Pokemon Sword & Shield: Ranking Every Gym Leader
The fabled 18 didn’t arrive, but the ones we got were still pretty great.
Gym Leaders have always been a core part of the Pokémon canon, dating back to the very first two we ever met: Brock & Misty. Sun & Moon toyed with the formula last time around with middling results, but Sword & Shield went back to traditions.
The gym trials add a little bit of extra character, and did a good job at making the world of Galar feel like a living, breathing place. The fact the gym leaders seemed like much more active part of the story helped them stand out this time too.
There’s also the version exclusive leaders joining into the equation, as well as some in game events which changed the makeup of the rosters.
The rankings aren’t based on strength, as that seems unnecessarily harsh on the early game gym leaders. Instead, their design, their teams, their gym itself and their trial plus their involvement within the story all factor into things. Obviously their general personality and likability or coolness matter an awful lot too.
Sword & Shield released under a bit of a cloud, with the most controversial run up to a Pokémon game ever. It seems to have weathered that storm though, coming safely through the other side.
12. Gordie
Gordie is just such a pain. Being a Sword exclusive doesn’t work against him in principle, but when he’s meh, it feels like a waste of an exclusive. In this mother/son match up of Gordie and Melony, Sword players definitely got the short end of the stick.
Melony seems a better fit for Circhester anyway, but that’s just for starters. While Melony has a sweet yet stern motherly vibe, Gordie’s personality seems to just be ‘he’s cocky’, and nothing else. When Raihan and Leon both do that schtick so much better than Gordie, he’s between a rock and a hard place.
His design is an uninspired collection of things that made you cool in the ‘90s, while his backwards battle stance just makes zero sense. Exclusives should be a chance to run wild with ideas, and really try and pull a player towards a version. Cynically, the ideal scenario is that players can’t choose, and instead buy both.
No one is going to buy Sword for Gordie.
His gym challenge at least feels like an homage to previous tricky dungeons, but that too feels better suited to Melony’s ice. He just can’t catch a break.
11. Marnie
Look, Marnie is a fantastic character. Her punk aesthetic is inch perfect for her cheeky cockney personality, and while Sword & Shield throws a fair few rivals at you, she stands out as the best. As a gym leader though, she’s a whole lotta nope.
For one thing, you don’t even get to battle her in any gym leader capacity. You can challenge her through the Champions Cup, but it’s just not the same. The decision to have Piers feature heavily in the post game in his sister’s stead aids his stock, but only diminishes hers.
Then there’s the fact she becomes gym leader after all. Piers seems pretty great at it, holding his own without Dynamaxing and all, while Marnie seems to have her own thing going on. Filling Piers’ shoes just feels so unnecessary.
It might have seemed sweet at least, but the fact that it totally steps on Bede’s toes ruins that. Marnie’s a silver medalist in her own narrative. She’s a great character, but she shouldn’t even be here to begin with.
It says more about Gordie than it does Marnie that she avoids last place here.
10. Opal
Opal is only the second Fairy type gym leader we’ve had, and while she’s certainly not boring, a lot of what she’s about just falls flat. Leaving aside Gordie, and considering Marnie is a great character away from her gym leader role, Opal coming this low is a testament to how good the leaders are here.
Opal’s slightly mean personality and obsession with pink do just about enough to characterise her, but like her home town of Ballonlea, it feels hollow. There just needed to be something extra to push her over the edge.
As it stands, she probably won’t live all that long in the memory. It’s a shame too, because there was a clear attempt at something different with Opal.
Choosing Bede as her successor gives her a foothold in the story, but also erodes her own importance.
Her gym trial of questions resulting in stat changes was a great idea, but again, half baked. Some questions require Pokémon knowledge, others are specific to Opal, but don’t feel like they belong. It’s nowhere near as fun as Blaine’s quiz at Cinnibar, and Opal just feels like unfulfilled potential.
9. Kabu
Kabu just is.
He completes the original starter type trio with Nessa & Milo, but he’s by far the least vibrant. He has an old, world weary, stoic sensei vibe to him, and while that works for him personally, it leaves him overshadowed by the other leaders.
