Prey: 5 Reasons Why The Story Ultimately Fails
It's good, not great.
Releasing to rather positive reviews, Prey is garnering comparisons to Half-Life and Bioshock. These are really big shoes to fill, and amazingly, the gameplay seems to validate such comparisons.
The same cannot be said about the plot however, which, although ambitious, ultimately fails to deliver on its promise.
Spoilers follow.
In the year 2032, siblings Alex and Morgan Yu are aboard space station Talos I, investigating an alien life-form named the Typhon, which has invaded Earth. As the Typhon don't use any language, their objective is to implement aliens with empathy, so that they can understand humans and hopefully leave our planet in peace.
The problem is that the Typhon are not willing to cooperate, and the player has to kill a lot of their kind in order to reach his goal, which is either save or kill everybody on the station.
The game tackles some interesting topics like enhancement or consciousness, but doesn't do it too convincingly. Granted, the ending explains some of these events, but it does not make up for rather disappointing script.
That is, if we want to put the game in the same category as the aforementioned first-person shooters that conveyed a deeper message.
If not, Prey is still a really good game, although not as deep as it intends to be...
5. Operator?
Your guide through this memory hole-created maze is January, an Operator, who serves as a backup to Morgan's memory, which she/he (dependent on the sex you chose for your character) created during his three years at Talos I space base.
This already creates the first issue - since the Operator is a backup, why doesn't it inform Morgan about everything immediately, but instead makes him walk around the base looking for clues?
Obviously because the game would be much shorter, and not as mysterious.
January is one Operator that you can listen to, the other is December, a presumably older backup, who shows you the way to Alex's escape pod. The third "voice in your head" is your older brother himself, who provides a different narration of the events than January.
The objective, as we learn at the end, is to teach you empathy, but how is the opposition between January and Alex supposed to do that? It's not a choice between good and evil, saving lives or saving the planet from containment, but rather between trusting yourself or trusting your brother.
This is more about reality and memory, than empathy.
4. Sibling Bond
At the beginning of the game you learn that Alex is actually tricking you and you're supposed to not trust your older brother, who brought you here.
At the same time your character, Morgan, although not expressing any confusion, is at times listening to January and at times doing what Alex says, dependent on... what, exactly?
The problem with Morgan is that she/he has no personality. We don't learn about his doubts or fears, so we can't really know what she/he thinks. We only learn about her/him through recollections and logs.
Since the whole point of the "experiment" is to check if the Typhon are capable of empathy, a couple of recollections of childhood or forming a truce against parents aren't really that much convincing in presenting the bond between Morgan and Alex as particularly strong.
3. We Can Remember It For You Wholesale
You wake up on Monday, 15th of March 2032, put on your TranStar uniform and head for tests. When something goes wrong during said tests, you blackout and return to the exact same date, which makes you instantly suspicious.
From January you learn that Alex has tricked you, while from Alex you learn that you've tricked yourself. The issue that should be explored here is memory and consciousness, not empathy. In a sense, the plot would be better served with a Ghost in the Shell-like (referring to the anime, not the movie, obviously) exploration of what it means to be human.
You presumably start off as a human and enhance to become an alien, but at the end, learn that it's the other way round - you're an alien with human-like characteristics.
This were the accent should fall in the end, not on your ability to feel for others.
2. The Crew
Most of the crew are rather poorly written, one-dimensional characters.
Two that stand out are commander Walther Dahl and "imposter cook" Will Mitchell. The first one is ordered to kill you by your father, but he makes double sure when hearing out the order, which proves that he is a moral character, who still values duty above everything.
The second speaks with a Russian accent, which makes his name seem all the more strange. You're supposed to suspect him of something. One of your objectives is to kill him. In a sense this is a valid request, as he killed other members of the crew, yet the same can be said of Dahl, who you spare.
Yes, he is a pilot and can be useful, but still, he has also caused harm and killed crew members. If the lesson here is empathy, why does the simulation involve making the distinction between life and death based solely on one's usability, not faults?
1. The Dangers Of Enhancement
A game like that should serve as a basis for such discussion, but really, apart from memory loss, are there any issues regarding leveling through Neuromods?
Presumably, Morgan changed because of constant memory resets. However, he still communicates with Alex and listens to him. To that end, is Alex not entitled to his own opinion, nor allowed to change it with time?
Blaming it on memory loss is rather, well, lazy.
January in turn claims that it is not the “first” version of Morgan that is the truest, but the final one, as it is closer to fulfilling its purpose, whatever it may be. This is a valid and interesting point that is sadly not expanded upon in the game. There should be more consequences of enhancement than a couple of flashbacks, which become understandable only once you reach the end.
This topic has been tackled better by Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare, which, although inferior and bland as a video game, actually 'got' what enhanced humanity was all about.