Ranking Every Naughty Dog Game From Worst To Best
The Last of Us vs. Crash vs. Uncharted vs. Jak & Daxter vs....
Of all the video game studios to grace this planet in the last 30 years (when gaming really took off, escaping the arcades and setting up shop in our living rooms and bedrooms), Naughty Dog are one of the most fascinating.
Starting off with a far more immature, "radical, bro" image, they quickly matured into designing RPGs (whilst retaining some self-aware humour), only for Crash Bandicoot to randomly get noticed by Sony, catapulting them into the eyes of the world. Thankfully, they handled the exposure and fame with relative ease, outdoing themselves at every turn and releasing subsequently phenomenal games one after another.
From Crash to Jak & Daxter, Uncharted to The Last of Us, how many other creatives can you point to that really wear their influences on their sleeve; that really take the requisite time to perfect each release?
Naughty Dog are pretty unique in that regard. Sony know they're worth it, and with such praiseworthy stature in mainstream and critical circles, every release is a labour of love, exemplifying why many of our all-time favourites come from their studios.
All that said, which Naughty Dog game is the absolute best, and what - if any - are their worst?
17. Way Of The Warrior
Oh, Naughty Dog. Your 'bad to good' spectrum had to start somewhere.
Though Way of the Warrior was actually the studio's sixth game (the third under the Naughty Dog name, having been JAM Software before), it was very clearly trying to get in on the Mortal Kombat zeitgeist of the early 90s.
More indicative of that time period than a pair of board shorts, Way of the Warrior chugged along with a nu-metal soundtrack from White Zombie, whilst angular, scratchy fonts were commonplace and characters killed each other before yelling "No sequel for you!". It was certainly playable enough and a good laugh with a couch-full of friends, but this is Naughty Dog we're talking about, and Way of the Warrior is easily their most uninspired release.
16. Keef The Thief: A Boy & His Lockpick
1989 saw the very first game from Naughty Dog (under their new name) - a supremely cool point n' click RPG where the titular Keef was tasked with exploration and combat through a pretty nicely-handled first-person interface. Penned and designed by Naughty Dog founders Andrew Gavin and Jason Rubin (the former of which is still with the company), Keef was surprisingly immersive, having a stellar colour palette, array of memorable characters and a surprisingly witty script.
All these things would later be perfected and championed by LucasArts' stellar Secret of Monkey Island in 1990, but Keef was an altogether deeper beast anyway - there were traps to disarm amidst labyrinthine mazes, spells to craft, enemies to slay and dialogue exchanges to be had with the royals.
It's outdated as hell now and the game's ending text includes your child finding a powered-up guitar and forming a metal band named Axe, but for its time, Keef presented a number of cool, varied gameplay mechanics to get lost in.
15. Rings Of Power
Showing that even back on the Sega Genesis/Mega Drive, Naughty Dog wanted to make a name for themselves through sheer ambition, Rings of Power is rather... 'primitive' to revisit, but man, you can't knock just how much the team were giving it their all.
Designing one of the biggest open-world RPGs on the system, it was made possible by showing you one chunk at a time on a screen that better resembled a D&D-inspired tabletop adventure, rather than an actual "world" you could look around.
Remember, this was 1991, and as such, Rings of Power became bogged down by a stuttering frame rate and more annoying, a brutally hard and unforgiving difficulty. Totally worth a look just to see where one of Naughty Dog's most beloved games (for some cult fans) got its start, but Rings of Power can't contend with everything that came after*.
-
*Minus the aforementioned Way of the Warrior, of course.
14. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
Now we get into real hair-splitting territory - and we're not even into the top 10 yet.
Simply because Naughty Dog's average bar of quality is so damn high, note that from here on out: They're all brilliant games, but small elements can cost specific titles valuable placement.
