Xbox One Vs. PS4: Should You Even Bother?

xboxone vs ps4 Originally this article was going to have the cynical title of "PS4 Vs. Xbox One: Who Deserves Your Money," but since every man and his dog has already been hooting their opinion on the matter, with a greater or lesser degree of bias, I wanted to look into whether it's actually worth the time and money to get either at this stage. So, whilst some articles are aimed at swaying you in one direction or the other, this one exists to have you questioning whether the rush is even worth it. I€™m a long way from the first to offer this sentiment, of course, which says a lot in its own right. On the other hand, if you do want to know which console to buy, I probably can't help you there anyway. Psychologically, chances are that you already know which one you really desire and you're just after some affirmation that you have made the right decision so you can rationalise doling out all that cash. Well, that€™s okay: the correct choice is the one you want. Excellent, well done - now scurry off to give Sonrosoft your money. If you are still unsure, flip a coin, maybe. Or you could perhaps just read on and see what happens...

5. Specs

xbox-one-vs-ps4 Okay, it€™s easy to list the hardware and how powerful it is, you can find this info plastered over the web like dirty posters in a teenage lad€™s bedroom. That is to say, bloody everywhere. Do that by numbers alone and the PS4 wins. But when you try and actually explain what this all means in terms of performance it gets a little more complicated. More numbers equals better performance, right? Not quite, as the law of diminishing returns kicks in. It usually means more potential, but the raw numbers ignore a very significant factor which is the system architecture. Of the previous generation, the Xbox 360 architecture was very easy to work with and the PS3 architecture proved little short of a Gordian Knot for games developers. PS3 seem to have learnt their lesson on this one and have channelled a lot into making it easier. But we come back to the question at hand: what difference does this actually make? Herein lies the problem. We don€™t know yet. Off the bat, it would appear that given the PS4 is running the next gen games in a higher definition. But then do you remember the Xbox 360 followed up thereafter with the Xbox 360 Elite. Remember, it€™s Microsoft - with the Xbox One on the table in front of them, they are likely saying "we have the technology€ but let€™s wait a while." It couldn€™t possibly be a highly effective marketing strategy to get people to buy a console twice€ could it? Cutting to the chase, then, compare this generation€™s starting line-up to the latest releases graphically. The way developers optimise and use the platform€™s muscle develops over time, so just because one has an early jump doesn€™t mean the race is won yet. Really the only way to actually notice the difference is by doing squinty-eyed side by side screenshot comparisons. Do you really want to be one of those people?

4. Media

Ps4 Revealed Gif Xbox One wins here, no two ways about it. The whole point of the console is as an all in one entertainment system, because Microsoft want to rule your living room. That€™s okay in theory - apparently you can run your TV and various other media services seamlessly and easily through the Xbox One and it works very well (with perhaps the exception of the fact it expects you to use the voice commands). Personally, I€™m saving "shouting commands at electronic devices" until I am a deranged old man, when I can get away with it and have my eccentricities treated kindly. The PS4 will have some multimedia functionality, but as general rule is sticking to being a games console and that€™s not such a bad thing. I don€™t need to feed all my devices through one box - or that is to say, I already do: it€™s my TV. It could be argued that the Xbox One streamlines this, giving it all to you on one menu and saving you the hassle of flicking through the various inputs. What€™s that, Xbox One? You have saved me the effort of pushing a single button using a reliable, effective and easy interface, and instead I can come out of one device and into another by speaking nicely to you? I don€™t do speaking nicely. My remote doesn€™t need to be told. I just give it a poke and it does what I want. In fairness, I am not doing justice to the Xbone€™s media capabilities: it does seem to have a lot to offer, but it all seems like the solution to a problem that doesn€™t exist. As my friends tell me, just because I can get naked when we go to the pub, it doesn€™t mean that I should, in much the same way that just because you can plug everything into the Xbox One, it doesn€™t mean it's a good idea. So this is another one to watch: the service may end up proving itself invaluable, but at the moment it doesn€™t strike me as useful. Then again, the exact same thing was said about Digital Rights Management. Everyone got caught up in the raging torrent of controversy over the Xbox One€™s prohibitive level of Digital Rights Management: always online, check in system and Big Brother camera. They rapidly back-pedalled following the backlash. Watch closely though, and I would bet the value of an Xbox One that this grand plan has not been dropped. See if it doesn€™t come creeping back at some point in the future. A friend of mine who was working on the Xbone at Microsoft at the time argued in favour of this ability to stop the loan and sale of second hand games because this meant higher profits for the games industry which would mean they could drop the retail prices of games and then pointed to Steam as an example of where this model has worked. If you haven€™t heard of Steam, it is a digital distributor that doesn€™t have to deal with the costs of packaging, storage, transport infrastructure, shop premises or staff for those premises so that they can offer you games at pretty much the same cost as every physical distributor anyway. Yeah, nice one mate. He pre-empted this point by arguing how great the Steam sales are. This is true, they are - but a sale event is not to be relied upon as a way of purchasing games. It's an opportunistic thing, not something to be waited on in case they put that game that I want on sale. On the PS4 side of things, they have taken a carefree, almost flippant approach, saying to the gamer that you are free to do what you want with it. They won a lot of support here, and so they should, but it is a very rare thing to see a profit driven organisation turn their nose up at a way of increasing their margins, so might they be trying to have their cake and eat it? Think about it, once they have the support and you€™ve bought the console, that€™s it - you€™re already invested. While this is purely conjecture, it once again wouldn€™t surprise me if the insidious creep of owning a licence rather than a game and the restraints that go with it begun to rear their ugly head before too long.

