Quantum Break Review - An Ambitious But Ultimately Exhausting Experience

Sadly, this isn't going to be the system-seller the Xbox One needs.

Remedy
Remedy

Rating: ˜…˜…˜…˜†˜† Length: Approx. 7 hours (plus 80 minutes for the TV component) Platform & Performance: Xbox One - Solid frame rate, no noticeable bugs, occasional texture pop-in.

If the name David Cage means something to you, and you like what games like Heavy Rain or Beyond: Two Souls were going for - the whole 'super neat idea trapped in a fumbled execution' ideology - you'll grow to admire and perhaps love Quantum Break.

A narrative-heavy third-person shooter, I say 'admire' first, because it's a very hard game to love, despite Remedy creating what is easily one of the most ambitious and riveting projects in gaming history. Over the years, the developer has gone from pioneering 'bullet time' with Max Payne, to flexing their narrative muscles in Alan Wake. Both projects were love letters to noir filmmaking and supernatural horror respectively and, with Quantum Break, it's a nod to action movies of the 90s and barmy sci-fi plots simultaneously, producing something we'll be dissecting for years to come - just not necessarily for the most positive of reasons.

Shaun 'Iceman' Ashmore, Aidan 'Littlefinger' Gillen and Dominic 'Either Merry Or Pippin I Can Never Remember' Monaghan head up the cast in both digital and live-action form as the hero, his best friend and brother respectively, the latter being genius scientist William Joyce, who has happened upon the secret to manipulating time.

Once that knowledge is out there, a botched experiment breaks the flow of time itself, heralding in apocalyptic visions of a nightmarish future where all life simply stops, and gracing Ashmore and Gillen's characters with fancy time-bending abilities. It turns out the latter is not as friendly as his introductory sequence made him out to be, and in fact he's heading up a secretive corporation called Monarch who appear to have Sinister Intentions, as they just might have a hand in all this time-breaking tomfoolery. Cue a quest to restore the flow of time, copious amounts of slow-motion shooting, bodies pinwheeling through the air and, well, laughing as everybody insists on saying variations of "We're out of TIME!" every few minutes.

Remedy
Remedy

Alongside this, you've got the revolutionary idea of filming a film's worth of live-action content, which is split up into multiple 20 minute episodes that conclude the first four acts of a five-act structure. They're intended to 'flesh out the world of Quantum Break', as a choice you make at the close of one chapter dictates how both the TV show and game will then play out. Scenes are compiled and stitched together almost entirely from these binary decisions, with mostly minor elements changing such as what an in-world news report may be talking about, but certain actors and a couple of very cool scenes later on only reveal themselves under specific pathways.

For all the talk of how the live-action component would 'respond' to your actions in-game, it boils down to triggering one of two variations on an episode overall, with occasional in-game secrets you've found slotting in to form additional scenes. A very early example is having brother William interact with a formula on a Monarch building whiteboard, only for a scene to show an employee remarking to his colleague that "someone" has completed it.

Remedy
Remedy

Sadly, outside one particular character only showing their true nature if you've stacked the deck a certain way, choices don't feel like they have truly meaningful repercussions once you start lining up the variations side-by-side. The four key decisions feel tangentially related at best, as opposed to building on one another. It's less a case of how Mass Effect would continue to juggle more and more consequential factors in a way that results in various, satisfyingly unique outcomes, and more that Quantum Break has a defined story to tell no matter what.

There are good characters, bad characters, setups and resolutions. Rather like Heavy Rain, Remedy designed these split paths to weave around the narrative's core strand, and in the pursuit of a fixed resolution, things can only flex so much. The Witcher 2 (where taking a particular path meant you didn't see entire cities CD Projekt RED had designed) this ain't.

Next, the things Quantum Break absolutely nails. The TV show is ace, it's just a shame it houses the best characters that barely appear in the game. Also, there's a reason the TV show has been the focus so far...


Remedy
Remedy

There's a real heart to what Remedy have created here; a labour of love in everything from the copious uses of in-world terminology thrown around regardless of your ability to keep up, to the real-world set design that you can tell a team of creatives had an absolute blast decking out every last inch of. Even extras are done up in costumes retrofitted with logos and symbology to remind you of the game's fiction, and every part of the TV show comes together surprisingly well, its drama being replete with car chases, hand-to-hand action sequences and hefty amounts of character expansion. Seriously, if Quantum Break launched on Netflix, it'd be a solid, if campy, The Blacklist-style action thriller, complete with Lance Reddick.