As such, there's a reason Uncharted didn't come into its own until the sequel. Besides the stellar character work, motion capture and scene direction, the original Uncharted was very much Naughty Dog flexing their muscles in an entire new genre: The cover shooter. With that in mind, yes the shooting is serviceable, but the core identity of Uncharted in a mechanical sense had quite some distance to travel.
Gameplay is supremely basic, seeing you alternating between pre-made platforming runs and stop n' pop shooting, mostly meaning you were playing to get to the next immaculately produced cutscene. A furtive first step, sure, but like with many Naughty Dog trilogy-beginnings, everything would only improve from here on out.
13. Jak X: Combat Racing
The sequel nobody wanted (but we all saw coming), Combat Racing is very much to Jak & Daxter what CTR was to Crash Bandicoot - a fun, "Sure, why not?" racing spin-off that, in Jak X's case, didn't have a kart racing pull to trade off.
Ultimately this proved to be its undoing, selling but a third of what Jak III had raked in but a year earlier. However, mechanically this was supremely solid - a more Burnout-style racer that mixed power-ups with the weighty side-swipes and takedowns of EA's cerebral speeder.
Arena battles, tunnel vision-inducing home straights and a nicely paced story that tipped more than a few nods to the trilogy we all loved so much, Jak might not have ended in style if you ask the wider world, but those who picked up Jak X: Combat Racing still got a fantastic game.
12. Crash Bandicoot
Another case of the first instalment certainly being enjoyable and beloved, but can you honestly say the first Crash is the best?
Everything from the amount of polygons in Crash's face to the level design, boss strategies and general proficiency with the PS1 tech would come into their own on Crash 2, leaving the original to certainly be a landmark release, but one that was bettered in its next two instalments.
Still, Crash gave us some of the most fun levels in the character's history, alongside immortally loveable bosses like Neo Cortex and Ripper Roo - not to mention the soundtrack, which backed the charming platformer with some of Naughty Dog's most infectious themes yet.
Oh, and those Indiana Jones-esque boulder-chases are just as white knuckle-intense today as ever.
11. Jak III
The "worst" instalment in an otherwise flawless trilogy, Jak III only gets knocked down thanks to not having the focus of the first or second instalments.
Aspects like having Jak birth a "Light Eco" state to match his Dark one from Jak II or the retread of unlocking the same weapons over again wasn't the best, but the main issue came from electing to have the majority of travel come by car, rather than the flying vehicles from Jak II: Renegade.
This felt like a step backwards, especially when handling was prone to flipping you out mid-race, kicking you back to the start to try all over again. Add in a much less interesting series of locations and even a stellar ending couldn't save Jak III - though of course, Naughty Dog's blend of platforming and gunplay was still a delight.
10. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception
Coming off the immaculate Uncharted 2, it was going to be very hard to end this particular trilogy in style, though Naughty Dog took it in a very experimental direction: Fleshing out Drake's past in an instalment that anywhere else, would've come right away.
This gave us a much younger Drake and a prime-of-life Sully, adding weight to their relationship that would culminate in a forced "death" of the latter, only to reveal they were alive all along. These aspects became emblematic of Uncharted 3 overall: A series of neat ideas, seemingly stitched together for the sake of manufacturing peril and consequence, despite the story itself never truly coming together.
In the end we were left with questions ranging from "Is Talbot secretly supernatural?!" to "Seriously, we're fighting gun-toting Djinns now?!" at the end, and though gunplay was tighter and better than ever, the actual meat of Uncharted 3 felt protracted and sadly, too much more of the same.
9. Crash Bandicoot 2
All the challenge from the original twinned with the level variety of what would later become Crash 3's entire focus, this second entry tends to be the hardcore Crash-fan's sequel of choice, though overall, it's not quite as polished as need be, to be the best.
Let's stay away from cheaply designed underground sewers and an all-too-present trial and error design ethos though, as Crash 2 introduced everything from hoverboards to polar bears for Crash to ride through, all across some expertly crafted worlds.
