NBA 2K19 Review: 6 Ups & 2 Downs

Familiar flaws return, but 2K's 20th anniversary delivers.

2K Sports

With the 2018-19 NBA season not tipping off until 16 October, basketball junkies are left to get their hoops fix through the digital realm, and to the surprise of absolutely nobody familiar with the series, NBA 2K19 is another triumph for developers Visual Concepts.

NBA 2K, like most sporting franchises, delivers quiet, subtle improvements over outright revolution every year. The latest entry in the series brings sharper A.I., a number of notable offensive and defensive adjustments, and the new Takeover system to the table, along with the usual graphical tweaks and stat upgrades. Is it enough to justify paying full price for? That's in the eye of the beholder, but it's hard to imagine the series' core audience being disappointed with what 2K19 brings to the table.

Though EA's NBA Live 19 made a significant leap in quality this year, 2K remains the market leader. Its consistency, elite presentation, and variety are unmatched. Now, on the series' 20th anniversary, Visual Concepts have delivered 2K's most authentic entry yet, though a couple of notable bugbears prevent a perfect score.

NBA 2K19 won't surprise you, but it's hard to argue with gameplay this good...


Downs...

2. MyTeam

Nba 2K19 MyTeam
2K Sports

No more than an attempt at cashing in on the giant financial success of EA's various Ultimate Team modes, MyTeam remains the shallowest and least rewarding way to play NBA 2K19, despite a handful of new bells and whistles.

SuperMax and Pack and Playoffs are gone, Triple Threat allows you to test a three-man team against every current NBA side's top trio, while gem levels and the packs themselves have been switched up, but the concept is largely the same. Packs of random cards are acquired using Virtual Currency, and players attempt to assemble an all-time NBA dream team either by grinding through MyTeam itself or splashing out on microtransactions. It's a gamble, and largely unsatisfying, particularly as the sense of progression is so minuscule without diving into your own wallet.

While MyTeam's core concept is solid, 2K are yet to deliver on a level that matches the hype. It's biggest pull remains the minute chance you'll unearth an absurd 98-rated Michael Jordan card among the Ron Bakers and Zaza Pachulias. If you're willing to sacrifice the colossal amount of time of money it takes to do that, then fair enough, but MyTeam still feels like a cash-grab...


1. Microtransactions

Nba 2K19 Microtransactions
2K Sports

Though the microtransactions debate has been done to death, they remain the biggest blot on NBA 2K's otherwise immaculate package, reducing this excellent franchise to a cheap, tacky mobile game in the name of profit.

The allure of Virtual Currency is strong. Buying coins out of pocket is still the most efficient way to work through MyTeam and MyCareer, because in-game progression remains frustratingly slow. Less so in Career mode, where the developers have upped the gold handed out per game, making developing your player significantly easier than it was in 2K18. Still, both remain a grind.

2K Sports' Senior Producer Rob Jones recently called microtransactions "an unfortunate reality of modern gaming," so no matter how vociferously we complain, they aren't going anyway. Regardless, this inherently greedy practice needs to be called out. The pay-to-progress mechanic is aggressive and invasive, and in nudging players towards them with the oft-glacial in-game progression rates, Jones and his cohorts are only taking advantage of consumers who've already forked out £40-50 for the base game.

VC transactions are voluntary, but the developers know what they're doing. Their inclusion is both predatory and repugnant.


Ups...

6. A More Strategic Approach To Offence

Nba 2k19
2K Sports

As a series, NBA 2K has typically veered away from arcadey stylings, opting for a more realistic basketball simulation instead. Its gameplay isn't complex to the point of inaccessibility, but mastering its more advanced mechanics takes time, and this year's incarnation favours a more strategic approach.

This is largely down to a handful of changes on the offensive end. For the most park, 2K19 rewards greater care and attention when in possession, encouraging players to turn themselves into mini floor generals. Tighter defences mean points are harder to come by, and it pays to take your time on offence, run plays, and learn what works, rather than exploiting the same handful of moves. On top of this, the retooled shot meter allows great precision and accuracy all-round, though timing shots on simple lay-ups takes some getting used to.

Slashing isn't as overpowered as it was last year, and 2K18 players will be forced to slow their approach. On the flipside, 2K19's post game probably needs nerfed, as draining buckets from such situations is all too easy, leaving the Javale Magees of the world looking like Hakeem Olajuwon.

These welcome tweaks aren't an overhaul, but they represent a significant step forward from 2K18, particularly for those favouring a more methodical approach.


5. Better Defence

Nba 2k19
2K Sports

Defensively, 2K19 feels a lot tighter than last year's offering, making several notable advances across the board.

