Mass Effect 4 Andromeda: 8 Big Risks Bioware Must Take

Star Wars managed to come back from the brink - now Mass Effect must do the same.

In order to make something really great, you have to take risks. It's a fact of creative art that some find uncomfortable, that you can't simply reason out a winning formula and apply it over and over again. God knows many have tried, especially in Hollywood. The Mass Effect series is an excellent example of this high-stakes game. The forthcoming sequel, Mass Effect: Andromeda, has not only the usual massive expectations attached to it, but the extra burden of smoothing out the dent Bioware's brand took with the backlash against the Mass Effect 3 ending. This game has to be extraordinary. Niggling doubts that seeded in the minds of fans about EA's acquisition of the company were allowed to fester and bloom like corpulent flowers. There were whispers of too much dumbing down, too much emphasis on getting those coveted 'new players' on-board rather than focusing on making sure the game had depth and soul. Mass Effect 3 was an imperfect cap to a brilliant series, but it was still a brilliant series. Still, I sense the goodwill for Bioware is about to run out. If it is to assert its dominance of the RPG market once again, it's got to do some really bold things. That said, the people holding the purse strings may not like the list that follows...

8. Commit Fully To Player Agency, Or Bin It Entirely

There have been so many reasons put forward as to why the ending of Mass Effect 3 wasn't well received, but ultimately it came down to player agency. Prior to the ending, the player had been told that everything they did mattered. The problem wasn't that the available endings were similar, but that each of them made the rest of the game's choices meaningless. Example: two races had been at war for ages. It's possible to end the war and sow the seeds of cohabitation, but then the ending comes along and destroys all of race B, with the line about how there could never be peace, because reasons. Some people found this unsatisfying. It was a mismatch of story-telling modes. There are plenty of RPGs that offer the player no choices, but provide an unbelievable experience (see The Last of Us). Mass Effect told its players it was doing one mode, then undermined it at the very end. It didn't work. Andromeda must choose a path. If it goes for the 'amazing story with no choices,' then fine. As long as it's breathtaking, no-one will care. But if it continues its pedigree and goes for 'choices with far-reaching consequences, and still an amazing story', then it must commit 100%. No snatching them away at the last moment to ensure a narrative coup de grace. It needs serious amounts of development time to work properly, which means serious amounts of money - and that means serious risk.

7. Feed In Some Of That Old-School RPG Arcane-ness

Most people agree that streamlining the inventory from ME1 to ME2's version was good design, but there's no need to throw out the Grunt with the tank-fluid. Back in the days of Baldur's Gate, wizards could choose from a spell list going into the hundreds. This was one class out of about 12. Granted, this was a game based on Dungeons and Dragons, but surely there's a middle ground. Now of course, this kind of massive choice has its disadvantages. It can be more like working an excel sheet than actually fun (see ME1's inventory), and it's expensive in development time. But it does give a huge advantage: meaningful customisation. One of the problems with modern Bioware RPGs is the lack of choice in skill development. If you have two characters in Dragon Age: Inquisition of a similar class, you have to actively work to make them different because the skill trees are relatively limited. Conventional wisdom is that gamers don't like to have to work to have fun, especially those new fans they're trying so hard to attract. This makes going back to the old ways a risk. But being able to make unique characters with diverse skills not only increases re-playability, but gives the player a sense they're progressing more in their own direction, not the game's. Mass Effect 4 Andromeda needs to find a balance between streamlined and two-dimensional - be the RPG fans have wanted it to be since day one, and match that with gameplay that feels natural and not needlessly action-heavy.

6. Give Us A Way More Diverse Paragon/Renegade Crew

Mass Effect works on the Paragon/Renegade dichotomy, yet doesn't really allow you to put together an all-Paragon or mostly Renegade crew. Instead, characters mostly occupy a centre-ground, with a couple of notable exceptions. The previous games cleverly played on this with the arguments that cropped up between crew-members to highlight differences, and in the context of putting together a ragtag band of heroes to save the galaxy, it made sense. But in Mass Effect 4, we're going to be pioneers in another galaxy. We need to go more extreme. If you had more characters available to take out in the field than we've ever seen before, you'd be able to make a more diverse set. It would force the player to make choices about who they'd want around and to be associated with. This isn't a new idea - this is pretty much how many isometric style RPGs worked. The risk here is that you're spending time on content that people could potentially never use. The reward is a hefty one, though: replayability. RPGs particularly suffer from a scarcity of replayable content because the main point is the story. Once it's done, a large section of gamers won't go back to experience the story again. If your playthrough is dependent on the characters you've recruited, and therefore the recruitment choices you've made, however, that's a very compelling reason to go back and replay. And that in turn could be a powerful selling point.

