NBA 2K18 Vs. NBA Live 18 - Which Game Is Better?
You probably know who wins this one.
Comparing the two premiere basketball games of 2017 may seem unfair, as right now you probably already know which game is going to emerge triumphant. However, the victory is not unanimous, nor even as decisive as you might expect. When getting into the details, it occurs that the EA Sports product isn't anywhere near as bad as one might assume.
2K games have been dominant in regards to basketball video games in the past, and it seems things will stay that way at least for a few more years, but let's not bury NBA Live's chances at winning some categories just yet. In some cases the difference between the two isn't as one-sided as it sounds, which makes picking between the two pretty hard.
The decision as to whether NBA 2K18 or NBA Live 18 is a better fit for you is based on expectations, and these were also taken into account when determining the winner of several topics. When it comes to an overall winner, the fact that only one of the two can satisfy novices and hardcore basketball fans - as well or is used to determine outcomes of real-life games/trades - is reason enough to give that game the nod.
9. Progress Since The Last Instalment
The last NBA Live game, NBA Live 16, was released two years after the franchise took a hiatus following the very-flawed NBA Elite 11. This time EA Sports took a year off, regrouped and created a far superior product to the 2015 version.
NBA Live 18 feels, looks and plays better. Various aspects of gameplay, presentation or controls are so improved that there's practically no reason to revisit the previous version - this is not a step, but a leap, and what is most important, it's made in the right direction.
NBA 2K18 is also an upgrade over the previous edition, but the progress is devoted more to rosters and game modes. Graphically, the game is too similar to its predecessor to be considered a substantial improvement. The presentation and commentary are better, but they're just minor tweaks to an already established, polished product.
NBA 2K18 is a better game, but not a solid enough improvement over NBA 2K17 to be a must-buy for fans. The same can't be said of NBA Live 18, which is much better than the last entry in the franchise.
The Winner: NBA Live 18
8. Roster
NBA 2K18 has the biggest roster in basketball video game history. Not only does it have present-day and historic NBA teams, but this year it added all-time teams for every NBA franchise. Thanks to that, you can determine which team had the best players in league history.
Yes, the rosters of some historic teams are lazy, but almost all of the key players are there, which still makes playing said team really fun.
All of the teams have a plethora of jerseys to chose from, which also enhances the experience and allows to make the next game between the same teams at least slightly different, simply by dressing them in historic uniforms
NBA Live 18 hugely disappoints in that aspect, as every team has just two jerseys. Lack of an alternative one is really a huge letdown, especially since NBA 2K teams have jerseys seemingly for every occasion.
The roster is also rather limited and WNBA teams just don't make up for the relatively small number of available players. Sure, they're fun to play, but the fact that they're only available in quick games is enough to deem them a nice addition, rather than a fully developed game mode.
The Winner: NBA 2K18
7. Presentation
NBA Live 18 has a deal with ESPN, which makes the games look really professional before the tip-off. This also applies to The One, which features the hosts of the TV show First Take discussing your player's progress. Once the opening whistle blows, the game is no longer as impressive though.
The half-time and full-time menus look better, also thanks to a deal with ESPN, but on the whole, the game pales in comparison to NBA 2K18. For example, the commentary is just OK, because Mike Breen and Jeff Van Gundy stay silent during some stretches and don't provide much personal information about the players.
NBA 2K18 on the other hand has a pre-game studio, a true opening with player introductions, and in-game interviews about the games. But the best part of the experience is the commentary, which really adjusts itself to the on-court situations. The commentators are actually talking to each other, joking around or discussing their past, just like they would during an actual NBA game.
There's a mood of intimacy and camaraderie that no other sports game has reached yet.
The Winner: NBA 2K18
6. Graphics
NBA Live 18 needs to update to the Frostbite engine ASAP, seeing how it has worked wonders for the new FIFA. By sticking to Ignite, the creators force us to once again look at unnatural, superhero-like players who are just too light and too agile for their size.
Surprisingly, the engine works great during WNBA games as female athletes look more natural as they float on the court. Well, maybe apart from their hair.
NBA Live 18 player faces are mostly bad. The athletes themselves have this strange aura around them - an issue connected to the court lighting, which is rather distracting - though baskets and arenas look rather nice.
NBA 2K18 is also in need of an engine update, which thanks to NBA Live's return, may come sooner than later.
Still, even without it, the game looks much better. Players are more real, their movements more natural. Faces and physical frames are especially noteworthy and some screenshots could fool the keenest eye as to whether a still is real or in-game.
