Super Smash Bros. Ultimate DLC: 9 Echo Fighters Nintendo MUST Add

There are still some glaring omissions.

Super Smash Bros Snake
Konami/Nintendo

In fighting game fandom, clone characters are traditionally a big no-no. Not only do they steal valuable roster space that could otherwise be given to a new or mechanically unique character, but they stink to high heaven of imaginational bankruptcy. Yet, Nintendo's all-star series, already an exception to other established genre rules, just can't add enough of them to satisfy demand.

Bespoke characters will, of course, always be preferable to simpler palette swaps - and to the team's credit, that's going to be Smash Ultimate's focus for the immediate future - but those take time and a whole lot of money, so with a character sheet already boasting more than 50 unique characters, there's bound to be some overlap.

It's for that exact reason that the term "Echo Fighter" was coined.

Without it, characters like Ken, Dark Samus and Richter could never have made the cut, but now? The floodgates are open.

All eyes are focused on the standalone DLC characters to come, but once those have settled in? Additional Echo Fighters have been neither confirmed or denied, but if the former comes true, these guys should be front of the queue.

9. Ganondorf - Toon Ganon

Ganondorf Wind Waker
Nintendo

It's about time Smash addressed the imbalance between good and evil for its Hyrule representatives. Both Link and Zelda (counting Sheik) are spoiled with multiple versions of themselves taking up space on Ultimate's roster, but what does Ganondorf get? Just one measly spot.

With Toon Link already present and accounted for, adding Wind Waker's bulkier, cel-shaded version of the Demon King as an Echo Fighter is a no brainer, surely? There's certainly enough overlap between the two's combat quirks to make the addition plausible. The major difference, of course, is Wind Waker's version never assumed the pig-shaped form seen in other games, necessitating the creation of a new Final Smash.

Either a transformation into Phantom Ganon or the use of his creepy Puppet as seen in Wind Waker's climax would be a perfect fit and tribute to a version of the character that gets little love from Nintendo as far as spin-offs go.

Make it happen, Sakurai!


8. Mega Man - Proto Man

Proto Man Profile
Capcom

An easy, relatively speaking, potential inclusion should Sakurai ever give it the go-ahead, Mega Man's sibling has largely the same abilities as his baby brother, the most notable difference being a preference for red. With that said, from Mega Man 9 onwards, Capcom's taken measures to distinguish the pair with slightly varying abilities, making Proto Man ripe for picking as an Echo Fighter.

The pair's arm cannons are functionally identical, though in the aforementioned game and its sequel, Proto Man takes considerably more damage as a trade-off for his superior shield, which deflects, rather than blocks, almost every type of attack and persists even when he's dashing. In the spirit of that risk/reward playstyle, Proto could fill the glass cannon archetype and serve as a technical, skill-testing alternative to Mega Man.

As for his Final Smash, Mega Man's existing 'Mega Legends' is more than suitable. All Sakurai and his team need do, is swap the two brothers' positions and hey presto: Here Comes A New Echo Fighter!


7. Captain Falcon - Black Shadow

Black Shadow F Zero
Nintendo

The unashamedly evil and cruel antagonist of the F-Zero series would love to join Smash Ultimate's roster, if for no other reason than to ruin Captain Falcon's day. As one of the most requested Smash characters since, well, ever, adding Black Shadow as an Echo of his nemesis wouldn't just provide a dose of delicious irony, but some much-needed lip service to fans of Nintendo's oft-forgotten racer.

As far as fighting ability goes, Black Shadow's command over dark magic and heightened agility could lead to his being a swifter, perhaps less hard-hitting version of Falcon with a projectile attack to account for Falcon's one major weakness. For the Final Smash, it's easy - copy Falcon's (it's one of the best, anyway) and just swap out the Blue Falcon for Shadow's own Black Bull racer.


6. Snake - Any Other Version Of Snake

Metal Gear Solid 4 Old Snake
Konami

There are two ways an Echo Fighter of Snake could play out, should there ever be one. Either Solid's older self as seen in MGS 4 could be used as a direct palette swap with a few minor alterations to set the two apart, or one of his test tube siblings could take the spot instead. Liquid's a tough ask, given that from the Twin Snakes onwards, he's little more than a magical arm possessing Ocelot's body, but Solidus? He's the red-headed stepchild as far as popularity contests go between the trio and the most underrepresented because of it.

The latter's an unlikely underdog, but for the sake of variety, Solidus would be the best pick of the three thanks to his Doctor Octopus-inspired exoskeleton. Would that be too much of a divergence for Solidus to be considered an Echo Fighter? In normal play, probably, but that's what Final Smashes are for.


