PS4 Vs Xbox One: Which Should You Buy In 2015?

The playing field has changed considerably since 2013.

It's that time again, the Xmas cheer is slowly bubbling up amidst a swathe of tinsel-covered window displays and festive TV adverts setting the scene - but there's only one question on the lips of every prospective gamer waiting to make the leap between console generations. "Do I get a PS4, or an Xbox One?" The last two years have done about as much to help you answer that as the Kinect did for motion controlled gaming, but now the consoles have received a huge amount of patches on both sides - Microsoft's Xbox One in particular being a totally different beast now than at launch, prompting anyone with cash in hand to wonder where it would be best placed. Fanboys, steady your pitchforks. Let's do this.

10. The Best Exclusives Already Available

First, the most obvious one; the games themselves. Chances are, the biggest titles you're looking forward to playing - your Witchers, Star Wars Battlefronts, Batman: Arkham Knights and Fallout 4s of the world - are multi-platform, and thanks to a parity in actual console horsepower (more on that later), it puts the onus on whichever franchises Sony and Microsoft can call their own. As it stands, the PS4 can offer you things like the brutally-hard Bloodborne, horror gem Until Dawn, PS3 upscales of legendary titles like the Uncharted trilogy and arcady phenomenon Rocket League. The PS4's indie game is pretty strong too. Supergiant Games' Transistor was many peoples' game of 2014, Super Meat Boy provides suitably engrossing platforming chops, and top-down strategy gem Armello props it all up nicely. In contrast, the Xbox One has the mighty Halo 5 which, for anyone who was a fan of Bungie's initial run before Destiny, will seal the deal right away. That sits quite nicely alongside Rise of the Tomb Raider, as although that is coming to PS4 at some point in 2016, it certainly doesn't hurt to have one of the best games on modern hardware as even a timed exclusive. Next to that we've got Sunset Overdrive - a great little fun title that challenges you to find a TV big enough to do its thunderous explosions justice, Dead Rising 3, and the absolutely spectacular platformer Ori & the Blind Forest. Point goes to... Xbox One It's a tough one, but mainly the PS4 has kept its lead thanks to stellar third party support, whereas when you knuckle down and compare the roster of exclusives, the Xbox One edges it considerably, the one-two knockout blow of Halo and Tomb Raider providing something the PS4 just can't live up to.

9. Dashboard Interface Look And Feel

I've been holding off doing this article, mainly because the Xbox One finally got a much-needed upgrade in November, 2015, one that aimed to completely remove any semblance of the voice-commanding Kinect ever existing. Thankfully, it's mostly worked. The 'New Xbox One Experience' has been quite the hit with fans, reminding all of us why we used to love the Xbox branding and general presentation of everything so much. Games and multimedia options are presented in both horizontal and vertical scrolling fashion, putting your game library directly below where you log in, and having the Store or other apps off to the right.
It's a neat idea, but still comes across a just that little bit too unnecessarily cluttered when put next to the PS4. Sony opted to keep their slick XMB from the PS3 days, doubling it into two horizontal feeds that have a row of apps and games on one, and your personal info, friends lists, settings etc. on the other. It's fast, responsive and you can instantly become familiar with where everything is. Point goes to... PS4 Microsoft just can't seem to resist forcing the Windows 10 tiled interface down everyone's throats, resulting in too many promotional squares and undesired screen real estate, ultimately making for a less pleasant experience by comparison.

8. Controllers

I'll get onto the Elite controller in a moment, as instead, it's far fairer to compare what comes in the box when you first pick up either system. For the PS4, that means the hulking DualShock 4, a fantastic piece of kit that saw Sony finally iterate on the ancient original, taking the core components of that design and bulking it up with the form factor of the 360's incredibly successful 'Controller S'. The DS4 is brilliant, but it does fall down considerably on things like the completely pointless Lightbar, and most cripplingly, the battery life. Where Microsoft not only manage to give you a bundled in controller that'll last you a good few days (alongside an optional Play n' Charge Kit to replace the battery pack altogether), Sony's offering will need charging after almost every single game session. Seriously, it's just that bad, and remains the only thing Sony drastically need to amend.
Over on Xbox turf, Microsoft played it safe. Their innovation didn't come with developer tinker-toys like touch pads and optional lights, but in dedicated rumble pack placement (so the pad can vibrate in specific areas and to specific amounts), streamlining the general size of the thing to remove the bulky battery pack, heightening the Home button and ensuring the analogue rubber grips could coat an F1 car and survive in one piece.
As for the Elite controller, right now it exists in the cultural psyche as a weirdly optional, overpriced extra. Custom button-mapping is a nice addition (that the PS4 already had), but can you honestly say you would benefit from mapping buttons to paddles you'd flick with your index fingers on the back of the pad? It's a strangely PC gamer-minded extra that ultimately doesn't offer anything meaningful to justify its asking price. Point goes to... PS4 They're both very robust and solid pieces of kit, both feeling very satisfying to hold for extended lengths of time, but the PS4 edges it from forward-thinking features providing developers with options in-game, vibration functions not feeling too intense, and one of its newer buttons being linked to a feature certain consumers will care about a great deal...