The Winner: NBA 2K18
5. MyCareer Vs. The One - Story & Options
Both story modes involve once great but now flawed players. In NBA 2K18, you're trying to refocus on basketball after a failed musical career, while in NBA Live 18 you're eager to make a comeback after a seemingly career-ending injury. So far so good, and at the beginning of the story the EA Sports game is actually slightly better.
However, later on, NBA 2K18 really crushes its opponent. There are a plethora of possibilities for you to explore, including going to the barber shop (although paying for hairstyles with Virtual Currency clearly sucks), the gym or a team workout. My Neighborhood is really fun to explore and spend time in, which contributes to the immersive qualities of the game mode itself.
NBA Live 18 offers just regular and streetball games, which are fun in their own right, but become boring when played for hours. NBA 2K18 allows for a more diverse, complex experience, and the story itself is not so bad, as you gradually get to know the players on the team and arena staff during this simple and coherent narrative.
The Winner: NBA 2K18
4. MyCareer Vs. The One - Pure Gameplay
Because it's so individual-player oriented and easy to master, NBA Live 18 actually gets the nod over NBA 2K18 in regards to the basketball games themselves.
The problem with both games is that your teammates aren't especially mobile and engage in some serious action only after you call a play. That's why - since it's up to you to decide what's happening on the court - thanks to its lack of realism, NBA Live is somewhat better, if only for the reason that your teammates actually react to your instructions.
NBA Live 18 allows you to make an immediate impact on the court, because even when the easy-to-master shot fails, you can always drive into the lane, with upgrades coming quicker since they don't require as much Virtual Currency. You are rewarded for your on-court contributions, and because in NBA Live you make a bigger impact from the start, you can become better faster, which results in having more fun.
In NBA 2K18, if you're not acquiring VC through playing in different modes or paying for it with real money, you're going to be struggling with your player for some time. Ain't nobody got time for that.
The Winner: NBA Live 18
3. MyGM Vs. Franchise
The new version of MyGM, story-driven and over the top, is a rather frustrating experience, but not to the point of being worse than the Franchise.
Quite frankly, the NBA Live 18 team management game mode is awful, as making trades, signing free agents and drafting players are so oversimplified that there's simply no fun in modifying your roster.
The salary cap seems to exist only to frustrate, as being under it doesn't allow a team to acquire any players, which isn't quite how it works. That's why, even though NBA 2K18's MyGM mode is now worse than in the previous editions, it forces you to deal with an idiotic owner and his manipulative son, it's still light years ahead of the Franchise.
MyGM allows you to scout players, hire coaches and trainers, or sign players to two-way contracts! Irritating story aside, the 2K version of NBA team management is very real and still extremely addictive.
The Winner: NBA 2K18
2. Realism
NBA 2K18 is a true basketball simulator, which takes into account so many factors to make the game as close to real as possible. In many respects it's hard to believe that such a game actually exists, and this applies to modes and gameplay as well.
The EA Sports game is more arcadey, which can at times be a positive, since thanks to that it's actually more accessible and allows for immediate enjoyment, while 2K requires at least some mastering. In spurts, NBA Live really looks authentic, but only in spurts, as the game is simply too OTT 'athletic' and floaty to resemble real-life basketball.
Basketball is a team sport, and NBA Live is more concerned with individualism. This might be a plus when you're supposed to play as one player on the court, but from a team perspective NBA 2K18 is a lot better. The creators simply understand how basketball works, making team-play the most important aspect of the gameplay.
In NBA 2K18 there's no place for hero-ball, which is the main feature of NBA Live 18.
The Winner: NBA 2K18
1. Online Community
The fact that NBA Live 18 is targeted at a specific audience, which can be characterized more as sports fans in general than strictly basketball fans, also pertains to the people you'll encounter online. This hugely impacts the fun that's a key part of the gameplay associated with The One.
During online games you must be prepared to fight for every touch with "me first!" players who only care about progressing their players and not winning games. That means you'll see a lot of ill-advised, contested shots for three that too often result in terrible misses or holding onto the ball until the clock runs out instead of passing to a better-positioned teammate.
NBA 2K18 gamers on the other hand, seem to know what basketball is all about.
Not to over-generalise, but you're more likely to encounter savvy, win-oriented and organized players here than during pick-up games in NBA Live 18.
This means that while the individual gameplay in 2K might not be as fun during MyCareer, you'll definitely have more of it on the Playground than in Rucker Park, Venice Beach or any other Live court.
The Winner: NBA 2K18