Netflix's The Witcher: Why Jaskier Should Replace Triss In The Love Triangle
Coins shouldn't be all he's tossing to his Witcher...
Joey Batey’s Jaskier was easily the best part of the first season of Netflix's Witcher adaptation. He was wonderfully charming, his songs, while inaccurate (that’s Geralt’s tutting you can hear on the wind), were torturously catchy and, on top of all that, he worked as a perfect companion to Henry Cavill’s moody, monosyllabic monster slayer.
He was so perfect a companion in fact, that many a fan have suggested he and the Witcher should become more than the friends they are usually portrayed as. This is a suggestion that I personally agree with; but I think Netflix should go even further than that and have the bard replace Triss Merigold in this version of the franchise’s central love triangle. I know, I know – it’s a massive change. And yet, with all the massive changes from the books that the Netflix version has already made, what’s one more?
Witcher purists have already been angered by the first season’s diversions so, really, what’s the harm in a little fanservice for those actually on-board with the series? Still not convinced? Well, let me try and remedy that…
5. It Makes Triss & Ciri's Sibling-Esque Relationship Less Weird
In Blood of the Elves, the book which will presumably be the primary inspiration for season two of the show, Triss comes to Kaer Morhen to help Ciri control her magical abilities while she trains with Geralt and the other Witchers. Over this period of time, Ciri and Triss develop a close, sister-like relationship, all the while Triss sleeps with Geralt, who has become Ciri's father figure at this stage.
I think we can all agree that this is rather odd. Even Triss' fellow sorceress, Philippa Eilhart, comments on it in The Witcher 3, straight up saying to Geralt that "there are times where I doubt you three realize how it looks" while the two of them explore some elven ruins near the end of the game.
Therefore, removing Triss from the love triangle would eliminate this weirdness, and make the bond she has with Ciri nothing but wholesome. Furthermore, there are two other relationships that would make more sense as a result of such a change.
The first would be Triss' and Yennefer's friendship as, in the books, the two are supposedly best friends - and yet Triss goes off and sleeps with the man Yennefer loves, which seems somewhat out of character given how nice Triss generally is to people.
The second would be her brief fling with Eilhart, which acts as a betrayal to both Geralt and Yennefer, as Eilhart is the founder of the Lodge of Sorceresses, an Illuminati esque group that seeks to protect magical interests by influencing the Continent's politics. A key part of these machinations is Ciri, so the Lodge is constantly trying to capture her and marry her off to a member of the Kovir royal family - hence why Triss' collusion with them is a betrayal to Ciri's adoptive parents.
Really, all this should be enough justification to remove Triss from the love triangle even if she isn't being replaced by Jaskier.
4. It Actually Doesn't Affect The Story All That Much
In the books, Triss has three main roles. The first is the aforementioned training of Ciri at Kaer Morhen, then there's her membership to the Lodge of Sorceresses and, finally, there's her romance with Geralt.
As the leaked synopsis for season two reads like this:
Convinced Yennefer’s life was lost at the Battle of Sodden, Geralt of Rivia brings Princess Cirilla to the safest place he knows, his childhood home of Kaer Morhen. While the Continent’s kings, elves, humans and demons strive for supremacy outside its walls, he must protect the girl from something far more dangerous: the mysterious power she possesses inside.
It is fairly logical for Geralt to turn to Triss Merigold for help with Ciri, regardless of them not being romantically entangled (given her help with Foltest's striga). Contacting Triss might not even be an option for Geralt if he believes Yennefer to be dead, seeing as Triss fought at the Battle of Sodden too, so this aspect of her character might have already hit the cutting room floor anyway.
As for her joining the Lodge of Sorceresses - that has practically nothing to do with her relationship with Geralt as, again, he can still trust her without them having slept with each other.
In essence, the biggest 'story' changes replacing Triss in the love triangle would have is that there would be no sex scenes between her and Geralt and the show wouldn't really fit into the canon established in the games. Yet, considering how the former of these problems can be remedied by a quick internet search and the latter would only be an issue for those who love the games and the Netflix series but refuse to read the books, these problems are solely superficial.
3. He Has More Chemistry With Geralt Than Triss Does
Admittedly, Triss had far less screen time with Geralt than Jaskier did in season one and yet, even with that caveat, it is blindingly obvious that no amount of shared screen presence would account for the difference in chemistry between Geralt and the bard and him and the sorceress.
