4. The Writing
Upon completion of the first episode, it becomes apparent right away that Telltale's writers know what they are doing. The writing is consistently good on just about every level. The characters, their dialogue, the setting, and various situations are all executed with a fluidity and precision most works of fiction can't hope to achieve, especially within the video game industry. It never ceases to amaze me in its ability to effortlessly force the survivors into increasingly horrendous situations without sacrificing its focus on the characters and their development. Three episodes in, and these people have been put through the ringer physically and emotionally, and it all feels real, immediate, and never without justification. The glimmer of hope among all the tragedy is the relationship between Lee and Clementine. Their dynamic is so naturally heartwarming in its simplicity, you instantly become protective of her. This creates a greater connection between the player and Lee, which in turn raises the emotional stakes to even greater heights. It is always a risk writing children, as the line between cute and annoying is a fine one, but Telltale's writers managed to created an endearing child with none of the annoyances. Some of the most enjoyable sequences are the scenes just between Lee and Clementine, where he (and you) often must explain to her the nature of a horrible event she just witnessed. It's up to you whether you want Lee to give it to her straight or remain as vague as possible. Other times they'll share moments of sadness together, longing for the old days, and growing closer to each other in the process. It is a classic father/daughter relationship done with finesse, and these sequences are the beating heart of the game, providing the foundation for which everything else is built upon. The writers also do an excellent job of establishing pace and mood. Events are always moving forward, forcing you and the characters to move right long with them and respond accordingly. There are scenes of genuine suspense that will have you on the edge of your seat, hoping that the situation doesn't get worse. Most importantly, however, are the moments that make you question your own actions.
The Walking Dead has always been about examining humanity in a world where is no longer exists, and how that affects our behavior, and Telltale keeps that theme prominent throughout. Don't think it is all sadness and despair though. While the game is most certainly not lighthearted, it is punctuated with well placed moments of humor to lighten the mood. One might think that this would damage the tone, but they hit all the right buttons. The real strength of the game comes from its ability to generate an honest emotional response from the player, and it does it so effortlessly it's remarkable.