Sometimes you need more of a down to earth character to help ground the whole world you’re building. It’s fair enough that Game Freak took that decision with Kabu for the good of Galar, but leaves him stranded in an individual ranking.
His gym trial is inventive, but it’s also short and doesn’t have the grand scale of some others. It suits his personality at least, but Pokémon’s colourful world isn’t exactly built for the strong and silent type. Well, except Red, of course.
His trial sees you wander in three mini patches of grass around him, involving yourself in a double battle with a fellow trainer against a wild Pokémon. It’s a fresh twist on the trainer battles, with points awarded for landing the final blow or catching the Pokémon yourself, but it feels like a Fire gym could offer a lot more.
At least you can catch a Litwick.
8. Melony
The second of four exclusives on the list now, Melony is the sixth gym leader in Shield in place of Gordie. She suits the town Circhester a lot better, has a far less grating personality and has an interesting trail. She does, however, only have a fleeting role in the story; likely a symptom of her position as an exclusive.
Melony is a sweet yet stern mother, and together with her fuller figure, big hair and thick clothes, makes for a very cuddly gym leader. She’s Gordie’s mother, in fact, and while she’s sweet in a fleeting visit, her overbearing nature might go some way to explaining him.
In the icy town of Circhester, she feels like a warm mug of hot chocolate. Spare a thought for poor Gordie though, drinking only hot chocolate for his entire life.
Pokémon’s fandom spins off in all directions, and Melony will undoubtedly inspire a certain genre of artwork. Still, it feels wrong to hold that against her in a world which already contains Goodra, Gardevoir and Hatterene.
Her trial of falling ice floors is the closest we get to a real dungeon, and it’s not her fault the rest of the game is dumbed down.
7. Milo
Milo does a lot of things right, so seventh place might seem a bit harsh. However, while he does things right, there’s not too much he really does great. He’s a solid gym leader to set the scene for Galar, but he doesn’t stand out all that much once you’ve met the rest.
His gym trial of rolling Wooloos into a pen is a nice fun intro to the mode, and despite Wooloo being a Normal type, feels a good choice for a Grass gym. It’s far less elaborate than most of the rest though (certainly the rest above him), and so Milo finds himself middle of the pack.
You spend a decent amount of time with him at the start, but there’s not really a story there at all. Instead, he’s more of an introduction to the gym mechanics, how Dynamaxing works in practise, and the general mission ahead of you, if the opening ceremony hadn’t made that abundantly clear.
It makes sense for Milo’s character, as a sweet but unassuming farmer, that he’s lost in the shuffle of the more eccentric characters. There’s definitely enough here for him to become some peoples’ favourite, but all things considered there’s still a few ahead of him.
6. Allister
Allister is the third of four version exclusive gym leaders, and represents Shield’s second exclusive here alongside Melony. He’s a better character than her, but just falls short of being the number one exclusive leader.
What he does have though, that both Gordie and to a certain extent Melony lacked, is a clear aesthetic. He’s the epitome of the Ghost type gym he leads, and his freaky mask gives him a distinctive edge. His personality, nervous and skittish, give him another hook too.
He’s just very well built however you look at it. It’s no surprise Game Freak pushed him forward for the trailers. He instantly fits the bill as a version seller, and there’ll definitely be some players who opted for Shield because of his gothic, moody style.
Being so withdrawn, he does struggle to get a foothold in the story, but then it’s better for them to have committed to his personality than twist him away from that to full story gaps.
His special card obtained in post game is one of the only two (with Nessa) which feels like it’s actual special. Not as good as Ball Guy’s, but still.
5. Bea
Bea’s quality somewhat makes up for Gordie, and she’s every bit the version seller that Allister is, just in a different way. Bea joins the ranks of the the lesser spotted Fighting type gym leaders, and is a great addition to the mix.
The feisty fighter has far more to say about things than her opposite number Allister, and is probably the most animated leader of the bunch. Her body language makes up for the lack of voice acting, fully selling her personality as a raging ball of fury.
Being an exclusive - and so very different from Allister - means she’s not used as much as she maybe should be in the story, and it’s that which keeps the medal places at arms length.