3. Line Up

A lot of attention has been given to both consoles€™ release line-ups. With a few exclusives on either side of the fence, there isn€™t anything that sets one ahead of the other apart from personal preference. There has never been a clearer example of why to give it a little time. Both contenders have a decidedly lackluster line-up. With nothing outstanding that can€™t be acquired on the current console generation anyway, it makes it hard to truly justify dropping over a third of a grand on a machine that will only give privileged access to a couple of competent exclusives. For the PS4, there are Knack and Killzone: Shadow Fall. Going by the consensus of reviews, Knack is novel and mildly entertaining, but frustrating and lacking polish, whilst Killzone is incredibly pretty and usually good at what it does, but nevertheless an unremarkably typical FPS. On the Xbox One, there is a wider selection giving the options of Dead Rising 3, Ryse: Son of Rome, The Fighter Within, Forza Motorsport and - most highly anticipated of all - Powerstar Golf. It is harder to judge this lineup as they have yet to be released. It certainly appears to be a bit more solid and trying to push the envelope a bit more, but as before this is possibly something you will be using for the next five years, give or take, so wait it out a little and judge it on what is to come, not what is in the now. So put your feet up, wait it out and pick up a better deal with a more informed choice once you are done with Dark Souls II, which will be releasing on PS3 and Xbox 360 in March.

2. Indie Developers

Playstation Loves Developers This isn€™t something that particularly needs a lot of discussion. Sony is throwing open the doors to independent developers. There are a lot of great things coming out of such studios, but most people have already got an amazing indie platform. I€™m typing on it right now. Chances are you are looking at this article through one. PCs rule the roost when it comes to indie games, and - to a slightly lesser degree -phones and tablets are another strong market. Don€™t get me wrong: I think it€™s great they have made it easier and this is one that will bear fruit given time, apparently already showing some strong titles from the indie market. But you never know, it may not spark a revolution or Microsoft could catch up in this regard.

1. Reliability

My day job is as an engineer, so maybe I find myself more annoyed by certain things, but I can€™t be alone when it bugged the hell out of me to find more than one reviewer who has expressed a sentiment that it seems unfair to judge the consoles on reliability, before they have worked out the hardware kinks and patched the software up a bit. Now let me qualify this and say if it is a pre-release console, then that's fair enough. But the second the product hits the shelves it should have a high degree of integrity. It is not unreasonable for someone who buys a product to, well, you know... expect it to work. If it is considered acceptable for the release of a console to be a harbinger of frustration and gremlin riddled equipment then something has gone seriously, seriously wrong. Development is the point at which a console should be tested. If it€™s riddled with flaws, then it has been released prematurely. I€™m not saying in my line of work everything is delivered to an acceptable standard all the time. Sadly, it isn€™t, but you won€™t find me trying to claim that it is okay when it clearly isn't. At the time of writing, the PS4 has been released and the NDAs have been lifted for Xbox One. The PS4 has a case of the gremlins, with some suffering a blue line of death-like syndrome and some port problems. Not necessarily as bad as I expected, but still not acceptable. We won€™t be able to make an informed judgement call until the Xbox One is in the hands of the masses, but going on prior experience and a healthy dose of cynicism, I suspect it will have problems. Possibly some fairly severe ones, too.. If it doesn€™t, I promise I will go to my mate who worked on it, buy him a pint, and tell him what a fine job everyone involved has clearly done. So yet another reason why maybe you should hang fire and be assured of getting something fit for purpose, perhaps? Click "next" for the conclusion...

Conclusion

xboxone vs ps4 I have to begin any conclusion I draw by openly stating that I have had absolutely no hands on time with either console. However, I have spent my research period digging out facts and then wrapping my own conjecture and opinions around them, rather than merely regurgitating the conjecture and opinion of others. By now, my opinion should be pretty clear. I don€™t suggest abandoning the idea of getting a console. I can assure you I will be buying one, but what I do recommend is waiting six months, maybe even a year. That way the technology, features and line-up will have matured enough that that you could make a properly-informed decision. I€™m going to go out on a limb here as well and say both will likely have a case of the gremlins. Let them chase those away first. Plus, you know they are only going to be releasing an updated version as soon as sales drop off anyway, the idea being to lure the naysayers, who have yet to succumb, and trick the gullible into buying the same product again. So I offer you the following: deferred satisfaction! No? Anyone? To the reader, please feel free to correct me on which is the better console in the comment section below, and I apologise for all the opinions I got wrong (and even any factual details I may have mistaken).

Contributor

An engineer by profession. When not working, Tony can generally found rattling around the country on a motorbike in severe need of a clean, with a sword strapped to the side of his rucksack, for genuinely legitimate reasons. Tony's last words are going to be "hey guys, watch this, this is going to be amazing," or "look at what I can do", so he's getting his midlife crisis out of the way good and early.