Ranking Every Devil May Cry From Worst To Best

Yup, even that one.

Devil May Cry
Capcom

There's something about Devil May Cry that's always been downright loveable. The red trenchcoat and albino hair, the overblown stylistic tone, the one-liners, the fact Dante makes a point of walking up to any-sized boss and insulting them to their various faces. It was instantly treasured from moment one.

Now, 18 years later (yes, really) the series is bonafide gaming royalty, responsible for kickstarting an entire genre of Spectacle Fighter that includes everything from God of War to Bayonetta, NieR: Automata to Metal Gear Rising. Even Platinum Games was founded by ex-Capcom devs determined to carry forward this sensibility into an entire run of passionate titles, purpose-built to exude the most insanely fun characteristics in gameplay and cutscene.

Back to DMC though, and the franchise only has a mere six instalments. It's what makes it so beloved; that restraint to not choke the market means the 11 year wait between DMC 4 and 5 was welcomed with open arms, but also means a ranking will comprise two generations' worth of gamers across almost 20 years.

Brilliantly though, as you're about to read, the series' overall bar of quality is sky high, only let down by one dud and a notably off-kilter experiment. It's still a franchise you should more than invest in today (and I recommend the anime series alongside), but for now... let's rock, baby.*

--

*I had to.


6. Devil May Cry 2

Devil May Cry 2
Capcom

DMC 2 was always going to be the worst one, both here and for the rest of time.

Following DMC 1, Capcom found themselves in a time in entertainment history where The Matrix was king, and post-grunge grimdark attitudes were in vogue. As such, they took the cocky, "got this" vibes of Dante and... turned him into completely different character.

Aesthetically he looked trim and honestly, pretty badass, but this was a Dante more concerned with saying as little as possible, as cutscenes are easily the most forgettable in the saga.

The worst thing though, was combat. Notably slower and with various disconnected animations that had to play out before you could do anything else, it felt soul-crushingly boring. Gone was the sense of flow that personified the original, and in was a repetitive, stilted experience where even firing guns in mid-air felt bland.

Levels too were brown and grey smudges filled with bad texture work and phoned-in puzzles. Dante might have debuted the ability to wall-run and shoot two targets at once, but literally everything else was spectacularly off.


5. DmC: Devil May Cry

Dmc Devil May Cry
Capcom

Following four instalments, Capcom sought to reboot the franchise in a pretty drastic way, announcing in 2010 that they'd be handing the IP off to Ninja Theory, having been impressed by PS3 title, Heavenly Sword.

The transition was full of promise... until we saw Dante, and this brown-haired, shoe-gazing moper was once again - like DMC 2 - not what any series' fans wanted.

Playing today, disconnected from all the hype and expectation - and knowing that this didn't actually kill the franchise, thanks to DMC 5's return - DmC: Devil May Cry is surprisingly brilliant as a "indie film"-style one-off.

The only bad DMC is 2, and Ninja Theory should've always been commended for remixing the core fiction in some effective ways that have only aged better over time. Stripping Dante of his memories so he's a useless layabout at the beginning; making Vergil a freedom fighting hacker group leader going up against the Fox News-style Raptor, lead by demon of the underworld, Mundus? This was all excellent stuff, it was just wrong place, wrong time, when all fans wanted was more of DMC 3.

Still, try DmC: Devil May Cry today. You'll find one of the best action games ever put to code, and even Dante's overall attitude isn't anywhere near as dour as we once thought.


4. Devil May Cry 4

Devil may cry 1
Capcom

Coming off the immaculate DMC 3, Capcom threw us a curveball: Nero.

Playable for the first half of the game, this Dante clone (visually, at least) came with the Devil Bringer - a demonic arm that let him grab enemies out the sky, as well as perform a range of grabs and ground slams. Not only that, but if you tapped L2/LT at the right time, you could "rev up" Nero's sword for extra damage mid-combo, Final Fantasy VIII-style.