7. Sharing And Social Media Functionality

Perhaps Microsoft just didn't see these features as big selling points - and who can blame them? When the public got eyes on pitches like "Now you can stream yourself around the world!" most of us just went "Yeah okay... but where are the games?!" Over time though, we started taking pictures, we started sharing videos and we started uploading them en masse to social networks and Youtube, hence the rise in successful streamers and footage of all your favourite games out there right now. The PS4 handles everything through a dedicated 'Share' button that you can choose to be a one-press screengrab of whatever's on screen, or hold to edit a video and upload. By comparison, the Xbox's older interface had these functions accessible once you'd opened the Snap menu, which on the new dash, still requires you to pull up the overlay and hit 'Take a Screenshot'. Outside of this, once you have something you want to upload, the PS4 has an impressive rundown of outlets including Facebook, Twitter, Youtube and more, whilst the Xbox One sadly only has Twitter, OneDrive, and Microsoft's own dedicated server hub. Point goes to... PS4 You can tell Sony really wanted the social media/sharing aspect of the console to be a big selling point, and the ease of having a dedicated button for such functionality makes it all work far quicker and more seamlessly than relying on a menu to pop up, and then choosing the option from there. Even if you get used to thinking "Right, double-tap, then hit Y", it's just not as responsive as the PS4. Don't worry though, Xbox fans, there's something pretty awesome I'll get to in a couple of points time, that the PS4 can't even come close to replicating.

6. Backwards Compatibility

Forget all the detractors who ponder just how ridiculous it is that we're celebrating a function the last generation of consoles had at launch, because this sort of thing really does matter. It matters when it comes to preserving your game collection, and although the industry seems intent on selling shinier versions of what's already right in front of you, Microsoft and the Xbox One took a major leap towards customer satisfaction by just giving you the functionality for free. By emulating a 360 console inside the Xbox One (it's just that powerful, apparently), the XO will let you run a constantly-expanding list of approved titles, adding to the experience by letting you pull off newer functions like taking screenshots and making videos. On the other hand, Sony's response is to push forward with PlayStation Now, their 'Netflix for games' streaming service that - although providing a huge chunk of games for a monthly fee, to stream as and when you like - is just too laggy and overpriced to actually recommend. Point goes to... Xbox One It's a no-brainer here. You've got one company who have adamantly stated they'll not be 'figuring out' or patching in access to your older library, all the while intent on pushing remasters and streaming services to play them if you want, whilst the other are happy for you to enjoy as many games you own on the new system as possible, albeit it publisher-permitting. Good on you Microsoft. We knew you had it in you.

5. Looking To The Future - 2016's Lineup

If 2015 was sharpening the swords and loading the cannons, 2016 and beyond is set to be an all-out Minas Tirith-style battle for your wallet. On the one side you've got Sony, their champion fighters being Horizon: Zero Dawn, The Last Guardian, Detroit: Beyond Human, Ratchet & Clank, Uncharted 4: A Thief's End, and whatever Final Fantasy VII's full remake turns into. Microsoft though, woah boy, they aren't just prepping to stand tall, they're playing to win. Gears of War 4, Crackdown 3, Quantum Break, Scalebound, Keiji Inafune's ReCore, Killer Instinct Season 2 and Forza Horizon 3. That's one game for every major genre (being Halo already has the first-person market sewn up), every one of them an exclusive. Exactly how it should be done. Point goes to... Xbox One Everyone's looking to Sony to supplement their sales lead with a reft of titles you can't get anywhere else, but with The Last Guardian delayed, Shenmue not arriving for years (it hadn't even begun development as of E3) and Final Fantasy VII's remake deal only being inked the week prior to the announcement, they're hollow 'exclusives' that are far less bankable than what Microsoft are already showing running right now.

4. Exclusive Console Features

Social media functionality gives Sony the edge if you're thinking of uploading a lot of your gameplay footage, but the Xbox has an underrated feature tucked away in its midst; in-game Achievement-tracking. For whatever reason, Sony and both the PS3 and PS4 have never seemed to totally crack the whole achievement/trophy thing, relying on a 'synching' screen to pop up whenever you want to access them - not to mention having to leave the game and hop across to a different menu anyway. The Xbox One on the other hand, has the 'Snap' function, which lets you allocate a chunk of the screen to everything from Achievements to Youtube, meaning you can hop across and highlight a particular achievement (watching it rack up the points in real time), or let any other feature sit there. Point goes to... Xbox One Sharing functions are all well and good, but for a console feature that would appeal to a universal audience of gamers - predominantly those who are yet to upgrade and are coming off the back of the 360 - it's the Xbox One's new and improved Snap interface that works a treat.