5. Sheik - Impa

Impa Zelda
Nintendo

Link, Zelda and Ganondorf: the three key pillars of every Legend of Zelda title are present and accounted for in Smash, but it's about time tribute is paid to some of the series' other famous faces. A playable Zora or Goron would be ideal but in the absence of any suitable base for them to be an Echo of, Impa goes straight to the front of the queue.

Breath of the Wild's version of the character is a little too far over the hill to be considered for a fighting game, so either Ocarina of Time or Skyward Sword's incarnations would need to be loaned out. As a member of the ninja-like Sheikah clan and the individual responsible for Zelda's badass alter-ego in the former, Impa's abilities are consequently identical to her protege's.

Perhaps a few changes to account for Impa's katana could be squeezed in, but an otherwise like-for-like palette swap of Sheik is perfectly acceptable.


4. Bayonetta - Jeanne

Bayonetta Jeanne
PlatinumGames

It's almost as if Platinum created Jeanne with the future prospect of her becoming an Echo Fighter in mind. As the childhood friend of Bayo and a fellow Umbra Witch, the white-haired wonder has access to all of her counterpart's abilities, including Witch Time and being able to stomp enemies with overlarge limbs woven from her own locks.

How the two diverge from each other in combat comes down to technical details. Unlike Bayo, Jeanne can dodge indefinitely and her special attacks do boosted damage. The caveat to her more aggressive nature is less defence and a harder-to-activate Witch Time, but the two are otherwise identical on the battlefield.

Those small, nuanced differences couldn't scream Echo Fighter material any louder. Tweak the numbers and change the colour of Jeanne's Wicked Weaves from Bayo's black and purple to white and pink and she'd be all set.


3. Sonic - Metal Sonic

Metal Sonic
Sega

Besides his egg-shaped creator, Sonic's metallic doppelganger has remained the most persistent threat standing between him and enjoying a carefree life with his chums, and it just so happens that the dead-eyed machine is a perfect fit for Smash Ultimate's Echo Fighter template. As are Shadow and Silver, of course, but those two knock-offs are exactly where they belong as Spirit Fighters. Metal Sonic deserves better.

On the whole, porting Sonic's move set wholesale over to Metal would be adequate, the only necessary replacements being the former's Spin Dash, Spring Jump and Final Smash. A functionally identical charge attack that revs the jet engine embedded in Metal Sonic's chest would solve the first; removal of the spring the second, it's just the Final Smash that could prove to be problematic.

Short of designing a bespoke finisher for the character, the only alternative is to have Metal flit across the screen as Super Sonic does, only minus the transformation. Is that flashy enough? Not really, but if it means Metal getting a spot on Ultimate's roster, it's a worthwhile compromise.


2. Mario - Paper Mario

Super Paper Mario Super Paper Mario 5611524 1280 960
Nintendo

Outside of a tributary stage exclusive to Smash's 3DS outing, Nintendo's spin-off RPG series has never been given the attention it deserves. Whether that's down to Nintendo not wanting even more versions of Mario clogging up an already massive roster or due to the difficulty of making a 2D character work on a 3D plane, who knows, but neither excuse holds much weight any longer.

Echo Fighters exist precisely to allow multiple versions of the same character to coexist in the space between wholly original and outright clone, a middle ground that Paper Mario is ripe for filling. As an Echo of Mario's standard form, the only change necessary would be replacing the Super Mario Sunshine-inspired FLUDD attack with Paper Mario's skull-cracking mallet. The Final Smash need only have its three-dimensional fireballs made flat and we'd be golden. As for the latter concerns, well, Mr. Game & Watch has already proven that Sakurai knows how to solve the two-dimensional problem.

Remember: if Dr. Mario can be considered distinct enough from his non-medically qualified self to get a standalone spot on Smash's roster, then so can the plumber's paper self.


1. Cloud Strife - Zack Fair

Zack Fair final fantasy
Square Enix

Truly, it should be Cloud serving as the Echo Fighter for Zack, given the two characters' tragic history, but hey-ho, such is the popularity of Final Fantasy VII that having its brooding blonde-haired hero serve as Smash's Square Enix rep was always going to be the obvious choice. 08000521251

The good news, though, is that aesthetics aside, the two former puppets of SOLDIER perform identically in combat, right down to using Angeal's body-sized Buster Sword as their trademark weapon of choice.

Really, the only radical change necessary to satisfy Crisis Core fans would be replacing Cloud's Omnislash Limit Break with Zack's Digital Mind Wave, itself a roulette-style special attack able to copy the signature moves of any he's seen in battle. With Sephiroth's inclusion as a Smash character looking ever less likely to happen, having Zack randomly perform his, or any of the other legendary SOLDIER 1st Class members Limit Breaks would be the next best thing and terrific fan service.


Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.