Mass Effect 4: 10 Things That Will Kill The Franchise

10 things that would totally ruin the Mass Effect franchise as we know it.

BiowareBiowareThe Mass Effect franchise has fast become one of the most popular action-RPG franchises of all time, and a legendary sci-fi series in its own right. The first two games were critical (and commercial) darlings, while Mass Effect 3 was still a worthy entry despite not quite meeting the high expectations. Bioware's creative universe, inhabited by bizarre creatures and filled with incredible locations, has resonated with fans worldwide. Thanks to the series' cult-like following, Mass Effect 4 is by far and away one of the most hotly awaited sequels of all time. While the game has been officially announced, EA and Bioware have been extremely tight-lipped with regards to the project, with only a few titbits of information being shared here and there. For example, they've made it clear that Shepard's story has ended, and the fourth entry won't be a direct continuation of the original trilogy. Of course, we also don't know whether that means it'll be taking place a few years after Mass Effect 3, just with new characters, or if it will be set hundreds of years later. Either way, Bioware need to take some lessons from the more questionable aspects of Mass Effect 3, if they want the franchise to live on beyond the fourth game. In this list, we've put together a list of 10 things that would totally kill the franchise if they were included in Mass Effect 4.

10. Action Over RPG

BiowareBiowareMass Effect 2 had a far greater focus on the action elements than the original game, and it worked well for the most part. Mass Effect 3 went on to emphasise the action even more, and it began to tread dangerously close to watering down the gameplay too much. The Mass Effect series has never been a straight-up third-person shooter. Biotic abilities, squad management and tactical planning will always be extremely important aspects of the combat in a good Mass Effect title. In fact, the combat itself has only been about half of what has made the Mass Effect games great. Above everything else, Mass Effect is an RPG series. While this might not be quite as marketable as an all-out action title, to focus on the action at the expense of the RPG elements would be to rip out the heart of the beloved franchise.

9. DLC, DLC, DLC

BiowareBiowareThe Mass Effect games' downloadable content has ranged from incredible to underwhelming. A fantastic example of DLC is Mass Effect 2's Lair of the Shadow Broker, which provided an entertaining story, fascinating lore, and unique gameplay elements. However, too much DLC can often prove be a drain on the investment in the game, as well as your wallet. Sometimes, it's nice to be able to purchase a game, play through a lengthy, inclusive story, and be done with it. When DLC is being thrust into the player's face at every turn (even worse if it's immediately after release), then it can feel like an incomplete product. Gaming audiences are beginning to grow tired of the ever-increasing monetisation of downloadable content, and Mass Effect 4 might just outstay its welcome if it proves to be guilty of this. Of course, we'd be more than happy to pay up for a couple of larger DLC packs that feature their own self-contained stories, similar to Bioware's sizeable expansion packs of old.

8. Rushing To Release

BiowareBiowareThere's been a bit of controversy surrounding EA releases in recent years, regarding their habit of releasing games before they're 100% ready. In particular, Battlefield 4 is still riddled with bugs that continue to plague the online multiplayer. With a game as huge as a Mass Effect title, fans should be more than understanding that it needs a long time to develop properly. Branching storylines, well-written characters and (hopefully) beautiful graphics just aren't things that can be rushed. While releasing a not-quite-finished game earlier to fit into a specific release date in the year might mean bigger bucks in the short-term, Battlefield has shown that it could have a devastating impact on the franchise.

7. Linearity

BiowareBiowareOne of the most thrilling parts of the Mass Effect games so far, has been exploring the galaxy in the Normandy ship. Deciding on what missions to do when, or just where you want to mine for precious minerals, really helps to put across the feeling that the Mass Effect universe is a real, living one. The missions themselves have also been somewhat open-ended, with multiple choices that can impact how they turn out. Additionally, players are generally presented with a variety of gameplay decisions, such as the option between resolving conflicts with force or diplomacy. Mass Effect 3 managed to continue this facet of gameplay, although at times it felt like the most linear of the trilogy. Thanks to the urgency of the Reaper threat, it was harder to justify dawdling around random planets, and it constantly felt like you were being pushed forwards to the game's ending. While this focused narrative wasn't a bad thing in itself, we'd like to see more of the episodic nature of the first two games in Mass Effect 4.

6. Making It Too Alien

BiowareBiowareMass Effect 4 has been confirmed by Bioware to be a separate entity from the original trilogy, possibly taking place hundreds or thousands of years later. We're more than happy with that, and the franchise could certainly use a bit of a shake up. We'll be perfectly fine with unfamiliar new locations, along with brand new characters and races that weren't seen in the original games. However, it can go too far either way, and Bioware would be making a mistake if Mass Effect 4 becomes too alien compared to the games that preceded it. By that, we mean too few elements that connect the game with the trilogy that fans have played through for hundreds of hours. Sure, if Mass Effect 4 ends up taking place a hundred years or more after the third game, it's unlikely we'll see many of our favourite characters. In the unlikely event that we don't have a range of Asaris, Turians and Salarians to join us on our journey though, then Bioware might as well create a brand new IP.