All of this was fantastic and exactly what the series needed on a mechanical level... but then we got to Dante. Aesthetically Capcom went with an ace cowboy look, and made it so you could access all of his DMC 3 stance attacks by tapping the D-pad in four directions... but he was only in half the game.

Not only that, but the "half" he was in, was all recycled levels from Nero's campaign. The exact same levels, in fact, in reverse order, with the exact same bosses, being defeated in the same way.

A baffling design choice that felt more like someone on the dev side wanted to make a Nero game, only to realise too late that fans would riot without Dante, so his gameplay was sublime, but that was it.

Thankfully, in making the leap to newer hardware, DMC 4's animations and cutscene fight choreography were something else, the latter being the new milestone for whatever we want to call "action cinema" in a gaming sense.


3. Devil May Cry 1

Devil May Cry 1
Capcom

You wouldn't have any of this without the immaculate original, and though it spawned from one of many prototypes for Resident Evil 4 (hence some survival horror vibes in the camera angles, architecture and "find item to solve puzzle" level progression), DMC 1 still made one hell of an impact.

To this day, combat is buttery smooth and wide camera angles only enhance the cinematic qualities of bounding around various gothic environments, slicing foes in three and writing your name in their hides with a few thousand bullets.

Every single line Dante says is gold; the formation of a new gaming icon designed from the ground up to be described to any player's grandchildren. Forgoing its immediate sequel, things would only get even better from here on out, but Devil May Cry 1 still feels like an essential action game with the perfect runtime.


2. Devil May Cry 3

Devil may cry 3
Capcom

After the euphoric, "Best.Character.EVER" delights of DMC 1 and the hype-resetting blandness of DMC 2, Capcom threw everything at the wall and came out with the "... why didn't they think of this sooner?!" DMC 3.

Young Dante.

In two words it all made so much sense. The cocksure attitude, the acrobatic combat - the ludicrous fashion sense that only a demon high on their own supply could pull off. A younger Dante trying to open his monster-hunting business whilst tussling with brother Vergil was beyond incredible. And then you played it.

Holding up brilliantly today, DMC 3 introduced the "Style" system - the ability to specialise in more advanced sword moves, evasive dodges, multi-target firearm blasts or defensive counters. You had to pick one before each mission, but this just meant you didn't have to worry about juggling a larger array of attacks, and could get to carving everything into chunks far more seamlessly.

You could ride enemies across the floor while firing both pistols, backflip off walls and rain down fire in a tornado spin from above. See a poll nearby? Dante will spin around it mid-combo, decimating that group of enemies who almost had you pinned down.

A sublime mix of character and game, DMC 3 would still be the reigning champion, if not for...


1. Devil May Cry 5

devil may cry 5
Capcom

Talk about a return to form.

After DMC 4's lacklustre use of Dante and the 2013 reboot killing off the original version altogether, Capcom reintroduces the world to the Dante we all grew up with in the best way possible.

The great scriptwriting was back; the original look was back. Even one of the most beloved weapons from DMC 3 comes back, but you'll have to play to know which one.

DMC 5 looks absolutely stunning to boot, but the reason it soars above its forebears is entirely down to gameplay. Both Nero and newcomer V are both incredibly fun to play as - the former especially, as Nero's arm is now replaced with a robotic assortment of specials - but Dante's moveset? It feels like every other game in one.

Almost like Capcom wanted to make up for the 11 year wait, Dante's four stance system is back, but it goes atop a weapon system that itself, has a separate skill tree per item. Levelling up then gives you a ludicrous amount of options for any fight, comprising everything from breakdancing with demonic foot armour, to literally wielding a bike in two halves like two giant hammers.

Combine everything - the overall presentation, fun-loving script and genuinely-the-best-combat-in-action-game-history - and you get something that finally lets you do as many things in-game as we always adored watching in the cutscenes.

DMC 5 plays with as much style, swagger and self-assurance as Dante on his finest day, and that makes it the best one yet.


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.