Last Of Us 2 Ending EXPLAINED - Why It's Dividing The Fandom
All the controversy and hate? It's intentional.
-- FULL SPOILERS WITHIN --
The Last of Us 2 is an ugly game.
It's disgusting, sickening, stomach-churningly violent and filled with regret. There are many shards of light punctuating the darkness, but Naughty Dog are pulling no punches with their bleak exploration of human violence.
Currently sitting with almost 20k negative scores on Metacritic, the reality is a project made to provoke a response and ask questions.
Why do we find it so easy to hate? Is it worthwhile on a human level, to be driven by such negative emotion? If this becomes all-consuming, what effect does that have on your loved ones, and your ability to be there for them? Is the only way to find peace through empathy, and trusting the "other" will do the same?
These are huge, incredibly important themes, and ones that video games were yet to touch on to such a powerful degree.
To dissect why it works so well, let's break down this 25+ hour game and provide a counterpoint to the ongoing vitriol that surrounds it online. It's plainly obvious that entire portions of the fanbase don't realise Naughty Dog have instilled the exact reaction they planned for.
You're Supposed To Hate Abby
For the longest time, creative director Neil Druckmann stated that The Last of Us 2 is "about hate".
Naturally, with all trailers pointing to Ellie on the warpath, new girlfriend Dina looking to be killed and Joel trying to help, we assumed this would be a clear cut story of Ellie butchering everyone in her path. Joel would try to stop her, and all sorts of comparisons to Joel's actions at the close of the first game would come through.
An hour and a half into a 25 hour runtime though, Joel has his kneecap blown off by a shotgun, and is beaten to death by new character, Abby. He's further spat on by her friend Manny, and later called a "little b*tch" by Nora, who follows up saying he "got what he deserved".
All of this sets Abby and her gang up as the most detestable figures in quite some time.
It's immediately clear from the 18,000 (and counting) zero scores on Metacritic, reaction videos of people rage-quitting and the discourse in general, that most people did not like this decision.
However, that's the point.
All that anger, sadness, the questioning of "Why?!" and the drive to do something about it is entirely what you're supposed to be feeling for the majority of the game.
Naughty Dog took the bold as hell decision to make YOU care about enacting this tale of revenge as much as Ellie. They knew you wouldn't feel this way if Dina or even Tommy got killed, and the first step to understanding what they're going for is accepting these feelings are intentional from the creator.
Joel's "Cheap" Death
Death IS cheap.
Very few of us live past 73 according to the latest data, and even fewer get to plan for a circle of family members, flowers and last words. Death in real life just... happens, and you have to deal with it.
In so many ways - especially in a fictional post-apocalypse - death can, and in this case, should, come at any time.
For The Last of Us 2, Joel's murder at the hands of Abby stems from her being the daughter of the lead surgeon you butchered in the first game.
Yes, Joel was saving Ellie, but it prevented the cure for humankind. On a bigger scale, it undid the work of multiple generations of Firefly members signing up to do the right thing for years upon years at a time.
Joel's death mirrors that of the surgeon from the first game - a character we didn't give a second thought to at the time, but whose role in this mythos was instrumental.
Joel's murder feels "cheap" because again, that's the point. Joel is a target Abby has been tracking for years; someone who in her eyes, came out of nowhere and destroyed her family and life's work on a personal whim.
Like some survivors who undergo trauma and enact a plan to ensure it never happens again, Abby has transformed her body into a living weapon. When finally given the opportunity, she unleashes a built-up fury that was harbouring for far too long.
Abby's attack is devastating to see and hear, but it succeeds in making both us and Ellie question her motivations more furiously than any other character in gaming history.
Again, you are not supposed to be okay with Joel's death. You just have to live with why it happened, and press on.
Why You Need To Play As Abby For 10 Hours
A huge turning point in the story happens bang-on the midway point, where after Abby has infiltrated the theatre where Ellie, Dina, Tommy and Jesse are staying - in retaliation for Ellie killing all of Abby's friends - she pins Tommy to the ground, kills Jesse and attempts to fire on Ellie.
We instead cut to black, and play the entire three-day Seattle timeline from Abby's perspective.
We see the Washington Liberation Front are an organised group with education systems, farming facilities, various social circles and homesteads. We learn Seattle is a warzone to them; a "front" that soldiers are being posted to, in an attempt to fight yet another faction, the Seraphites.
