Returnal PS5 Review: 9 Ups & 3 Downs

Returnal is another killer PS5 exclusive.

returnal game
Housemarque

Being the first major exclusive since Sony dropped the PS5 last November (sorry Destruction All Stars), there’s a lot of expectation hanging on Returnal.

It’s developer Housemarque’s biggest game yet, it’s one of the few true next-gen exclusives Sony has on its slate, and it’s trying to mesh the procedurally-generated nature of Roguelikes with AAA production values.

Returnal casts players as Selene, an astronaut who’s crash landed on the uncharted alien planet Atropos. The twist is, though, Selene is caught in a time loop. Every death resets progress to the moment she crashed, and every time she returns the planet’s geometry changes in classic Roguelike fashion.

Pre-release trailers showed a game that looked pretty solid, but plenty of caution has remained. Will the gameplay get bland across tens of hours? Will there be enough variety in the environments? Does it justify the $70 price point?

Well, I’ve spent the past week and a bit playing it, and can say with confidence that Returnal is another winner for Sony.

--

There are NO spoilers in this review.


UPS

9. Combat Is Super Satisfying & Great Enemy Variety

Returnal ps5
Sony

The structure of the game will be familiar if you’ve even briefly brushed the genre before: each new run will throw a procedurally-generated area at you as you enter a new room, which will either be full of enemies, platforming sections or safe spaces that’ll award you with buffs. Your job is to get to the end of each of the six biomes, kill the bosses, and proceed onwards.

If you’ve played a Housmarque title before you know the studio excels in creating exhilarating combat systems, and that remains true here.

The combat itself kind of works like a mix between Control and Doom. It’s a fast-paced experience: you’re encouraged to keep moving, dashing, jumping and put pressure on enemies. However you’ll also be playing a bit of combat chess in your head, analysing the specific attacks of enemies and methodically eliminating the biggest threats. The mix keeps the fights hectic and spectacular, but laser focused in their challenge.

The enemies themselves are ferocious, aggressively hunting you and filling the screen with projectiles. You will die. A lot.

Understanding your opponent is a huge part of the experience, as is reacting to their attacks and ultimately taking them all out in a shower of colour.

Bosses are suitably epic too, and test everything you’ve learned previously. There are some late-stage ones I don’t want to spoil that are so visually dynamic and challenging I’ll be thinking about them all year.


8. Dualsense Adds So Much Immersion

Returnal PS5
Sony

Part of what makes the combat special is that this is a true next-gen experience.

Much has been said about the potential of the Dualsense, but there was a worry that its best features would go under-utilised, or even worse, that they would end up like the PS3’s sixaxis. Thankfully, Returnal is proof of how much the controller can add to the experience.

On a base level, the controller gives you more - well - control over Selene. For instance, holding the left trigger halfway down allows you to zoom and aim, while pulling past that threshold activates the alt. fire mode. It might sound finicky but in the moment it’s anything but, and is so intuitive that going back to shooters without this feature feels like something’s missing.

You also get more feedback from your inputs which both increases immersion, and offers sensory combat data. The environment is reflected in the haptic feedback: rain results in a light pitter patter on the pad, melee attacks give it a punch, while even certain enemy projectiles are signposted through vibration cues.

This, combined with the subtle use of the in-built mic to add more dimension to the sound, makes for a more visceral, tactile, next-gen experience overall.

It sounds like I’ve just reeled off a bunch of marketing buzzwords and shilled the controller there but, honestly, it’s just that much of an ace in the hole. In fact, that’s kind of an issue for Sony. It adds so much functionality that you simply can’t convey in trailers.


7. A Proper Next-Gen Game

Returnal PS5
Sony

Returnal is an audio-visual treat as well.

While it feels good to run, jump, slice and shoot your way through enemies at a base level, it’s the attention to detail that makes it so captivating for so long. Enemies explode into balls of light, the scale of this alien world and its beasties is massive, and when everything is popping off at once and you’re flitting by on muscle memory and instinct, you get into the kind of zone where it’s just you and the game and nothing else matters.

