Madden 16: 10 Overrated Players Who Need Downgrading

Three of the greatest players in the league need bringing down a level.

Every year, EA improves their Madden formula, constantly seeking to produce games better than the instalment before, to ensure that it's worthy of the fans' annual investment. To reach the point of perfection for any given year, game mechanics need tweaking and exciting new features need to be added, though one of the key components that draws fans back to the game is realism. EA's ultimate mission is to a recreate the next best thing to pulling on the pads and charging head first into a terrifying frenzy of beefed-up lunatics. There are many ways they can go about this. Improved graphics make for a more immersive experience, deafening crowds add to the intense atmospheres, while advertisements, commentators, TV-style displays and backstories all add together to make a huge difference, but there's also a need for players to be accurately rated. The game could be inch-perfect, but if one player is rated too high or too low, fans will be eager to bring the matter up across the many forums and internet communities that have been built around the game. It's becoming an even wider ritual for fans to rip the box open and scan through each player's ratings before any actual football takes place. So here's a look at some players who were overrated at the start of Madden 15 that need to be scaled down on the next edition.

10. Jake Matthews - 81

OT Jake Matthews was drafted as the sixth overall pick in 2014, with great things expected from the young man who hails from a family steeped in NFL glory. His father Bruce is in the Hall Of Fame, his uncle and grandfather were also players, while the Falcons offensive lineman is also the cousin of the Green Bay Packers' OLB Clay Matthews. Unfortunately for Jake Matthews, his rookie season was a relative disappointment. It's too early to label him as a bust just yet, but he has failed to live up to expectations immediately, and certainly wasn't the fourth best rookie to feature in 2014. He could develop into his current 81 rating, but for now a mid-to-late 70s rating looks more suitable.

9. Jadeveon Clowney - 83

Moving from one rookie to another, and without a doubt one of the most disappointing first year displays came from Jadeveon Clowney. He failed to register a sack in his meagre four performances during an injury-plagued season. Of course, it's not entirely his fault. Injuries are mainly down to chance. However, in the games Clowney did play, he looked unconvincing, and while he'll be fit and raring to go alongside J.J. Watt and Vince Wilfork this season, he hasn't proven himself to be worthy of the top rookie rating dished out by EA last year (83). For now, he could be around a 79, but with a good 2015, that could spring back up depending on how he settles into the league given a regular run in the team.

8. Colin Kaepernick - 89

QB Colin Kaepernick isn't having a great time with the 49ers at the moment, with the organisation seemingly in disarray and his closest ally, coach Jim Harbaugh, departed from the franchise. At 3,369 passing yards, Kaepernick set his own personal best in 2014, but that doesn't make him a fantastic quarterback. He's the 11th top QB on Madden, so not wildly overrated, but that puts him ahead of Ryan Tannehill, Matt Ryan and even Andrew Luck. Kaep is closer to an 85 than one notch away from 90.

7. Russell Wilson - 93

Russell Wilson is a great player. A phenomenal athlete, an exciting quarterback, and a young leader of a Super Bowl-winning team of monsters. He's already a very good QB, but 93 is excessive, considering four-time Super Bowl champion Tom Brady is on the same rating. There's no doubt Russell Wilson could reach a very high level indeed, but to put him on par with Brady right now is madness. He's certainly worthy of a 90 rating for now, but another Lombardi Trophy would see his stock rise again.

6. Vernon Davis - 94

Vernon Davis suffered in tandem with the 49ers as their 2014 season dwindled into nothing, as he posted his lowest receiving yard total (245yds) in his nine NFL years with the franchise. He only received the ball 26 times during his 14 games, but that was from 50 attempts, far more wasteful than other players with the same amount of receptions in the stats tables. His production rate has also slowed when it comes to scoring, with his TD total dropping from 13 to 2, from 2013 to 2014. He's not an awful player, of course not, but 94, and a spot as the third top TE in the league, might be a reach.

5. Matt Forte - 95

Matt Forte had a stellar 2013 campaign and EA responded with an immediate boost for the Chicago Bears star. But after tallying up the 12th highest rushing yard total in the league this year, is he really the fourth best running back in the entire NFL? Doubtful. Madden 15 ranks Adrian Peterson, LeSean McCoy and Jamaal Charles ahead of Forte, with none other than the mighty Marshawn Lynch sitting in fifth place. That's not even taking into consideration the likes of DeMarco Murray and Le'Veon Bell who topped the charts in 2014. Forte is obviously a great player in a poor team, but 93 seems a fair rating, though his receiving stats were very impressive last time around.

4. Brandon Marshall - 96

Brandon Marshall falls into a similar category to his former Bears teammate Forte; he's a great receiver, but is he really the second best in the league? No, he's not. As things stand, there's only Calvin Johnson rated ahead of him. That means Dez Bryant, Antonio Brown, Demaryius Thomas, A.J. Green and basically every other player who catches the football all rank below the Jets' new signing Marshall. A rating of 96 is too high. However, a couple of points down and he'd still be mixing it with some incredible receivers, while not standing head and shoulders above basically everyone. It's also hard to measure temperament on a virtual game, but there's a reason why Marshall hasn't been kept around too long by three different teams...

3. Peyton Manning - 98

Peyton Manning is one of the greatest quarterbacks of his generation, there's no doubt about it, but is he still the joint best in the league as things stand? Unfortunately, no. Aaron Rodgers is the standout 98 at the top of the pack, with Drew Brees perched in third at 96. That should be similar to Manning as he begins his descent towards retirement. He'll still claw his team into the playoffs, but his post-season record doesn't look great recently, with the young pretenders coming to steal his crown.

2. Richard Sherman - 99

Richard Sherman is a fantastic, fantastic player. That's a fact, regardless of whether you like him or not. But 99 ratings need to be preserved for one or two staggering, unquestioned talents, but does he really live up to the hype he's surrounded himself in? Sherman is one of three 99-rated players in the whole game; the joint best player in the whole NFL. But he's not. While Sherman has many talents and a Super Bowl ring to back himself up, his hype has added an extra point or two to his overall rating, and should rank closer to the still-incredible Darrelle Revis.

1. Calvin Johnson - 99

Okay, time to firmly put the tin hat on. Calvin Johnson shouldn't be a 99 rated player any longer. Of course he'll go down as one of the all-time great receivers, there's no doubt. But is he still a perfect player as his maximum rating would suggest? Megatron's numbers were down last season from the one before. He fell from 1,492 receiving yards in 14 games to 1,077yds in 13. Of course, that's still an impressive total, but his production is showing signs of slowing down. Johnson's first game of 2014 saw the receiver record 164 yards, his highest total of the season as he notched four straight games without a 100+ total before he was struck by injury. Then he posted sub-60 yard totals against the Cardinals, Patriots and Vikings without marking any game with a touchdown. It would be stupid to dismiss him as a top class player, but knocking a point or two off would be enough to represent the fact that Megatron is beginning his gradual, natural descent.

In this post: 
NFL Madden 16
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.