in the way of concrete story progression, before the final few hours of the game rush through enough epic incident and character development to fill an entire RPG.

It basically feels like Square Enix is just ticking things off in those later hours, bombarding the player with relentless battles and exposition dumps without much of a reprieve.

Had the story been doled out more evenly between worlds, then the game surely wouldn't seem so genuinely boring with such baffling regularity.


8. No Final Fantasy Characters

Final Fantasy 7 Remake
Square Enix

Perhaps the most obvious complaint about Kingdom Hearts III is the total lack of Final Fantasy characters in the game (apart from the shopkeeper Moogles, of course).

Including characters from Square Enix's beloved JRPG franchise has been a staple of the Kingdom Hearts games, so their complete absence here is just bizarre.

Considering the tried-and-tested awesomeness of combining Final Fantasy with Disney, it's extremely odd that the likes of Cloud and Sephiroth are nowhere to be seen.

Yes, you can argue that their stories have been tied up already, but in a game that's all about fan service, that's an indulgence it could've easily gotten away with.

It's probably more likely that the Final Fantasy aspect was cut during production given the game's noted developmental issues, because from a marketing perspective, cramming as much Disney into the game as possible was the obvious priority.

Even so, it feels like a little of the franchise's soul - or its heart, even - is missing without at least a few nifty cameos from the legendary franchise.


7. It's Too Damn Easy

Kingdom Hearts 3 Attraction Flow
Square Enix

Probably the most surprising thing about the entire game is just how absurdly easy it is.

On Normal difficulty Kingdom Hearts 3 is an absolute cake-walk, but even Proud doesn't really offer a whole lot of push-back, making this decisively the least-challenging game in the core franchise.

And though accessibility certainly is a good thing, it does feel like Kingdom Hearts 3 makes the player a little too capable for their own good.

The links and attraction flow mechanics make it easy to cheese your way through even the most seemingly imposing boss, making Sora and co. feel hilariously over-powered in the process.

You're not obliged to use these powers most of the time, of course, but it still detracts from a lot of the satisfaction that the game can be breezed through with no trouble whatsoever.


6. The Boss Fights Are (Mostly) Underwhelming

Kingdom Hearts 3 Aqua
Square Enix

Square Enix is of course renowned for their creative and memorable boss fights, but again like FFXV, Kingdom Hearts 3 falls massively short of the mark in this area.

Despite having numerous iconic Disney IP at their disposal, most of the themed worlds don't present much in the way of awe-inspiring bosses, mostly settling for giant and/or dark versions of creatures you've already encountered.

Only really at the tail-end of the game do the boss fights truly boast the epic scale you'd hope for, yet given the easy potential for some creative battles against some of Disney's most memorable recent villains, they mostly feel like a hugely missed opportunity.


5. The Incoherent Writing & Flat Direction

Kingdom Hearts 3 Sora Goofy
Square Enix

It's no secret that the story and general writing of the Kingdom Hearts games is extremely divisive, even among the series' most hardcore cheerleaders, but this game's approach to narrative is especially infuriating.

For starters, the dialogue is toe-curlingly corny and stilted at almost all times - take a shot every time someone says "heart" and die within a half-hour - and unless you've got a strong cringe reflex, you'll likely start tuning out after a short while.

It's too convoluted to be truly engaging, and though the themed worlds do help break up the monotony of the main story somewhat, it is a strictly "for the fans" approach that, even then, isn't terribly alluring.

Cut-scene direction is also a major problem, with the majority of them featuring weird pauses between dialogue, awkward shot selections and failing to make the most of the gorgeously rendered characters.

Simply, the aggressively exposition-heavy script combines with flat direction to make most of the story elements painfully boring to all but the most invested Kingdom Hearts fan.


4. It Plays Like A PS2 Game

Kingdom Hearts 3 Monstropolis
Square Enix

Though it certainly doesn't look like a PS2 game, mechanically Kingdom Hearts 3 feels positively retrograde, and not always in the fun, throwback sense of the word.

The biggest culprit by far is the game's terrible camera, which often actively works against the player's efforts during combat, making it tough to keep track of enemies even with the ability to lock-on. In 2019, is that really acceptable?

Character movements and traversal also feel incredibly awkward, with Sora's stilted running and jumping animations looking like a far cry from a contemporary AAA blockbuster game.

Running up buildings looks especially janky, and given the general polish of the core combat - camera issues aside - it sticks out like a sore thumb.


3. Gummi Ships Are (Still) A Total Bore

Kingdom Hearts 3 Gummi
Square Enix

The Gummi Ship system has always been hugely divisive among fans, and though Square Enix deserves a small measure of credit for making mandatory Gummi sequences pretty infrequent, they're still incredibly dull and grind the game's pacing to an immediate halt.

If you want to, it's easy enough to just spam the boost button and make your way to the next Disney world without too much trouble - bar the occasional unskippable boss fight - though these sequences are still insanely boring for the few minutes they last.

Square Enix should've made them entirely optional and just allowed players to fast-travel between worlds, because the Gummi Ship elicits a groan every single time it shows up.


2. The Finale Is A Dull Slog

Kingdom Hearts 3
Square Enix

No spoilers here, but the final 3-4 hours of Kingdom Hearts 3 are an absolute chore. Though it's hardly difficult, the player is assaulted with more than a dozen boss fights, most of them punctuated by exhaustingly over-baked cut-scenes.

Between the simplicity of the fights, their general repetitiveness and the lack of imagination on display, Square Enix clearly would've benefited from a less-is-more approach to the game's finale.

By the time the ending finally rolls around, you may find yourself more relieved that the tiresome avalanche of soulless fights and nonsensical dialogues is over, which is a damn shame.


1. It Wasn't Worth The 13-Year Wait

Kingdom Hearts 3 Xbox E3
Square Enix

The most crushing disappointment of all? Kingdom Hearts III just wasn't worth 13 years of hype and anticipation.

Again, it's not an awful game by any means, but given the absurdly long wait between core titles, the end result feels bizarrely low-effort and malnourished in a lot of key areas.

Between this and FFXV falling short of the mark for many fans, it's probably best to lower your expectations for any future entries into either franchise, even if it's sad that "merely decent" is what Square Enix is content putting out nowadays.

The best thing you can do to enjoy this game is remove any preconceptions that it's going to be an epic, satisfying conclusion to the trilogy and just accept it on its own terms as a sloppy, fitfully enjoyable JRPG.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.