It might sound cliche, but once you’re in Returnal’s rhythm, it’s spellbinding. I can’t tell you how much sleep I’ve lost this week because I’ve been on a good run and couldn’t put the controller down.

Returnal is a real looker, too.

The lighting especially is magnificent, whether it’s the gloomy interplay of light and shadows in the forest or the onslaught of colourful projectiles in boss fights. The particle effects are glorious, as is the spectacle of fighting against enemies made from hundreds of independent tentacles.


6. No Performance Issues

Returnal game PS5
Housemarque

Thankfully, the gameplay is never let down on the technical side. Returnal runs at 4K60fps, and in my experience never faltered.

I can count maybe two or three times where the framerate dropped a tad during particularly heavy moments, but it was otherwise the rare polished experience.

The super-fast SSD load times keeps the action immediate as well. Whether you're moving to different biomes, fast travelling to previous rooms or having to respawn, you're never waiting around for more than a few seconds.


5. Awesome Level Design Encourages Replayability

Returnal Ps5
Sony

So, the core combat is excellent, but where Returnal excels in the long run is the sheer amount of variety that keeps each session fresh.

While you will see the same rooms repeat, what’s impressive is the scale of these areas. You’re not ushered down claustrophobic corridors, but given free-reign over wide open, vertical spaces.

Narratively, these add to the grandiosity and mystery of the planet, but they also allow for a bunch of diverse gameplay opportunities, allowing you to adapt your playstyle depending on enemy selection or weapon choice.

These areas are given an extra dimension too with a dose of MetroidVania-esque exploration. You’ll notice on your first few runs that some parts of rooms are off limits: forcefields will block doors, some heights are inaccessible, and hazards hide essential upgrades.

That’s because as you progress you’ll attain some specific, permanent upgrades to your character that open these areas up. As a result, there’s a mechanical incentive to return to older locations even when you think you’ve seen everything they have to offer.


4. Risk/Reward Systems Keep Each Run Fresh

Returnal PS5
Sony

Returnal encourages replayability through its focus on risk-reward gameplay as well. On top of regular upgrades you find in the world - resin to increase your health, weapon parts to upgrade weapon proficiency - there are malignant items scattered around.

These will offer helpful buffs, but will leave you vulnerable to a suit malfunction. You’ll still get the perk, but a malfunction will knock you back a peg, maybe halving your weapon damage while in the air, or making you take fall damage. These malfunctions come with their own criteria to fix, whether it’s performing a certain amount of melee kills or picking up x amount of obolites, the game’s currency.

And then there’s parasites you can attach to your suit, another system which will give you a buff in exchange for a trade off. Unlike malfunctions these are permanent stat alterations. One might give you 10% weapon damage in exchange for lowering your melee cooldown, or increase the alt. fire cool down while lowering your defence.


3. Gameplay Systems Are Surprisingly Deep

Returnal PS5
Sony

These risk/reward elements are all on top of your regular shooter systems as well. You have plenty of weapons to find and experiment with, fabricators to craft essential buffs, consumables that have both passive and active attributes, keys to unlock secret routes and plenty of enemy drops to steal. There’s even a system where you can avenge the deaths of real-life players by risking a fight against a tough enemy for loot.

Learning these mechanics means no run is wasted. You’re always getting more powerful - whether that’s physically through permanent upgrades, or through your understanding of enemies, locations and how to maximise the efficiency of buffs.

So, while the base gameplay might be able to be boiled down to clearing out rooms and destroying bosses, Returnal’s systems are surprisingly deep and keep things interesting even tens of hours in.

You’re running through the same areas, but rarely in the same way twice. You’re constantly making in-the-moment tactical decisions and thinking a couple rooms ahead.

The trailers might make it look like a brainless shooter, but Returnal requires you to be in the moment, and engage with it in its totality. If you do, you’ll be rewarded with a rich web of interlocking mechanics to master. If you don’t, you’re dead.


2. Story Is Fascinating (And Scary)

Returnal PS5
Sony

This is on top of the story too, which provides its own incentive to keep pushing on. Replaying levels and pushing further into different biomes unlocks more about the wide-reaching narrative, and for the most part it’s a fascinating one.

