Ranking Every Naughty Dog Game From Worst To Best

The definitive list!

As far as game developers go, Naughty Dog are undoubtedly up there with the best of them. First formed as Jam Software by Andy Gavin and Jason Rubin in 1984, the company created two games for the Apple II and two for the Apple IIGS, Amiga and DOS, changing their name to Naughty Dog before the release of the latter of these, a title named Keef The Thief. After producing a poorly received game on the Mega Drive for Electronic Arts called Rings Of Power, Gavin and Rubin's creation of a game called Way Of The Warrior got the attention of Mark Cerny, currently known as the lead architect of the Playstation 4 but then the Vice President of Universal Interactive Studios. Signed by Cerny to develop games for Universal, Naughty Dog expanded and came up with Crash Bandicoot. They haven't looked back since, having made a total of twelve games for Sony's assorted Playstation consoles over the last eighteen years. Each of these games have been well-received, to the extent that their mean review score on GameRankings is currently 88.6%. As a result of this, it's not uncommon for gaming fans to state their belief that Naughty Dog have never made a bad game. This statement cannot be held as entirely truthful, given the lack of praise awarded to their early titles, but since 1996 it is a fact that the company have consistently put out high quality releases, regardless of changes in personnel (Gavin and Rubin having long since left to pursue other endeavours). Ranking said releases is therefore a difficult task, but one that will be attempted over the course of the next few pages....

12. Jak X: Combat Racing (2005)

After the release of three platforming entries in the Crash Bandicoot series on the original Playstation, Naughty Dog wrapped up proceedings with Crash Team Racing, a driving game. The same pattern was followed on Playstation 2 with their second platforming franchise, the Jak and Daxter series, and Jak X: Combat Racing was released in 2005. Despite possessing a solid (if short) story and a variety of engaging modes, the game suffered at times from questionable physics and a frustrating AI, who seemed particularly apt at constantly respawning with an offensive weapon directly behind you, much more so than in other racing games of this type. Regardless of its flaws, the game served as a more than adequate send-off for the Jak and Daxter series. Unlike many other Naughty Dog games, however, it hasn't 'gone down in history' and even at the time of its release it wasn't exactly a title that stood out, given that fans of the racing genre were also gifted with the releases of Gran Turismo 4 and Need For Speed: Most Wanted in 2005, even if these were genuine racing games rather than cartoony action-orientated ones.

11. Jak 3 (2004)

Whilst the original Jak And Daxter was a colourful and child-friendly platforming game, Jak II radically altered the dynamic of the series by adding guns and a handful of elements 'adopted' from the Grand Theft Auto series, such as the carjacking of vehicles and the introduction of criminal employers in the crime-ridden metropolis of Haven City. Jak 3 built on this, setting itself in a scaled-down version of the same city as well as a large desert wasteland and an additional settlement named Spargus. In these, the player must jump, shoot and drive to progress and close the plot threads both introduced and carried over from the first two games. More than anything, Jak 3 struggles from a lack of originality, as it includes little that wasn't already featured in the series' second outing. The decision to set much of the story in a barren desert wasteland as opposed to a varied cityscape wasn't the greatest idea either, in retrospect, as despite the game's graphics being quite impressive for 2004, there's only so much sand you can look at before becoming bored out of your mind. Because of this, the game is Naughty Dog's weakest platforming effort, though their weakest effort is still vastly superior to the majority of titles that have been churned out by their competitors over the years.

10. Crash Bandicoot (1996)

Now this is a controversial shout. Crash Bandicoot was the game that made Naughty Dog, and its titular character became Sony's mascot on the back of the original game's phenomenal success, giving them a counterpart to Nintendo's Mario and Sega's Sonic The Hedgehog. Pitting an anthropomorphic bandicoot against a stereotypical mad scientist, the game was a colourful (and highly challenging) adventure from start to finish. In a year that also saw the release of Super Mario 64, it significantly helped to raise the bar in the platforming genre. Ultimately, its low ranking comes down to a matter of replayability over legacy. Subsequent Crash games improved upon the formula so much to the extent that the original feels ridiculously sluggish in comparison, largely due to the limited nature of Crash's moveset. The considerable linearity, frustrating camera and the ridiculously difficult task that was saving your game also haven't helped it stand the test of time, regardless of what those who nostalgically view the past through rose-tinted glasses might think. It's definitely worth playing to experience the evolution of the series, mind.