At this point you are SUPPOSED to dislike being forced to inhabit the enemy's shoes. I personally just wanted to "get back to the main story", and as each day wore on, I questioned whether this was a negative for the game or not.
Over time - and it really does take many hours in the company of someone you're supposed to hate, for the paradigm to shift - your perception of Abby and these sequences changes.
Maybe you still don't agree with what she did, but you don't hate her as a one-dimensional villain anymore. You fundamentally cannot, unless you're forcing yourself to ignore the human qualities that are clearly on display.
It's this choice - this hugely ambitious, risky artistic choice - that coupled with Joel's earlier death, lies at the heart of the game's controversy.
Many just want Abby to die no matter what, and that mentality is what Naughty Dog made The Last of Us 2 to address.
You're Not Supposed To Be On Ellie's Side In The Final Third
By the time we return to Abby and Ellie clashing in the theatre, Abby comes close to killing a pregnant Dina, but finds it in herself to leave both her and Ellie alive.
We're shown a kindness from someone who lost their father and entire social circle to what must seem like psychopathic tendencies, the result letting Ellie and Dina raise a child on an idyllic farmland some time in the future.
And yet, even after living a completely different life, Ellie cannot settle.
After Tommy visits the home and notes that one of his tracker teams has found Abby and younger companion Lev hiding out, you should be filled with one feeling: Rejection.
Ellie has responsibilities now. She has a partner and child. She has a house, animals to look after and many sunsets to watch go down.
We KNOW this on a human level. That she, under no circumstances, should give up her home life and all the love therein, to risk another bone-breaking fight with Abby to "make things right".
And yet, at 3am one morning, she sneaks out her own house.
Walking away from a crying, pleading Dina and not saying goodbye to their own son, Ellie decides that pursuing revenge no matter the cost is more important than living in peace.
Can You Understand And Spare Your Enemy?
No other game has ever made me feel the sheer level of putrid, stomach-churning negative emotion that these final hours conjured up.
Seeing Ellie make the decision to track Joel's killer - a woman who has spared her twice at this point, and repeatedly asked her to stay away - was the wrong move in every possible way.
And yet, by again forcing you into the shoes of someone you don't agree with, you're forced to see these actions through.
Ellie ultimately tracks down Abby, and the pair have another horrifically bloody fight. Wounds are ripped open, faces punched, arms bitten. Both characters end up as bloody, exhausted messes, until Ellie is strangling and drowning Abby underwater.
Here, at the zenith of her actions; her face a contorted mess of anger, sadness, malice and perhaps some satisfaction, she stops.
Ellie spares Abby, she and Lev leave on a boat, and Ellie returns home to find Dina has taken their child and cleaned the house out.
The game ends with Ellie walking away from the house, alone.
This action of sparing the person who killed your father figure and friend might be seen as "weak", but the overwhelming feeling is sadness; of being overwhelmed at the depiction of violence, and being thankful that two people you care about are not tearing each other apart anymore.
The Last of Us 2 is asking if after everything, you could forgive or at least understand this individual you've conditioned yourself to hate.
Multiple times throughout the story, Abby and Ellie are proven wrong about the machinations behind the WLF or the Seraphites. They're forced to see people as human, rather than one-dimensional villains it's easy to hate.
Applying these lessons in reality, could we do the same to avoid horrific circumstances happening in real life? Do we need to get as far as brutally beating each other, or could a peaceful resolution be reached much earlier?
The Point Of It All
The Last of Us 2, despite having to dig deep into the human psyche to spotlight our worst primal tendencies, is in the end, an incredibly positive, philanthropic and pro-life game.
It's uplifting in its highlighting of genuine human interaction amidst dire circumstances, champions starting a family no matter what, showcases the beauty of nature alongside humans, and even includes multiple moments where characters break into song.
Naughty Dog's latest is a clarion call for empathy and understanding. Of fighting through our nature of easily hating, to strive for something better. We see "heroes" and "villains" flirt with peace and resolution, but get drawn into the same conflicts over and over, simply because they choose physical violence over anything else.
As a triple-A video game from one of the industry's leading companies, this is bold as hell. It's jarring, shocking, something that will take real consideration and conversation to understand, but a risk worth taking.