Ranking Every Pokémon Mobile Game Worst To Best

Pokémon GO isn't the best thing you could be playing...

Pokemon Games
Nintendo

Everyone loves a Pokemon game. Whether you started by catching Rattatas in Red and Blue, or only got in to the games recently by catching Alolan Rattatas in Sun and Moon, anyone who has played a Pokemon game has been drawn in by catching and fielding the best army of pets they can.

But there's a wild range of games beyond this core series that not everyone knows about. From the Trading Card Game and the Mystery Dungeon series to some obscurer titles that are hard to come by or only available via digital download, there are many, many subseries and standalone games that take the beloved pets on adventures.

In particular, there are now many Pokemon games available on mobile devices and tablets. Some of these are ports of games originally available on other platforms, such as the Switch, and others are games unique to mobile devices that deliver gameplay unavailable anywhere else.

Unfortunately, not all of these games are born equal. While many come out to huge acclaim and popularity, like the popular Pokemon Go, others go unnoticed like a hard-to-catch Ghastly. In order to help you decide which to play (and which to leave in the Pokemon Day Care), I played them all for you.

7. Pokemon Magikarp Jump

Magikarp Jump
Nintendo

The worst Pokemon game is based on the worst Pokemon, Magikarp, which seems rather fitting.

Magikarp Jump takes place in a town where people only ever catch or use one Pokemon - you can guess which - and they compete to see how high their Magikarp can jump. Gameplay consists of clicking on food to tell your fish to eat it and... well, that's just about it. There's no real gameplay.

The point of the game is to train your Pokemon to jump as high as it can and beat various leagues, but all you do to train or battle is watch cutscenes of your Pokemon doing the work themselves. There's nothing for the player to do save decorate their pond, tell the Magikarp to eat food in it, and sometimes try to catch a Magikarp that looks minimally different.

The game was released to little fanfare, which isn't surprising given that there's nothing interesting that could be put in a trailer, and the image the title evokes, of a Flappy Bird-like reaction game, is far more interesting than the glorified Tamagotchi we got.


6. Camp Pokemon

Camp Pokemon
Nintendo

Camp Pokemon was designed so that adults could give their tablet to their kids and distract them for a few hours. For kids, it's probably some light fun, but if you started playing Pokemon in 1998 with Red and Blue, you might be a bit old for it.

The game consists of some mini-games that are intended to teach children the basics of how Pokemon games work. One involves searching a picture for Pokemon hidden in it, another is a reaction game about throwing Pokeballs at Pokemon, another teaches which elements are strong against other elements.

Camp Pokemon isn't designed to be a fun experience for fans of the series; the game is intended to train young kids to be future customers that'll buy the games, the cuddly plushies, the clothes etc. It's some harmless fun, but there's an insidious feeling throughout that it's only purpose is to indoctrinate kids to the cult of Pokemon at a young age.


5. Pokemon Shuffle

pokemon shuffle
Nintendo

If you're going to make mobile games based on your popular franchise, it's inevitable that you'll end up making a match-3 game. Pokemon Shuffle, originally released on 3DS, is this game.

As a match-3 game, it's fine. A grid has three or four Pokemon faces in a random jumble, and you have to re-arrange them to make lines of three which then disappear. If you've played one, you've played them all.

The Pokemon theme comes in through a few mechanics, including Pokemon types that means if you match the right Pokemon you get closer to completing the level than you otherwise would, and various themed abilities that trigger if you match four or more Pokemon in one go.

The game is a fine time-killing experience, but the Pokemon theme seems little more than a decoration rather than part of the game. There's nothing that makes Shuffle better than any other match-3 game - if you play this around your elderly relatives, they're going to think you're playing Candy Crush just like they do.


4. Pokemon Quest

Pokemon Quest
Nintendo

The most recent Pokemon game on mobile devices is a port from the Switch. It seems designed for mobile, but must have been pretty boring on its original platform.