The last Naughty Dog game to still have a foot in the old-school, "Learn this level thoroughly or you won't survive" mentality, there is always a brilliant sense of accomplishment to making it through - especially because once again, the coding department knocked it out the park, presentation and production-wise.
8. Jak & Daxter: The Precursor Legacy
At the turn of the generation, Naughty Dog found themselves keeping their heads down and focusing on what was most definitely their forte. Nobody outside of Nintendo was doing 3D platformers quite so proficiently, but where could the genre go after Crash 3?
Well, "anywhere" came the reply, as Naughty Dog built Jak & Daxter with what was essentially an open-world design at its core.
Mission-givers were peppered across the stunning landscape, you were free to come and go between a number of different environments to mop up any remaining collectibles, and across the board both Jak and Daxter's animations (and the latter's voice work) were simply loveable.
Come the close of the story you'd been on a brilliant 'unassuming villager embarks on the epic quest and saves the realm' tale, but with an overall mark of quality that - whilst worlds away from Jak 2 and 3 - gives Jak & Daxter a purity that still encourages a playthrough today.
7. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
Easily the best-looking Uncharted of them all, A Thief's End is a genuine jaw-dropper from beginning to end, but especially once you start getting to explore an small archipelago of islands in the chapter, At Sea.
Plot-wise, Naughty Dog weave a phenomenally fourth wall-acknowledging tale of Drake growing older and settling down - yet forever reminiscing on the days of the original trilogy's stories. It results in a brilliant meld of our own memories as gamers being twinned with Nate's, and though the story plays the "He had a secret relative all along!" card in brother Sam, the level of heart present throughout is outstanding and emotionally affecting.
Uncharted 4 would be the best of them all if not for an over-extended back half, as it truly has the finest combat Naughty Dog have ever designed. From top to bottom it's highly recommended, but if you grew up with Nate, Sully, Elena and the gang, there's something extra special that no other franchise has ever produced.
6. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
The game that made Uncharted the household name it remains, Uncharted 2 was received with rapturous applause when it was shown off at E3 2008, showcasing Naughty Dog's mind-blowing "collapsing building" set-piece, only for Drake to emerge in one piece, remarking "Holy crap, we were almost in that!"
Needless to say it was enough to make Nate one of the most beloved game characters of all time right there (as if the original hadn't already laid suitable foundations), but the phenomenal standout moments didn't stop there. We had a true marvel of game design in the physics-dependant moving train sequence, another where Drake leapt between moving jeeps, and a combat model that actually made sense; blending platforming with gunplay in a way no one saw coming.
Uncharted 2 is certainly the best Nathan Drake instalment, but a notably off-putting finale throws a spanner in the works, letting an unassuming - yet altogether more well-paced and well-written - sequel steal the next spot...
5. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy
Confidently making strides into showing how the franchise can exist without Nathan Drake, Lost Legacy rolls together all its past instalments' gameplay innovations and has hands-down the finest action set-pieces Naughty Dog have ever devised.
Uncharted 2's train sequence or Uncharted 4's jeep chase? Why not combine to create one of the most frenetic and experimental finales of all time? The very fact you can leap from carriage to car, weapon turret to rooftop with such ease is cause for celebration - and then you have Nadine and Chloe, who have the best dynamic between two characters since Drake and Sully in Uncharted 1.
With Chloe the history expert hiring Nadine, the brawn, the pair have a real "thrown together" quality that sees them grow as real people across the story. Villain Asav is the only undercooked portion of the package, but overall, Lost Legacy has a perfect pace, length, balance of puzzles with gunplay and the best combat encounters in 10 years of Uncharted history.
Don't overlook this as "just DLC made into a full game". It's easily everything Naughty Dog and Uncharted stand for, wrapped into a supremely tight package.
4. Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped
Speaking of culminations in iconic franchises, Crash 3 is by far the easiest of the bunch - but that's precisely why it's so moreish; so playable; so enjoyable to take in.