It must be said though, this additional stuff being designed to 'fill in the blanks' as it were, focusses on characters that are mostly ancillary to the overall experience, and without getting spoilery, it's a real shame that once the live-action and game worlds collide in the fifth act, certain people I'd grown attached to weren't dealt with in a satisfying manner. In fact, I'd make the case that the two most interesting characters in the entirety of Quantum Break's narrative play second fiddle to the cast that's heading up the marketing materials.

Remedy
Remedy

As you might have guessed by me focussing on what works outside of the game, the biggest problem comes in matching this level of quality when you're in control, as there's a degree of confidence in the narrative delivery behind the camera that just doesn't come through when things go digital. For a start, dialogue is badly delivered across the board, save for Lance Reddick's Martin Hatch, and 'hero' Jack Joyce (which you never buy for a second that Ashmore is a gun-toting badass) is a total blank slate, but not in the way you can project yourself onto; more that other characters refer to him as having purpose, intent and a reputation, yet we know or see nothing of the sort.

It wasn't until a second playthrough I discovered you can find a collectible that hints at his backstory, but if you miss that - and it is easy to miss - you'll go the entire game wondering why he can handle himself with a gun, why he's not remotely phased by freakin' time travel and why after certain cataclysmic events, he's not losing his mind just a teeny tiny bit. Next to him is Monaghan's William Joyce, and boy have you not heard an English actor fudge up an American accent so hilariously in quite some time. You have to hand it to the guy for trying his best 'neurotic-scientist-who-didn't-want-any-of-this-to-happen' shtick, but he sounds like Mordin Solus doing his best Boston detective impersonation after drunkenly watching a season of The Wire.

Remedy
Remedy

The gunplay though? Remedy's bread n' butter that eventually took a backseat to Alan Wake's increasingly scripted walking sequences is back again. Taking out enemies is snappy, responsive and favours more than a little auto-assist targeting on its default setting. For the most part it's phenomenal... the handful of times you get to take part, that is.

Next up, how Remedy combined what they learned from Max Payne and Alan Wake to form one of the best-playing third-person shooters in years. There's just not enough of it...


Remedy
Remedy

Sadly, whilst the team continue to manufacture gunfights that will genuinely command your jaw hit the floor in adoration, they're more preoccupied with fleshing out the motivations of everyone around you who isn't the main character. You'll spend more time reading emails between various figures that only show up in the TV show than you will firing bullets, and although in typical action movie fashion, the final act houses a fantastic Matrix/Max Payne-style 'lobby scene', the work put into realising these sequences feels like a missed opportunity, as there simply aren't enough excuses to get your gun off.

Outside the story-based stuff, the time powers you have on offer here are fantastic. You can trap guys in 'time bubbles', instantly 'time-dodge' in any direction, sprint as fast as time itself and then warp back into reality to deliver a haymaker that would make Conor McGregor wince. Once you get a feel for how fast you can pull these abilities off - and they're given to you in quick succession very early on - fight sequences are pyrotechnic extravaganzas of visual effects.

Bodies hang in suspended animation before resuming their trajectory and slamming to the ground, your 'time shield' will allow you to catch your breath and heal, watching in awe as hundreds of bullets ping-pong off around the room. You'll freeze enemies and unload a clip into their face, the bullets gathering right in one place before the world kicks back in they all impact at once. Every final kill in a given section has a slick camera-spin that hangs for just long enough so you can wince pleasurably, the entire exchange ending with a visual victory punch that hits home every time.

Remedy
Remedy

I make a big deal of this, because you'll miss it when you're forced to do such arbitrary and thoroughly last-gen things such as finding a switch for a gate that's out of power, or partaking in awkward platforming sections where instant death is an invisible wall-break away. Also, for the love of all that is holy, can we stop with the 'now your character must turn sideways to get through this narrow gap' animations? When you have a story predicated on narrative propulsion and someone discovering they can bend the laws of time and space, that discovery and excitability is hampered by actions that feel decidedly 'video gamey', and not in a good way.

Lastly, Remedy have included an upgrade tree for your powers, but it's severely under-utilised to the degree of being pointless. A specific collectible can be built up and spent on expanding damage or how long a power will stay active, but as each refreshes fast and fights are over relatively fast, I forgot it was even in there after a few hours - especially seeing as its buried in a menu next to optional diary entries. Remember how arbitrary Bioshock Infinite's weapon upgrades were overall? It's that.

Remedy
Remedy

Thankfully, as a technical showcase, performance across the board is incredibly solid. Even when you're deploying powers in unison and the game has to handle physics models for various bodies, projectiles and pieces of scenery, it never asks to stop and catch up. Quantum Break is right up there with Halo 5 as a powerhouse for what the Xbox One can do when it's firing on all cylinders, but there are a couple of things that must be addressed.