9. Jak And Daxter: The Precursor Legacy (2001)

Naughty Dog released four Crash Bandicoot games on the Playstation before being bought out by Sony. As Universal owned the rights to the Crash character, this forced the studio to develop a new franchise in the form of Jak And Daxter on the new Playstation 2 system, though Crash would live on through the playable Crash Bash before plunging into obscurity after starring in a handful of progressively worse games made by a variety of developers. Jak and Daxter was a highly enjoyable game in the early days of the Playstation 2's lifespan, but it wasn't a 'must have' game like the entries in the Crash series were, largely due to the fact that traditional platformers were becoming largely obsolete as technical advances began to allow for an influx of more diverse action/adventure titles, such as the Ratchet And Clank series developed by Naughty Dog's 'sister studio' Insomniac (also responsible for the original Spyro The Dragon trilogy). Colourful it may have been, but ultimately Jak And Daxter could be completed in just a matter of hours and it became stale even more quickly, given that the mute player character was mostly tasked with doing the same things repeatedly.

8. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune (2007)

Before they ended up releasing The Last Of Us as their second intellectual property on the Playstation 3, Naughty Dog were seemingly hell-bent on releasing just one series of games per console. Much like how they swapped Crash Bandicoot for Jak And Daxter when they switched from Playstation to Playstation 2, the studio 'abandoned' their man/ottsel platforming duo for their first take on a real-world story on the Playstation 3, Uncharted. Set across thirty chapters (arguably about five to ten too many), Uncharted's mix of climbing, puzzles and shooting, combined with highly likable characters, strong storytelling and just the right amount of comic relief saw it become one of the first great games on Sony's third Playstation console. It can be highly repetitive at times as a result of its linearity, however, and constrained by its setting and frequent one-sided gunfights that task you with taking down armies of henchmen with just a pistol. As was the case with the Crash series, the first Uncharted now feels dated and sluggish as a result of how impressive its sequels were, but not to the extent where it cannot be played and thoroughly enjoyed.

7. Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped (1998)

Naughty Dog ultimately created three platforming entries in the Crash franchise, with the third, Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped being the median of the three in terms of quality and enjoyability. Similar to how Crash 2 built greatly upon the original in terms of new features, Crash 3 adds even more to proceedings. Why then, is it ranked lower than its immediate predecessor? Overload. Almost all over the levels in the first Crash Bandicoot were traditional platforming levels, tasking the player with jumping and spinning their way through to the end. Crash 2 had a larger proportion of 'special' levels, which saw Crash do things such as mount a polar bear or strap on a jet pack, but its core was still jumping and spinning (with the addition of sliding, double jumping and bodyslamming). The traditional platforming elements of Crash 3 are undoubtedly the best in the series, but they are far too few in number, as Crash (or his sister Coco) are far too frequently forced to eschew jumping in favour of snorkelling, jet-skiing, motorcycling or piloting a plane, and the game mechanics is such levels are unrefined, to say the least. Still, the third Crash was a high point for the platforming genre, and ranks up there with the finest games that were released on the Playstation. There were better, however, some made by the same developer...

6. Jak II: Renegade (2003)

Every sequel in the early noughties was seemingly bound by law to have a subtitle attached to it. Some of these were relevant or witty (Ratchet And Clank II: Going Commando), whilst most were downright unnecessary (World Rally Championship II: Extreme). The 'Renegade' element of Jak II probably falls into the latter category, though the removal of Daxter from the title would've left it rather short otherwise. As mentioned previously, Jak II couldn't have been more different from the first game in the series. Gone was the silent protagonist, the colourful environments and the platform-orientated quest, replaced by a murky urban landscape, a mission-based structure and a heavy focus on gunfights and vehicles. In a market where people were abandoning traditional games in favour of the likes of Grand Theft Auto (despite its age rating), the drastic change in style worked, offering players a hugely immersive experience that remained engaging from start to finish, and which still today stands out as the highlight of the Jak and Daxter trilogy, which is now available as a HD collection on the Playstation Store.

5. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception (2011)

Much like Jak 3, Uncharted 3 'suffered' in that its predecessor, Uncharted 2, set a ridiculously high standard that it couldn't quite live up to by offering 'more of the same'. Though the gameplay itself was enjoyable as ever, adding horseback gunfights, a British pub brawl and many other things to the established action/exploration mix, the story was all over the place at times despite delving into the history of the always likable Nate and Sully and exploring the origin of their partnership in excellent fashion. The visuals were nothing short of sublime, however, and still rank amongst the finest on Playstation 3. The multiplayer feature, meanwhile, was improved from the offering featured in Uncharted 2, rivalling the online content in similar games such as Assassin's Creed in terms of scope and variety. All in all, the game would've been more than an adequate send-off for Drake and company, and it was widely expected to be the last entry in the series given Naughty Dog's history with trilogies. A fourth and final game, subtitled A Thief's End, has been announced for the Playstation 4, however, and will most likely be excellent given the pedigree of the three games that have preceded it.