Every subsequent level comes with a fresh mechanic, set of enemies or incredible art style, as whilst Crash 2 certainly retained the challenge of the original, upon reflection you'll realise there are only a good four tile sets for all the levels to be made from.
No such thing in Crash 3, where the titular 'Warped' setup has Crash beamed off to everywhere from neon-lit futurescapes to ancient Aztec tombs, shining oceans to ride your jetski over and - best of all - sun-scorched highways where you'll fight other racers atop your motorbike for the win.
Crash 3 is emblematic of a confident studio firing on all cylinders, rolling together their time-tested signature platforming with a number of genre experiments that quite simply, work. The icing on the cake is Crash's new abilities - ranging from a jump-extending super-spin to a Wumpa fruit-firing bazooka - encouraging replayability to see which new paths you can discover second, third or fourth-time through.
3. CTR: Crash Team Racing
Crash 1? Slightly primitive platforming. Crash 2? Trial and error mentalities underpinning some otherwise brilliant levels. Crash 3? Stellar presentation and an attitude that let the whole world enjoy the fun - at the expense of those wanting a challenge.
Crash Team Racing though? Just about the most pitch-perfect game Naughty Dog have coded on a purely mechanical level.
The feel of the karts has just the right amount of weight, with courses being perfect blends of tight corners, home straights, pepperings of power-ups and boost-pads to nail. Once you get the whole thing down, races elevate into furious blends of rockets, boost-chains and last minute overtakings to secure victory.
For single players, the courses and story mode were a total joy to take in - but as a local multiplayer experience, well, it would take Mario Kart until 2014 to implement the sort of speed CTR was flaunting in 1999.
In many ways, this is Naughty Dog's most pure video game, but the top two entries have to reflect everything they can offer as a studio, leading me onto...
2. Jak 2: Renegade

Just about the only non-Rockstar developed video game to take all the lessons learned from GTA and do something just as phenomenal, when Naughty Dog plied their trade to the open-world, they did so with an unprecedented amount of character and charm.
Replacing basic cars and cities were hover-bikes and industrial complexes right next to jungles, sand dunes and beaches to explore, rather than just an assortment of pistols and rifles we had laser-blasters and power-ups - one of which being a Dark Jak state that could end in a whopping great smart bomb detonating all around.
Missions comprised a primally satisfying mix of guns, platforming and the occasional vehicle chase, with a mid-game unlockable hoverboard showing that within all of this, Naughty Dog could tick the Tony Hawk's box too.
Put it this way: There's nothing better than evading the Krimzon Guard whilst kickflipping over their heads, landing on a rail, grinding your way out of sight and jacking a car in mid-air to tear off down the highway.
1. The Last Of Us
To some The Last of Us winning will be obvious, and to others a reaffirmation that it really is a transcendent piece of work.
Rolling together all the lessons learned from seven years of Uncharted motion capture, letting duel-scribes Neil Druckmann and Bruce Straley once again take the healm on a brand new IP paid dividends as we got one of the most impactful, nuanced and expertly paced stories of all time.
Both Joel and Ellie feel like real people, but that's only the quintessential ingredient allowing the rest of the game to come to life. Joel's slow embrace of Ellie as his surrogate daughter wouldn't have the requisite weight without him first being mortally wounded, enacting his revenge against a number of kidnappers or going through hell to find the Fireflies together.
The entire ending setup is built to make you ask the question of what is more important - the needs of the many, or the needs of the person you love?
Naughty Dog make Joel answer this by choosing the latter, demonstrating one of the most shocking scenes of their career, leading to the most ballsy cut-to-black in gaming history: A hint that he'll have to live a lie, and the comfort that comes with never acknowledging the truth to that question.
It's all of these thematics routed through solid shooting and complimentary survival mechanics, that make The Last of Us a perfect combination of world-building and playability - the best Naughty Dog game of all time.
For now, at least.