PES 2016 vs FIFA 16: 8 Key Aspects Previewed And Compared

The two footballing giants get ready to collide again...

Back in the sixth console generation, it felt like football couldn't get any sweeter. The Pro Evolution Soccer series had reached its zenith with its sixth PS2 outing, offering a football simulation that captured all the emotions of the beautiful game. Since then, graphics have progressed, engines have advanced, and, erm, diving has been introduced, but Pro Evo never quite recaptured its PS2 form. The series did a Micheal Owen - It peaked too soon and has been plagued by injury ever since, only occasionally showing glimpses of its true potential. Yet Pro Evo's form in the 2015 season gives us hope that the series is on the brink of greatness again. Then there is FIFA. FIFA is Wayne Rooney. Several years ago, it felt like the successor to the footie game throne, and has since gone on to claim it. However, there is an air of stagnation about it and a feeling that it could be something more. FIFA may be brilliant, but it rested on its laurels last season rather than marched towards legendary status. Now, with the 2016 season approaching, we know most of the details about the two football giants' latest outings. Pro Evo was on the verge of regaining the title last season. Has its time now come? Or will some inspired new features in FIFA - of which there are plenty - help it retain the crown? Let's find out...

8. Graphics

Let's get the superficial but most divisive stuff out of the way first, and say that when it comes to player likenesses, there really isn't much between Pro Evo and FIFA. There, now fanboys of both games are unhappy. However, FIFA 15 did a better job of adapting to the current console generation in the graphics department. While likenesses were good in Pro Evo 2015, the overall aesthetic was washed-out and bleak - like a drizzly League One match in mid-February. FIFA, meanwhile, felt vibrant and crisp like a Sunday afternoon clash on Sky Sports HD. From what we've seen so far, PES 2016 looks like it's finally got the generational update it needed. Players look more alive, less robotic, and sweatier and shinier than before. Looking at the pic of Neymar above, perhaps PES has gone a bit Madame Tussaud's on us, making players look a bit too polished, but it's certainly a big improvement. Graphically, FIFA had things down pretty well last season and looks like it's refining rather than overhauling the looks for its 2016 outing. We can see more detailed textures on player faces, and EA Sports has said that players will now be more to scale, giving players like Peter Crouch the in-game advantages that are their birthright! Based on what we've seen so far, FIFA will do just enough to get the edge here. But looks aren't everything, right?

7. Animations

Neither FIFA nor PES has fully mastered player animations yet, both with flaws in different areas (don't you just sometimes wish they combined into one ultimate football mega-game?). The increasing pace of FIFA in recent years has made everything feel a bit jittery, while Pro Evo - although smoother - made players look too stiff when going to ground, tussling for the ball, and so on. Goalies in PES 2015, meanwhile, seemed to be stuck in the previous console generation. Both FIFA 16 and PES 2016 have added a whole bunch of new player animations, while more offering any massive overhauls to the overall physics. In PES 2016, for example, we saw a right-footed left winger more willing to use the outside of his boot to spin in a cross, if his positioning and balance was right for it. Among FIFA 16's new animations we'll see more mid/waist-height tackling, so players will no longer just stand back in amazement when an opponent controls the ball on their knee or their chest, but will be able to get stuck in and try to get it off them.

6. On-field Presentation

Certain aspects of FIFA and PES' presentation are a foregone conclusion. FIFA 16 will have the wonderful licensing, decent soundtrack, and navigable menu system, PES 2016 won't. We know these things, so let's focus on what will be new in terms of on-the-pitch presentation. In PES 2016 we will see the inclusion of those little things we love to hate about the beautiful game. Players will complain to the ref when fouls don't get given, and get frustrated with their team-mates over missed opportunities. We're not sure how much player personalities come into this mechanic, but we'd love PES to capture the fact that Cristiano Ronaldo is a whining prima donna, as well as arguably the world's greatest player. FIFA has had things pretty much nailed in the presentation department for a long time. But, as if to show off just how up-to-date with the times it is, we'll now see vanishing spray! Yes, there will now be a little cut-scene during crucial free kicks where the ref will spray that famous line in front of defensive walls. We're yet to find out whether the defending player will be able to sneakily inch the wall forward over the line in these situations...

5. Tactics

If you could get your head around the awkward menus of PES 2015 and actually find your way to the tactics screen, then there was a deep, rewarding system that paid more dividends than FIFA's relatively facile - but more accessible - offering. PES 2016 has simplified the tactics menus, giving you control over team and player strategies directly from the line-up menu, rather than having to scroll through confusing sub-menus. We've not seen too much on the tactics front in FIFA 16 yet, with much of the footage focusing on what happens on the pitch. FIFA tended to keep things simple in this area in the past, while letting you quickly make strategic shifts like the the infamous "Park the Bus" tactic. We're hoping to see more options to save custom formations though.