4. Crash Team Racing (1999)

On paper, Crash Team Racing was nothing more than a Mario Kart rip-off, given that it took an assortment of characters from the Crash series, put them in karts, added in a healthy dose of weapons to make things interesting and tasked players to race around an array of circuits. The game was so enjoyable, however, that any similarities were irrelevant. Gameplay was fluid, the majority of tracks were well-designed and the content was immersive - players were tasked not only with playing through a story mode, but a gruellingly challenging time trial mode and a diverse multiplayer experience that allowed them and their friends (remember when we went to other people's houses to play games split screen rather than over the net?) to compete in tournaments and use the game's zany weaponry to compete in party-game style battles (because who doesn't want to play as a polar bear and blow up a giant tiger with a missile?). Today, the game remains a wondrous experience, despite its age. It's just a shame that, unlike the Mario Kart franchise, which continues to evolve and improve, there has never been a true follow-up (Jak X and the average (and non Naughty Dog) Crash Nitro Kart and Crash Tag Team Racing notwithstanding) capable of competing with Nintendo's juggernaut.

3. The Last Of Us (2013)

To commemorate the release one hundredth issue, UK Official Playstation Magazine recently polled its readers to create a list of the one hundred greatest Playstation games of all time. Though the results were heavily skewed towards newer releases, almost all of Naughty Dog's games were rightfully included. One came out on top, however, beating the various Grand Theft Autos, Final Fantasies and other groundbreaking releases that have graced the three Playstation systems throughout the years. This was The Last Of Us, the company's most recent game, which marked the first time that they'd developed a second original series for one Playstation console. Though many could argue that there are several other games that are equally worthy of the top spot, none can deny that the survival epic is one of the most beautiful and groundbreaking releases of recent years. Tugging at our heartstrings from start to finish, Joel and Ellie's journey will be looked upon favourably for many, many years to come. The recent remastered re-release for Playstation 4 has succeeded in building an ever larger fanbase for the game, which has continued Naughty Dog's trend of delivering nothing but the best.

2. Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back (1997)

After putting themselves on the map with the original Crash Bandicoot, Naughty Dog sought to quickly profit from the game's high sales and the popularity of its titular character by developing a sequel in the space of a year. This is a common marketing strategy for successful game series (as it is for films) and can often lead to developers releasing rushed cash cows that fail to innovate or build on their predecessors. Crash 2 did not feel like a rushed cash cow in any shape or form, as it built and improved on the original Crash in every conceivable way - the fluidity and moveset of the titular character were overhauled for the better, whilst levels were linked by the then-innovative warp room feature, which allowed for quick gameplay access and saving. The levels were an interesting mix, whilst secrets contained within them expanded on the games admittedly short lifespan. Infinitely replayable, Crash's second outing is criticised by some as overly simplistic, but this is part of the wide-ranging appeal that led to it becoming the top-selling Western game in the Playstation's home of Japan - anybody can pick up a controller, learn the mechanics in a matter of minutes and drop in and out of the game at will, progressing at their own speed and losing themselves in a colourful fantasy world as a result. Nintendo purists will always stand up for Super Mario 64, but Crash 2 is definitely up there with it as one of the all-time greats in the traditional platforming genre, which is, sadly, all but dead nowadays.

1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves (2009)

A train has crashed in the middle of nowhere. The environment is a snowy one, cold and desolate, whilst the level of detail is second to none. Precariously hanging over a cliff is one carriage of the train, which contains a wounded Nathan Drake, who must escape before gravity takes his toll and best a group of his fellow survivors, who are armed, dangerous and on the hunt for him. Few scenes in gaming can top the in medias res opening of Uncharted 2, which reintroduced players to Drake and immediately invested them in his survival, as well as giving them a thirst to delve into his second adventure and realise how he came to be there in the first place. Said adventure is a whirlwind from start to finish, eschewing its predecessor's 'one island' setting (which resulted in lots of similar locales) by sending Drake and his cohorts, with whom his banter is always excellent, around the world. Whether it's knocking off a museum in Istanbul with a sleazy Brit or traversing a Nepalese city in the midst of urban warfare, the diversity of Nate's adventure ensures that it is rarely not both captivating and challenging. Online multiplayer felt tacked-on but was by no means poor, allowing players to engage in cooperative missions or competitive game types better suited for a first person shooting equivalent. Regardless of this, however, the game's timeless appeal was in its single player offering, which in the view of this writer has not yet been bettered. I still hate those goddamn yeti-things though.

In this post: 
Uncharted
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Alex was about to write a short biography, but he got distracted by something shiny instead.