Jaskier really brought out the best in Geralt - giving the quote unquote emotionless Witcher someone to constantly bounce off, even if those reactions tended to just be some variant on mild irritation.
With Triss, Geralt seemed to not even manage a slightly more angry or cheerful grunt than his usual output, reducing what is usually one of the franchise's most important characters to a glorified quest giver that the Witcher has zero connection to beyond employment. Sure, there would be the opportunity to develop that connection in future seasons, but why put all that effort in when there is already a character perfectly suited to being Geralt's secondary romantic partner that has far more chemistry with him?
Basically, as already suggested in this list, this version of Triss would work so much better as Geralt's ally than lover, just as this version of Jaskier would work so much better in the inverse.
I mean, Geralt and Jaskier already bicker like a married couple, so why not make it official? The romantic pairing of a quiet, moody character with one that has a loud and bubbly personality is already such a tried and tested formula anyhow, while the romantic pairing of two friends generally only works if the audience actually believes those characters to be at least friends before they become something more.
Jaskier ticks the box of contrasting Geralt's personality and, even if Geralt himself refuses to admit as such, is clearly on friendly terms with the Witcher. Triss, however, seems like little more than a resource to Geralt right now.
2. He Already Has A Rivalry With Yennefer
A key part of the original Witcher love triangle is the rivalry (AKA Yennefer bullying Triss) that develops between Triss and Yennefer as a result of their respective relationships with Geralt. From the few brief interactions between Yennefer and Jaskier we got see in season one, it seems that this rivalry/bullying is already an aspect of those characters.
Now, the likelihood is that the less than friendly dialogue between the two was merely there for the purpose of illustrating that Yennefer finds Jaskier annoying, but it could so easily be expanded upon in future seasons to instead be a more personal dislike of two strong personalities fighting over the same lover. Adding this layer would really make Yennefer's rescue of Jaskier from the mage Rience interesting too, if the Geralt/Jaskier romance had been established by then, of course.
For a slight tangent from the main point of this entry, another positive of swapping out Triss for Jaskier in the love triangle would be the distinctions in their escapades with Geralt. Think about it, bards and sorceresses are very different people, much more so than, oh I don't know - two sorceresses?
Given both characters' histories, these escapades would almost always mix work and pleasure - Yennefer's place in the Continent's high politics meaning balls and banquets that allow for some diplomacy before the couple find a quiet spot while Jaskier's need for inspiration would see him following Geralt as he kills monsters with some ballad-material coming afterwards. It's a distinction that allows for some efficient storytelling and a bit of variety at the same time, as well as providing more talking points for Yennefer and Jaskier's arguments.
In summary, Jaskier has already been established as a great rival to Yennefer and would continue to be one.
1. It Would Mean More Jaskier
Logically, if a character is one of the two central love interests of the protagonist, they are likely to show up a lot.
So, given the lack of chemistry between Geralt and Triss and how Jaskier is the best part of the show, him showing up more can only be a positive, and if that has to happen by Jaskier becoming one of Geralt's romantic interests, who am I to stand in the way of progress?
Added comic relief doesn't always equate to added quality, but in the case of The Witcher's dark, oppressive world, a little bit more would not go amiss, especially if it were taking the place of a fairly band character. Furthermore, despite Netflix's desperate attempts to brand The Witcher as its answer to Game of Thrones (it even being set to include actors from that show like Kristofer Hivju) Netflix has simultaneously been desperate in its attempts to differentiate its gritty, adult-oriented fantasy show from the HBO goliath. One way they could achieve this latter aim is by lightening the tone and including more Jaskier.
There's also the most important matter of them all: song. With more Jaskier, the most famous musician and poet on the Continent, there will inevitably be more of his work to enjoy. Just think of the possibilities - there will be more ballads, of course, but the romance with Geralt opens the gates for a wider variety of songs about the Witcher and friends (personally, I think a Yennefer diss track would be a great place to start) that could surpass even Jaskier's breakout hit, Toss A Coin To Your Witcher.
Okay, perhaps that last bit was a little far-fetched, but the rest seems like a flawless plan to me, and all the other fans of The Witcher franchise too, I'm sure.