Like Selene, you initially know nothing about the planet or its inhabitants, and slowly uncovering the reality of what the time loop is, why you’re there and the culture of this alien race gives each run a narrative purpose as well as a mechanical one.

The existential horror of the story gives Returnal another appealing dimension as well. It can be a genuinely frightening game when it wants.

Selene is tormented by a creepy Astronaut - an unknowable figure whose presence usually spells disaster. Likewise, following in the footsteps of your previous selves and listening to their audio tapes is a suitably grim way to meld the story with the actual gameplay, as it narrativises every failed run. As does returning to a mysterious house that swaps the camera to first-person for more narrative-driven horror sequences.

These, along with flashes of a potential future and past every time you die, constantly peel back new layers of the story. Again, the developments act as positive reinforcement, and contributes to the feeling that every run matters.


1. There's So Much To Do Even After Credits

Returnal PS5
Sony

It took me just over 15 hours to first hit credits on Returnal, but that’ll vary considerably depending on individual skill and deaths. If you’ve played a Roguelike, you’ll know credits aren’t the end anyway.

There was still so much I had left to do after that - story threads to finish off, areas to fully explore, weapons to max upgrade, databases to fully research, daily challenges to complete. After 20 plus hours, I was still seeing new weapons introduced, and more ways to play.

More importantly though, I actually wanted to play more. I didn’t hit credits and feel done. If anything, I was more ravenous than I was before to finish more runs, and clean up the remaining secrets.

Honestly, I didn’t expect to come out of Returnal loving it this much. I thought the trailers looked fine, and I’m far from a roguelike veteran, but it got its slimy, alien hooks in me.

It’s a true next-gen spin on the genre, with best-in-class combat and a world that’s a pure joy for fans of sci-fi horror. I’ve run through it over and over but unlike Selene, I don’t want this cycle to be broken any time soon.


DOWNS

3. Story Can Get Confusing Or Undermine Emotional Moments

Returnal PS5
Sony

While the story is mostly interesting, the presentation of it isn’t perfect.

With the structure of the genre, it can mean beats land differently depending on the player. For instance, if you find yourself on a big session, progressing from biome to biome in one life, it can feel like you’ve leapfrogged a bunch of narrative points.

Of course you’ll eventually die and get the blanks filled in, but proceeding too quickly can result in some big moments feeling more confusing than they should, or lacking emotion.

Still, meshing a story like this with the structure of a Roguelike isn’t easy, and Returnal mostly pulls it off.


2. First Few Hours Are A Little Overwhelming

Returnal PS5
Sony

If there’s a mechanical issue with the structure, it’s perhaps that the game saves too much of the good stuff for later. The best biomes are the ones in the back half, and the starting weapons - namely a pistol, carbine and shotgun - can make Returnal appear unimaginative in its early hours.

Fortunately, this assumption is proven wrong, but the worry is some might not play long enough to realise.

If there’s a drawback to the wealth of interlocking systems mentioned previously as well, it’s that it can feel overwhelming at first too. You’ll spend the first few hours scanning a lot of new items, experimenting, dying and maybe even feeling like you’re not getting anywhere.

It’s certainly a hump to get over, but it more than pays off in the long run, and there definitely is a long run.


1. Environment Design Can Lack Detail

Returnal Ps5
Sony

If Returnal does fall down somewhat it’s occasionally in the environmental design. While there are imaginative areas, others can appear a little plain or lacking in detail.

Some rooms feel a little empty and don't encourage exploration, while it's also a game that looks better in motion rather than in still images. Consequently, there'll probably be a few rooms in each biome that don't inspire much passion in the player when they inevitably show up.

That’s not a huge issue, but because the environmental storytelling can be so great, you want more of it.


Watch Next


PlayStation 25th Anniversary Quiz - How Well Do You Remember Sony's First Console?

crash bandicoot n sane trilogy
Sony

1. How Many Crash Bandicoot Games Were Released On The Console?

3

4

5

6

In this post: 
PS5 Returnal
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.