Pokemon Quest takes place in a Minecraft-style block world, transforming all the 151 Pokemon in the game into adorable blocky bundles of joy that are undeniably the best part of the game. The gameplay is rather unique - a team of three Pokemon run around a level attacking the nearest opponent, sometimes unleashing powers if commanded to by the player.

While the gameplay is very different to other Pokemon games it is quite limited in how interactive it is, as all you can do is sometimes boost a Pokemon's attack or make them unleash a different attack. There's no skill involved - you can't scrape through a hard level that you wouldn't normally beat, or chain together attacks to ace a boss. Since your team is given a numerical value based on their attack and health, and each level has a difficulty number that corresponds, the game can be a simple 'make your numbers bigger than the level's number' kind of game, which isn't fun.

It also gets really difficult quite quickly, and a big wall presents itself to the player after the first few levels. But due to the extreme cuteness of the Pokemon, and the novel gameplay style, it's still an interesting game.


3. Pokemon Go

Pokemon Go
Niantic

Pokemon Go revolutionised mobile gaming when it was released. It needs no introduction - it brought the adorable pets into the real world, and according to statistics nearly everyone on the planet played it.

Opinions are now mixed on it due to its limited amount of content, despite newer Pokemon being released. In addition really similar apps based on other franchises, such as Jurassic Park Alive or the upcoming Ghostbusters and Harry Potter ARG games, have ruined the magic of the original.

Despite this it's still an important milestone in mobile gaming. It got people running around the real world to visit gyms and catch rare Pokemon, and united people in hunting down something that isn't another god-damn Rattata.

While its shockwaves are still being felt in gaming and mobile technology, it still can't be called the best Pokemon mobile game - there are two games that are simply better experiences.


2. Pokemon TCG Online

Pokemon Tcg
Nintendo

The Pokemon trading card game was released in 1996, which is before Red and Blue was even on shelves in America, and it quickly became the biggest force in trading card games in the West. It was adapted to a browser game in 2011, and has slowly been making its way across digital platforms ever since then.

Although it was already proven as a fantastic game already, the TCG's mobile port is the high-point of the sub-series. It's affordable, unlike the real-life cards which cost money, it's portable, unlike the PC and console ports, and it's constantly changing and expanding with new expansions all the time.

While some online TCGs lose popularity after release, making playing them online impossible, Pokemon TCG Online has a reliable and large player-base which means you're rarely stuck for a game. Even when you can't make a match, the AI and Trainer modes are convincingly human and make for challenging battles.

It's just a shame that long-time players have fool-proof strategies and decks, meaning first-time players can have a hard time getting their first victory.


1. Pokemon Duel

Pokemon Duel
Nintendo

The best Pokemon game on mobiles is undeniably Pokemon Duel. It takes a nuanced strategy game and adds Pokemon-themed mechanics that transform the experience into a game that's easy to understand yet difficult to master

Based on the short-lived Pokemon Figure Trading Game, a board game that never made it big, the game is a simple strategy match where you have to move your Pokemon around a grid and reach the opponent's goal. When you reach an enemy's Pokemon, you both spin a unique spinner that each Pokemon has, and the Pokemon that spins the lowest number gets knocked out.

But with the addition of interesting abilities Pokemon have which lead to changing gameplay, and evolutions which means your Pokemon gets better if it beats enemies, the game steps above Pokemon mobile games by successfully combining a great game with the Pokemon theme to create something truly unique.

Although the microtransactions included as part of the game can put a dampener on the fun of creating a great team to stomp all over your opponent, Duel is still the best Pokemon experience you can have on a mobile device.


In this post: 
pokemon
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm based in the UK, looking to make a career out of writing about entertainment and culture. The only thing I like as much as watching films, playing games or listening to music is enjoying as much hummus and crisps as I can while I do so. My favourite film is Eddie the Eagle and I like any game that lets me wander around beautiful worlds (or eat hummus and crisps).