Stealing sits atop the list of improvements. 2K18 often felt like a coin flip, with even the most immaculately timed steals drawing fouls whenever the game felt like it. Even when you did tap the ball, it'd regularly go flying halfway across the court (as it did in 2K17), rendering the whole process useless. 2K19 not only makes it easier to read the situation, but come away with the rock whenever an opponent gets sloppy in possession.

The same goes for shot blocking, which feels a lot less clumsy this time around. The Intense D function isn't the one-cure-fits-all solution it was a year ago, either, so lazy players can no longer get away with incessantly squeezing LT or L2 to stifle an attack. It's still effective when used in appropriate situations, but spamming it doesn't work anymore.

All these changes leave 2K19's defence feeling tighter than ever, resulting in the most balanced gameplay flow the series has seen in years. The offensive skew is gone.


4. Presentation

NBA 2K19
2K Games

First-class presentation has been one of NBA 2K's hallmarks for years, and the latest edition is no different. Yes, there are a handful of graphical glitches and hiccups, but these can be patched out, and for the most part, 2K19 is a beautiful sports game that looks and sounds sharper than ever.

The menus are slick and intuitive, the Travis Scott-curated contemporary hip-hop soundtrack feels both fresh and current, player models are second to none, and the commentary is the best in any sporting series. What's most impressive, however, is how 2K19 captures the experience of a live basketball broadcast. Little touches like Ernie Johnson, Shaq, and Kenny Smith's pre-game banter to the crowd's buzz and the sound of Jordans squeaking across hardwood create the impeccable "game night" atmosphere fans expect from the series, and it's incredibly immersive.

NBA 2K remains the standard-bearer in this regard. No other sporting franchise (from FIFA to WWE 2K) can match its level of gloss and sheen, and with the TV style too close to real life to ever go stale, it's hard to see the developers ever veering from this immaculate format.


3. Content Is King

NBA 2K19 MyTeam
2K Games

The sheer volume of content in NBA 2K19 is, once again, astounding, with the developers once again delivering a vast, varied package that should cater to every single corner of their fanbase.

Want a rich, rewarding, RPG-like single-player experience? There's MyCareer. How about gambling your precious Virtual Currency for cards? Have a bash on MyTeam. Feel like pitting the classic '95-'96 Chicago Bulls team against today's Golden State Warriors? No problem. Sharpening your skills while competing in a series of fun pick-up games? Hit the Blacktop. Are you more attracted to running your own organisation, rather than competing, directly, against the best of the best on-court? Head to MyGM.

The list goes on, and while MyCareer's new story is the only major change to these modes, their variety means NBA 2K remains the most diverse sports series around. MyGM still feels a little flimsy, though...


2. MyCareer

NBA 2K19 The Prelude
2K Games

MyCareer remains NBA 2K's biggest single-player selling point, and with this year's 'The Way Back' eschewing much of the cheesy dialogue and cringe-worthy characters that plagued the past few editions, 2K19's offering is strong, though it brings no real innovations to the table.

This year's tale starts with your MyPlayer avatar, 'A.I.', getting overlooked in the NBA draft. From there, he has no choice but to head to Shanghai, China, to hone his game in the CBA, and force his way back onto American scouts' radars. Though the story itself offers nothing that'll surprise 2K loyalists, this different pathway to NBA glory is a fresh take on the old format, and soon, players will find themselves carving out the kind of careers LaVar Ball likely thought his Lithuanian vanity project would yield for LaMelo and LiAngelo.

Microtransactions remain an issue, but they're at least tempered by a faster progression system. This year's Neighbourhood is a lot more enjoyable than last year's sparse collection of functions, too. Navigating it is no longer the chore it became after a few hours in 2K18, it's crammed with mini-games, and you no longer have to fork out VC for a haircut (shoutouts to the developers' self-awareness on that one).

If you buy this series for MyCareer, you won't be disappointed with 2K19. Marvel's Anthony Mackie even shows up for a chinwag along the way...


1. Takeover

NBA 2K19 Takeover
2K Games

Though unlikely to sell any additional copies of the game on its own, the new Takeover system is a welcome feature that does exactly what you expect, allowing "hot" players to run riot with a series of temporary attribute boosts after strong periods of play.

Each player has their own individual meter. They fill it by making positive on-court contributions, then go nuts, imposing their will on the game in ways that vary greatly depending on their play style.

Triggering Steph Curry's Takeover will see the Warriors' sharpshooter drain buckets from far beyond the three-point line, but won't suddenly transform him into a shot-blocking rim protector. Similarly, wont fix Bin Simmons' wonky shot, but it will take his freakish athleticism and playmaking to the next level, creating new space and opportunities for himself and his teammates.

Takeover succeeded by mirroring real-life hot streaks, but it goes the other way too. String several mistakes together and your character will end up with a dreaded snowflake by his name, turning every pass into a turnover, and shot into a brick. Thus, the system's risks are as pronounced as its potential rewards.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.