Firstly, the facial animation. On the one hand, it's the finest motion-capture work we've seen since L.A. Noire or Halo's 4 and 5, but on the other, in-game transitions for faces are non-existent. Characters can go from full smiles or all sorts of expressional emotions, straight back to 'standard looking forward face' in an instant, almost like at the end of any dialogue exchange, their face 'resets' for the next one. It's not game-breaking by any means, but you'll notice it, and you really shouldn't considering the calibre of the tech otherwise on display.

Second is a strange, dreamlike blur filter that's applied to everything, an inclusion I assumed was hinting at some kind of "It was all a dream!" ending reveal, but is instead just distracting, especially in lowly lit areas, as characters appear to 'drift' around. The same thing was in Alan Wake to a lesser degree, and is perhaps a Remedy trademark, but for that game's "Who are you, really?" setup, it worked a treat. Here it's a super minor thing, as overall Quantum Break is a joy to see in motion, but worth pointing out all the same.

Lastly, the deciding factor. Do you like carefree action, cheesy dialogue and over-the-top plots, or will they turn you off? Remedy try and please both sides, and ultimately it just doesn't work...


Remedy

Speaking of visual flourishes, we get onto stylistic choices and tone, and again there's a lot that's really going to divide people. Quantum Break really wants you to take its setup of breakthrough science fiction seriously, but it also wants to be a pulpy, fairly carefree action flick with one-liners and accepted use of the aforementioned "We've got no !*$% TIME!" lines. Such ideologies don't mesh well - just ask Batman V Superman and the "Is she with you?" scene.

This leads to a handful of outright weird dialogue, tone and plot hole problems such as each act ending with a smash-cut to a random licensed song. Nothing says "Take this plot revelation seriously" like a cut to black and then back up to Royal Blood thundering away. Again, Alan Wake had this, but as that game framed your own "What the f**k!?" plot reactions as that of Wake himself, the music complimented the assault on your senses, but here it just feels jarringly out of place given the otherwise serious tone.

However, most of the negative stuff stems from the time-travelling aspect being needlessly hard to follow for the majority. See, Joyce is narrating his past exploits from the present day. He's discussing the events of each scenario and the 'struggle to repair time' in retrospect, meaning you're forever balancing the notion of limitless, incident-repairing time travel with an endpoint you're going to reach no matter what. It makes for strangely forced story beats, as both Joyce and the person he's talking to incessantly need to remind you that your past actions have weight, saying things "went from bad to worse', or alluding to someone "not being who they say they were", all while not providing a solid foundation on who you are, or what's really going on.

remedy
remedy

Inception proved that a big budget production can mix entertainment with education, and despite Quantum Break's very name and the occasional scientific theorum getting dropped to remind you Remedy have looked all this up during development, we're given only the barest explanation for what's actually happening from beginning to end. Jack Joyce - despite being nothing of a scientist himself - never questions anything outside of a few 'Woah, cool, now I can do this? Neat!' lines, and even when other characters enquire as to his abilities, he shrugs it off as "Yeah, something happened, I don't know... DID I MENTION WE'VE GOT NO TIME?"

Remedy want you to just go with it, and you'll want to as well, but so much of the story's revelations hang on fully understanding exactly what's at stake, that ultimately it's exhausting trying to map everything out in your head, all the while more complications and possibilities present themselves. By stretching the events of the game over multiple time periods, having main characters appear in almost all of them and then referencing things that happened on an hour by hour basis within each, it ends up feeling needlessly convoluted, especially come the fifth act when you can see the full picture and realise there was a far easier way of teasing "What was really going on".

It's an experience that benefits from repeat viewings and playthroughs, to which you then have to ask yourself the question of if you're becoming accommodating of its flaws and learning to live with them, or if they were truly jarring for a reason. I'm going with the latter.

Remedy
Remedy

In the end, Quantum Break is one hell of an achievement by sheer definition of succeeding as something that has one foot in its base medium and the other in television. Its TV parts and world-building excel and are well put together on paper, but it's a shame you can't say the same about the storytelling and execution in the game itself.

From hilariously bad dialogue to a final boss that feels like you're battling visual effects overkill more than anything else, Quantum Break falls short of being that killer app the Xbox One so desperately, desperately needs.

Are you planning on picking up Quantum Break? Let us know in the comments what you've thought of the pre-release hype, and what your favourite Remedy game is!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.