4. Defending

For some years now, PES has been scraping past FIFA in the tackling department, while still being riddled with more defensive flaws than the Brazilian national team. In FIFA, defenders' efforts always seeming lethargic in comparison to the more direct, rugged efforts of PES players (even though FIFA on the whole feels more physical). FIFA 2016 makes progress here in big ways. You can now tap 'X' to get up quicker from a slide tackle, carrying the momentum of your slide into getting back on your feet. The same applies for standing tackles, with players demonstrating much better powers of recovery and ability to have a second crack. Sliding blocks - popular with PES players for years - are also coming to the fore in FIFA, so pressing the tackle button at the right moment will have your midfielder reach out to intercept a pass, or slide across the goal in a last-ditch attempt to block a shot.
For its part, PES 2016 is introducing shoulder-barging - a feature that Konami should've added years ago instead of diving. This is another move to address the criticism of previous PES games that attackers would effectively be 'glued' to the ball, and will add some much-needed physicality to the game. Speaking of which, can Konami please make the AI play a bit dirtier so I actually get the chance to practice my free kicks? Both games will feature more interceptions by midfielders - which will prevent many frustrated yells of "Why did he just let the ball right past him!?!?". Tapping 'X' at the right moment in Pro Evo 2016 will now have a player reach out or even lunge for a ball to intercept it.

3. Attacking

At the basest level, the thing that football fans want most is goals. Sure, you can admire gritty defending and the genius of tiki-taka football, but just as in boxing you need the KO, in football you need goals - and nice ones. PES and FIFA have been delivering this in abundance for years, and the latest installments look set to build on this. In FIFA 16, you'll now be able to hold down R1 to make the player in possession move independently of the ball. EA has compared this mechanic to a car clutch - disconnecting the engine while you coast, turn, and plan your next move. For example, you can let the ball roll slightly ahead of you, then catch up to it, feint, and regain control of it, shifting the pace of play. FIFA will also include a new hard-pass mechanic, designed for driving the ball through those fine defensive gaps, or smashing it across the goal in the hope that a striker gets a touch on it. Naturally, such passes are harder for the recipient to take control of, but open up a welcome new layer of dynamism and attacking possibilities. Whipped crosses into space were the order of the day during matches in both PES 2016 and FIFA 16. Directing your crosses correctly yields better chances of swinging in speedy, defence-splitting balls for your attackers to get on the end of. In PES 2016, Konami appears to have cut down on that odd anti-gravitational 'float' when delivering high balls.

2. Shooting

Player balance will play a much bigger role in all aspects of attacking, and nowhere will you feel the effects of it more than in those crucial goalscoring opportunities. In the FIFA 16, we've already seen players as great as Carlos Tevez scuffing and slicing shots due to being off-balance. In both games, the way a player shoots will be more contextual, depending on their position relative to the goal. For me, PES has always had the edge in satisfying mid-to-long-range shooting, offering a real feeling of 'oomph' that FIFA's more airy long shots lacked. The perfect shot in PES 2016 will now be punctuated with a rumble in your gamepad, which is a small but nice little reward for your efforts. We're yet to see evidence that the R2 placed shot - so overpowered in PES 2015 - will be balanced out a bit in PES 2016.

1. Goalkeepers

Goalie - the most important player on the pitch? Not in the video game world, he isn't. Neither FIFA nor PES have quite managed to capture the authoritative and crucial role of the goalkeeper to a football team, despite years of trying. In PES 2015, keepers felt robotic, with a limited number of save animations meaning that they were often unable to respond well to rebounds, or would knock away seemingly easy mid-height shots then unnecessarily go to ground as an attacker gleefully pounced on the ball. We do know that Konami is introducing more personality to each 'keeper. Given how well PES 2015captured player individuality, we're optimistic PES 2016 will be capable of finally bringing keepers to life. However, only after playing more of PES 2016 will we know whether goalies will respond better to those awkward, scrambling moments that football throws up. FIFA 15 suffered from its fair share of keeping calamities too, and EA Sports is bolstering the arsenal of animations available to keepers. No more lob-spamming either, as FIFA 16 keepers have finally evolved to handle those cheeky little dinks. Which will it be for you then? Will PES do enough to nick it, or will FIFA prove that it's learned its lessons after a lax last season and get the title?

Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, Researcher of strange things. I'm a writer-editor hybrid whose writings on video games, technology and movies can be found across the internet. I've even ventured into the realm of current affairs on occasion but, unable to face reality, have retreated into expatiating on things on screens instead.