NBA 2K18 Review: 5 Ups & 2 Downs
Probably the best basketball video game ever made.
NBA 2K18 was one of the most anticipated sports games of the year, and its release on Sept. 15th was welcomed with great fanfare. Rightfully so, because the game meets most of its lofty expectations, just as it has done year after year.
Creating such a successful franchise is a double-edged sword the longer it goes on, because fan demands sometimes rise to inexplicable levels. 2K's NBA games are so good and polished already, overall a new entry can only improve gradually each year, yet potentially minor elements may not seem enough for fans who mostly know what to expect.
NBA 2K18 is great, with changes visible at first sight, however, it's not without flaw - not to the point of stripping it of the title of the best sports game of the year, anyway. At least not until FIFA 18 comes out.
Every NBA 2K fan knows what to expect and the game delivers on its promise of being the best basketball video game simulation on the market. This year's version is more true to the experience of an authentic basketball game than ever, which should rightfully make it the best basketball video game in history.
Ups
5. Presentation Is Impeccable
The commentary is a big part of the game's success. Kevin Harlan and his co-commentators are not only accurately describing the events on the court - something that other games, like FIFA, sometimes lack - but they also joke around and chat in such a natural way.
It feels like they're calling an actual game of basketball, as David Aldridge's pre-game and Doris Burke's sideline reports also enhance the experience.
This year, the Pre-Game Show is even more polished and Shaq, Ernie and Kenny also feel more natural, successfully conveying the atmosphere of a real basketball game. Apart from that, there's the national anthem playing before games and more pre-game animations that make NBA 2K18 the closest thing to a real game of NBA basketball even before a match starts.
4. This Is NBA Basketball
This also applies to the situations after tip-off, as players act like they do in real-life games. Steph Curry raises his hand with his finger up when he's calling for the ball, LeBron James attempts a spectacular dunk when he's going to the basket, Russell Westbrook is unstoppable inside, etc.
If you have a superstar on your team, be prepared for him to perform their signature moves, whether it's an actual play or a celebration after a made basket.
There are more interviews, more NBA Wired-like moments involving the coaches and there's also more on-court sounds you should really enjoy. For example, when one of your players, say J.R. Smith, is taking the position to shoot from the corner, you may hear "J.R. from the wing" shouted by one of your players, which is the game's way of suggesting the best play for your team.
Give Smith the ball and he'll most likely make that shot. Brilliant.
3. Gameplay Is Even More Realistic
Shot contention is more important than ever, as it can impact the shot quality of the best players. This may anger you at the beginning, as you might expect some great shooters to score no matter what, but with time, you'll learn to score in different ways.
The shot meter is also more sensitive and requires more effort to master. The best way to do it is to approach each player individually and practice, instead of jumping into the deep end immediately after starting the game.
The defensive game is now more important and successful too; steals and blocks are more instinctive and organic, which makes scoring harder, and hence more authentic. More often than not a player with a high-rated three point show but an overall low rating won't become the focal point of your offense.
Likewise, a player that's better at rebounding is more likely to catch the ball than a better positioned, but inferior opponent standing next to him.
2. MyPLAYER Is So Much Fun...
NBA 2K18's demo didn't seem too promising, but once your player joins an actual NBA team, the whole experience is incredibly fun.
There are some ridiculous aspects of the mode, like the fact that DJ - your player's nickname, because he wanted to be, you guessed it, a DJ - lives in an apartment with a basketball court in it, or that he can walk to the basketball arena - which is clearly not taking into account property prices in major American cities. These aspects actually enhance the experience, precisely because the mode does not take itself so seriously as in the past.
You'll be mostly interacting with your agent, Bryan, who isn't all that keen on managing you at first, and Shammy T. Wells, a veteran, who takes you under his wing. The story is simple and, what is most important - it doesn't interfere with your career. As an un-drafted player you can make mistakes and learn at your own pace without the commentators praising you, despite your lacking - hopefully just at the beginning - basketball achievements.
The coolest moment however is when your player walks onto the court for the first time. It's not during a game but a shoot-around before. When taking to the court, the player puts his hands over his head, overwhelmed by the atmosphere, and only then starts to practice.
A small and subtle animation, but one that makes all the difference.
1. ...And A Large Part Of That Is My Neighborhood
In the MyPLAYER mode you'll be moving around My Neighborhood, which allows you to truly experience the life of an NBA player, also off the court, like during in-store appearances and interactions with your fans. You'll be allowed to practice basketball drills in the team arena, which was already available in the earlier modes, but not in such a physical, realistic way, involving walking into the arena or players practicing on other courts.
Apart from that, there's the ProAm Team Arena, where you can create your team and play with friends and the ProAm Walk-On Gym, where you can join a team. There's also The Playground, which is the 2K18 version of MyPark. There are basketball courts in which you can attempts dunks or score as many shots as possible during a limited time and other players can see your achievements on a big billboard.
Yes, there are other players running around the neighborhood, who can watch you play or practice.
Coming back to the gameplay options, there's also the Ante-Up High Stakes arena, where you can bet VC and earn twice as much or lose it, dependent on your performance during games. You can enhance your player's athleticism in the Gatorade Training Facility too, either by running drills or lifting weights. There's also tattoos, haircuts... you can even create your own t-shirts.
This mode will probably grow after the NBA season begins too, but what's in there is more than enough for now.
Downs...
2. MyGM Is A Rather Frustrating Experience
Truth be told, My GM was already frustrating, with role-players and glue guys asking for starter minutes or a trade, but this year prepare for it to be even harder.
While it's applaudable that the creators decided to try something new and enhance the experience, it's already frustrating that the future GM - you - played for the Dallas Mavericks and not any other team, maybe the one that he's about to join. You're also not allowed to start during the off-season, which is a bummer as well.
That's just the beginning, as the whole thing feels less like a simulation and more like a joke. While the dialogue is ridiculous - in a good way - and the idea of the team owner constantly interfering in your business feels like something that would occur on the Kings or the Knicks, there are also teams where the owner allows the GM to simply work.
Here you must be prepared to spend endless minutes in his office talking (or rather listening) about the players that you should buy, relocate to a different city, or about an extraordinarily talented son that'll take over the team in the future.
Yes, it's new, it's funny, and there's always MyLeague for all of those not interest in this mode, but this time MyGM doesn't have the same aura of realness. Hopefully it gets better at the end of the first season or during the next one.
1. A Lack Of Significant Progress
The addition of All-Time Teams and new Historic Teams is great, but the roster of said teams could use a little bit more work. For example, Byron Scott played for the Vancouver Grizzlies for one season, didn't even start a single game, yet somehow he's on their All-Time team.
Why? Also, why does the All-Time Oklahoma City Thunder have classic Sonics players, but doesn't have classic Sonics jerseys? The newly added Historic Teams are also problematic. The 2006-07 Warriors have only six (SIX!) original players. The 1996-97 Miami Heat lack Voshon Lenard and Isaac Austin, both very important to team success. The list goes on and on.
That's just the rosters, but the whole experience, while improved, is a step forward, not a leap. The game plays better, looks better, but the roster upgrade - NBA 2K18 has more players than any basketball video game in history - may be covering a bigger issue; the lack of significant progress.
Yes, NBA 2K18 is great, but it somewhat leaves the impression that it could actually be even better.