3. Online Store Functionality And Frequency Of Discounts

Since 2006 and right across the last generation, Xbox Live was the straight kick to the PlayStation Store's vulnerable chin, positively dominating the notion of digital sales thanks to Xbox Live Arcade and a consistent rollout of demos, all whilst the PS3 Store struggled to maintain a menu transition without crashing or waiting a few minutes. In the new generation, that's flipped considerably. Now the PlayStation Store is a streamlined rollout of menus you can hop between with ease, always knowing how 'deep' you've gotten through what's showing on the left side. Everything from full games to demos, themes, add-ons and more are easily linked, with each title having it's own social media page (a Facebook profile for games, basically), launching you into the store from various places on the initial dashboard.
On the other hand, the Xbox One's new screens actually work worse than before, thanks to them having only the barest of sorting options, resulting in an endless list of every game on the store in a massive list. The new dashboard does incorporate the PS4's 'game hub' for each title, but it's still a confusing mess of links that take you into other apps (like trying to watch a trailer and ending up in the Upload Studio), or simply don't provide enough information on what you're purchasing. Point goes to... PS4 Although Microsoft have done better with their Xbox Live Gold service (more on that in a bit), the new dash still has some odd issues when it comes to backing out into previous pages, resulting in a cut-to-black stutter that's very off-putting. There are simple things like it not remembering where you were in a custom search's results, and all-round it's not very helpful if you're looking for anything other than the newest, full-priced titles.

2. Hardware Specs

Depending on if you know your GPU cores from your peak shader throughputs, let me summarise the techno-babble with what you need to know: The PS4 is more powerful than the Xbox One. As for the rest of you who want more, let's delve a little deeper. Microsoft's baby has the benefit of being geared around running two operating systems simultaneously, which aids with running multiple apps at the same time, background downloads and app-switching in general. The PS4 certainly has more horsepower under the hood - although keep in mind that the consoles are very similar in terms of what developers are doing with them right now - giving it the edge in the long run. Its GPU, system memory and general output of data is far stronger than the Xbox One, but it's worth noting the PS4 doesn't hold together smoothly when handling multiple functions. Doing something like streaming Spotify in the background whilst a game downloads and you play a third can really bog it down, and seeing your system come to a standstill is an immediately jarring factor regardless of what it should be capable of. That said, Point goes to... PS4 With so many developers working on titles for both platforms, it'll be a rarity something releases with a marked difference between the two, but the facts speak for themselves. If you're looking for the most bang for your buck purely based on the specs available, the PS4 takes it.

1. PS Plus Vs. Xbox Live Gold

Everyone was so happy when Sony announced they wouldn't be charging or imposing any sort of restrictions on buying used games, we almost missed them slipping in the addendum that you'd now have to pay to play online. Luckily, PS Plus as it stands right now is a far more impressive beast than across the PS3 generation. Both that and Xbox Live's 'Games With Gold' services will get you a handful of free titles each month, with Microsoft definitely delivering in this area. Not only have they been great at providing landmark releases like The Walking Dead and Metal Gear Solid: Ground Zeroes, but every month, thanks to the backwards compatibility addition, each free 360 game will work on your Xbox One too. Price-wise they're both very close (at time of writing they're sitting at £40 each in the UK, with $50 and $60 for PS Plus and Xbox Live respectively in the US), meaning it comes down to what you get alongside the actual service of playing online - which is where Sony have the upper hand yet again. Point goes to... PS4 The sheer amount of discounts for PS Plus members are staggering. There are regular reductions on premium titles that shave a few notes off the full price, alongside monthly deals and some massive weekly discounts for top-tier games - all things that Microsoft just don't have, and on the occasion they do, are very hard to find. The monthly free titles are the biggest reason to stump up the cash and get something new to play every month (an area where Microsoft excels), but outside of this there's very little even on a surface level to reward you for opting into a premium service.

So, let's tally up the points...

The Winner Is... PS4

PS4 - 6 Xbox One - 4 Overall, despite Microsoft making some very key changes to their software and ensuring the Xbox One works without the Kinect, alongside having one hell of a catalogue for games next year, the PS4 is still the better system to recommend to those yet to jump ship. It's got the better controller, better user experience on the dashboard end, better overall value for money if you put down the cash on a yearly PS Plus subscription, and better hardware specs to future-proof it considerably, providing Sony do right by the consumer and use its power to full effect. The vast majority of titles you're going to want to play are most likely third-party, and will continue to be - so take stock in your head of what you're dying to get your hands on, and if something like Halo 5 sways you enough, then let that be your guide. Outside of that, if you don't have one specific game you simply can't live without (hey, I bought a PS3 for Metal Gear Solid 4), the PS4 stands proud with a better set of features across the board that'll give you a better experience as a consumer. Are you team PS4, or Xbox One? Let us know in the comments, and sign up to write for the site if you'd like to contribute your own content!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.