Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Incredible Secrets & Locations You Must Find
1. Broken Pirate Sword
If knives and hatchets aren't your preferred weapon of choice in close-quarters combat, look no further than the Broken Pirate Sword. Seen better days it has, but the weathered blade is arguably the best melee weapon in-game and only requires that you be in Chapter 2 to obtain it.
First things first: ride or catch a train to the industrial city of Saint Denis and then head West until you hit a collection of small islands South of Caliga Hall. Hitch your horse here and then make your way Southeast through marshland, looking out for a shipwrecked boat. Inside the wreck, you'll find the sword sticking upright out of the hull and its presumed former owner.
For those wanting to complete the pirate look, an island just West of Morgan's camp in Chapter 2 has another wreck with a Tricorn hat inside, though you'll need to purchase a boat in order to reach it.