5. A Rehash Of What Came Before

BiowareBiowareDon't get us wrong, we love the Mass Effect trilogy. The format of travelling the galaxy, picking up a multitude of side-quests and recruiting new characters is addictive fun. However, it's high time that the series switches up the formula a little. We don't need Mass Effect 4 to reinvent the wheel, but we won't be too excited if the game winds up being mechanically identical to the previous games, just with a new setting and story. A total rehash of what's already been proven to work might seem like the safe option for the developers to take, but it would likely hurt the longevity of the title. Bioware could take a leaf out of Deus Ex's book, by introducing a greater range of gameplay options when dealing with certain scenarios. For example, stealth elements have been briefly flirted with, but never expanded upon properly. If Mass Effect 4 can effectively rework the series' staples rather than just superfluously adjusting minor aspects, then it may well surpass all expectations.

4. Too Big A Focus On Multiplayer

BiowareBiowareWe won't deny that we ended up having a lot of fun with Mass Effect 3's online multiplayer coop mode. That said, the single-player has always been the main event, and we'd be saddened if development focus was placed on multiplayer at the campaign's expense. Despite being surprisingly decent, Mass Effect 3's wave-based coop was little more than a comparatively shallow distraction compared to the intricately woven experience offered by the campaign. It could also be a deceptively deep money pit, thanks to the paid-for weapon caches. In Mass Effect 4, it's a near certainty that there'll be some sort of multiplayer component. We can only hope that this won't impact too heavily on the single-player development (although, if we're honest, we wouldn't be too adverse to a co-op campaign).

3. No Impact From Previous Games

BiowareBiowareDespite Bioware confirming that Mass Effect 4 won't be a direct continuation of the original trilogy, they'd be crazy to not include references to the choices players made in previous games. After all, look at the furore over Mass Effect 3's restrictive ending. We don't need the choices to have overly deep consequences, but Shepard defeating the Reapers and saving the universe just isn't something that can be skirted around. All we're asking for is some recognition of our earlier game heroics. There doesn't even need to be a problem with importing data between different platforms or generations of console. As proven by the Playstation 3 version of Mass Effect 3, it's possible to handle all that stuff by a short 10-minute interactive animation, in which players can dictate the events that lead up to the current game.

2. Excessive Fan Service

BiowareBiowareWhile Mass Effect 4 will need to be linked to the narrative of the original trilogy in some way, we also don't want it to be completely tied down by repeated references. While a little fan service in this respect is a good thing, too much can be a game killer. It'd be cool to walk past an intergalactic academy that's teaching about the genophage that took place centuries before, possibly name dropping Mordin Solus' role in ending it. However, we're not sure that we could handle having a distant relative of Garrus fighting by our side, or Joker's great-great-grandson flying the ship. Although it'll have some ties to earlier games, Mass Effect 4 needs to forge a path of its own. Constant references, no matter how fan-pleasing they might be, will make for an ultimately shallower game.

1. Meaningless Player Choices

BiowareBiowareThe biggest criticism that Mass Effect 3 faced was its ending, which boiled three games' worth of stressful choices down to three dry-and-cut options that left fans bitter. It's testament to how much players value the choice aspect of the Mass Effect series, when the entire third game, which was otherwise pretty incredible, got completely tainted in their minds by its poor ending. Smoke and mirrors only go so far in disguising choices as anything but meaningless and superfluous, and players have become adept at recognising when their decisions are actually having any impact on the game at large. In particular, many of Mass Effect 1's choices were rendered ultimately pointless by the third game. For example, one of the more memorable decisions is whether to save or kill the Rachni Queen. In Mass Effect 3, if you chose to save her then she's taken by the Reapers to indoctrinate her young. If you killed her, then they'll just create an artificial queen that fulfils the exact same role. What was a key moral choice in the first game ultimately led to a purely superficial conclusion. As one of the key things that drew players to the series in the first place, Mass Effect 4 will need to see Bioware step their game up when it comes to meaningful player choices. They've got a lot to prove after Mass Effect 3's disastrous finale, but we're confident that the Bioware team has the potential to prove themselves as the kings of AAA RPG releases once again. What do you dread seeing in Mass Effect 4? Is there anything significant that you'd change from the original trilogy? Let us know in the comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Butler hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.