Much like Melony suiting Circhester, it’s clear that Bea is a much better fit for her own town of Stow-On-Side. Ground typing feels ideal, but considering her gritty aesthetic, Fighting feels almost as good.
Her gym trial is identical to Allister, and the whirly tea cups meets pinball game is great, but doesn’t exactly fit either. It doesn’t count in either’s favour over each other then, but both of them get a little boost from it.
4. Raihan
Raihan is the final gym leader of the game, and comes with the tough (though occasionally vulnerable) Dragon typing. He’s a fairly constant presence throughout the game, and has a great design with some neat little touches. While a stripped back trial didn’t work for Opal or Kabu, it definitely does for Raihan.
The one thing really keeping Raihan off the top though is the quote unquote unbeatable Champion of Galar, Leon. The two of them are just too similar, and it has to hurt to Raihan’s rankings. There’s clearly an attempt to make the narrative alive outside of yourself, with the pair as rivals, but it could be more nuanced.
With so many characters, there’s always going to be some cross over, but there could be more between them. Especially as they’re positioned as the number one and number two trainers of the region.
Raihan is image conscious and likes selfies. Take away the Leon comparisons and that’s all there is.
One of the most compelling parts of the Messi v Ronaldo debate is how different they are off the pitch. Raihan and Leon though are both Ronaldo.
3. Nessa
Nessa was one of the first gym leaders revealed to us, and remains one of Sword & Shield’s best. We meet her early on, and after Milo has set the table, Nessa is the first gym leader with any semblance of a story.
We learn of her friendship with Sonia, and meet her by the lighthouse in Hulbury, giving her more depth outside of her specific role as gym leader. Through her links with Sonia, we see her pop up at various times through the story too, cementing her as a key part of Galar.
What really lands her so high though is her gym challenge. The inventive waterfall pipe maze is one of the few where the game actually attempts to stretch you. It might have committed to that further without the colouring coding maybe, but it’s still a nifty little mini game.
There’s just a few other flourishes to Nessa’s character which eke her ahead of Raihan and Bea. She has the most animated face, defining her character more, and she’s one of the few gym leaders whose reward uniform isn’t a standard football kit knock off.
Her special card in post game is actually special too.
2. Bede
Sound off in the comments if you think it’s hypocritical to have Bede so high yet Marnie so low, but allow me to get my justification in first. Bede isn’t a particularly likeable character, but all the flak Hop gets for being too nice a rival seems to ignore Bede’s existence.
He’s a Oliver Twist homage, and while he’s not perfect, it certainly suits Galar’s British sensibilities. His narrative, of trying to impress Rose and ultimately being discarded without thought, has far more substance than Pokémon usually offers in main titles.
His pseudo adoption by Opal to become the Fairy gym leader feels earned and realistic, plus before Marnie stole his idea, offered a sense of uniqueness too.
Like Marnie, you don’t strictly get the option to battle him as gym leader, but he challenges you in the initial tournament with some weight of narrative behind him, as well as during the Swordward and Shielbert post game storyline.
He has a considerable evolution throughout the game, and deserves to end it as a fully fledged gym leader. An unusual one, no doubt, but when you look at the best of them, that seems to be a necessity of the job.
1. Piers
Piers sneaks in out of nowhere and takes the crown. He’s not even there for the opening gym ceremony, as the game keeps him under wraps until the very last moment. There are a couple of things against him, which we’ll get to soon, but they’re massively outweighed by the positives anyway.
He doesn’t really have a gym trial at all, but the whole narrative around Team Yell shutting down the town and Marnie sneaking you in makes up for that. No Dynamaxing also means there’s a bit less drama, but then your mileage may vary on whether that works for Piers or against him.
What’s undeniably in his favour is that we finally have a Dark type gym leader. His adherence to Team Yell’s aesthetic means he doesn’t wring every drop of potential out of Dark, but he’s got a solid team nonetheless. His design is the most over the top of all the characters, but the commitment to the bit is well received and makes Piers stand out even more.
He comes into the game very late, but from the time you meet him at the seventh gym, he’s constantly involved until the post game is done and dusted.