5. Make Vehicles Absolutely Integral

We've seen that the plan for Mass Effect 4 is to make it about exploration. We can safely assume that vehicles will play a large part, but we don't know if they'll be made with the same care and attention to detail as say, the character's stories. Why spend the money designing large amounts of vehicle gameplay when the last time that was done, the company got burned? Why not instead just have them as a thing that gets you from A to B and nothing more? Or better yet, why not just reskin the galaxy map mechanic? Wouldn't that be safer? Well yes, it would. But it would also hamstring the game. Take Red Dead Redemption, for example. It could have gone for Skyrim's version of horses i.e. things that certainly look the part, but handle like malfunctioning jet engines. But they didn't, because in a game where immersing yourself in the wild west is the whole point, horses are kind of a 'do or die' thing. If Bioware really wants to make an RPG about exploration, it's got to make the players feel like explorers, with a dedicated 'steed' in the Mako being reliable and worthwhile. The feeling you get in Red Dead when your horse skids to a halt at a cliff and you're looking over a vast canyon? The Mako needs to be able to exude the same barely contained exuberant flair, on alien worlds with endlessly beautiful vistas.

4. Do Not Compromise On Quality Over Quantity

Part of what has given Bioware the edge over Bethesda, at least in my opinion, is their commitment to making quality encounters over quantity. In Skyrim, you can do a billion different things, but you can only really do them a couple of ways. In Mass Effect, there are fewer things to do, but many more ways to do them. We can probably expect an open world for Mass Effect 4, it makes it much easier to immerse players for all of the reasons mentioned in the vehicles point. The problem with this, is that it becomes very tempting to pepper such a world with cookie-cutter quests. There's no point having an open world if it feels empty (Here's looking at you, Elite: Dangerous), so it's tempting to make very simple 'fetch this thing' or 'kill this dude' type quests to fill it with, rather than meaningful interactions. If Mass Effect 4 is going to be any good, it absolutely must not do this. Bioware has managed to keep its slate pretty clean with the Mass Effect series on this count so far, but if you look at their other works you can see it starting to creep in. Dragon Age - especially the second game - is far too transparent, with players even recognising reused pieces of dungeons for certain areas. And that, is simply not good enough.

3. Ship A Complete Game On The First Try

This shouldn't be a risk. This shouldn't even be a consideration. But unfortunately, it is - especially since EA's acquisition of Bioware. To be fair, Bioware has managed to avoid shipping an incomplete product so far. All of its games are largely fully functional, and any DLC seems fair and substantial. There haven't been any launch crises on the scale of say, Battlefield 4 or Empire: Total War. But when your competitors are releasing games much faster than you are, shareholders can get restless. It comes down to whether EA's might is being used to protect Mass Effect 4, or to corrupt it. On the one hand, it can remove the pressure attached to releasing it way too fast, because EA can absorb costs. On the other, EA are notorious got getting their money's worth in other ways, like less-than-ethical DLC that holds parts of the game for ransom. I don't believe that any company - yes, even EA - are indifferent to making great games. Great games make an absolute bomb: just look at Skyrim. But they're also incredibly risky, with dodgy tactics being ways of mitigating such risks. It makes sense... kinda. But they also erode the reputation of any company that employs them. If Mass Effect 4 goes the safe option of launch-day DLC, it may well be the beginning of the end for Bioware's reputation.

2. Spare Us The Fan Service

This one might be more controversial with fans of the series than with the makers, but for the sake of all that's holy, make sure Shepard stays dead. In a world where comic books are basically the new Western and Dr Who is the new ... um ... Dr Who, it's become the norm to pay far too much service to fans of a franchise. Excellent narrative must always come first. Take a leaf out of George RR Martin's book and do what best serves the story, not what best makes the diehards squee. Mass Effect 4 will be joining at a point where everything has gone in a pretty bold direction. The ending of Mass Effect 3 was not popular, but it was certainly pretty final. Given all the backlash, it's must be extremely tempting for Bioware to give the fans a little something to keep them sweet, a gesture that whispers 'please love us' through the monitor ever so softly. Maybe a little bit of Garrus showing up, or a hint of the Normandy saving you at a perilous moment? Hmm? You like that? Do so, and you lose any gravitas the story has built up. That chapter of the series has ended. Those characters' stories have finished. Leave them as lore and let them go.

1. Be As Bold As The Mass Effect 3 Ending Was

If we're talking about risks, we have to acknowledge that they don't always pay off by definition. It's easy to look at the Mass Effect 3 ending and say 'it's simple; don't do that'. But that's missing the point. It would be so easy for Bioware to back away from the cutting edge, but that's totally wrong. They need to put their cajones back in the fire. The willingness to be bold is what can push a game from being just entertaining to being a work of art. Making games that move people is inherently risky, and thankfully there's never going to be a dedicated formula for it. The Last of Us, a game with one of the most powerful endings of any game ever, wouldn't exist without boldness. That ending tested very poorly, but Naughty Dog did it anyway. They stuck by their guns, and it totally worked. Bioware did the same with Mass Effect 3 though, and it most certainly didn't. It can't be easy to pick yourself off the floor when you've taken a huge risk and lost. But if you want to make the next Mass Effect game, a game with a godlike heritage of excellence, that's exactly what you have to do. So pick yourself up, Bioware, and knock my two front teeth out. I might bleed, but I'll love you for it. What risks do you want to see Bioware take to deliver a perfect revival of Mass Effect after the third game's ending? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Nervously over-uses hyphens. Thinks semi-colons are artificial smarteners. Big fan of the full-stop.